Salad is kind of small for the price, but I get it for the dressing combo. Pizza is always good i haven't been in a long time and I did notice this pizza was a lot more greasy on the top and bottom than normal. Service is good. I don't like sitting inside but I love their outdoor seating read more

See all

Me and my family came for a bite on Saturday. They were pretty busy BUT that didn't stop them from taking care of us accordingly. The food came on time and was delicious! Thank you. read more

Ate inside and just tried takeout. Very good and food packaged so it traveled well. Looking forward to better weather and sit outside.

Haven't even tasted the food yet but the togo service was horrible. Went in to pay for food and nobody knew what was going on. Everybody was so confused. Once the lady who took my order finally caught on it was attitude. Instead of placing my change in my hand it was placed on the counter. Instead of handing me my food it was placed on the counter and she walked away. No have a nice day or anything. After leaving I called just to let her know what just happened was kinda rude. The response I gat was "oh you're gonna tell me how to do my job" no ma'am not at all I just want you to improve. But never again. That was my first and last time. read more

Partner and I come here once or twice a month for quality food and friendly service. He is very picky and only likes pepperoni calzones with no ricotta, and this satisfies him completely. We also love the bread, which is served warm. I've had several dishes here from the pasta soup to their Alfredo as well as their spaghetti and meatballs, and I've never had a bad experience with any of my food. My favorite is their fettuccine Alfredo with vegetables; it's very filling and there's a hearty amount of vegetables and well-cooked noodles. Sauce keeps me coming back for more! Pricing is just a bit higher than average, a hearty pasta dish is around $18.95 or more. Slowly working my way through trying out nearly everything on the menu as we keep coming back for a great experience. Outdoor patio seating is nice, just your average clean (if not a bit dated) restaurant interior and Italian decor. Always happy to have a meal here! read more

Little Italy - Fettuccine Alfredo with vegetables - Italian Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Yes this is the perfect little Italy with a perfect Italian vibe! Love a good authentic italian dish. A simple pasta a meat balls does the trick for us. Service was great and accommodating. I love that location is away from the college scene which make dinning here to me more peaceful and enjoyable read more

Enver Sulollari is the Best Italian Chef in Tallahassee! Excellent Veal! Best in town. Good quite atmosphere, good wine, good service, excellent high quality Italian dishes. Soon my family is coming to town and this is the only Italian Restaurant we will visit. I highly recommend Little Italy on S. Magnolia Dr. in Tallahassee. read more

Great Italian! This is an exceptional place! Tasteful atmosphere and good people. The food was delicious, and Riley is an Olympic class server. I hope they'll have me as a regular! read more

Little Italy - Spaghetti and Meatballs! My kinda comfort food! - Italian Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

We had a wonderful meal tonight! I ordered the linguine with clam sauce at Alec's (waiter) recommendation. INCREDIBLE! If you order it definitely save some bread to put extra sauce and clams on. Yum! We sat out on the patio and it was a beautiful night! read more

Little Italy - Linguine with clam sauce. I added sprinkle Parmesan and red pepper flakes. - Italian Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

I used to work for the owner at another place and He is a great guy! His pizza dough is exceptional and his pizzas are fantastic. His other dishes are very tasty too. You can't lose eating here. The food is great and the prices are too. I need to get back there myself very soon. You shouldn't miss this one! read more

The food is always delicious. Very friendly staff. Never been disappointed.. Wish there was more space for dining.

Had dinner here on my birthday. We sat in the courtyard outside. Our waitress was very young yet managed her tables well, obviously given good instruction / training. The meals were very good and as is usually the case plenty left to take home for lunch the next day. It is pretty standard fair for these small family owned Italian restaurants but good food at a reasonable price and there's a lot to be said for that. I don't think you'll be disappointed if you try it. read more

I ordered the spaghetti/w meat sauce and the Caesar salad with chicken. I received about three layers of meat and a thimble of sauce. It tasted BLAND! Like they INTENTIONALLY decided not to use seasoning at all. The salad came with no grated cheese. Smh. I'm from out of town but will be back. Definitely not rushing back here. Not for a meal over $40. The garlic bread was good though! I went to the hotel lobby and bought a microwave pizza. read more

Little Italy - Bland spaghetti w/meat sauce. I couldn't eat it! Chicken ceasar salad...no Parmesan smh. DEFINITELY not worth it - Italian Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Ventured out to Little Italy tonight haven't been there in about two years. The food was very bland. The service was very poor and they couldn't get my wife's order correct the ambience was just OK at that and the bathroom was dirty. Sorry to say I wouldn't go there again. read more

Perfect neighborhood Italian restaurant. We love going for date night and sitting on the beautiful patio. Very romantic & everything is delicious. Great takeout as well read more

If you can even make a decent carbonara, don't bother! Place and service was ok, but the pasta was awful.

Dinner tonight and I cannot wait to dig in. I absolutely love their food. I have a large cheese pizza a large pepperoni pizza and a order of shrimp Alfredo a side salad and some bread. read more

See all

We have eaten here a few times over the years and have always enjoyed their food If I lived on this side of town, I would come more often. However, I would have to pass several equally good Italian restaurants between my house and here so we don't get much. The first thing you will notice as you enter the courtyard where they are located is a enticing outdoor eating area. I imagine when the weather is nice in Tallahassee that this is quite popular during the evening. Our most recent visit was a party of 12. We were served by one very experienced waitress who did an excellent job keeping all of us satisfied. Drinks were refilled regularly, bread and butter was brought promptly (and replenished), salads came timely with the correct dressing for each and all 12 entrees came out hot and at the same time. That is a sign of a well organized restaurant, especially considering there were 2 other large groups plus plenty of other diners. I loved my red snapper piccata special and had enough to take half of it home. My wife enjoyed her carbonara and also had to take over half of it home. Everyone in our group enjoyed their food and commented on the great service we received. read more

See all

I had been running around town after work looking for costumes for my kids for Halloween and I was in the mood for some good lasagna! I searched but couldn't find one and then I remembered this place. I'd never been before but I've passed by it (since it's in the Winn-Dixie and Chick-fil-A shopping center) and wanted to try it. I looked up my trusty reviews and decided it was time to try it. They have a really nice outdoor patio area and it was busy for a Tuesday night. I saw so many positive things about how the bread was delicious... and I'm a bread lover! I was torn between the lasagna and the Baked Cannelloni but decided I'd stick with the original plan for lasagna. The lady at the register seems to be Italian and she was very nice, she suggested that I do the lasagna since she too loves it and that I should try the cannelloni the next time I was back ;) When I got home with the food it was still hot, however there were a few cold spots in the middle. Nonetheless, I can say that I was pleasantly surprised at how good it was. I ate the entire container and the delicious bread all by myself! I'm a very picky eater and I will definitely be back to try more of the menu items. They are priced great for the portions and to be able to get a home cooked meal. read more

See all

What a great find! Do not let the Winn Dixie next door deter you. It's a quaint little restaurant who knows how to do Italian! I got the Chicken Country Style and it is the perfect blend! My husband got the Carbonara and it was delish too (rich, but delicious). The bread is fresh baked and the wine is also yummy! Special shout-out to our waitress Abi for not only being a great waitress for us, but running the whole place (inside and outside) all by herself! P.S. I didn't think to get photos of the food - ate it too fast, so you get a photo of the courtyard on a rainy day. :) read more

Little Italy - Courtyard at Little Italy - Italian Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Super good italian food (better than Z'bardis). Totally cool and casual. I've been going for 20 years and I've never had a bad meal, I've never had an okay meal... I've only had good to great meals! I love their Calimari, the Sliced tomatoes with fresh mozzarella and balsamic vinagraite, and you can never go wrong with their pizzas or the veal piccata! read more

It isn't that great but for the prices it offers accordingly. Simple but good. It is a very spacious place both seating inside as outside. As modern as it looks outside, it is outdated inside. Friendly staff. Simple menu. Full open bar. I had a sangria which came without fruit. I ordered the caprese salad which was terrible but for the price what you expect. Cheap thick cut tomatoes with tasteless mozzarella. It's as good as me fixing this myself at home. But again reasonable for the price. The spinach lasagne was really good. The soup of the day and eggplant Florentine were really good, better than when we had this at Cipriani's! read more

See all

I've been to Little Italy on a few different occasions and have always enjoyed the food. I recently had my graduation party here, BEST decision I could have made. Everyone made sure my day was perfect! I can't thank you all enough! The space was great and my guests enjoyed all the food options. I really love the outdoor courtyard, perfect for pictures. My mother enjoyed her pizza she loved the fresh dough. I generally eat spaghetti or chicken alfredo and it never disappoints. My aunt also noted she loved the cheesecake. I had to skip the cannoli this time but grab one while you're there. As always I'll be back and absolutely recommend for a quiet lunch/dinner or an event! read more

See all

Boy what a hidden gem! My wife and I ate there for lunch taking advantage of their lunch sandwiches special during the week. When we arrived there was one other couple there besides us but by the time we left there was plenty of patrons. The food was great. The atmosphere felt very Italian. The service was attentive and polite. Overall very pleased with this restaurant and will go back again and again. Great first date or any dinner place. read more

Little Italy - Meatball Parmesan sandwich. - Italian Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Saturday evening, I came in here with my wife and my daughter and really enjoyed our meal. The server, whose name I do not remember, was extremely friendly and hospitable. The food consisting of pasta fagole, an anti pasta, spaghetti & meatballs, and the tortellini were very good. The atmosphere, with indoor and outdoor dining, is exactly what you would want in a small neighborhood Italian restaurant. I ordered a bourbon on a large ice rock, however, and it came out with ice cubes. That is my only reason for not giving that additional star. The bourbon rock is essential for any place with a bar and when I asked, the server said "no problem". Otherwise, a very positive experience. I would go again. read more

Most excellent. Many delicious choices. Friendly staff and superb service. The menu is endless with other delicious choices. I highly recommend this place. read more

See all

One of our favorite places in town the past 4 years and must try if you are in Tallahassee and love great authentic Italian food ! It's a very intimate family owned type of restaurant. Usually plenty of seating and can be busy for holidays like valentines definetly reserve. Their prices are fair and provide a range for any budget! Gotta try the dinner or lunch specials that bring a soup or salad and the entree. Amazing service everytime we've had nimrod servers and they're always constantly checking in and super attentive to our needs. The food was fairly quick and tasted homemade! read more

See all

Had an amazing dinner here, super friendly servers, family friendly, very quick service, and delicious food. We got the baby pizza, chicken parm and veal. Loved the ambiance and feeling of being in a family owned restaurant! read more

See all

Very friendly staff. Good food but nothing I would write home to my Italian parents about. The restaurant seemed very clean. The food came out quickly. read more

It pains me to write this, as we have ordered from Little Italy many times. But our experience last night will be the last birth due to the quality of the food and the attitude of the owner. We often order veal parmigiana dinners for delivery. While not exceptional, they have been good and Little Italy is one of the few places that sells veal that is open on a Monday. So last night we ordered 2 veal parm dinners and a fried calamari appetizer from Little Italy using bitesquad. Note that the dinners each come with a side salad, a side of spaghetti, and bread with butter. The deliver arrived on time. We started with the calamari, which was cooked well and was tasty. Next came the salads, served with ranch dressing, which were crisp and fresh. However, next came the veal. We removed the veal parm and spaghetti from the metal containers and put them on plates. After a few bites of the veal, it was clear that something tasted off about it. Upon closer inspection, the veal was brown all the way through, which to us indicated that it was either way overcooked or too old. The spaghetti was fine, but the veal was simply bad. So we stopped eating it and contacted bitesquad through the chat feature in their app. They asked me to send a picture, which I did (and which is attached to this post). To make a long story short, bitesquad would only agree to give us a $5 credit. I told them that we would happily pay for the calamari, but that we would like a refund for the two dinners, each of which cost $16.95. They told me to contact the restaurant (which they are actually supposed to do). So I called and talked to the owner, ave had her on speaker so my wife could listen. The owner said that if we didn't like the food then it would be no charge. She said that quickly and repeatedly. But she said bitesquad is supposed to call her. She told me to contact bitesquad and tell them no charge for the dinners. So I called them and told them this, and they wanted to call the restaurant to verify. Perfectly understandable. They came back on the line to tell me the owner was only willing to credit one dinner because her husband, who is the chef, and she said that they thought the veal was fine. That's not At all what she told me, but she would but budge. So we are ending up partying for one that was just as bad as the one they credited. I then decided to take a look at the food inspection reports and discovered that they had 20 violations at their last inspection in September. That's a lot. Maybe the poor quality of the veal was related? It's imposible to know. In any event, we will never return. Poor food can happen. Poor service by the owner when it is reported is inexcusable. read more

Little Italy - Their recent (09/2019) inspection report with 20 violations. - Italian Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Sorry for the lack of pictures, everything was great. Seemed really authentic and great portions for the price. Will definitely be back next time I'm in Tallahassee! read more

Little Italy - Caprese - Italian Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Food and service is always amazing. Thai is one oft favorite local Italian restaurants.

One of the few places I enjoy the food from in this God forsaken city. Located in the Winn Dixie plaza, but in its own little world is the gem Little Italy. The chicken piccata is always so bright and satiating. I haven't ordered anything on this menu that I didn't like. Chicken Alfredo & chicken parm were really good too! Seems like a popular place as there's usually a good amount of people there when I go to pick up. The restaurant is basic on the inside typical booths and outdoor seating too. Good service never had to wait too long after placing an order. Overall pretty good Italian food. read more

Good food. Fair price. Server was nice... ...but reservations not honored. Long waiting line ! Limited staff ! Out of pizza ! Out of clam sauce !!!! read more

Always fantastic.... Food is always perfect. The patio is a great place to eat when the weather is nice! read more

Little Italy - Create your own calzone. Spinach, beef, and mushrooms. - Italian Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Excellent staff, food, and atmosphere! Even on a very packed evening, the restaurant was able to quickly and easily accommodate large parties on the spot. We were not the only group and servers were extremely friendly and attentive to detail. Highly recommend if you are looking for tasty Italian cuisine in Tallahassee! read more

Fairly new Tallahassee residents. Born and raised in New York, Italian Mom. Tried Little Italy for the first time, wife picked up take-out on her way home from work. Sicilian pizza was OK, better than most around town, but not up to what I'm used to in a Sicilian pie (thicker crust, more cheese and sauce). The meatball and chicken parm sandwiches were good, but dry (should come with extra sauce so one can get as messy as they like). We'll try eating in next time to see how service is and meals are, then I can ask for extra sauce. read more

One of my favorite Italian restaurants in Tallahassee! Unassuming and tucked into a courtyard in a strip mall, this little restaurant definitely impresses. You can get your usual Italian-American fare at the $15-20 price point. Huge portions make for great leftovers. The house chianti is wonderful. I adore the framed photo of Marlon Brando on the wall. I will return! read more

I don't live in Tallahassee anymore but come home a couple of times a year to visit, and Little Italy is probably my favorite restaurant in town. The food is always excellent (I usually get the white pizza - you can get a mini size at lunchtime) - and the Italian owner is so nice. We usually get a pizza to go and the drive home with it is just mouthwatering. Thank you for so many great years of Italian food in Tally! read more

Quaint outdoor experience with water fountain. Hidden spot in shopping center and busy parking lot but wouldn't know with the relaxed setting. Food was amazing! read more