Good pizza but way too much money. Better pies in NYC and Philly for half the price. Not sure if…read morethere's a better pizzeria on the island but I'm up for trying others.

Great pizza and open until December weekends on the Island. Pricey though. Service friendly and…read morewings were meaty.

Grandma pie worth the wait and the price by a long shot. That crust is unbelievable, sauce is…read moreoutstanding and they put down some fresh basil leaves and grated some real nice parmesan right before boxing it up. Everyone was impressed with their slices ... doesn't matter if you're a corner , edge or inside type of person you will be happy. Substantial weight to that pie too. Not greasy at all. We will try the fig poppa next time.

Cold stale pizza with overly sweet sauce - not the worse pizza but definitely not the best on the…read moreshore. The website says you can have it delivered but instead when we called the place, they said they don't and we had to pick them up.

Amazing in every way! The inside was decorated nicely with lights for Christmas…read more We had 7:00 reservations and we had a to wait a few minutes but we didn't mind, they have complimentary pizza in the waiting area which is a very unique touch. Dinner Portions are big in my opinion. The Brooklyn bolognese and chicken parm were delicious. The chicken cutlet was pounded thin, the sauce in both dishes tasted very good and authentic. The server was excellence! She didn't rush us out and we were the last table. Highly recommend making a reservation! Keep in mind it is BYOB

Always a great time, love the Godfather Pizza, the meatballs, and mostly everything. Great service,…read moretoo.

Had a slices of sausage pizza, hot, yummy, and fast. Staff was friendly and no frills…read more Was worth stopping for a quick bite on the way out.

I ordered a slice of mushroom pizza here and it took about 20 minutes to get it, even though there…read morewere only a few people ahead of me. The slice itself was large, but unfortunately it couldn't hold its weight--it was very thin yet not crispy, which made it a bit floppy. I came in craving that classic boardwalk-style pizza, but this just didn't deliver. While it might work if you're looking for a quick bite in the area, it's not the kind of boardwalk pizza I was hoping for.

This pizza is legit. I ordered take out as there are no tables and therefore no service. The…read morelocation is a small spot on the east side of Long Beach Avenue. The crust is chewy and crusty - the way it should be with great flavor. The sauce is flavorful and thankfully not sweet. The cheese is great. The B&T is basic and good. The Margarita is excellent and I recommend getting the Margarita over the B&T. We will not be getting pizza from anywhere else.

Do yourself a favor and give Liberta a shot if you haven't already. Friendly staff and honestly…read moresome of the best pizza on the planet, and that's coming from a New Yorker who eats pizza almost every day. I come to LBI every summer and crave Liberta all year long. Side note -- It's pretty ridiculous that someone would leave a 1 star review without even eating there just because they don't know how to look up a business's hours. Get a grip, Howie B.

I was truly impressed by this new spot on LBI. My parents have quickly become regulars and I was…read morevery excited to try this out. The pistachio mortadella pizza might be my new favorite on the planet. Pasta portions were generous and well flavored. Ambiance was lively and well decorated. Staff was kind and helpful. I'll certainly be back!

Came here last weekend to eat and celebrate with our family post-proposal. Everything was delicious…read moreand loved that we didn't feel rushed at all. The lemon pizza was a stand out for me, and something unique that I will forever associate with that night. Will definitely be back to celebrate again soon.

Solid take out large cheese pizza, reasonably priced, lots of cheese good crust…read more Friendly takeout counter help

Stop here if you have a group that everyone needs a different topping ij their pizza. So many…read moredifferent slices available at the counter. Something for everyone. They have a full menu too but we go her bc our crowd all likes different toppings. Easy lunch and delicious. Tables are usually available, not too crowded.

We stopped in at Anthony's on a day trip to Beach Haven. We have found that pizza on the beach is a…read morewonderfully easy way to enjoy the day. Anthony's was easy on and off of 72, we ordered ahead and our onion and sausage pie was cooked to perfection. It was ready when we arrived and it made for a wonderful day.

I've stopped here a couple of times. The pizza was pretty good. Nothing outstanding but worth…read morerevisiting. However we ordered one night late apparently right before closing. The person on the phone was kind of rude, but it seemed like she just wasn't hearing us so we really didn't think anything of it. When we got there to pick it up, she was very rude and said she told us she was closing and basically walked out the door, handing us our food. It was unbelievable.

KEEP THE PICKLE BOMB!!!!…read more We love this place. BEST PIZZA .. Nothing bad to about the food service or the place.

We went here over the weekend and didn't have a good experience unfortunately. The pizza was…read morereheated and was very hard and crunchy. It also had no flavor in the sauce. The owner yelled at a customer right in front of everyone in the restaurant. Due to the quality of the pizza and the unprofessionalism of the owner, we will not be returning. Editing review based on response: I never feel comfortable saying something is bad when asked "how is everything?" I also was very uncomfortable after the interaction with the owner and customer yelling that I didn't want to cause any more issues.

We ordered a large pie with pepperoni and extra cheese for delivery. It arrived piping hot and was…read moredelicious! The delivery driver was a doll too. Had no problems with service as others had mentioned. Staff were friendly and efficient. The pie was well done and had a nice amount of sauce and cheese. The pepperoni was especially good. Gets 4 stars for the crust which was a little too thick for our liking. Would definitely try another pie or something else from this new pizza place.

Best pizza ever! Nice thin crispy crust! Haven't tried…read moreanything else yet but the pizza.