I'm picky about pizza. I've said it before in prior reviews, and I'm sure I'll say it again.
Sleepover is a win in my book, from crust, to sauce, to topping and everything in between (is there anything else? I don't think so... but just in case).
The crust is just amazing. It's baked to perfection, to where you have a sturdy & crispy-crunchy bite, but not so crispy where you cut your lips & mouth into smithereens... you know the slices. It's also puffy & pillowy and oh so chewy... so perfect, in fact, that my dogs were shooting daggers at me for not sharing my crusties with the them.
But do you see that the toppings go edge to edge? Yea... no real crusties there, girls, sorry not sorry.
The sauce is everything this East Coast Italian girlie dreams of: there was some sweet, some tang, it had a jammy, tomato-y mouth feel... I could honestly have eaten just the crust & sauce by itself. Which, coincidentally is known as Party Pizza back home in RI, so maybe I need to see if I can just buy that next time too
The toppings on both pies were plentiful, and neither overbearing to the point where you could no longer taste either the crust or the sauce, which to me equals a perfect pie. I'm normally a pepperoni girl, but the Hawaiian had my heart, with its salty ham & sweet pineapple a perfect balance to each other, and a delicious complement to the sauce & crust.
Since this was a take home order, I wasn't the one to pick it up, but my roommate said it was basically window service, and it was ready at the time indicated. He was a little frustrated by the online ordering, but he's also technically challenged, so take that with a grain of salt.
The cost may feel high, but I 100% feel like you get what you pay for: the quality is top tier and I wish Sleepover were closer to home as it's 17miles away, so quite a hike. The pies are on the smaller side, but could definitely feed 2 people alongside a salad for a nice meal. read more