My husband, Bob, grew up in New York City eating pizza in Brooklyn and the other boroughs and we laughed before trying Brooklyn Pizza because we've eaten at so many places promising to be NYC-style pizza over the years. But this was the real deal! The crust was perfectly baked like back in the day, not doughy or soggy, and the top reminded him Bob of pizza he used to get working in Manhattan. The person who helped us, Faith, was extraordinarily kind and thoughtful. I'm thinking she may be the owner because she really cared about the quality of service. From now on Brooklyn Pizza is our go to place for quality pizza and excellent service. read more

Real good pizza at a reasonable price! I've never been to the Big Apple myself, but if it's anything like this, get me on the closest train to NYC baby! This gig started out near me on P-cola back in my college days. Ah what times! It has followed me through my move across town to the NW side. Like it's meant to be! Crispy crust with fresh salami and the sauce brings those college days flooding back. read more

I thought I'd do them a favor so I called because our cheese pizza tasted like black pepper. When my husband tasted it then you know the taste of pepper was strong. The lady that answered the phone said that they don't put pepper in the sauce so I told her it was the crust that tasted like pepper. Very disappointed and even more disappointed that she didn't say I'm sorry for the issue. I even said that I wanted to give them a heads up in case some pepper got in the area where they were preparing the food. Not a thank you for letting us know or an I'm sorry. I'm sorry but I won't be back. read more

Wow that was trash. I ordered a plain cheese pizza well done, 10 hot wings and a Diet Coke. Simple right? Not so much... pizza hardly had any sauce on it, tasted bland, wings were decent size but not a bit of sauce on them. They forgot my extra - Diet Coke was the best part of the meal! Lol at least that was cold. I won't be ordering from here anymore. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Plain cheese pizza and 10 wings blah - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

The previous tenant on Fred George Rd was Solle's Pizza. I paid $29.01 for a 20" 3-topping pie from them vs. $29.14 for a 16" 3-topping pie from Brooklyn Pizza. For whatever reason BP overcharged by more than $4.00 according to their take-out menu.The crust was good, but the toppings were minimal. I could barely see the spinach, let alone taste it. We'll find a different place that hopefully won't rip us off! read more

I love New York pizza so I decided to check Brooklyn pizza out. I sat down to dine in and place my order right away. I ordered mozzarella sticks and a slice of pepperoni pizza. I had to wait a long time for my food. The mozzarella sticks were decent. The slice of pepperoni pizza was pretty good in comparison to New York pizza. I heard they have a great lunch special! I'll be back to try out some more menu items. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Mozzarella Sticks - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Using my credit card on Saturday November 18 I placed an order to deliver my granddaughters pizza at approximately 8:20pm. When my granddaughter called me saying she never received the pizza, I immediately called Brooklyn Pizza and spoke with a man who never identified himself to ask why. He initially said a woman named "amaris" (sp) picked up the pizza. I told him that my granddaughter nor her babysitter knew any woman by that name nor did either receive the pizza. Both had been eagerly awaiting the pizza and were sitting outside the apt and never saw the delivery. The man then said, (with a nasty attitude) "ma'am we never got any order. What was the name of the order?" I gave him my name, my daughters name. I then gave him the number of my order which I was looking at. I then asked him again "who is Amaris" because I heard you ask me initially who was a woman named "Amaris" that picked up the pizza he then said with an even nastier attitude,"ma'am I'm telling you nobody here even placed an order you need to find out door dash or whoever placed the order because we don't have a way to track orders." After researching Door Dash told me they could see the order was placed by my husband as a pick up and someone named "Amaris" picked up the order at the restaurant Brooklyn pizza. I then called Brooklyn Pizza again. This time I spoke with a woman. She told me "there are only 2 of us and none of us received the order nor did anyone pick up a pizza." I then asked her who was the other employee who sounded as a male. She then said "oh yes there's a male but he didn't receive an order and he didn't sign for a pizza." She offered to contact Door Dash & call me. After speaking with her, she said Door Dash needed to speak with my husband, and I because there was some misunderstanding. I called Door Dash again and they again said "Please contact your bank because we are showing Brooklyn Pizza made the pizza then wrote that they (Brooklyn Pizza) would deliver the pizza and did but they did not write what apt they left it nor did they state that they actually delivered or who received it. Please call your bank immediately." We then called Brooklyn Pizza. A man, the same man I spoke to the first time, answered and immediately he was nastier... indifferent as he again repeated "we never received an order...while, "yes we got other orders but none of them using your name...none of the orders we got even sounded like a order you made so I don't know what to tell you. Call Door then." I asked him his name. He then hesitated then said "I'm Edward." I asked his last name. He refused to give his last name. I then asked the name & contact of his supervisor. He said verbatim "I'm not giving you my last name and yeah I'm the manager...I'm the only person on over everybody so they're nobody who can talk about you or what happened so I'm the only one who can do anything." I told him I found that hard to believe and due to how indifferent, nasty and obviously dishonest he has been behaving from the first conversation, he knows he messed up BOTH orders and knew, especially, the second order after Edward knew the unnamed female employee told me how to place the second order from their website brooklynpizzatally.com and did. Now both of those orders $31.78 and $24.10 ORDER # 1E2860B4 Nov 18 7:21pm 22.55 ORDER # 7117A533 7:03pm (pickup) never delivered to my granddaughter. At 11AM Sunday: My granddaughter & babysitter notified me that the neighbors saw the pizza left on the ground in front of the apt door of a vacant apt. sometime after 9pm Saturday. They did not remember seeing a delivery person. First off, both employees affirmed they had not cooked or seen an order let alone acknowledging they delivered a pizza yet witnesses saw the pizza in a Brooklyn Pizza box. Today at 2:41pm I have not heard from Brooklyn Pizza once. I need BOTH charges reversed. Immediately. read more

See all

Wanted a break from the holiday food and went to a "go-to" quick meal - pizza and wings. We wanted to try a different pizza place this time and chose Brooklyn Pizza (for delivery). I ordered the veggie pizza, which included mushrooms, tomatoes, broccoli, artichoke hearts, and eggplant (a bit different from the usual mushrooms/green peppers/black olives/onions veggie pizzas). My husband ordered the steak and cheese sub, which was quite sizeable. We also ordered buffalo wings. Everything was good; will definitely plan to order from this place again. Next time, I will try the Spinach and Feta pizza! read more

See all

2nd time ordering from here. Super fast delivery. Pizza is not your run of the mill fast food pizza. It's really good. Best pizza I've had since I've been in Tallahassee read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

The pizza was delicious. Definitely, New York style! Friendly service and good place to sit down for a bite to eat. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Extra Large 18" Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

I gave the Uber eats delivery person a bigger tip because I felt bad since they had to deliver this box of disappointment. A medium calzone is thin, which I didn't know was how some places view this item. It wasn't mentioned on the menu. The mushrooms were still wet and had the distinct taste of the can they came from, showing that the calzone was cooked just long enough for the bread to be done but not long enough to cook everything inside. For 15 bucks I should feel moderately full, which I'm not. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Medium calzone with 2 toppings. - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

The large 2 topping pizza was tasty but very oily. Salad was mediocre. No ambiance but excellent service. They were the only one open so for that they get an extra star read more

Passing through town. Ordered from grub hub. Driver was great! Pizza was good. Thin crust Hawaiian with sausage (sausage was weird thin slices). Amount of toppings was ok but nothing to write home about, kinda skimpy. Caesar salad was tolerable. Not very much cheese. Mostly lettuce and 4 Groupons. Not worth the money. Would I order again passing through, probably not read more

Looking for a new place near our home, we made the mistake of ordering here. The medium 2 ingredient meatball Calzone looked very good on the surface but upon further inspection the meat was lacking, there was more cheese and onions than anything else, and it looked like they thinly sliced 1 small meatball. Next was the large Hawaiian pizza, although it had good flavor, it was lacking in pineapple and ham and the crust could have been cooked a little longer. Pizza in my highschool cafeteria back in the 80's was better. The flavor of the ingredients was good and that's about all. read more

See all

Kind of hidden off W Pensacola but very nice environment. Better than expected, 7 dollars for these and a drink with the lunch special. TVs showed English and Spanish shoes. My gf got the pizza and salad and said the salad was the best salad she's had in Tally. Def consider giving this place a try read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pepperoni Rolls (5 Pcs) - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

These are a few of my favorite things, Brooklyn and Pizza. When you combine the two, enlightenment may be achieved. There's a certain authenticity and more importantly, a specific taste that comes to mind when you think of a slice from the City That Never Sleeps. In Tallahassee, we have Brooklyn Pizza. And it's a damn fine slice of pie. Chewy, dense, and a crisp crust make for an above average pizza. The Supreme is loaded with meats and veggies and the flavor profiles pair well together. Of course an extra sprinkle of Parmesan and red pepper flakes don't hurt, either. The garlic knots are garlicky and this guy ain't complaining. Not the best knots in town, but still decent. Garlic, cheese and bread. Don't expect much else. Honestly, what else do you really need, though? Brooklyn Pizza has outstanding lunch specials. $6 (tax included) for 10 different options. Truly, a steal. The store is usually quiet - I've never encountered a rush. However, they're open late. Until 3 am on weekends! Now, I'm no genius but instead of ringing the bell for a taco (wink) during those late night hours, call up the great, local pizza joint on Pensacola Street. You'll be glad you did. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Knots - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Really good pizza, there was a hurricane a few months ago, and me and girlfriend were searching all over town for a place to eat and they were one of the only places open. They were really friendly and even gave us some free sauces for our wait. If you love New York style pizza this is the place to go! read more

Hailing from the 718 I was intrigued, would this pie be reminiscent of the motherland? I ordered the cheese pizza & hot garlic parm wings for lunch. The crust is thin and crisp on the edge but soft within perfect for folding & wasn't drowned in sauce which is appreciated! The wings were good just a heads up the hot in the hot garlic parm wings is essentially buffalo sauce. Overall a good place for a thin crust pizza I'm used to a bit more flavor but ya can't win 'em all. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Ordered a cauliflower pizza online, paid for it. Went to pick it up 45 minutes later only for the girl at the counter to laugh and say "Oh, we canceled your order because we don't have any more cauliflower crust." Be careful ordering because we were charged and will take 5-7 days for a refund!! read more

Pizza Very delicious I love this place. I would recommend this place to everyone. friendly employees, clean environment

Two stars for effort I have a head ache from the amount of sodium in there sauce. I'm from up North this pizza is not from NY. It's a cardboard dough soggy fried wings and the pasta?! I tried it twice just to see if maybe we might get something good from it. read more

Traveling through Tallahassee I stopped at my go-to pizzeria. Brooklyn Pizza never disappoints. I asked the owner to open a second location in Florida so that I could get my favorite pizza more often. The crust is always delicious and the toppings are fresh! I am so happy I found this little gem. read more

Best Veggie Pizza, Stromboli, Cheese knots and chocolate covered cannoli The service is awesome and they are open 7 days a week from 10:30 in the morning to 11:00 at night. They are even open on Christmas Eve and Christmas read more

Brooklyn Pizza - a menu on a table - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Been here a few times now, they are consistent and always deliver a great meal. Along with that the serivice team is great!

Brooklyn pizza is a good local pizza joint to bypass corporate bland pizza. Definitely above average and tasty. The draw here is definitely the value. I ordered delivery through Penny Delivery and my order came through within 40 mins. So not bad. I got the Garlic Chicken White Pizza which I've never had before anywhere. Delicious and satisfied that pizza craving I had. Garlic taste wasn't strong so if I had one criticism would be for more, but that's just a personal preference. Pizza was chewy but had crispy crust which I LOVE. Overall good pizza joint to try outside of your usual Pizza Hut or Papa Johns read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Garlic Chicken White Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Good Pizza - no frills menu - self serve soft-drinks AND iced tea. The "sell" here is the value. The lunch special is a winner (six bucks). If you want pizza - and you're close-by, then by all means come. It's worth passing every corporate pizza to buy it. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

I feel bad giving a bad review. The service was not good. The pizza tasted really bad. It's very unusual to get a bad pizza. Their crust, sauce, and cheese were not good. I ended up tossing most of the pizza because no one wanted to eat it. read more

Gross pizza. They used canned mushrooms. The veggies were soggy. Barely any pepperoni. Asked for crispy hot wings and they were not crispy or barely cooked and not hot wings at all, more like mild sauce. Find a different pizza place is my recommendation. read more

Simple order of 2 cheese slices was a disaster. We were given old slices of pizza that they put different cheese on and reheated. Dough was tough and flavorless. Restaurant conditions were under par. Would not recommend. read more

Best pizza in town, the staff is wonderful, and the pepperoni rolls will change your life. Seriously, order them. Brooklyn Pizza never disappoints! read more

Ordering from here was a huge mistake. The pizza was stale, extremely thin and arrived cold with a hard thin crust. It was just horrible especially after waiting an hour for the order. I didn't eat it. read more

Best NY Style pizza in town. Great price, great food, and fantastic staff! Seriously, you won't be disappointed.

Really like this place! Pizza is tasty, thin crust, NY style! Also reasonably priced! (: Best for takeout, the inside is very small but has a couple of TVs usually with sports on. read more

My roommate orders probably once a week. He is a loyal customer. He ordered 20 hot wings. He only got 18... of the 18 received; 12 toothpicks and 6 small for average. They usually aren't the biggest wings but this is completely embarrassing for Brooklyn. I will never order from Brooklyn again. Look at picture attached for reference. I know it's a college town and it's probably get what ya pay for... but this is the worst group of chicken ever assembled. These chickens must've been the most underfed chickens in the history of the world. Overfried, overcooked, whatever it is... it's sad. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Note: these haven't been eaten already. These are what they actually delivered. - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

I ordered 10 piece chicken wing medium with blue cheese that cost $9.95 and a small Italian salad for $4.95. To my disappoint, when my door dash driver delivered the food I received 2 large Italian salads. I immediately called the restaurant to make them aware of their error. The manager and employee I spoke were rude and weren't even willing to review my order. They did not offer to see receipt or even try to have come in. They making weird accusation when I had a receipt to prove what I paid for. My advice is to go to the Wingstop (1964 W Tennessee St #4) or Buffalo Wings (392 S Magnolia Dr) down the street from them. I ended ordering my wings from the Wingstop and my order was correct and there was no rudeness. read more

I got a pizza and the pepperoni rolls. They tasted great, and you could tell even the garlic butter that this business takes time to get their food right. The delivery driver couldn't find my apartment so the food wasn't very hot, but even warm the food was still worth it. read more

Nice comfy small place. Great atmosphere. Front door parking. Had a good size pizza slice , not exactly NY original. Pizza definitely thin, good flavor ; sauce not potent with the cheese just a mild robust blend. The pizza crust was hard waitress explain defining it Brooklyn pizza due to how it's made thin. I a NY know NY PIZZA is thin, but deliciously dripping oils from cheese. The NY eater gives it a different taste. Overall I recommend Brooklyn pizza. read more

See all

If you've been searching for a great, simple NY style pizza joint, look no further. Great value, excellent customer service and a phenomenal rendition of thin crust, no frills pizza. Perfect balance of cheese, sauce and pepperoni. You know the pizza is good if it only requires one topping at the most. Hats off to Brooklyn Pizza for not trying to reinvent the wheel...simple is sometimes best. If Tally has a "comfort food" pizza, this is it...no imported ovens, overpriced pies or gimmicks. I only wish they weren't on the other side of town. I can't wait to go back! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Thin and greasy...very New York! - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

I don't know where those low stars come from. I went to Brooklyn Pizza for the first time today. I got a small pizza and it is enough for 1 person. I am a person that eat a lot and I saw some of the reviews said the pizza is"small". IT IS NOT SMALL AT ALL! If u are a large pizza guy, then don't order a small one and blame the size! Also, the pizza is fantastic! It reminds me of the homemade pizza by my grandpa, and the owner looks like my grandpa too haha! He and his staff were super nice and patient. Anyway I will certainly recommend this store to my friends and Ill definitely come again! read more

Great pizza. Perfect amount of crisp and great flavor! Crust,sauce and toppings were amazing! Will for sure order from again next time we're visiting! read more