Dave's Pizza Garage is always on point. The pizza is consistently great, and the cheese curds are a must--crispy, melty, and impossible to stop eating. Everything comes out hot, fresh, and done right. It's one of those reliable spots you can count on when you're craving good pizza and comfort food. No overthinking needed--Dave's delivers every time. read more

while I was in Tallahassee for work for a few months, I tried to have pizza on Fridays as a way to relax and decompress from the week. I was on this part of town because I found a sauna to try and on my way back to my hotel I looked up the closest pizza place. This place was busy and seems like a neighborhood favorite. I was quickly greeted and ordered a pizza and a salad and went outside outside to sit on their very large patio. My food was brought to me in a timely manner. It didn't take too long, but it was definitely cooked fresh. I made it a pattern to get a Bianca style or no tomato sauce type pizza and a Caesar salad at most of the restaurants. I tried while in Tallahassee. So I ordered a pizza with a non-tomato base. It was absolutely delicious. Well cooked good toppings and I really liked it. The Caesar salad I added chicken too because there was no meat on the pizza and I believe they don't charge extra for chicken so that was nice. The salad was great. Everything was great and the atmosphere seems like a fun family place to have pizza. They also had ice cream. And if I wasn't full and moderately lactose intolerant, I would've gotten some ice cream. But again I was staying in a hotel with no freezer so I didn't wanna risk having to eat it quickly. read more

Dave's Pizza Garage - Famous white pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Daves has been one of my favorite local spots for quite some time. I first started coming here when my wife and I started dating and I've been coming back ever since. I miss the old school arcade games but the pizza is still good. We end up getting the same pizza every time we come, the Cheap chicken finger. It's something about a fried chicken that just does it for me. We always get extra Buffalo sauce and it hits the spot. I would recommend this place to anyone looking for a good pizza spot. read more

Dave's Pizza Garage - Fat Tire and Root Beer - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

We took the kids for pizza. The inside of Dave is nice and quaint. The atmosphere was pretty good too. The staff was good. The only issue I have it closes too early. The kids and I got a pepperoni pizza. The crust was very good and lots of pepperoni. My wife got the penny pasta with cheese. We got a strawberry shake for the kids. It was not very thick. They need help on their strawberry shakes. read more

See all

It would be greatly appreciated if you would update your website, socials, and on-site advertisements regarding promotions. As a new customer going out of their way after verifying the Mystery Envelope information across multiple platforms, it was such a waste of time and money only be told unapologetically by staff during pickup that they had run out (over two weeks early) and had no plans to resupply. read more

Amazing place would love to compliment the owner food perfect service amazing ambiance stellar love the restraunt love the food

The pizza cheese, sauce , and crust are all very good . My pizza could have been cooked a wee bit more to my liking but still 5 star over all experience in eating pizza here In Tallahassee. My dog Ace gave it 5 stars for looks and smells. I'm a homemade pizza guy and I still give Dave's 5 stars too . read more

Dave's Pizza Garage - My dog Ace - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

This is still a great place to get delicious pizza. I just wish they were closer to home so I could come more often. Tried Bradley's sausage pizzas today with the picky eater getting Bradley's and extra cheese and this adventurer trying the Bradley's Devil Dog pizza. Both were delicious. In all of the visits we have never been disappointed by what we had. Dave's has a unique and creative menu with many tasty options. You order at the counter and they bring your food to you. Service has always been friendly and efficient. They give you styrofoam cups to fill your drinks from the machine nearby. There is a large outdoor dining area (handy during the pandemic) and a comfortable dining room inside with booths and tables. read more

See all

We've lived in Tally for about three years now. This is the best pizza I've found. We had a supreme with extra cheese. Amazing! Crust is light and not greasy. Ingredients are fresh. read more

Pizza was excellent, service was smooth, next time we will dine in and enjoy the ambiance. We did a quick pick up, staff being very busy, but still nice, friendly and accommodating. Great place! I will go again. read more

Filthy! Owner yells at employees in front of customers. It is so dirty. You can see the dirty kitchen. Not worth it, even eating outside on dirty porch. GO to Brickyard Pizzaria! Better everthing! read more

NEVER DISAPPOINTS we've been ordering from Dave's for years and have introduced to many friends since they were located in town and at the new location. Love the pizzas and the salads read more

We ordered wings and garlic bread for dinner tonight. Takeout. The wings were overcooked, dry, and hard. Inedible. There was not a hint of garlic in the bread. Very disappointing and unacceptable. read more

I love everything about Dave's. Their pizza is unBILLSlievable. Never had a bad experience. Staff are welcoming and treat you like regulars even when it's been a long time between visits. It's always clean and GREAT for families. You don't have to feel guilty for having children when you come here! I could go on. But really you should just check it out yourself. You won't regret it. read more

The pizza and staff are excellent. Covid is over so how about using real silverware? Quit wasting resources. The owner has horrible taste in music. But again the pizza and salad were great. read more

Great pizza and location! My UPS husband loves delivering to the owner and encouraged me to order. I was pleasantly surprised. Our new go to for pizza! read more

We made it 30m before closing for me to enjoy a personal pan pepperoni pizza and for my guy to get a personal pan chief chicken finger with extra buffalo sauce. Lo and behold, who is there to bring the pizza and Abita root beer? Dave! We talked it up about his teaching days turned pizza chef and dug in on one of the best pizza spots in TLH. His location is 30m from where we live, and it's a bit of a "do we want?" But we always do it with no regrets. Next time I'll experiment with different toppings to turn it up a notch. read more

Dave's Pizza Garage - The infamous pepperoni pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Dave's is a local gem - excellent food, service, and location. Great for any occasion to dine in or carry out. Would definitely recommend as a regular staple or to anyone passing through! read more

Only 978 miles from Houston to Tallahassee Florida to get some of the best pizza in the country. After doing a YELP virtual event a few months ago with Dave's Pizza Garage , I was completely inspired in making pizza at home and knew I had to order some when visiting Tallahassee over Memorial Day weekend. OUR ORDER: Cheese pizza on the most delicious crust you will ever taste.The sauce was reminiscent of New Jersy style from a moms Italian kitchen .Complete and utter deliciousness.For cheese lovers you will not be disappointed. They can customize light or heavy cheese and customize any ingredients. Margherita pizza was also beyond decadent with lighter cheese fresh tomatoes and a sprinkling of aromatic basil Try the Cheesy breadstick nubbies with garlic cheese .These were so good I would drive another 900 miles just for these. The large pizza's were enormous and cut into generous slices . THE SERVICE: Even though we missed the owner Dave today, we experienced excellent customer service from Hannah who took our order and James who provided extra secret dipping red sauce freshly made . I will absolutely be back next time in Tally because I am pretty sure they won't deliver to Htown. One thing is for sure.You will be happy to be in a food coma at the end of your meal. read more

See all

Dave's has really good pizza, but they also have salads, chicken Parmesan, and many other things. On top of that you can get beer and wine, and they have really delicious ice cream flavors. Just a great family place. There's also covered outdoor seating. read more

So good! We got Dave's delivered on a lazy Sunday night and it was so yummy. The pizza was delicious. We got pepperoni and it's the pepperoni that flips up when cooked (the best kind). The pepperoni has amazing flavor and the cheese is thick! This is not thin, NY style pizza. It's thick crust and very very filling. But, that did not stop me from indulging in the delicious five cheese calzone. It's bread filled with cheese - my two favorite food groups - so to say I liked it would be an understatement. The appetizer was so-so. Don't get my wrong, I ate them but they just didn't compare to the pizza and the calzone. Overall, this restaurant is super delicious with a great menu. Prices are very reasonable. I would highly recommend them! read more

See all

I was craving some serious yummy food. I have had Dave's Pizza Garage in the past and loved it. I order a box of mild and a box of hot wings with a large cheese pizza my tummy was very loud about its feelings. The food came out quickly, hot, and just as I ordered it. The wings were cooked perfectly with a crispy skin. Their house made sauce was a match made in heaven. I enjoy these every time I come here or have a to go order. The cheese pizza was tasty. It did not disappoint. They do offer a variety of toppings. Overall, the service and food were great. I will be back again. read more

Did a take out for a GTO pizza- a margarita pizza with chicken. Enjoyed the fresh basil, especially. Love their thin crust- not like a cracker, just thin and tasty. read more

Place never disappoints. Best pizza in Tallahassee hands down. Fresh ingredients every time.

Dave's Pepperoni Pizza is really special. It hits the spot every time in an almost nostalgic way. Maybe the tiny pepperonis remind us of the Oscar Mayer Lunchables once-adored by us millennials across the nation? Of course, we're discussing a much better quality sausage now that we've entered our '30s. The pepperoni's edges brown and spring up as the pizza bakes. The crust and marinara are solid and I can promise you that both the take home pizza kit and taking home a pre-baked pizza to go are worth making the drive to Bannerman Crossing for. Because of the restaurant's name, it's easy to forget that they serve more than pizza, but don't forget about their wings! You can buy Dave's Signature Wing Sauce by the bottle and after tasting it, I will continue to buy it by the bottle. It's a vinegar-based sauce that tastes a bit like a thicker, more complex and aromatic Crystal Sauce. It might be the perfect wing sauce. If they are serving them, the Toasted Teriyaki and Hooter Brown Beer-B-Q sauces are also delightful. This is a family-oriented restaurant that puts care into the food out of love for the people they serve. Dave and his team are wonderful folks serving great comfort food. I'm a customer for life. read more

Ordered a few pizzas and some cheesy breadsticks for a small-ish family gathering last Sunday and Dave's came through with the timing and food! All the varieties of pizzas we had were so good and good at every size which isn't always the case. The service I got on the phone was excellent and when picking up as well. Everyone's favorite was obviously the pepperoni. I highly recommend Dave's for some great local 'za. No pics cuz we ate it all. And they gave us yummy cookies because obviously they love us back! read more

Yum! The pizza was delicious. The chicken on it was juicy. There was option to sit outside or inside. You can ask to see how big the sizes are and they will show you the pizza pan before ordering. I also appreciated the Christmas ambience and looking at the Christmas tree during my mealtime :) read more

Dave's Pizza Garage - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

This is a five star establishment. I was introduced to DPG through a virtual Yelp event and I forgot half of my ingredients at home. I reached out to Dave and he graciously said I could get another at-home pizza kit! I decided to play an order to try out some of the other items I heard mentioned on the virtual pizza making event. I had a cheese pizza kit I put together myself, their BBQ wings, full-sized savory apple salad, fried cauliflower bites (Starter Spark Plugs) and for dessert I tried their mint chocolate chip ice cream, cookies n cream, brookie *and* chocolate chip cookies (clearly I wanted to try a lot) ! But I'm glad. It was so good! The salad was delicious! I only wish I ordered extra dressing and there was enough for both my hubby and I to have some and still have leftovers. The wings were saucy and delicious and also great sizes. The ice cream was perfection! read more

See all

Yesterday was my first time at Dave's Pizza Garage. I was served by James primarily, but also Hannah. They were so helpful and courteous. James said they are known for their meat-stuffed pizza logs and wings. Since I don't eat meat and asked about vegetarian options, James recommended the five-speed cheese calzone, the cheesy lugnuts (cheese curds), and the Brookies (chocolate brownie decadence)...I got them to go, and started eating the cheese curds on the way home. Everything was fabulous. I especially enjoyed the unique way the calzone is made...I liked it better than most calzones I have had in my life! I also really appreciated how safe the restaurant felt. Inside dining is closed, and the outdoor seating is nice and covered. They also have heaters outside (not that we would need them very often here!). I ordered a local brew, Lake Tribe Satsuma wheat, while I was waiting on everything cooking, and it was delicious. There were many other local brews to choose from including my favorite Deep Brewing. I was impressed with all the safety protocols in place. Next time I go, I'm going to order some chocolate mint ice cream, too! It looks like they have a nice selection of ice creams. My only suggestion for improvement would be to stop using styrofoam...I would pay more for more sustainable options. Thanks to the initial introduction to this restaurant by Tallahassee Foodies then a great event by Yelp plus ordering some awesome food, I am now a fan of Dave's Pizza Garage and I will be getting take out from there again. read more

See all

Okay. I've known about Dave's for some time, but never made it to their old location, or their new location, until now. Wow. This is good stuff. We did 15 mild wings (kids present) and a large meat pizza. The wings were great. Now my new favorite wings in the NE of Tally...make that all of Tally. Really crispy and the sauce was spot on. The pizza was delish. My son declared that it beat out his other favorite in town, now to be his new favorite. It is a very good pie, different than anything else in town. I love the pepperonis as it reminded me of a pizza join I grew up eating from as a kid. Give this place a shot. This isn't anything like the old restaurant that was here...a definite upgrade to the location and to the NE area of Tallahassee. read more

Dave's Pizza Garage - The meat pie. Those pepperonis rock. - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Ordered the cheese and pepperoni pizza. Very good! Reminded me of the pizza when I lived in Buffalo. So glad to have a good pizza spot in Tally. Staff were very friendly. Look forward to going back to try other items. read more

This is easily the best pizza place in Tallahassee. From the owner to the servers to the people cooking your pizza everything is amazing. The flavors are great. I cannot recommend this business enough Dave thank you for being an amazing business owner in Tallahassee. read more

I've been going to Dave's to support through the COVID pandemic. They have a pick up window to keep workers and customers safe. They offer $17 Yuengling jugs to go from their keg and give you a coupon to use to get 10% all of your orders from April through July. Please support this local business. read more

The pizza isn't my fav but good lord the poutine and beef on weck is with the five stars. Thank you for giving tally a taste of the north.

Best pizza in Tally! Awesome crust with great tasting and fresh ingredients.

Can't remember how many times I've been here but I can say each time is delicious! I always crave this pizza after a hard day at work. read more

Dave's Pizza Garage - Curled pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

My husband and I had a great late lunch at Dave's the other day. Everything was cooked perfectly! I get my pizza without sauce, and they have no issues accommodating any special request. As you can see I had them deconstruct the Poutine (I really like my fries crispy) and it was SO good - lots of cheese and gravy that was delicious!! The pizza is very good - a soft crispy crust (if that makes sense) not chewy or hard. Mine has shaved ham with crispy bacon and I always enjoy it!! My husband really enjoyed his Supremo pizza - he did say the pepperoni has a bit of a kick, but not too much that you couldn't enjoy it. Every time we have ordered the Lugnuts they have come out perfectly hot and crispy (not greasy at all) I have eaten there several time now and have not been disappointed at all!! I would highly recommend them when you are on that side of town!! read more

We were pleasantly surprised to find the owner fared from Buffalo new york and they had roast beef on a Kimmel wick roll. Amazing sandwich brings backs memories of my time in western New York. A true find in tallahassee read more

The food is very good and the family friendly ambiance is very easygoing. Everything is freshly made. The staff is always welcoming.

In my search for gluten free pizza, we stopped at Dave's. The GF Pizza was good, but it was not great. It came in its own little tin tray, indicating to me it was likely purchased and not prepared in house. I get it... gluten free is challenging, particularly for pizza, but the obvious absence of work on this meal made me think my frozen pizza of choice would have been a better option. I will say, the wine was a hearty pour and a nice accompaniment to the pizza pie. read more

See all