First time ordering from this pizza place as quite a few people from my husband's work said it was good. We were a little surprised by the cut of the pizza into strips and squares but it was a nice surprise as it kind of reminded us of the late 80s early 90s vibe. We got a royal feast pizza and the chicken chef salad for pick up. The pizza was good with alot of toppings, good amount of sauce, good flavor and it holds up well for leftovers the next day. The salad was huge with a good amount of dressing provided and very filling. We will order from here again read more

Service is always great but $25 for a pizza is a lot. Plain cheese starts at $22.50 and pizzas are only 14 inches. Also they always overcook it and use a conveyer oven like 'fast food' pizza. Bottom was all crunchy, black, and full of air pockets . Not as good as it used to be. The place is also right out of the 70's. A major dining room overhaul in decor is needed. read more

We came in for a bite after driving most of the day . We ate always looking for good pizza just like our former state of NY. We found a pretty good slice, we ordered a pie with garlic powder . Usually it's on the table but they do it for you. Pizza was very good and had a tasty sauce and this crust . Our waitress was great and the ambiance of the restaurant was cozy . A bit dark but cozy. Price was reasonable as well. Would come here again when in the area. read more

Sir Pizza - Dining area - Pizza Near Me - Murfreesboro, Tennessee

See all

East Main location is fantastic. Food has been my favorite since they opened the door in the 1970's. Cool atmosphere with good service.

Love their pizza one of the best in the area . This is our fav Sir Pizza location. There aren't many dine in pizza restaurants in the area. Yes it's older but pizza is amazing. Staff was very friendly. read more

Great pizza! Service was okay too! It's an old time pizza place with quaint atmosphere.

Don't order brownies you get 1 that is 1in by 2in for 8.00 something. We were missing a breadstick also so called was told what do you expect me to do and they hung up. read more

Sir Pizza is our favorite pizza in Murfreesboro! Not only is the pizza delicious, but the service is wonderful, and the price is reasonable. The Farmer's Almanac is my go-to, with ham, pepperoni, mushrooms, peppers, onions, olives, and sausage! read more

The pizza was exceptional! Outstanding flavor and authenticity. However the price was very high! read more

My favorite Sir Pizza location is in Main Street. Nostalgic and comforting. Over the years there's been changes but the Pizza is what you should be coming for. read more

My favorite pizza place ever. Definitely has the most character and best interior of any other restaurant. I hope this time capsule stays open forever and never changes. The staff is always super friendly to me, too. read more

They no longer have the buffet and have gone strictly to conveyor belt pizza. Instead of cooking it in the oven. As you can see conveyor belt pizza becomes burnt on top. read more

Sir Pizza - They no longer have the buffet and they've gone strictly to conveyor belt pizza, which, as you can see overcooked the top of the pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Murfreesboro, Tennessee

Excellent calzone! The crust was not overly thick, as most restaurants tend to make them. Seasoned and filled terrifically. Still thinking about the immaculate flavor, even long after the fact. The atmosphere of the interior is something that I won't forget. Built in the 1960's, its vintage style has been maintained beautifully! The stained glass fixtures and overall medieval theme is nothing short of charming...I must confess...I kind of wish I lived there! Craving more. 10/10. read more

I've been going to Sir Pizza for over 40 years; met my wonderful husband at the East Main location 44 years ago, so Sir Pizza holds a special place in my heart! However, I'm sad to say that the culinary quality has diminished, while Sir Pizza's prices have soared! At best, if the food was its once-phenomenal self, I'd still only eat here rarely as the prices are so high. Many of the reviews here are about the pizza specifically, and I think many are expecting "traditional" pizza, which is what sets SP apart from the rest. In saying that, the ingredient quality if the pizza isn't the same. We either order Farmers Almanac or Royal Feast. The wings are imho, awful. Greasy, gloppy and inedible. Did I mention the pricing? Fun fact as I depart-the phone number of my in-laws was one digit different that Sir Pizza East Main's number. My father-in-law grew weary of taking the calls and explaining. So he just started taking "orders". Pretty sure there were some unhappy customers back in the day! read more

No delivery service, we chose another pizza place that delivered. Traffic is terrible here and we have little kids, having pizza delivered is important for us! Wish we could have tried your pizza. read more

It's still my family's favorite pizza in the 'boro. The staff is friendly. The pizza is the best. Our go to order: cheese fingers & kings feast + add mushrooms = YUM. read more

One thing we miss about living in Indiana, is the pizza. Seriously. Pizza King Pizza is where it's at. Recently, we visited family near Nashville, and were told of this Sir Pizza. Holy crap, it's almost identical to the pizza we've so dearly missed. We ordered take out so I can't say much about dining in. But the fella on the phone was very friendly, our order was ready in about 15 minutes, and the food was amazing! I hear they have a buffet, as well, which sounds intriguing. The pizza is the square cut pieces we love and tasted amazing! We ordered a 14 inch pepperoni and an 8 inch cheese-less pineapple, ham, banana pepper pizza for me. It was perfect!! I do wish they had the breadsticks that are like the ones we've missed from our Indiana days, but I can't fault them for that. Everything was perfect and we were so excited to get a hold of some amazing pizza on this trip. read more

My family and I have been going to sir pizza for years! We had no idea this location even existed until recently! We checked it out and wow! It is SO cool on the inside. You have to check it out for yourself. It has "castle" or "renaissance" vibes! So neat! Not to mention amazing pizza! read more

Hands down this is the best pizza ever!! I've been eating here for as long as I can remember. My parents brought me here as a very young child. The building is old and parking is limited BUT the pizza is NEVER a disappointment. Tuesday night has the special of but one pizza at regular price get a second for $2; Monday and Wednesday evening has buffet which includes salad and pasta. During the weekdays they have buffet also during lunch. I will have to admit that we only go to this Main St location as the one on Memorial wasn't near as good. Main St. location is the original location in Murfreesboro and still the best one. Cooks and staff have a nostalgic appearance and they are extra friendly. 3/2/2018 visit was amazing as usual. Tried something different this time, Calzone. You get 3 toppings for $9. It was over the top good. I haven't had a calzone that good in probably 25 years. It was my first time trying it there. You can't go wrong with a Kings feast pizza, Royal feast pizza or a Calzone. The salad bar is not much but I don't go to pizza restaurants to eat salad. Anyway, great meal as always!! read more

I have ate sir pizza since I was a child and it is a good local spot that has always been constituent with a neat atmosphere . That being said I will never understand the prices especially for the pizza. read more

I had not eaten from Sir Pizza in over 20 years since I moved to Texas. As I headed east on Main that craving set in. That night I ordered the Royal Feast for me and my daughter. It was terrific. The same great quality and taste over two decades later. Thank you for enduring. read more

Sir Pizza on East Main St. Still has the best pizza in town. However, the salad bar was not good this week. Lettuce was old & shredded like cole slaw. Very disappointing as that's all I ordered. read more

Wow. Step back into 1976 and enjoy a great pizza. Place is somewhat tired looking mainly the carpet but the ambience is all 1970s with true pizza making expertise. Don't hesitate to stop in. The pizza sauce is special and really helps make it a top 20 pies I've ever had. read more

This place has been here since 1966 so keep that in mind. The fact that it is an older establishment is what makes it so charming and cozy. It's a fun atmosphere with a "stranger things" vibe. Stopped by for the buffet. Service was friendly. Salad bar was plentiful, thought the pizza was decent tasting, my husband on the other hand thought it was great. Overall had a nice lunch. Worth a visit , would be a cool place for a birthday party. read more

See all

Old school vibe. Great pizza. Cold beer and great service. I've been coming here since I was a kid. Love it.

The Pizza is amazing! I've lived in Murfreesboro my whole life and tried Sir Pizza for the first time. We went to the location on Main Street in Murfreesboro. It is so cozy and warm inside! You really do feel like you're in an old castle My seven year old really enjoyed it. She ate almost a whole small pizza by herself! We'll definitely be back for our next family pizza outing. read more

Me and my husband have been going to the sir pizza on memorial for 20 years and my ladies always take care of me but these last few months I have been going have been terrible they never have beer that's on the menu there always out of lettuce or something else on the menu the employees stay in the back so you have to say hello just to get some attention there dinning room stays dirty. The lettuce taste like dirt the pizzas have no toppings even though your paying 30 dollars for a pizza. I don't know if this place got new management or new owners but this place is going down hill I don't think I'll ever come back I don't recommend this restaurant to anyone get a manager that cares about the family owned business like your east main location. read more

I was looking forward to trying out the restaurant and wasn't disappointed. Food was fantastic, the staff were friendly and provided a good service. I will definitely be coming back and will recommend to family and friends... and 10% off for MTSU students!! read more

Sir Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Murfreesboro, Tennessee

See all

I've been coming since I was a kid in the 70's. Decor hasn't changed a bit. Always great pizza. Thin hand tossed crust. Toppings to the edge. Square cut. Melt in your mouth. Huge glasses of soda. Crushed ice. read more

Sir Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Murfreesboro, Tennessee

If there were an option for ZERO stars I'd do it. Horrible service. Rude staff. Dirty. Ignored the entire party until we spoke up. We had to clean our own tables. On a good note. We avoided food poison by the looks of the food and the competence of the staff. read more

Stopped by at noon with a friend... One of the pizza heating units for the pizza buffet was not working...the unit that was working seemed to have only one or two types of pizza that seemed to have been reheated, I was very disappointed. I had to ask for refills for our drinks twice. This was once one of the 'Boro's best pizza places. I'm sorry to see it's decline read more

Sir Pizza on East Main St. Still has the best pizza in town. Great service too! They no longer have the lunch buffet, but we like ordering our own pizza with salad. read more

This review is on the lunch buffet. Was not impressed at all. They advertize soup, pasta and salad bar along with the pizza. Well the pizza choices were slim, just two different types. NO PASTA AND NO SOUP. Salad bar was good though. For the price I should have stayed on campus and gone to one of the cafeterias. I do not reccomend the buffet at all especially when they charge you for soup and pasta and dont deliver. Hopefully there regular pizzas are better. read more

not my favorite but the buffet is good when you wanna chow down on pizza at a reasonable price. a couple of the booths have hanging swings. kinda funny that a place with porch swings for seating has spring mix on their salad bar instead of iceberg. ha! we had the cheese fingers appetizer and they tasted like bland, frozen stuffed breadsticks. i'm glad their pizza was much better than the appetizer. fun place to go when you want cheap beer and decent pizza. i'll go back for sure. read more

Sir Pizza - half cheese, half black olive pizza & $1 happy hour beers - Pizza Near Me - Murfreesboro, Tennessee

See all

Pretty disappointed. We were looking for some good local pizza delivery other than ordering Papa John's. Unfortunately Sir Pizza isn't it. They are quite expensive, $40 for two pies, delivered, with a $4 tip. The quality didn't even come close to the price. The dough was soft and undercooked and the toppings were subpar. Do yourself a favor and move on looking for a good delivery pizza joint. read more

I've lived in Murfreesboro for 12 years, and I've never been impressed with the quality of food. I've eaten at Sir Pizza 2 times and won't again. On top of that, I now live close by to one of the establishments and when I'm near the restaurant I have heard any number of weird things coming from there but today there was screaming from the back, presumably a manager SCREAMING at one of her employees at full blast. I understand being reprimanded, but it left a terrible taste in my mouth. It's disturbing to hear when casually walking by, and concerning for safety. This isn't the first time something like this has been overheard. I will support any other local establishment any day over them, especially after what I heard. Deeply unimpressed. read more

1st visit to any location. I understand this is the original. An Elite gave it 5 stars so, what-the-heck. Since my kid really digs pizza it won't be a total loss. Atmo pretty retro. Limited menu touts claim of serving since '66. Ordered the Queen's Feast medium. Canned mushrooms, canned olives and frozen green pepper pieces. This may pass for quickie pizza or maybe people come here for the buffet (quantity) but overall it's not far removed from frozen food section pizza in the grocery store. There's a patronage for buffet-style pizza but I am not it. read more

Great service! I like this location so much better than the location in Madison. It just has a better atmosphere. Also, they have a buffet during the week that's cheap, great for nearby MTSU students. read more

Overall a decent pizza place. Theirs is a bit different, the pizza is thin crust, with small topping over the whole pizza to the very edge...which is I guess their trademark. I've been here a couple times and wouldn't mind coming back again, I like the change from the 'big chains'. Service was okay, seemed like there was only 1 waitress for the whole place this past visit. Prices are decent too, overall a solid 3 star to 3 1/2 star place. read more

Second time here. Pizza is good. Ingredients cut small and plenty on pizza. Crunchy crust. Tasty. Wings are very tasty and chicken was moist, sadly though, wings had no crunchiness. Service is just okay. When i arrived all tables were not cleared. Had to find a clean one. Not busy enough to not be clean. Otherwise pretty good. read more