Craving a NY style pizza, came to Milano's and they deliver!!! Thank you Durium and staff!!! Delicious food, easy going atmosphere and did I already say delicious food!!! Glad you serve Tallahassee!!! read more

Milano Pizza - Slice of Cheese and a slice of sausage! - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

This is the place if you are in the mood for a great calzone or pizza. The staff is easy to work with and the owner is nice. I wish I'd captured photos but I didn't. One pizza I had was meat with onions and dollop of ricotta cheese. It was a hit. My calzone was two meals for me. This is now my go to place for takeout pizza and calzones. I am going to try some of their other dishes though. read more

Your family is wonderful. Their staff is also wonderful. Very friendly service and it's great. The pizza is awesome! My brother and I love the meatballs the steak and cheese sub chicken parm sandwich. I haven't had anything else, but, I have to venture out and try the rest of the menu. Very peaceful and relaxing. People were talking, but they weren't shouting like a lot of restaurants and I don't like load places. I eat out a lot I don't like to cook. Had my own kitchen in Miami in the 80's and a catering business in Ma. read more

Pizza crust it so good. Two slices of pepperoni pizza which I rate as 7.6 we're just right and I will be back. read more

My Wife and I Were greeted by the owners Son, as soon as we arrived. From the time we were seated ordered and waited for our food to arrive, Great service, great food and a great place to eat authentic Italian food! We will definitely be returning customers soon! read more

Fantastic food. Wonderful service. And, the take out is just as wonderful as the dine-in. How often does that happen in this town??!! And, they're right down the street. What they call a medium pizza, most places call large. Their"baby" pizza is a medium elsewhere. Generous portions, toppings. Love it. read more

Both the pizza and the Caesar's salad were just average it was the cost that blew us away. My wife went in to pick it up and paid $42.00 for a medium pizza with three toppings and the salad. When we got home and she told me the price I called and got the manager who was surly and gave me a poor rundown on the charges. I'm leaving a photo here so that you can see what we got for our $42.00. I'll leave it to you to decide if I'm nuts for thinking that this is wrong. read more

Milano Pizza - Pizza and salad - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Just got done eating a medium pie with mushrooms and enough for three people. Very good and the crust is true New Yorker pizza. We are from Philly and know what a good pizza is. This place is it. Looking forward to the calzones. The pizza was room temperature due to Door Dash. Not Milano's. Will be back again. read more

will be back! Ordered two slices ( one pep and one cheese) we ended up loving it and ordered 2 more. Only jersey/NY style in town.

The food & service was phenomenal! We ordered chicken fettuccine alfredo, fried calamari, pasta e faggioli, mezze Luna's and our pizzas (supremo, plain regular and a Sicilian w/extra cheese), plus our drinks. Our food came out super fast, the waitress was really nice and very professional! We used to go to their other location on Tharpe Street, they moved from over there to here on 1874 Thomasville Road. So glad they are closer to my home. We will be going over more often. My family & I truly enjoyed our dinner with lots of leftovers to bring home!! Totally awesome evening. BTW the owner Sam was awesome too! read more

As of August 2021, this sweet little pizzeria has closed. The building is being renovated to house the Tallahassee Police Department. The scoop is they are seeking a new location in midtown, so keep an eye out! read more

Amazing service and great tasting food. Ambiance is great aswell. Overrall It's a amazing place.

Thank you JJ for the great service today We will be back !!! Great food and zero complaints!!

Passing through my old college stomping grounds (FSU)(Go Noles), stopped by for a calzone to take on the go. While waiting, I noticed the venue is big with outdoor seating and that the staff was friendly. The calzone was another story-- was so hot it burned a hole through the entire bag. It wasn't a bad calzone, the ingredients were fresh. But it completely fell apart as it wasn't sealed and was very messy to eat. Because of the hole it soaked the napkins in grease. Definitely unsatisfied with the calzone and definitely took an "L". I don't plan on going back next time I'm in Tallahassee. read more

Milano Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

One of my go to delivery restaurants mostly because their menu has something for everyone! The chicken diablo is by far the best pasta they offer. The pizza is New York style & all pastas come with a salad and rolls. The bbq wings are way better than buffalo! read more

Milano Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

This isn't the works pizza I've ever had, it wasn't the best, but I can say I would eat it again probably. I came in for a late lunch around 2:30 and ordered two slices and a water, they do not have bottled water so they gave me a glass of water. My two slices I ordered with pepperoni, and I was served very quickly, probably because I was the only person in the restaurant. My bill came to $6.40, that's more than fair. read more

Milano Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Called ahead. Picked up pizza when they said it would be ready. (Anyone who trusts a delivery person with their pizza deserves whatever they get.) Ate good, hot, pizza. What more could you ask for? Pizza was acceptable for New Yorkers, so I guess I sure couldn't have any complaints. Pizza tastes are quite subjective, but Milano's did what they said in the time they said it would be done. read more

Milano Pizza - Pizza....good - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Bottom Line: flavorful dishes to be had at this good neighborhood pizzeria & ristorante with great room for private & large banquets, outdoor terrace with covered and open seating, and full bar. If you're a big fan of Village Pizza up in The Village Commons shopping center - then you already know this is going to be good. This is a neighborhood Joint and all the usual suspects are on the menu, along with a "house specialties" section which I focus on in any restaurant when it presents itself. We've generally come with kids in tow, and tend to eat outside or inside equally. Interior has a remarkably comfortable sofa at the entrance with ample car enthusiast magazines. If I'm not having pizza (which I like just fine, but I tend to order pizza at other places) I generally order one of the following three: The Chicken Diablo, The linguine, garlic, broccoli, olive oil and artichoke dish or The Chicken Florentine. Worth a visit! read more

See all

I'm a little disappointed. We've been here quite a few times and have never been impressed with the pizza. The pizza taste bland, and the toppings were very sparse. I hope the quality improves one day. read more

Milano Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

I feel like this restaurant has got a bad rap in Tallahassee. I never see anyone eating there and there are never cars outside. I went to Milanos today for lunch just because I have lived in Tallahassee for 2 years now and have always drived passed it but never went in. Like many other Tallahassee residents I simply passed it for what I thought to be better options. However this is unjustified. I got there lunch special which was $4.95 for two slices and a drink which was a steal. The pizza was hot and fresh even though there was no one else in the restaurant. The crust was crunchy and delicious. I was not skimped on toppings and the cheese did not slide off of my pizza when I bite into it. All together I had a great experience food wise. Service wise I was blown away. I did not happen to catch my waiters name but he ensured that both my friend and I' s drink was full during our entire visit. We did not even have to ask for our check. Once we finished eating and our conversation died down, he came over and dropped off our bill. All together it was a great experience and I think more people should stop by and try their food, I know I will be coming back! read more

Milano Pizza - The lunch special - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Had the stuffed shells, Greek salad, garlic knots, and pasta fagioli. All was fantastic. The filling in the shells was extremely creamy - moreso than I've ever had - and it was delicious. The sauce was very well developed (obviously cooked a while) and seasoned perfectly. First Italian food I haven't had to salt or add other seasonings to in a very long time. I would 100% order from here again. read more

Great Ziti, and fantastic Cesar salad. The cannoli was yummy, but super small. Very happy!!!

Just average. We ordered a ex large meat pizza with mushrooms and olives added. Not impressive enough to be $32. You cant charge $6 for a handful of olives and mushrooms. And the pizza was floppy and soggy read more

Yummmm....and free delivery through bitesquad! Very good food, and very well priced. Only thing, bruschetta needed balsamic vinegar, and the garlic cheese bread needed more garlic. Stuffed shells were awesome, Eggplant parm was really good. Pizza, yummmmm.....I got the soup too, don't know if it's vegetarian though...that'd be nice to have listed. read more

Waitress is an airhead, she should not be a server with no consciousness of how to serve people. I asked for a Arnold Palmer she forgot and when I asked for a refill at the counter I was ignored by several employees. Mexicans cooking Italian food in the back of the restaurant owned by Albanians. Wish I had a picture of the expired chicken breast they served me and my Dad on a bed of linguine that was frost bit on the edges and should of been thrown out. I have had more authentic Italian food at Fazoli's. read more

Four and a half, to my count! UPDATE! We have now used their delivery service a few times. From ordering either on-line or call in; service was prompt, hot and efficient! Tonight we tested (our true test) of red sauce spaghetti and meatballs. An easy pass with tasty sauce, al dente thin spaghetti and tender, delicious pair of double palm meatballs. Yumm! Terrific cheesesteaks, pasta dishes, too. I love their fresh made garlic knots, but they should be delivered in something other than a paper bag that absorbs the butter and garlic (They readily honored my request for a container when I asked!). Their house salad is simple, but very fresh with good dressings (Ken's). My favorite dish, so far, is their chicken piccata. A simple creation of butter, lemon juice and capers finds a perfect balance in this generous dish. A better version you cannot find, in town; perhaps on Earth. I highly recommend this perfect dish! Their recipes are tasty, their portions generous and the service and delivery is quick and efficient. Being pleased with the reasonable toll at the end of a meal here is also better than expected. read more

Pizza is best in town. Thin crust and fresh ingredients. Greek salad is excellent. Cannolis are first rate. Delivery is dependable and on-time. read more

This is my go to place for life. The pasta is delicious well seasoned and filling. The soup is tasteful not overdone and is very comforting. The pizza reminds me of your north a TRUE New York pizza in Tallahassee. If you order the long island iced tea it will get the job done. If you and your friends are looking for you bang for you buck when it comes to drinks THIS THE PLACE. Everything is good. Yes it's a 4 mins from campus but it's def worth it. And in Thursday nights you can see cars bikes in the parking lot. Milanos is a great place for food and they deliver for FREE!!!!!!! read more

Milano Pizza - Chicken Diablo. My favorite dish. Amazing - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Every time I get spaghetti there, it is served swimming in water. I guess they don't take the time to drain it which leads to the otherwise good sauce being soupy. The pizza has to be blotted with napkins because it is over the top greasy. I like the location since it is close to h o me, but am about to give up on it. Several years ago, the food was better. read more

I am in town for a day and felt like eating Italian. Ordered calamari and chicken parm!!! Everything tastes old like it's been frozen for years. Th calamari was so chewy I ate 2 pieces and throw it out. The only thing I could eat was the side salad. Even the garlic roles were stale!!! Never again!!! read more

The pizza was so good and fresh- we got the garlic knots and they were a little dry but overall very good and would go back!

I love their Bianca, Margherita, and Florentine pizzas. These are my faves and my daughter loves their cheese pizza. Toppings are pretty generous and the flavors do not disappoint. I have tried their subs, just as tasty. I can't wait to try their gyro. I haven't tried the pastas yet and have been ordering from them for years. The wings are decent but the pizza is what I come back for. read more

The employees are rude and judgmental. Unprofessional business in itself. They acted like helping me was the hardest thing on earth to do. If I could rate 0 stars I would. The experience I had there makes me want to shut that place down for good read more

Horrible place!!! Not only was the food terrible but I saw what looked like the owner/ manager yelling at the employees! Will never go back!

It reminded me of being back home in Jersey. I've been looking for a place that gave me that authentic feel, now I know where to go.

Ordered Milano for delivery & it came so quick! The food was delicious. The lobster ravioli in a pink sauce was my favorite! Definitely will order from there again! The only thing I was disappointed about was the garlic knots :( they were hard & bland but overall was great! read more

Milano Pizza - Stuffed shells and lobster ravioli in a pink sauce, Caesar salad & a Greek salad. - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

I have been living in Tallahassee now for 4 months. I have tried every pizza place between here and Gadsden County.This place is the only that even comes close to being on par with pizza from New York or New Jersey (Where I am originally from). I've had Momo's, Gumby's and everything in between all are low grade ingridents. They think brick oven means you burn the pizza and that makes it good... The amount of mediocre to bad pizza I have had to endure to finally find Milano's is incredible. I always thought the north east superiority complex in terms of pizza was a bunch of BS, but it in Tallahassee it is not. The pizza in Tallahassee that is considered good, would be out of business on the Jersey Shore or in NYC in a week. Milano's on the other hand is good quality pizza with great ingredients for a reasonable price. No gimmicks of super large pie, or pizza so cheap you just know it's doomed before you try it. They have a everyday special of 2 slices and a drink for $5... Which is awesome, a large pie cost $13 and is worth every penny. I have also had there wings which are quality. This is by far the only acceptable pizza in all of Tallahassee. Do not think I am some pizza snob either. In other cities in Florida I have found plenty of acceptable pizza establishments, but here in Leon making quality pizza is something no place but Milano's does. Other establishments instead cater to a college crowd that is so drunk they can't taste what they are eating. Worse I suspect many other establishment's yelp reviews to be of their own creation. I do not drink but they do also have a bar with good prices television and a decent dine in experience. This place would easily be a 4 star pizza joint in other cities, but here in Tallahassee they are by far the best and deserving of a 5th star. read more

I love this pizza. My favorite type is New York style and this is the closest to it. There is inside and outside seating which is great on a nice day. read more

Pleasantly surprised by portions, quality, and price. Ordered delivery : meat ravioli in pink sauce, salad, dinner rolls, drink, and cheesecake, all for $20 (including tip for driver)! Showed up 30 min sooner than expected and WOW, delish. Look forward to trying the pizza. read more

Great Brooklyn style pizza with plenty of other options. The service really shines and you can tell they are looking to make your stay enjoyable. Also affordable options all over the place. Only pizza joint I've ever seen with a halal (Muslim version of kosher) items. You wont be disappointed. read more