Ordered the large Stromboli with peppers and fresh basil It was pretty good. Thought it would be a little bigger than what I got. It definitely just looks like their calzones with extra steps... Don't think the current staff knew the difference. Service was busy after 5pm. Lots of orders being placed. Ambiance is small and tight kinda like most parlors in NYC. There has been a huge price hike among alot of local pizza parlors. Paid $18+ for this. read more

See all

I have to update from my previous rating of 5 stars as we have had more than one disappointment with burnt crust and extremely thin crust. On my last experience (yesterday) they managed to burn it and make the crust soggy at the same time. This is my last time. We try and support local businesses and have been going to Solle's for over 2 years. The staff are very friendly and that's why I gave this two stars. read more

Solle's Italian - This is how the crust was so thin and soggy in the center. All the cheese and toppings slid off trying to get a piece out of the box. - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Not many places make Sicilian pizza. The dough is thicker than NY style but not as thick as a deep dish pizza. You can get Sicilian pizza and slices in many NY pizza places, but it's harder to find outside of the area. Solle's makes Sicilian pizza and it's pretty good. Note that they don't often have it at their Madison location (I'm guessing it's not a popular option for college students) but they readily have it at the Fred George location. They have a 3 topping option and we went with mushroom, sausage (which is the NY style sliced sausage) and onions. It was very good. For me, Sicilian pizzas are all about the puffy and crisp edge slices and these were really good. This is going to be a new favorite to order from them. Speaking of ordering: we wanted delivery and while we are in the delivery area for their Madison location (the one that didn't have Sicilian pizza) we are not in their delivery area for Fred George (the location that does have Sicilian). The helpful person that I spoke to at the Fred George location told me that I can also order from them through other delivery services. I'm glad he said that, because that's exactly what I did. And the pizza arrived hot and on time. And we had a great dinner. read more

Solle's Italian - 3-Toppings Sicilian Pizza (with 2 slices already eaten) - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Another hidden gem. It's attached to a gas station. Quick service. I ordered the Stromboli which is filled with mozzarella, pepperoni & sausage w/ a side of marinara. This Stromboli does not disappoint. Full of flavor! Enough to feed 2 people, maybe 3. Can't wait to try this place again. read more

Solle's Italian - Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Excellent pizza and Super friendly peeps! We Got the 20 inch half cheese/ half pepperoni and family at the whole thing. Great thin crust - not soggy and sauce was great- get over to this hidden gem! read more

Drove a long way out of my way to get here only to find a closed sign on the front door. There were people inside. Yelp says open till midnight . But didn't say they were closed between 3 and 5. So I will set here till they come back and see how good the food is. To be continued Very small place, very little parking. Ok here is the rest. They are closed 3-5 then re-open. I got a Stromboli and one with pepperoni, Anchovies, Mushrooms and Onions. This is the best Pizza I've had in years. Positivity delicious Well worth the wait read more

I'm going to preface this by saying my partner and I both work in the service industry, so it takes a LOT of ridiculousness for me to come on here and make a negative review. But here we go. Two nights ago, we ordered one pizza. The ETA was 45 minutes. We waited about an hour, but decided not to fuss too much about it since the game was just ending, and this pizza place was surely busy. After an hour and 30 minutes, we called to check up on the order. We were told it was very busy and it would be another 30 minutes. We were a little bummed and extremely hungry but decided to keep waiting. After 45 minutes, we called again and politely asked for a refund or free pizza, because we live literally only 5 minutes down the road and this was getting ridiculous. We were told no, and that the pizza was coming out of the oven. 20 minutes later, my partner called again and was just placed on hold for over 5 minutes, which led us to hang up and drive over to the restaurant. Upon arriving, there were quite literally only TWO customers inside, and the kitchen staff did not seem stressed or rushed whatsoever. We asked about our pizza again. We had spent over $30 on a single pizza that we waited 2 hrs and 45 minutes for and NEVER GOT, so we were extremely frustrated but still spoke to the staff with respect and patience. They told us the delivery had been picked up 30 minutes ago. We told them we haven't received it and are staying only minutes down the road. Then they said oh, it looks like the delivery driver either kept it or delivered it to the wrong address. They mentioned this was the FIFTH time that had happened in the same night, and offered no solution. We said, okay, can we please get a pizza then? (My god.) And we were told NO pizza and NO refund due to the fact that this was the fault of their 3rd party delivery company. The lady, I'm assuming who was the manager, rambled for a bit about how giving us a pizza would cause shrink and told us we would need to seek a refund through this other company. So basically we were being told that, because this restaurant hired an obviously unreliable delivery company, we had to pay for what happened instead of them. And being that I work in the service industry, I know full well that the cost of the dough, cheese and sauce for this pizza would probably only set this restaurant back a few dollars. We basically just had to leave. Today, we disputed the charge with the cc company and thank god we're getting our money back. But the icing on the cake is that the credit company verified for us that there was no 3rd party company involved. All of our money went directly to Solles and they were lying the entire time. Holy sh*t do not go to this place lol read more

Solle's Italian - a hand reaching for a pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Fast delivery. This food is to die for. I'll eat it for 2 days. I can't express how everything is so delicious. A++++ read more

Solle's Italian - Calzone and Antipasto - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

This is the second time we have ordered Solle's, so I can officially say it isn't a fluke. This place is now my favorite spot to eat in ALL of Tallahassee. In total, we have tried the pizza, the spaghetti, the calzone (which is my favorite calzone in town). HOWEVER, for me, it's all about that meatball sub. I'm Italian and the meatballs and sauce compete with my own family recipe. That's saying a lot. Don't believe this place is THAT legit? Just take a gander at the pics below. Swing by, or have DoorDash deliver. We live pretty far away, and the food has always been piping hot by the time it gets to us. read more

See all

Calzone, delicious Pizza with Italian sausage was really good, reminded me of those we used to get up in Connecticut read more

Great food, best white pizza and the pasta sauce is on point. My daughter who has always been a butter and Parmesan on her spaghetti LOVED their red sauce. The meatballs were moist and tasty. It's our go to for delivery read more

Our daughter told us that this was delicious pizza; she informed us that it was attached to a gas station, but not to let that discourage us, lol. Truly, it was a kind of "hole in the wall" type place, but the pizza was certainly decent; nice, crispy crust (not soggy as is the case with some pizzas). I ordered (for pick up) a small pizza with green peppers, onions, and spinach; my husband ordered the stromboli; also, we ordered garlic parmesan wings. The wings were good but were a tad bit greasy. Note, the place is not really designed for dining in - there is only one table in the place; great customer service, by the way. Overall, we enjoyed the meal and will plan to order for pick up again. read more

See all

Called three times couldn't get an answer thought it because they were too busy drove clear out there only fine the place closed when it's listed as open Yelp you're doing a very poor job of policing the folks you advertise read more

I've only tried their delivery so far. I ordered a meat lovers pizza, and it was very good The crust was New York style which is my favorite and hard to find with the right thickness in Tallahassee. I was very pleased. read more

The best calzones east of the Mississippi River Also enjoyed the lasagna , Service is always with a smile and prompt , it's hard to find fast and good,at the same time but this Solles has managed to do just that , so far with me above average experience for me . Ambiance is just fine for a take out place . Be careful parking because it's a very busy parking lot . read more

Very good food especially their pizza. It's one of the three decent restaurants on the Northwest side of town. Delivery is very prompt. Can't remark on ambience since I've never dined inside. Locally owned as well as the other 2. read more

Anti pasta salad was delicious . One of the best Inhave ever had . Order smaller cheese pizza - my son enjoyed as did I . Would order again if traveling through. read more

Solle's Italian - Large antipasto salad . Yum ! - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Mishap with a 3rd party app! I never use 3rd party apps and always call to order but I don't know why I did it this time. Long story short, the store never received my order and by the time I called it was already late and I had to figure out something else for dinner so I asked for a refund. I called today and the owner was AMAZING! He explained the situation (which I basically already knew, 3rd party apps are the terrible) and while he wasn't able to refund to my card (only the app company can and I can't find information on how to contact them) he offered a full cash refund. Now that is amazing service! They have amazing food and everyone should support this business and NOT 3rd party companies!! read more

Great food and speedy delivery. We've never been disappointed with any item. We'll continue to enjoy their menu, I'm sure.

Solle's Italian is a quality restthat brings solid pizza to Tallahassee. I would definitely recommend a visit here. You won't be disappointed. read more

As a NJ native, this is top notch in Tallahassee. Highly recommend. Friendly staff and owner. read more

Solle's Italian - 16" Plain Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Ordered pizza and wings on Saturday at 7:30pm. Busy night, we expected to wait. At 8:45 our app all of a sudden said order had been delivered. Nope! Contacted Support who offered to place a reorder that would be delivered by 9:30. At 10pm still no pizza and no response from restaurant. It's a shame because their pizza is so good but I will never order from them again. read more

Spend your money somewhere else. Terrible customer service! my order was shorted and they pointed the finger at everyone else. They could've cared less read more

My favorite thing about this restaurant is that they really stack toppings on your pizza. I got a vegan pizza with vegan sausage and mushrooms, and they absolutely piled the mushrooms and sausage on there. The Stromboli we got was also enormous, so you definitely get a bang for your buck. Our food came out promptly, and the staff were personable. read more

Solle's Italian - Vegan 12 inch pizza with mushrooms and vegan sausage - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Nice lunch spot. Another solid 3.5 stars. I was the perfect average Stromboli. Customer service was on point like you would expect from a local diner. Everyone one in the back said hi, and I can tell they really appreciated my business with them. Going back again! I just wish they were in a better location. read more

Solle's Italian - a hand grabbing a piece of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

About a week ago, I decided to try out this new place because I'd heard about the eggplant lasagna and wanted to try it. Since it was just sold on Wednesday, I decided to pick up garlic cheese bread, and mozzarella sticks, and I also tried the tiramisu! The flavor was absolutely perfection! While there, I met the entire family and love the family atmosphere! I promised to come back and get the spaghetti since I was informed they sold beyond meat, because I'm vegetarian. Well, guess what i got for Mother's Day? My spaghetti with Beyond Beef and Beyond Sausage! I'm in love! Solle's is my new favorite spot! read more

Solle's Italian - Spaghetti with beyond beef and beyond sausage! - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

This place competes for one of the top spots in town. They have their own delivery, so we ordered delivery on a Friday night. The phone got a busy signal a few times before I got through, so I know it was a popular place right away. We ordered a white pie with bacon, spinach and tomato and a classic pie with onion, mushroom and pepperoni. Both are AMAZING! My favorite was the white pie because it had so much creamy ricotta and garlic. My fiancées favorite was the classic. He is a true Italian and raves about the pizza sauce, which is a big deal. Overall we will certainly be back (or get delivery again). Love love love! read more

Best italian town. Make sure you follow up. If you're ordering online as they will forget stuff however, the flavor of this kitchen is amazing. read more

This pizza is really good the new York style is the best ive had in town. My husband enjoys thick crust pizza and their Sicilian is on point. Their Stomboli is huge and very good. Their tomato sauce is so delicious perfect amount of sweetness and tanginess. I like that we live a bit far and the pizza still arrives hot when we pick it up and bring it home. If you want good New York pizza this is y our spot!! read more

See all

Great local pizza place with delicious pasta dinner specials! This is a frequently visited spot for my family, and everyone is always friendly whenever you walk in. Highly recommend the white pie and Thursday's stuffed pasta shells special! read more

I was rushing during the lunch hour and wanted something quick, pizza. I arrived here, kind of unsure based on the location and appearance of the building. Never judge a book by its cover, the pizza was amazing. I had there lunch special which is two one topping slices with a drink. I kept it simple, one cheese and one black olives. It tasted great, honestly, a top five all time favorite. I can't wait to go back and order a whole pie next time. I'm new to the area but this could potentially be the best pizza shop in town. Prices are decent and the taste is SUPERB. I rarely leave a review but just had to for this place. Try it, I doubt you'll be disappointed. Next time I'll take a pic, just gobbled the food up to quickly. read more

5/20/24 we ordered med pizza 3 toppings & 12 wings for delivery. They 4got to put the ranch & blue chz in box. The wings were burnt & tasted old. The pizza was tasteless, dry & the toppings were very little. You could have shaped all the toppings together & it would fit on 1 slice. $47 hard earned dollars for this disappointment. It has gone downhill & we will NEVER EVER order from there again. I'll pass this on to whoever I meet so they will not make the same mistake....trusting & ordering their food. We actually made sandwiches cause chewing this was leaving a bad taste in our mouth. It's sad when businesses take your $$ & give you seriously unedited food. Unedible food. Plz do better for the next family cause u no longer have our local support. TY read more

They earned every single penny from me. Went for the first time yesterday and I am blowed. Tallahassee is notorious for having OK food and people hype it up. But when I say this place is the TRUTH?? I mean it. I got two pizza slices add pepperoni and it was the perfect crust to pizza ratio with a well equipped amount of sauce. Also had spaghetti and while I wouldn't get the Italian sausage again the MEATBALLS were well drenched and had steam coming out even when I arrived at home. We add a house salad for health and it reminds me of every other place but it was refreshing for my palette. But what really puts this place over the top is, the customer service! They use the name off the orders and speak to us like HUMANS. The business is family ran and you can tell they have a lot of fun. DEFINITELY will be back. read more

Stopped by and got a cheese pizza, it was absolutely delicious. Closest to a NY slice you can get in town

First time I went there was 01/28/23; everything was wonderful. The pizza was very good and they were so large! Ordered from them again on 02/02/23 and both pizza bottoms were burnt as the attached pics. I emailed them and have yet to hear back from them. I ordered again last night, 02/10/23, thinking the burnt pizzas were a fluke. I told them about the burnt pizzas and no one, I mean no one, said anything. I would have expected an "I'm sorry that happened" or something but no no one said a word. The manager was even there and he didn't say anything. I also noticed the price I was charged was not the price on the menu in the window, all the prices had been blacked out and written over in a marker. When I asked about this, I was told the prices had gone up from the last time they printed the menu. How is this even legal! I won't be going back since they seem to not care about their customers nor making sure they post the correct prices. This is infuriating to say the least. I also believe this is illegal. I went online to see what I could do and fond this from Channel 7 in Miami by an attorney there: Patrick Fraser: "A simple question from Alexandria. Can you show one price on a menu and charge another price nearly twice as much?" Howard Finkelstein, 7News legal expert: "No, you can't. The menu is legally an offer, and when you place your order, it's a binding contract and they have to sell the food at that price." So I will be following up on thsi with an attorney. read more

Solle's Italian - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

probably the best pizza in Tallahassee. Not too thin or thick. Great cheese. The red sauce is pretty close to perfect. Quality ingredients. Just enough St. Jean it. No Edian it's only pick up or delivery. They do one pasta per day as well. read more

Growing up in New York I have high expectations what a great pizza should taste and Solle did not disappoint at all. The texture and flavors were all there. Definitely best pizza in Tallahassee. read more

Ordered Solle's tonight after I made the mistake of initially trying to cheat on them with another place, only to have my order never arrive (I think the GrubHub driver stole it). The pizza was hot and fresh. The service when I walked in was efficient and extremely friendly. Lots of great toppings, the sauce is as close as you can find to NY style in Tallahassee. Definitely worth cheating on my diet. read more

Carry out Italian. Excellent service and tasty pizza. Steady flow of patrons. Will try more traditional dishes in the future if back over that way. Impressed with courtesy and service. read more

Real NY style pizza. Delicious!!!! The staff was super friendly and funny too. Will definitely come back when I'm in town.