Delicious, very small, almost always a wait, no cash! The best pizza in the greater area, easily. There's always a wait due to being very small inside, so don't come if you're in a hurry. But it's worth the wait. Note: they take CASH ONLY!! The staff is friendly. It is warm and cozy - a small town "place to be". It's old school - hand written tickets and cash register. Their pizza is the best, but also have amazing hoagies, pasta, and appetizers. Huge selection of local beer. You haven't truly been to Davis until you've eaten here! read more

See all

Stop in here during a road trip thru WV. Had good write up on Yelp. Atmosphere is very rustic with multiple types of seating to choice. It was middle of week during off season so it was not very busy. Ordered waters to drink and our Red Lodge pie. I took a little bite to get pie but it came out very hot. There is parmesian cheese and red pepper on tables to spread on your food. My wife and I both thought the pie was lacking in flavor. We could hardly make out the individual vegie flavors and the chicken was bland. There seemed to be a good amount of ingredients on it and grust was medium thickness with good flavor. Service was good, several staff checked in with us during our meal. read more

Sirianni’s Pizza Cafe - Red Lodge Pie - Pizza Near Me - Davis, West Virginia

The town is very small but the strip of businesses that this pizza place is on is adorable. When you walk in, it's very small and homey. It has that small diner feel. We were immediately welcome upon entry and quickly got seated. Service was good, very straight to the point. We ordered the artery clog and the BBQ chicken pizza (when you order a pizza you can split half and half). Both pizzas were very good but I will say the crust on the BBQ chicken was a little doughy. Over the taste of the pizza was very good but I will say I didn't think it was anything special. Just good pizza. It wasn't like amazing or a must have but if you're in the area it is a good place to eat. If I could give it 3.8 stars I would but 4 works! Hope this helps! read more

Food was EXCELLENT, best breadsticks (technically, wedges) I've had in years. Pizza was AMAZING, with sauce I bet was house made. Service was really good, friendly staff. Nice atmosphere. Cash only, so remember to bring your dollars. Will be a frequent diner from now on. Can't wait to try some of the salads, sandwiches, and pasta! read more

Sirianni’s Pizza Cafe - Interior showing seating, signage. - Pizza Near Me - Davis, West Virginia

LOCAL, local, local,... We Love local and local Italian.... A favorite for many years - all pasta is excellent. Lots of street parking. Sirianni's is much too small and crowded; service is always excellent. Request Italian Sausage sandwich - hot read more

Sirianni’s Pizza Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Davis, West Virginia

Our server was excellent! She was so sweet and helpful whenever we needed something or had any questions. We ordered one pizza for dine-in and one for takeaway. The wait to be seated was short but the wait for the pizza was a little long. I don't blame them, though, since it was a pretty busy Friday. Both pizzas tasted delicious, especially after the long hike we took. Highly recommend if you're in the area! read more

Pretty good pizza. Nice people and quick service. Will buy from again when I'm in the area and ordering out.

The food was way below the average, we didn't finish it, but that wasn't the issue Only AFTER we were given a bill we were told they don't accept credit cards. That was shocking. Nowhere there was a sign "cash only" and no one told us up front about cash only service The waiter was extremely rude when I told him I had no cash. While I was looking did anyone in the staff who takes Venmo, they lost my ticket (they have nothing computerized, everything hand written). After I Venmo'd the bill, I had to explain myself what I ate and were I was sitting while they were looking for the ticket That felt extremely humiliating and ruined my day. Avoid this place at all cost read more

Very local pizza shop. When you walk into the restaurant, you know there is a history. Delicious pasta, and pizza! They serve local beers and have takeout. Also, I love that you can take a bag of the homemade pizza dough home and make your own pizza in the upcoming week. read more

Sirianni’s Pizza Cafe - Johnnies cheese - Pizza Near Me - Davis, West Virginia

See all

My husband and I went here for my birthday. It was crowded but the service was attentive and the food was great. I got pizza, he got pasta and we were pleased. We'd def be back when we come back to the area. Loved the decor and historical stuff on the walls. read more

Highly recommend this quaint, cozy Italian spot that has clearly won the hearts of travelers and locals. The ever-present line out the door is proof of their amazing food. Whether you're picking up a pizza to-go or settling in for a casual dine-in experience, this place is almost always buzzing. While the menu offers fresh salads and comforting pasta dishes, we never stray from the true star: the pizza. Perfectly crisp crust, vibrant toppings, and quality ingredients make every bite memorable. It's the kind of pizza you crave again. The restaurant itself is a charming hodgepodge of local memorabilia combined with global decor, with mix-and-match plates that add character and reflect a sustainable, reuse-friendly ethos, the true Davis way. Their beer and wine selection rounds out the experience nicely, making it just as suited for a quick bite as for a relaxed evening with friends. Sirianni's is popular for a reason. This little Italian haven is proof that good food, genuine atmosphere, and community spirit never go out of style. read more

The main reason to come to this restaurant is the atmosphere. This is the type of place you expect to find in a small town with oodles of charm. The food was good too. The salad was made with really fresh vegetables and the pizza was loaded with those same fresh ingredients. I recommend this place 10 out of 10. read more

Sirianni’s Pizza Cafe - Chef salad with ranch - Pizza Near Me - Davis, West Virginia

See all

Stopped in for lunch on a busy Thursday ! There was a small wait for some big parties but that's how you know it's worth it, since it was just my boyfriend and I we were seated when we walked in! Such a cool atmosphere! Got the Ellie Mae's bbq chicken pizza and I'll tell you what, I know I'll dream about that pizza! Definitely stop here if you want a good pizza! read more

Great service, best place to eat in this town. Wonderful pizza! We wanted pizza and thankfully we found this place.

I like the vibe, and the people are nice with good service. The food is pretty middle of the road though, and especially the sandwiches are pretty much just all bread and cheese. read more

I love the food, especially the pizza. Salads are absolutely the best I've ever had at any restaurant- get the garlic dressing that is homemade. Service is always top notch too! The passion of the business is strong and the food remains to be a favorite of mine in the area every time we visit. Atmosphere is nice, lots of history surrounds. read more

Disclaimer: cash only!! There is an ATM by the entrance if needed. This place was one of the few restaurants open downtown on a Monday night so my family stumbled in. They were pretty busy so we sat a table near the door and we quickly found out that the front door swings open if you don't close it properly and with every incoming customer who didn't close it all the way everyone at the front of the restaurant shot darts from their eyes. My family visited during ski season so they were pretty busy and they seemed to also be short staffed. We waited over an hour for our pizza and pasta so we were glad we ordered salads for an appetizer. There was a sign saying there is a $5 fee for whining so we made sure to wait patiently (haha). For the food, it was pretty standard American pizza. We were surprised when we ordered a Neapolitan pizza and it was basically a cheese pizza with some basil. The pasta is apparently all made in-house - a pleasant surprise. read more

Sirianni’s Pizza Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Davis, West Virginia

See all

Options for lunch on a Monday are limited in Davis, but Sirianni's was open and easy to access, being right off the main road. The interior is small, and we waited more than 5 minutes for someone to come take our order, but the drinks and food came out quickly after that. The restaurant was probably half full while we were there. We had a mozzarella plate, a small Caesar salad, and a large Johnnie's cheese pizza. The Caesar salad was a big portion (the waitress might have accidentally brought the large size--I didn't check the receipt), and the lettuce was fresh and the dressing light, although a tad too lemony. The pizza crust was the star of the show: crisp at the edges and just chewy enough in the center. The pizza was not heavily sauced (which I loved), but I personally found the chopped basil on top a bit heavy-handed and the overall flavor of the cheeses slightly bitter. The prices are a little high, which is to be expected from a touristy area near ski resorts and state parks. We would definitely try Sirianni's again if we were in the area, although we probably would order different items. read more

See all

Decent pizza. Also okay pasta. One of the few decent places to eat in Davis other than up at the state park. Owner was kind of rude to us once though read more

We went to this place after seeing the great reviews and they lived up to it!!! We walked into a warm and cozy place, and after camping that's just what we needed! They had friendly staff, clean bathrooms, and DELICIOUS food! Will definitely make it back here. read more

Pizza is great. Hot sausage appetizer was excellent. They are cash only. It's a tight fit inside, not a lot of tables. Staff was very polite. read more

This is the only restaurant in eastern West Virginia as far as I'm concerned. Super friendly folks, great service, unique and fun decor, and surprisingly good food. Veggies are actually fresh. Pasta dishes are spiced/flavored by a real professional with love. Soups are creative. We didn't try the pizza. If you like real food, and you're in West Virginia, you would otherwise be completely out of luck. So this is a mandatory stop. read more

Stopped in to get seated and after 15 minutes no one spoke to us. Floor was chaotic and seemed to just let giant tables consume all the business. If you're looking to get food and be seated this place is way too small. Call take out or something read more

I ordered takeout. Friendly staff and a short wait time. Quality food and a Chef to match! The pasta was delicious and I'll definitely order again! read more

Fun quirky authentic restaurant. Great food, especially pizzas and sandwiches. Good service. No credit cards though, cash or checks

Decent food but lousy service. They only take cash and seem to prefer that you not even come there in the first place.

We arrived just before one and they told us we had a thirty minute wait. At 1:15 some one came and said that they could seat us but we would need to be done by 2:00 because they had a party coming who would need the table. We felt we would have no problem with that. Then another person came and rudely said it would be another 30 minutes to be seated and if we wanted that table he would kick us out at 2:00 when the next party came. I said we are usually pretty quick and we already waited fifteen minutes, he argued with us about how long we had waited and he just said no we will help you another time and walked away. We have eaten here before and felt the wait was long in the past but we're shocked at the way we were treated. If they simply said sorry the wait will be longer than we thought we would have understood. Clearly they do not like people who are not local...if you are on vacation avoid this restaurant. read more

Had a lovely experience at Sirianni's, which is in the heart of Davis. We were seated immediately (granted it wasn't ski season) and the place has lots of fun decor and eclectic seating (and a pay to use jukebox if you're into that). My partner and I shared the parmesan wedges, which were good but really just cheese pizza. They were lovely with both the marinara and the ranch. We then got Johhnie's cheese pizza, which was a great blend of cheeses. It came on a lovely thin crust and the basil was a nice touch. Don't expect the best Italian you've ever had, but it's good for what it is. Don't forget it's cash only! read more

Sirianni’s Pizza Cafe - Parmesan wedges - Pizza Near Me - Davis, West Virginia

See all

Every time I'm staying in Davis I try to make it to Sirianni's! I'm a big pizza fan & there's is one of my top 10 favorites. Service is always very quick and love the small-town feel of the restaurant! read more

Visited Davis, WV on a day trip from our Airbnb in Cumberland, MD. Originally from Louisiana, we are serious about our food here and we struggled to find things we enjoyed in Cumberland. After we visited Canaan Valley and Blackwater Falls, we were ready for a good meal. We drove through the cute town of Davis and stumbled upon Sirianni's. The place was PACKED to the brim with people waiting outside in the cold even for a table. It was loud, bustling, and smelled delicious so we were pleased with our choice. So much character in the walls of this restaurant--even down to the numerous letters and notes shoved underneath the glass tabletop covers. We ordered an antipasta salad to split and a large artery clogger (haha!) pizza. The salad was a little different than what we're used to because it had a sort of sweet vinaigrette on it but we devoured it. The meat and cheese on it were so fresh and delicious. The pizza was piping hot with a thinner crispy crust and zesty sauce with yummy amounts of Italian sausage, pepperoni and bacon. We thoroughly enjoyed it as well. Heads up though--it's cash only! I didn't notice if there was an ATM in house there but I'm sure you could find one nearby if not. Great conversation with the owner about football and our food in New Orleans when we were heading out. Worth stopping in and grabbing some yummies! Would certainly return! read more

See all

Always enjoy a visit here. Last time we had the glen plakes which I love, a cheese pizza and the Magherita. All fresh and so hot! The owner was lovely to chat with and we enjoyed some juke box music. It was a busy night but they stay moving. I love that the staff have cell cubbies at the front so they can't be distracted when they are working best part was desserts that night. The Italian lemon cake was the best ever and the peanut butter pie was amazing. read more

I've never left Davis WV without first eating at Sirianni's. Truly an old school Italian restaurant with little room for a crowd, so be mindful if visiting during peak mealtimes. The food is great-an authentic touch of traditional old time Italian food. Really have never had a bad dish - can't complain about anything with this restaurant. Cash only but they do have an ATM. read more

Well - I should have listened. We originally wanted to eat next door, but thanks to an outbreak of flu at that establishment - they were closed. There are plenty of places to eat along this stretch and unless everything else but here is closed - eat somewhere else. FIRST PROBLEM: Being addressed by anyone upon entry. There is an army of waiters waitresses, etc etc - NOT ONE PERSON SAID HELLO UPON ENTERING. We stood and waited .. and waited .. and waited to be acknowledged. Workers looked at us - nothing. Finally an older lady asked how many and we were sat up in the corner. Waiter (young kid) came up and immediately asked us if we knew what we wanted to order......... what? So we started with drinks. He came back almost instantaneously and asked if we knew what we wanted to order. So we ordered mozzarella wedges which I thought sounded like cheese sticks. We also order two small pizzas - one the artery clogger Bc it had meats on it. Waited. Waited. Other people near us sat after us getting food - waited. Waited. We get the wedges - which is just a pizza with no sauce. Came with sauce and ranch - both were very good. But------ the dough was almost stale. Had no flavoring. Was very very bland. Then we waited. Waited. Waited. A couple who ordered after we ordered the appetizer - got their pizza. We waited. Waited. Waited. And the waiter who was so pushy early? Nowhere to be found. Pizzas came out - little to no toppings, the crust was stale again - and it wasn't as "big" as advertised by our waiter. Really disappointing. I like divey places with good food - this isn't one of them. read more

See all

When you come to Davis, WV you must know the options are a bit limited for dining out! Fear not, Sirianni's pizza is a famous hole-in-the-wall Italian inspired place. Of course, they are known for their pizzas for which we got the "Artery Clogger." Though it was delicious, the mounds of meat and oil made me not want to have pizza for weeks afterward! read more

See all

Well, really disappointed that we didn't eat at the place I originally researched. I guess when we get used to such an up to the minute, google world and the place is closed when you travel 1.5 hours away, it reminds you to go back to the archaic phone to call and see if they're open. Anyways, not this place's fault. Well, it looked cute from the outside and just a quick, last minute glance on Yelp from past photos, looked appealing. When we go to the waiting area, we did wait for a while without a hello or hi. Lucky, I think, this place had a sign reminding me that its only cash or check. They have an ATM so I snagged 40$ thinking that would be enough for pizza and drinks for 2. WE sat in a nice place where we weren't in the middle of everything, but regrettably we may have been out of sight. I think this is the first time I have ever been to a restaurant where the waiter is asking what I want to order before I have even read more than the first page. Maybe he assumed we were regulars and knew what we wanted. WE ordered the Parmesan appetizer because I just shot from the hip. We got some sodas and waited for quite a while for just the app. Luckily it came before I fainted from starvation. :) We finishes day that and then we waited again for our pizzas. My pizza was legit on fire it was so hot. I am happy it was serviced warm of course, but beware to blow on it before you bite into it. It was all okay and the women's bathroom was really cute with framed vintage store cut outs from catalogs, like Tiffanys & Co. I also tried to play some music on the touch tunes, but even though it was on the app, the juke box wasn't hooked up to an internet so that I could select a song from the comfort of my chair. Hopefully my date enjoyed the day even though it was pretty much a bust. read more

Sirianni’s Pizza Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Davis, West Virginia

Unfortunately we did not have the great experience most people did on this site. I thought it best to post my review as it was life threatening. Six of us dined there Thursday around 2pm, out of the six of us, four of us ended up with salmonella poisoning and one of those persons are still in the hospital (my 74 year old mother). The salmonella was confirmed by the hospital and it was the only thing we all had to eat that day. One person was immediately sick after leaving the restaurant, the other three it hit later and lingered into the next day. We all ate pizza except one of us and all of us had different toppings. My only thought is that it was cross contamination somehow. read more

So I'm from DC and won a mystery trip which turned out to be to wonderful West Virginia! Our big group dinner one night there was at Siriannis. As soon as the trip staff told me they used a ton of garlic, I was all "SOLD!" There was about 20 of us in our group and they had put together a lovely spread of different things for us. We started with 2 big salads, seemed to be Greek and Antipasto of some sort. Then we had two types of cheese sticks - garlic and parm. Next it was several types of pizza including the veggie and BBQ. And as if that wasn't enough already, we then had the Aglio Olio and Pomodoro pastas! As a huuuuge garlic lover, the garlic cheese sticks and the Aglio Olio pasta were my two favorite items from the night. The pasta was legit swimming in garlic and so freaking good! I mean, everything we had was delicious! I really liked the crust on the pizza as well - not too thick and not too thin... it was juuuuust right! Our server, Misty, was fantastic and didn't even skip a beat handling our big crew. She was super attentive the entire time and always made sure my wine glass was full! Definitely a good spot for some good eats! Whenever I return to WV next, I will make sure to stop in! read more

See all

Spaghetti from a Italian Restaurant should be a easy basic crowd pleaser. This dish I was served was not pitiful Pasta- acceptable. nothing too bad or good Sauce- I think the sauce should accommodate the pasta and meatball this sauce did neither was more of paste then a sauce leaving the dish dry and hard to digest. Meatballs- This is my biggest let down. Super simple a lightly seasoned mix of meat cooked into a tasty ball that blends with the dish these meatballs were undercooked and mushy with poor flavor with the mixture of thin soft angel hair, paste"sauce", and a mush meatballs makes a very unpleasant mixtures of texture. Overall- Maybe someone enjoys this stuff but I would visit this establishment again nor would I Suggest it. read more

Sirianni’s Pizza Cafe - Sirianni's Pizza Cafe, Angel hair, marinara, and meatballs. - Pizza Near Me - Davis, West Virginia

The XXX pizza was amazing. Also. The stuffed peppers with cheese is to die for. The waitress recommended them. She was outstanding also. Will definitely go back. read more

Absolutely recommend this place. Staff is very friendly and hard working so be patient if there is a bit of a wait. It is worth it! Salads are delicious starters and big portions. Pizzas are great are served hot. read more