I placed an online order for five large pizzas for my daughter's birthday. When I arrived to pick them up, I found Brickyard Pizza completely without power after a storm. Trees were down in the area, the lights were out, and the entire crew was working in the dark. Because the internet was down, they hadn't received any of the online orders, including mine. At that point, most places would have locked the doors, put up a sign, and called it a day. Instead, they apologized, explained what had happened, and told me the gas ovens still worked. They offered to make the entire order from scratch. The team stayed in a hot, non-air-conditioned building, cooking pizzas by flashlight and waiting for every customer who had placed an online order to arrive. They could have gone home. Instead, they chose to take care of their customers. The pizza was excellent, but what stood out was the character of the people working there. Flexible, resilient, and genuinely committed to doing the right thing despite difficult circumstances. That's the kind of business worth supporting. Five stars. read more

Half of the pizza, one topping with a drink for eight dollars The pizza is delicious. The crust has the perfect crunch, and although the cost of this lunch is low, the qualities is very high. I give them a four star. I'll be back. read more

Staying with family and we got take out from here. The pizza hits the spot. The portions are huge. The taste is amazing. Can't wait till I am back in town again to stop in and dine in. read more

The pizza was good! My nephews enjoyed it so much, they went back a few days later! Not too greasy and just a good, quality pizza. I called in the order and they were quick and friendly over the phone and when I went to pick it up. read more

Mixed review. Once we ordered a couple of pizzas and they were good. But recently we ordered a veggie lovers and it was a bit worse than ordinary. There was not enough pizza sauce and sparsely spread out and there was not enough veggies on it to justify it. Have not tried it again. read more

Pizza carry out was very expensive with few add ons that I ordered. Very pleasant staff; however $26 for a large pizza with 3 toppings is a bit over the top considering the few topping provided. read more

Just PICKED UP pizza, had to be one of the worst in my life!! They sure let this place go? My wife had eggplant and I had pizza, $47 AND THE NERVE TO ASK FOR A TIP!!!!! BS read more

We were so happy with our experience here! We were bummed out they don't offer dine in but it ended up working out for us. Their pizza menu is extensive and I have to say that their gluten free crust was actually delicious! The service was friendly and fast. The environment is cozy but we only got to enjoy it from the lobby area. We would definitely return! read more

I could have sworn I did a recent review, anyways the Stromboli and calzone were the best in Tallahassee I have had so far . The dough is gold brown every time. The owner sources only the best ingredients for sauce made fresh and the cheese is incredible too . Highly recommended experience. read more

Brickyard Pizzeria - Me - Italian Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Terrible take out. Screwed the order up, admitted it then said they can't give a cc refund that we would need to come in the store to get cash. We live 15 miles from them so no chance of that happening.would not deliver. So we go hungry. If you still patronize them check your order before you leave. Especially if you don't eat meat. read more

The eggplant rollatini is fantastic! I usually get that and a side of spaghetti. I also order their meatballs which have a great flavor and are huge. My brother likes their spaghetti with meatballs. I would love for them to offer on site dining again instead of just take out but Covid changed their business model. I will continue to support them! read more

Greasy, floppy pizza and my stomach hurts next morning. Lots of cheese that slides off pizza, little sauce. Meatballs a little salty and featured a big chunk of melted cheese in the middle of the container....not sure if that was supposed to be mozzarella sprinkled over all the meatballs but just collected as one chunk in middle (?). Baked spaghetti was very good, lots of cheese on that too but evenly dispersed over dish. read more

First time here! Hostess was extremely nice & gave mouthwatering suggestions on the menu!!! We got the magherita pizza, baked ravioli, eggplant rotini, & a dozen garlic knots (it's only two people too lol but it all sounded so good!!)!!! Plus at like $3.59 for a dozen garlic knots how can you 'knot' do it!! Also got two extra marinara sauces for 75¢ each. And they have a sign showing that they sell their saw for $8.99 for a 32oz jar so how can you ignore that it's literally A SIGN THAT THEIR SAUCE IS GREAT ENOUGH TO TAKE HOME TO GRAMMA!! I will be updating after my feast!! (Has to do takeout because they're seating area is pretty small so for extra covid measure it's probably best to carry out. Plus it only took 15 minutes to finish making so not long at all!!) UPDATE: OK THE PIZZA WAS AMAZING !!! The ravioli was great too and my only issue was that I should of been more patient and put my eggplant in the oven to warm up vs the microwave because it did make it soggy (flavor was amazing still don't get me wrong). And we drove about 20 minutes to bring the food home so i definitely believe if you ordered it there (or live nearby) and ate it the crunch would be amazing because it was perfectly coated in a golden brown layer. I have some leftover I plan on finishing soon and I'm definitely going to be better and use my oven instead!! read more

Brickyard Pizzeria - So excited just got so much food to eat - Italian Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Great food the BSC is a favorite the staff & cools are always nice! The prices aren't bad at all read more

My go-to "neighborhood pizza place. Picking up my order has been an adjustment, from where I lived previously. But I've made it a "reward" on my way home from Walmarts. Or from picking up a bottle of wine at ABC . I'm usually not a crust person, but their's is really good. My only negative is that I wish that were more consistent. Otherwise I really enjoy their pizza, has become a once-a-week treat. And when my college kids come by. read more

I stop here every time I go through Tallahassee. It's amazing. We moved from Texas in 2022 and it's difficult to find good pizza in Florida because of the salt content in the water. read more

Great food. Pizza, spaghetti and calzones. Turn around is quick for great Italian food.

We returned one cold rainy night and everything was just right. Though our first experience wasn't the best, I do give them a five. Just goes to show, you can't really judge a place on one visit alone. Ask for the Markie Special, those DIY meatball knots are my favorite thing!!! Love, love, love them. Love em. Mnm. Lol :) I can see why they get such great reviews. It's a nice place, everyone's happy and having fun, I just wish we had a better experience with the pizza. Don't even ask. Solid three something rounded up. read more

See all

If you don't have dine in available you really should state that on your website! Can't tell what the food is like because we left.

Ordered take out- small cheese & mushroom pizza- almost inedible the crust was so thin and overcooked- tough. Bianca: tomato, spinach-frozen, and ricotta- a bit better, but not much. Asked for no garlic- garlic on it. Who uses frozen spinach on a pizza?? Small house salad: head lettuce 2 slices tomato & cucumber- pitiful. How does this place stay in business?? I have had better frozen grocery store pizza. Avoid. read more

If you order on the phone be ready to be overcharged. I have been eating their regularly but I was over charged again and my sides were not included. Just going downhill. So unfortunate. I never believed the rudeness but the others are correct. Garlic Rolls burned. Overcharged... read more

They must close before 10:00 as I've tried 3 times to order a pizza between 9:00-10:00 and nobody answers the phone. Sad because it's pretty good pizza and I like supporting local businesses. read more

Unfortunately, these are the "garlic knots" that I received with my meal. I'm not quite sure what else to put here, since yelp requires more words to post a review (though a picture should be worth a thousand words). There. read more

Brickyard Pizzeria - "Garlic knots?" (Gourmet Mold) - Italian Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

The Margherita pizza is so good! Fresh ingredients and made to perfection. Every time I order from here I'm never disappointed. The staff is really friendly too and ensures I have everything I need. When I order for pick up it is always ready in a timely manner. I love this place! read more

Brickyard Pizzeria - The Margherita - Italian Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Pizza is ok, but don't waste your money on the grinders. Ordered two meatballs and both came with 2 meatballs cut in half, for a 12" grinder. Called them and was informed both should come with 3. BOTH of mine only had 2, mistake, BS. Do better and don't waste your money. oneal read more

Brickyard Pizzeria - Meatball less grinder Meatball Parmigiana - Italian Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

I have been trying to find a solid pizza/Italian spot for 5 months now. So far, I am really happy with this place. We have been twice in the last 2 weeks. Every other place has just been okay and i've tried about 12 spots so far. This is a tiny spot between a gas station and an Ace hardware. It is not the most quiet nor uppity and the prices are good for the amount and quality of food you get. The first time we came, we had Ada (I believe that's what it was) and she was absolutely lovely. Great service from her, refills super fast, and no hovering. Perfect. I love the marinara-it's simple and isn't sweet like a few other spots around Tally. Cheese is really good and the dough is also simple. I like it because they aren't trying super hard to do 1000 different menu items or things. It's really good food with good service. I'm very happy to find this place and we will keep coming back. read more

See all

Brickyard was once nice. However, it has gone way downhill in management, operation, and quality of product.

This is the best pizza I've ever eaten and trust me I've had em all. If there was a Ten star review I'd give them an 11. Born and raised in Tally so I know what I'm talking about! Jon T. read more

The buffalo chicken and the Brickyard pizzas are my family's absolute favorites. Their weekday lunch specials cannot be beat.

The best lunch special I've ever run across. $7 for numerous choices. It is lunch portions but you can get 2 lunch orders for $14 depending on how you eat. Lunch specials come with drink and if Sammy is in the kitchen you're in for a treat. All cooks there are great and I've never been upset or disappointed with an my order. Dinner is great too but the lunch special if you like saving money is worth every penny. Brickyard salad and pizza lunch specials is what I get. But I've heard the eggplant sandwich is amazing also. Give it a try, I usually do 2-3 times a week. read more

Although I have been back in Tallahassee for four years, I had not had the pleasure of trying Brickyard until recently. I had a friend tell me their chicken parmesan was her favorite in this area. Being that chicken parm is my husband's favorite dish, I had to make sure we gave Brickyard a go. His chicken parm came with a great deal of pasta and sauce. In addition, I ordered myself their large meatball appetizer (needed keto friendly) and a large antipasto salad. Their meatballs are hearty and dense, not full of fillers like some places. My kids shared a Stromboli with bacon and enjoyed. While in there I saw on their food board an advertised Family Meal Deal of ziti with six meatballs and 12 garlic knots or spaghetti with six meatballs and knots for only $24.99! We feasted on this a few days later and I must say, that ziti with the meat sauce is enough to feed at least 6-8 people. Brickyard is only about 15 minutes away from my house and will be added into our rotation of restaurants moving forward. read more

I was really craving pizza for lunch, so I googled some pizza places near me. I noticed Brickyard had a lunch special for 2 slices and a drink, so of course that sounded great! I called them, they took my order, and off I went. When I arrived, I was greeted very happily and my order was ready to pick up. When I opened the box, I was even more excited to see that not only had they given me my 2 promised slices, but FOUR! A whole half of a pizza! And it was very yummy, I was extremely pleased with my order and was very excited to go back. The only reason I've knocked off one star, is because I haven't been able to go back. The last couple of times I tried to call in and place an order, their phone just rang and rang, forcing me to give up on the dream. I'm not entirely sure why this has happened twice now, but I would absolutely love to go back! I loved the pizza and WHAT a steal for lunch! read more

Everything about this place is great! Their dough is awesome and the sauce is like homemade. The salads are huge, fresh and loaded. And the best part is their people and service. read more

Have incredible eggplant and chicken Parmesan! Their pizza is one of the best in town read more

Ended up here on a whim and what a great place. Not a lot of tables so get there early or be prepared to wait (worth waiting for - and I HATE to wait!). Arrived on a Wednesday night around 6:30 PM and they were on a short wait. Almost went to the Food Truck Bazaar across the street (every Wednesday) but the aromas and the constant line of pickup and deliveries indicated that we should stay. We ordered a Large Greek Salad, a medium pie with pepperoni, onions and basil along with a B.S.C. (Brickyard Stuffed Crust). Each was amazing, memorable and will be ordered again when we visit. The staff was friendly and engaging. Provided good advice for those whom have not been there before. They also had won an award for Best Pizza for their area - I haven't eaten at any other pizza joints in the area - and there is NO REASON TO! It truly was a great dinner. We did end up getting some cupcakes from the Bakery Vendor at the Food Truck Bazaar after dinner - that is a separate review (awesome)... read more

They serve decent food. For the most part I'm satisfied with them. Try them you may like it.

Really love their calzones. We have ordered 3 times so far since moving to Tallahassee 7 months ago. We have also ordered the pizza but, the calzone reigns supreme! read more

Brickyard is truly the BEST pizza in all of Tallahassee and the surrounding areas. I have yet to find any other pizza place that is as delicious as Brickyard. I know what good pizza tastes like and it is very hard to find in the southern US. I am from CT and Brickyard reminds me of the amazing pizza that you'll find up there. It's all about the crust, the sauce, and the quality of the cheese and other toppings. They also have "grinders" on their menu, which is a New England term for sub sandwiches...I love it! No one else in the Tallahassee area has that on their menu. I wish Brickyard was closer to my home, but they are worth the drive. Do yourself a favor and order your next pizza (or grinder!) from Brickyard! read more

This place hands down makes the BEST Eggplant Parmigiana and Pizza in Tallahassee. The staff is friendly and the restaurant is always clean. It's one of those neighborhood restaurants that you are glad is nearby. Casual dining, good atmosphere, and the great food! read more

Best pizza & Italian food in town IMHO. Love their Eggplant Parmisan and Garlic knots! Used takeout all through Covid year, and it was excellent & now the dining room is open don't hesitate. Whatever works best for you but try it! read more