I was in Oak Park today and happened to park near your bake shop and knew I had to go in. I bought two chocolate chip cookies. The first and every bite to follow tasted like all was going to be okay in the world. The two friends I brought in enjoyed it too. I can't wait til I can get back into Spilt Milk. I think a slice of their key lime pie may be next on my list. With some more cookies of course. read more

Spilt Milk is a cute little neighborhood bakery that serves homemade pies and baked goods. You know their food is homemade when you peer through the windows of the adjacent storefront where you can see them actually preparing and baking their scrumptious desserts. As much as the displayed baked goods look very tasty, I had their quiche of the day which was ham and guyere for lunch. It took about 12 minutes for the quiche, but I have to admit it was one of the better quiches that I have had. The quiche was filled with sliced ham which is different than most places that would use ham bits. The quiche was extra fluffy, almost omelet-like, with guyere cheese and was absolutely delicious. The crust was definitely homemade from the adjacent storefront and absolutely perfect. The only disappointment was that the quiche did not come with any side, be it a small salad or even one of their cookies. Split Milk is a wonderful neighborhood find. I will definitely come back to try some of their mouthwatering baked desserts. read more

See all

Cannot believe it took me so long to try out this place. Very cute shop, very family friendly. My favorite pastry was the salted caramel passionfruit thumbprint cookie. The monkey bread was moist in the middle and caramelized on the edges. The coffee and cream shortbread was too strong for my taste. My favorite drink was the strawberry matcha. I cannot wait to go back and try their loaves (banana and almond) and some more of their specialty matcha drinks. read more

See all

Ok here's what's so...nice, quaint, cool lil spot.....food looks totally scrumptious. I had the oatmeal raisin white macadamia cookie. Coffee was good. Smooth. Not bitter as my SB( Not saying the name). Cool that they make everything literally right there. The reason I gave it such a low rating....it would at least be a 4 if not higher. However, you can't have a coffee house and no internet these days. Can you? Peo0le were phenomenal. But really, no internet? I guess next time I come, I will bring a book......check it out but that's a HUGE issue for me. read more

See all

Very friendly staff, welcoming atmosphere, delicious cookies and tea breads, excellent croissants and scones. I wish I could rate the pie higher, but I am not a fan of the crust (to me, it doesn't have any flavor and the bottom crust is soggy) or the somewhat thick and gooey fillings, even though the taste is good. Chai latte and other milky hot drinks are good. read more

The 4 stars are for the pastries. They're really 5 stars. Every baked good I've had here has been amazing. Key Lime pie is incredible. Scones, cookies, quiche--all good. Breakfast sandwich I had once was barely edible, but don't really count that. The baked goods are amazing. But beware of ANY drink modifications. I ordered an Oat Milk horchata steamer. Which "starts" at $5. I needed caffeine but love horchata. "Can I make that a horchata latte?" "Sure. What size?" "Large." "It usually comes with 3 shots, and is oat milk still ok?" "Yep." The drink was $11.00. Eleven Dollars. So I got a scone and a drink. And the total for those 2 items with tax was $17.44. This place is regularly expensive anyway. But this was...extra. That's really a 2 star situation, that. But the baked goods are really top notch. So. read more

Spilt Milk - Seasonal drink specials. Make modifications at your peril. - The menu board features holiday drinks such as gingerbread cookie latte, peppermint mocha, peppermint hot cocoa, pumpkin pie latte, peppermint matcha latte, brown sugar latte, and oat milk horchata steamer. Prices range from $5 to $7. The design includes decorative green ribbons and illustrations of rabbits and a red chili pepper at the bottom, with a note to ask for whole, almond, or oat milk. The background appears to be inside a bakery or cafe setting. - Bakeries Near Me - Oak Park, Illinois

Through the years, Spilt Milk has lost a lot of what made it great when it first opened. What once felt warm, thoughtful, and inviting, now feels manufactured, unorganized, and cold. I think part of that is because their new location is too big and a bit of a mess, but also because the service is incredibly underwhelming. Sure, you can get a yummy pastry or slice of quiche, but is it worth being treated like an afterthought (or worse, an annoyance) to the person behind the counter waiting on you? It feels like the people who work there either (1) don't know what they're doing or (2) just don't want to be there. Consistently poor customer service in a community-loved bake shop is really disheartening. Not only that, but if you submit a custom pie order (like we did), there is a chance they'll sell it "by accident" without informing you (like they did to us)... that's horrible! read more

Cute small cafe/ coffee shop in the oak park neighborhood. I stopped in to grab a drink and check out the ambiance on an early morning Wednesday. I decided on a small oat milk horchata steamer. It was a Fall 2023 special. It's incredibly small for the size to the price of $3.75 but was insanely delicious. I believe the cafe could stand to put their prices on the boards regarding the food selections that way patrons are aware. My only only reason for four stars was the price of the drink versus the size. The prices are fairly high but the quality being served is amazing. I will return to check out their savory quiche options. read more

Spilt Milk - Oat milk horchata steamer - A beige-colored, frothy beverage is served in a white, disposable takeout cup with the lid removed and placed beside it. The cup is on a patterned metal table with a geometric design. In the background, part of a person’s arm, a laptop with stickers, and a green drink are visible, indicating a casual outdoor or indoor dining setting. - Bakeries Near Me - Oak Park, Illinois

Clean, warm, welcoming. Beautiful mural on back wall painted by local artist. Nice open artisan bakery where you can watch the bakers in action through the front windows. Cookies, pies, croissants (two choices on the Sunday I visited: 1. Almond. 2. Ham and Gruyère.). Freezer with take and bake options. A few well chosen books, chocolates, etc available as well. Excellent espresso, long draw. The almond croissant was beyond phenomenal. Flaky, lots of slivered almonds, sprinkled with powdered sugar, just the right amount of almond paste. Again, phenomenal. I must confess, about six months ago I had a negative experience with poor service here. But now, it appears the service issues have been addressed and resolved. Five stars plus. Of note, opened at 8a, by 830 no more almond croissants available. read more

See all

Service was exceptional. Light deserts and bakery items were good. Very cozy environment. Definitely worth checking out. read more

Spilt Milk - Peanut butter cookie - A round peanut butter cookie with a crumbly surface and powdered sugar sprinkled on top is placed on a turquoise ceramic plate. The plate rests on a wooden table with visible grain and texture. Part of another baked item in a foil container is visible on the right side of the image. - Bakeries Near Me - Oak Park, Illinois

See all

Delicious pastries. I especially enjoy the Mexican chocolate cookie and almond croissant. Coffee is mediocre but I had drip coffee rather than my typical espresso. Even so, drip coffee can be a litmus for custom coffees. The shop is beautiful with a little seating inside. There's more seating out front and a patio in back. Ambiance is lovely, as is the staff. Everything is pricey but delicious. Parking can be a little difficult but there is some paid parking across the road and a few hours free parking of you walk a few blocks. read more

Spilt Milk - Cookies for every cookie monster - A vertical stack of four brown butter sugar cookies is placed on a small decorative plate. The cookies are golden-brown with a slightly cracked surface. A sign above the cookies reads 'Brown Butter Sugar Cookie $4' and features a small illustration of a black mouse. The background includes other baked goods and a window, suggesting a bakery or cafe setting. - Bakeries Near Me - Oak Park, Illinois

The baked goods are wonderful, the biscuits, scones, cookies and cakes are among the best I've ever tasted. Service is friendly and efficient. Highly recommend read more

Kids love all the desserts here. Pies are okay - our favorite may be one of their apple pies. The staff who took our orders are usually very nice and energized to help. It is a cute bakery - good to see they've expanded. They are very busy, especially around holidays when their lines to go in to pick up pies can wrap around the corner outside! Parking available on streets. Close to trains. read more

I paid $55 for a blueberry rhubarb pie today. That's insane! It was good. But Bang Bang Pie charges $38 for the same pie. I want to go to Spilt Milk more but at that price, I'd rather go to my city bakeries like Bang Bang and Hoosier Mama that are more affordable. read more

Get the key lime pie, it's my favorite. Better than even the ones from Key West. It's fluffy, zesty, and the graham cracker is perfectly crunchy and buttery. I love it here! read more

All of the food here is truly incredible. Have been here many times over the years, the key lime pie is def my favorite. Some other noteworthy items for me are the pecan pie, ham and gruyere quiche and the lemon poppy scone but fr everything is amazing. The staff are very friendly and helpful as well! read more

Love this place food is always amazing and staff is very nice! I always get the pies they always hit!

My friend used to live in Oak Park, and she gifted us this delicious sour cherry pie. The crust is flaky tastiness and held up to the tart cherries. Can hold its own among pies from Hoosier Mama, Bang Bang, and First Slice. read more

Spilt Milk - Tart cherry pie- deliciously flaky crust - A cherry pie with a golden, flaky crust is shown inside a brown cardboard box. The pie has a heart-shaped opening in the center revealing dark cherry filling. The box is lined with white paper, and part of a person's hand is visible holding the box. The background includes a table with a striped tablecloth and some utensils. - Bakeries Near Me - Oak Park, Illinois

Updating to add that I was gifted two pies recently, one from Spilt Milk and one from another Oak Park bakery, and the other one was quite a bit better. If I had been paying for the Spilt Milk pie, I would have been pretty disappointed. With bakeries and coffee places in Oak Park only growing in number and quality, there's just no reason to go to Spilt Milk at this point. read more

This is such a pastry shop, I wanted to buy things I did not need. It is nice to see everyone working while waiting on our goodies to be ready to go. Be prepared to be strong down some gorgeous looking pies, cookies, breads and more. Truly delicious food, nice quality and packaged perfectly for travel. read more

Spilt Milk - Heritage apple pie and cranberry apple pie - The image shows two slices of pie on separate plates placed on a wooden table. The top slice has a golden, flaky crust and appears to be intact, while the bottom slice is partially eaten with crumbs scattered around. The plates are a light blue and a dark blue color, and there are striped napkins and a fork visible nearby. The setting suggests a casual dining environment, possibly a bakery or restaurant. - Bakeries Near Me - Oak Park, Illinois

See all

First time going to Spilt Milk; I've lived in the area forever and JUST found out about this hidden gem in Oak Park! Staff was super nice, my latte was excellent and the slice of pumpkin bread I had was to die for! It feels cozy and friendly and warm! For sure will continue going there now that I found it! read more

Friendly staff, quick service, I tried the turmeric chai and had a meat pie. Both were delicious. A large bench on the side wall and a few tables on the opposite side, gives options for seating. read more

Spilt Milk - Cute and cozy sitting area. - Bakeries Near Me - Oak Park, Illinois

Good thing I don't live in OP anymore! Yet somehow I've still been here a couple times. It would not be good for my waistline for sure. So many good things to try on their menu! We've had the ham and Gruyère sandwich, rainbow m&m cookie, apple pie, coffee with cream, hot tea, and all have been delish! Also got cute sparkly birthday candles here! The staff couldn't be more patient, and nicer. You're paying a slight premium, but honestly it's so worth it! Can't wait until the next time I have an excuse to swing by! read more

After ordering a pie for Thanksgiving, i received instructions to wait for a confirmation text that my item was ready before coming to pick it up. That morning, I called to check because I hadn't gotten any texts. The person who answered was snappy: they were closing so I'd have to pick it up within 30 minutes. When I got there, the woman was quite rude and didn't even have it ready to go on a table, I had to wait for 6 minutes for them to bring it from the back (!). For all that, the pie was just so-so, half of it was left at the end of the night while the other one was wiped out. I decided it's just not worth the price, or the hassle of dealing with the inconvenient pick up process and the prima donnas, especially when I'm hosting and juggling many other details the day of. So thankful for other yummy options in the village read more

So happy to see this place up and running again! One of my girlfriends favorite coffee shops in Oak Park and had been dying to go back. It's always nice supporting a local/small business so we've had good experiences at this location & their prior location a few feet away (haha). I like the inside of the shop, has so many things you can buy and possible gifts for Xmas. Little stocking stuffer kind of gifts. This day we had two cookie and two drinks. One coffee and the other hot chocolate. The cookies were to die for... so tasty & soft and those cookies are the main reason I'll be back. As for the hot chocolate, let's just say I would not order that again. It was not super terrible but it just taste like watered down chocolate oat milk. Coffee was good to. Keep in mind, there is no place to sit in this location (unless we missed something), so it's an in and out kind of coffee shop! Still good times though. Personal Review: 6.1/10 read more

Spilt Milk - Hot chocolate - Bakeries Near Me - Oak Park, Illinois

See all

A sweet neighborhood shop with the cutest vibes inside! Winter specialty drink I had was pretty expensive at nearly $10 (hence why 4 stars instead of 5) but was super delicious read more

Spilt Milk - Iced lavender matcha with oat milk - A hand is holding a clear plastic cup filled with iced green matcha latte topped with foam and oat milk, outdoors on a sidewalk. The background features a mural wall with colorful cartoon characters and abstract designs, with a blue sky above. The image captures the beverage and urban street scene. - Bakeries Near Me - Oak Park, Illinois

AVOID! I agree with the others about them going downhill. There are much better local bakeries in Oak Park. Prices here are much higher than every bakery yet quality is poor and keeps going downhill. Very bad service from all of the very rude teenage staff, food not fresh, charging more than Publican and better bakeries. read more

Here is a new thing--like I said in my last review, if you place an order for a holiday, you must cancel 2 weeks before the holiday- that is ridiculous-- most places take new orders a few days before the holiday. But here is the kicker-- if their holiday cancellation policy is what it is as I just mentioned how come I get emails a day before ( Thursday) to order their ( next day) "Friday Night Dinners"? And they are here felt expensive and you have to heat them yourself! They just upped their delivery fee from $7 to $9 but the website says the delivery charge is based on your order--so unclear delivery fees. Obviously this place doesn't care about their customers, every part of this business cares solely about themselves. Sometimes businesses have to put the customer first- not this place- they are all about their comfort and greed. read more

Oak Park's bakery and pastry shop. Owned by two sisters. I stopped in one day to see what kind of baked goodies were on display. There were pies, scones, cookies and many other baked goods. The shop has a nice old fashioned and trendy look. I quite didn't like the stale smell inside. Strange that the air wasn't filled with sweet flavors. The prices were a bit expensive. Some of the pies looked dry. I just ordered a small lavender latte. It wasn't busy maybe one person ahead of me. But it took 15 to 20 minutes for me to get my latte. Glad I was able to support a local neighborhood family- owned business. But I won't be returning back read more

See all

Was in the area last week and needed 2 pecan pies to take home to Michiana, MI for a Gumbo party dessert. Yelped "Bakeries" and found Spilt Milk on South Blvd, took a ride and was delightfully surprised! Scratched the pecans for an amazing heirloom apple-pear-cranberry crumble pie and a best-ever heirloom apple pie, (witha slice of pecan and peanut butter cookie on the side). The quality of these pies was so over the top, there were only scraps left over. The 2 young ladies helping me were fun and added to the experience. Way to go Spilt Milk! 6 out of 5 Stars!! read more

We got a wide variety of goodies to eat on their back patio; sprinkle cookie, veggie quiche, buttermilk biscuit, and ginger lemon scone. Every single thing was buttery and moist and truly exceeded our expectations. Patio had great seating for the little too! read more

Spilt Milk - Back patio, seating for the littles too! - Bakeries Near Me - Oak Park, Illinois

Spilt Milk has one of the best Key Lime Pie in the area! You ever get that feeling walking into a restaurant or store that you're not welcomed? I always get a ridiculously loud, semi rude associate at Spilt Milk that makes it obvious that they would rather walk over broken glass than help me with my To-Go orders. I continued to patronize them because the location is so close and the desserts are kinda awesome. But Today was the last. They had the audacity to give me rotten fruit on 10 stems of wilted arugula. $13 of fruit from the garbage - Heirloom Tomato, Stone Fruit, & Burrata Salad. If that wasn't enough, they sold the (2) pasta salads I PAID for and had to refund me. Now I know why the guy helping me was so nice because he quickly packed my bag with bullshit as the manager was on her phone and never apologized - b*tvh! She always has a pissy demeanor. Avoid the tall guy as well who last week gave me the evil eye because I refused to take the bag with visible grease spots and put it on my car seats - what a Tool! read more

See all

3 times I have ordered a pie online only to get to the shop for them to tell me they sold it to someone in line. 4 times I was physically in line looking at a pie in the display case only to be told it was already sold online. Staff was rude to me and offered no form of compensation for driving an hr out of my way to pick up a pie that never existed. I was one their first customers 10 years ago. Beyond disappointed in the establishment as the owner told me they aren't worried about my concerns as they pump out $4k+/ day orders. I too am a small business owner and did not expect that response. My family, especially my daughter went without a pie for her first thanksgiving. read more

I come here for the Key Lime pie! Hands-down best I've had here in Chicago. A great pastry shop with many different items. Currently order via toast app and pick up at door. They had hand pies and enjoyed their sweet potato one for lunch on a recent visit. read more

This place used to be the best bakery in Oak Park. That is no longer the case. During the pandemic, they were selling $50 chicken pot pies. They are overpriced and not as good as, say, Broken Tart. read more

I love this place, and it's one of my favorites to stop by on a the way home from work for a little treat (namely their rainbow sprinkled cookie, lol). Their quiche is also great, and I've enjoyed their pies and other baked goods when I've ordered them for holidays and events. The ambiance is very nice, and their wine selection is phenomenal. I also like that they do wine tastings sometimes. Awesome spot! read more

I'm always looking for new dessert places in OP, especially ones that are near me because who wouldn't want to be lazy and eat their cake too? I dragged myself out of my air-conditioned apartment on a particularly hot and humid day just to get me some pie--and I'd do it again. In fact, I wish I'd checked this place out sooner because their pies are absolutely delightful! That's right, I said "pies", plural. I wasn't going to walk 10 min to get a single slice of pie when I could get more, guys. Thoughts: It's a tiny little shop so keep your eyes peeled or you just might walk past it! But don't let the size of this little gem fool you because there's a slew of yummy-looking things inside. How do you choose? Well, you don't, silly! I had the salted honey, chocolate cream, and some coffee to go, but definitely wished I'd also gotten the peanut butter chess and the key lime! The salted honey was a little too sweet for my taste but it was exactly the sugary pick-me-up I needed after walking around in the 93-degree weather. The chocolate cream filling was smooth and rich with a buttery flaky crust that made me wish I'd gotten the whole pie. I just didn't want to look like that sad person getting a whole pie to eat on his/her own. Well, that sad person is a genius because that's EXACTLY what I wanted to do after eating my pies. Oh, there will definitely be a next time, Spilt Milk. read more

Sign and website say they close at 3. Showed up at 2:30 to locked doors. Annoying when headed to a party on a tight schedule.

At one time, this was the best bakery in Oak Park. As of early 2024, this is no longer the case. Their food is pretty good overall. Ordering in there is unfortunately a little complicated, as the staff are sometimes a bit clueless and there's a lot of stuff around they have to find and ring you up for while you stand there between a counter and a big kitchen space behind you, so we can feel cluttered and odd as you order and then stand off to the side, waiting in this big open space and other people can come in and don't realize that it's their time to order. The point is, you can get a little confusing. Good bakery, a little on the price of your side for what it is. read more

Spilt Milk saves the day, again! We had company in town this weekend, so what else should you do but pick-up a quiche from Spilt Milk? We always go with the meat quiche, because why not? It's delicious & filling, & the crust is perfection. The ingredients are so fresh, too. We knew that wouldn't be enough, so we also grabbed the Chai-spiced coffee cake. That was our first time buying it, but it definitely will not be our last! It was a HUGE hit with the fam! Just don't tell them we picked up two of our favorite, yummy breakfast sandwiches, a latte, & a Chai to eat their before we came home :-) read more