We love the pizza and the garlic knots! We make sure to stop here every year. The cheesesteaks are a hit as well!

I have been on the Island for 38 years and not have been to this pizzeria for 20 years. We ordered a simple large cheese pizza. It was delicious with thin crust and plenty of cheese. I will return sooner than later for their fresh read more

KEEP THE PICKLE BOMB!!!! We love this place. BEST PIZZA .. Nothing bad to about the food service or the place. read more

Speakeasy Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Ship Bottom, New Jersey

See all

We went here over the weekend and didn't have a good experience unfortunately. The pizza was reheated and was very hard and crunchy. It also had no flavor in the sauce. The owner yelled at a customer right in front of everyone in the restaurant. Due to the quality of the pizza and the unprofessionalism of the owner, we will not be returning. Editing review based on response: I never feel comfortable saying something is bad when asked "how is everything?" I also was very uncomfortable after the interaction with the owner and customer yelling that I didn't want to cause any more issues. read more

Speakeasy Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Ship Bottom, New Jersey

See all

Ordered pizza and heated it later on the grill. Still delicious! Planning on dining in and trying it hot out of the oven.

Best pizza on the island. Nice crisp crust, lots of cheese and good sauce. Good deals on Wednesday, and fast friendly service. Make sure to check out shark fishing photos on the wall read more

If you've been following me over these last 10 years or so, you KNOW I am NOT a pizza person; it's just not in my DNA even though I am Italian. You make sense of that since I can't. My husband can eat, sleep, and breathe pizza 24/7 without a problem. I knew pizza would be one of our meals while away, and we decided to give this "NY style" place a try since we were both curious. THIS PLACE IS A 10/10 - RUN here; don't walk! The pizza reminds me a bit like a tavern style pizza with how crispy and firm the crust was. The sauce packed the right punch, and the pizza wasn't smothered in greasy cheese; it had just enough! I loved how there was just enough crust to hold on to; I hate too much crust. Walking inside on a Thursday afternoon, you got a great vibe of just being a part of this fun, laid back beach community, with children in bunches at tables, and old regulars. The inside is dated and nostalgic; places like this don't need to have modern decor to draw in a crowd. The pizza alone is enough to bring all the boys to the yard. Called a head to pick up; said 15-20 minutes but it was already waiting for me by the time I came to pick it up! Super friendly staff, and the smells coming from the kitchen still haunt my nostrils. Highly recommend! read more

See all

I came in this place to get one slice of plain for my son, I asked them to cut it in small pieces as my son is developmentally disabled an that is the only way he can eat a slice. A young girl behind the counter cut the slice in small pieces as she was turning around to bring me the slice 2-3 pieces of the slice fell on the floor, I informed her of this, she looks over at an older woman who was doing the cooking who scowls at me a states in a very angry and indignant tone "what!, do you want me to give you another slice"! I stated" as a matter of fact yes I paid for a WHOLE slice I want what I paid for" she responds by calling me a jerk, I stated "excuse me this is how you treat a customer YOU drop some pieces of the slice I paid for and you are calling me a jerk" she responds to me "get out" I said " ok give me my money back" so she gives me my money back and then gives me the slice any way for free! further another customer, an older man walks in, I am assuming she knew him, she then says to him "this guy is being a jerk" I responded "what's he going to do?" as I was walking out I said "maybe you need to learn how to treat a customer. And again she calls me a jerk. I initially informed the young girl she dropped some pieces of the slice, I did not initially ask for a new slice, if the woman would have been nice and said I can give you a dollar off the price I would have been fine with this or at least responded in a professional manner. I cannot believe this person is in a position dealing with customers. I hope the owner sees this review because he or she needs to fire this person! See the response from the owner which states I called the girl who dropped the pieces careless, this is a lie! I stated "you dropped 2 pieces of the slice" she did not see it when it happened, she made a mistake, I was not rude at all. I certainly did not deserve to be talked to or treated as poorly as you treated me as a customer. And yes, I am a grown man, unlike you I know how to conduct myself. You on the other hand are choosing to deflect and blame others for your ignorant behavior. Further, my review is 100% accurate, I left nothing out, you are lying! normally I would not waste my time writing this in detail however, I thought it was important to let the public know what type person you are and how you treat your customers. Oh, and by the way not to worry, there are plenty of other pizza establishments on LBI rest assured you will never see me in your dump again. read more

Great place to grab an Italian meal. Prices are great, special are amazingly affordable, and portions are big. Staff and owner is very nice.

Basic pizza, decent but doesn't stand out in any way. Convenient location in Ship Bottom. Good garlic knots. Nice Italian menu.

Doordash did not show and they personally drove it over. The pizza was AMAZING!! Their customer service was amazing! Awonderful family run business!! Please come to Speakeasy Pizzeria! read more

Very good pizza . First time ordering and I'm not from the area was there on vacation but if I come back will order

Awesome dinner and great service. I got the Kansas City Steak and my buddy got the Godfather as well my wife loved the Vodka Pizza. As a local we love supporting local business. read more

We got speakeasy pizza twice on our vacation and we're very satisfied each time. Being from NJ, I've missed the pizza. I know shore pizza isn't quite the same as regular Jersey pizza, but this was pretty good! The fries are also good too--nice and crispy, so they survive the drive back to your beach house okay. read more

The Wed cheesesteak deal is amazing. Great price for some great food. I like the pizza too but only during the other 6 days of the week !!! read more

The volcano chicken cheesesteak here was amazing! Both the buffalo sauce and the cheese were clearly mixed into the chicken on the grill, and the portion size was great. The buffalo sauce tasted homemade and the habeneros added an extra kick with a little bit of smokiness. The bread they used was not very fresh, but it wasnt soggy or undercooked. Thats the only reason I gave them 4 instead of 5 stars. The service was great, the food came out very fast despite being very busy. The design inside is really nice, it truly feels like an old school beach pizza shop with all the decor and cool pictures. I wish I remembered to take pictures for the review but was with my family and forgot. Great place! read more

A great and easy classic pizza option in Ship Bottom. We love it here. Delicious pizza and classic NJ pizza restaurant vibes. read more

Speakeasy Pizzeria & Restaurant - Classic diner vibes - Pizza Near Me - Ship Bottom, New Jersey

Food was delicious. One of the better places we tried while on LBI for vacation. Prices were a bit high but I believe that's typical for the area! Would definitely recommend to someone traveling in the area read more

Even if I was stoned and this was the only place on LBI to get pizza, I would still have thrown out the two pizzas I just bought. I would not recommend to a friend. read more

Food- I had pizza and a steak submarine sandwich. Both were excellent. The pizza crust was perfectly done, crispy but not burned. Toppings were plentiful and balanced. The steak sub had plenty of meat without having to ask and pay for "extra meat". I ordered the sub fairly plain for the benefit of my wife but the meat was tasty enough that the extras were not needed either for taste or as a distraction to cover for a lack of meat. Service- there were three active servers- two ladies and a young man. ALL were professional and engaging. I had grandkids with me and they interacted with my kids in a gentle and friendly way. I couldn't have asked for more regarding their demeanor. As well the food was delivered in a timely fashion, hot and inviting. Ambiance- the restaurant is a local pizzeria at the beach and its appearance fits the mental image of what a beach pizzeria should look like. So, friendly staff, good food, well priced. Recommended if you're near LBI. read more

Thin crust, delicious sauce, lots of well crafted specialty pies. Our favorite pizza on the island hands down. My 6 year old says, "this pizza better than anything in the world!" read more

The pizza was excellent. Great shore pizza. Service was also exceptional fast service friendly staff. My favorite spot on the island.

Staying two blocks from this place and thought we would give it a try. Sure glad we did. Stuck to the basics. One Sicilian and one reg pie. Both very good. Asked for well done which in my opinion made them better. Would recommend and will be back. Beach Pizza 8 plus. Real score 7.3 read more

Speakeasy Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Ship Bottom, New Jersey

Delicious pizza - nice staff - we ordered takeout and they were slammed, but they were right on point with their timing.

Can't say enough good things about the delicious and interesting combinations on pizzas. Had a Vinnys prosciutto and a Caesar white slice and they knocked our socks off. Been going there for years and normally just order regular plain Pizza and cheese steaks. They are great too- but just love the specialty pies!! I commend everyone there for doing an amazing job! read more

The pizza was delicious!! It was cooked well done but didn't even take more than five minutes to come out. The service was great and everything is priced right! My friend and I will be coming back! read more

No frills BYOB pizza joint. Very kid friendly. Pizza was delicious. Order at the counter. All employees were friendly.

Awesome deals, really friendly, great food and military discount. Manager came right over and took care of us when the gen z had no clue what a military or a discount was... super nice!! read more

Handled a 10 pizza and 3 dinner salad order flawlessly. Pizza was delicious and done well. Thank you for the stress free feeding of a large group. Staff was very friendly as well. read more

Thanks to Yelp my friend and I found this Ship Bottom gem. Fresh ingredients, awesome customer service and an overall great pizza time. We'll be back, for sure! read more

Speakeasy Pizzeria & Restaurant - Arugula Feta Bruschetta Sicilian Pie - Pizza Near Me - Ship Bottom, New Jersey

See all

I vividly remember walking into this place once every week with my Pop-pop when I was little. I would always get a slice of pizza and he would always get the pasta, claiming it to be the "best pizza and pasta for miles." Now although this might not be true, it's darn near close if my memory doesn't fail me. I also remember the employees being very nice towards me and other little kids, as other places don't really acknowledge the kids in a restaurant. And of course, I have to complement the ice cream I got as well. I don't think I need to say anymore! read more

Delicious pizza. We went with traditional plain and pepperoni. Amazing!! Quick and friendly service.

Food and service were excellent. My 2 small kids ate an entire pie by themselves, which was a first. The buratta salad was amazing too. I will definitely stop here again when I'm back in lbi read more

This place is fine. Pretty standard pizza, no complaints. Little bit expensive, but that's to be expected in a vacation spot. They have a daily special that's a good deal if your not too picky. Fries, chicken fingers other kinda fried stuff nothing stands out, nothing is a letdown. read more

We stopped here for lunch a couple weeks ago on a whim, and our meal did not disappoint. They had a specialty pie that day - basically an Italian hoagie on a pizza - that was delicious! Garlic knots were also excellent. We will definitely be back! read more

Overpriced for a slice but I guess that's what you get when you are in new jersey. Overall it was good, order the pizza "well done"

For the inquiring minds: six bucks cheesesteaks on Wednesdays. Not mentioned on website or menu. (Drives me nuts when restaurants only mention offers when you drive by). Another reviewer mentioned Tuesday specials, but didn't see anything about that at the restaurant. The side garden salad was fresh. read more

Speakeasy Pizzeria & Restaurant - Wed Six buck cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Ship Bottom, New Jersey

Absolutely delicious pizza and friendly service. We ordered a pepperoni and a white with spinach. The pepperoni pizza was delicious but the white was amazing. read more

Best pizza on the island. The Burrata salad is delicious. Great food and very nice service.

Everything here is delicious!I love their pizza.Always a good experience.10/10 recommend.