It was so depressing in there. I guess it was previously a doctors office or something? It had little to no work to become a diner. I ordered a western omelette with hash brown and rye buttered toast; my boyfriend got a cornbeef hash omelette. His came out and was all cheese, but his potato's looked good. However my potatoes looked completely different. My onions in my omelette were not cooked; practically raw. My toast was practically just butter. Our waitress messed up our drinks after confirming with us. Then didn't check up on us the rest of the time as she was talking to another server in the back. She just brought us the check and didn't ask if we needed anything else. read more

Silverton Diner - butter with no toast - Diners Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

Personnel very friendly, helpful and customer service oriented. Food always presentable, hot and very tasty. read more

We have eaten here a lot and also ordered to take out! Food is ok for a local diner however eating in requires a lot of time! Service is slow, so if you are in a rush go somewhere else! Brunches are good omelettes, French toast is good! Ambiance is average. read more

Perfect quick bite with super friendly service. Everything is freshly prepared. This is truly a classic American diner. I ordered a turkey club on toast, side of Russian dressing. It comes with fries and coleslaw. It was on point. My husband ordered a grilled chicken Caesar wrap which Aldo came with fries. We left full and happy. That's what a finer is about! read more

The Silverton Diner is a very straightforward one with basic American food. I have driven by it countless times but never went in. When I first entered, I did not expect much because the atmosphere is very basic and a little dated. However, I soon realized that they have their procedures down. I respect restaurants that provide food in the way they promise with no fluff. I ordered basic chocolate chip pancakes, and that's what I got . . . efficiently. They have basic coffee, but it serves its purpose, and your mug keeps getting refilled. I also found the service to be polite, straightforward, and efficient. The place is a well-oil machine. I didn't go for dinner, just breakfast, but maybe I'll try dinner next time. They could also tidy up the back counter area, too. They could use longer hours, but that's their business decision. If you are looking for a bougie brunch with a hip atmosphere and trendy recipes, maybe this isn't the place for you. But if you just need a quick, efficient meal that hits the spot for relatively low prices, then the Silverton Diner does that very well. read more

Silverton Diner - Chocolate chip pancakes (comes with three of them. Hungry me already ate one before I took this photo) - Diners Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

Always order chicken fingers from there comes with fries and coleslaw, awesome! Portions are generous.

I have only had breakfast here once- it's close to my house. It looks very small from the outside but that's deceiving. The eggs, English muffins, pancake and potatoes were very satisfying. The sausage a little dry. I like the big juicy links from other places better. Their English muffins were very good. Not Thomas' which are flimsy. But these were dense and very good and seemed fresh. Servers check in often if you need anything, and take away empty plates often. Nice bright place- needs updating and maintenance of booths and walls, decor, etc. overall it was a nice breakfast that I was happy to eat they also had some nice unique seasonal specials which included soft shell crabs. Prices are average. read more

Silverton Diner - Placemat - Diners Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

I actually work at this Diner and have worked here on and off for seven years. The owner al is an amazing boss and owner. He is fair when it comes to prices and the portions are amazing. The food is also fabulous! You wouldn't be able to tell it from the outside however, it is very big on the inside. The whole ambience of the restaurant is just very nice. He's decorated for holidays waitresses are always nice and respectful and after a few cuts in workers, the place has been running very well. I know I am a server here however, I'm all about telling the truth. There is some things that could be better however, all in all, it's a great Diner one of the best I've ever been to, and plenty of people can contest to that, so come on down and get yourself some Silverton Diner food thank you guys. Lobster Bisque Hot Pastrami Chip Beef Chicken Croquettes Chicken Salad Corn Beef Omelet German Specials Paninis Pebble Peach Salad Philly Cheese Steak Stuffed Flounder Wraps Amazing Specialty burgers Delicious deserts Also they have a small appetite for 16.99 that comes with soup or salad.. pot and veggies and also desert read more

Food was very good Service was also very good Ambiance was nice nothing special. I would go again if in area read more

Very comfortable, clean, and decently decorated. Good portions and fair price. Did the oktoberfest dinner sauerbraten...big portion and dumplings n red cabbage. Fair price, and I've done breakfast here as well. If your senior citizens then for breakfast, u should go to IHOP for 55+ in all fairness. Otherwise I've been here a few times big portions and good. read more

Expensive , mediocre breakfast for a DINER! If you can't serve a great breakfast as a diner, you've lost. I ordered pancakes, plain ol pancakes. I received 3 cool to warm cakes that tasted like there was cornmeal somewhere in the pancake batter and that cost 10 dollars! Enough said! read more

I'm visiting my parents down the shore, and saw the good reviews for here. We love diners so we wanted to try. Our waitress was super nice. She was the only good thing about our visit. The food was terrible. My mom got a burger (tomato on it looked fresh But after she ate , and it my toddler went to taste it and handed it back immediately we realized it must have been sitting in something that had gone sour and had an odor.) My mom was sick from the food all night. My dad had hot pastrami , cheese wasn't melted it was ice cold. My dad ate half. The waitress realized how bad it was and nonchalantly told my dad she took it off the bill (even though we weren't saying anything). She said it didn't look good. I got eggs, potatoes and bacon. Eggs were so over cooked fried they were like thin burnt paper. Potato's were barely fried. My Toddler had spaghetti and meatball. She wasn't feeling good when we got home too. I tasted the meat ball. Idk what meat it tasted weird. Skip this diner for dinner. Feel terrible my parents wasted money eating here and got sick. We would have had a better meal at Roy Rodgers down the street. While I know things are tough bouncing back from these tough times there's no excuse to use sour/bad food or cook improperly. read more

Another enjoyable breakfast at the New Silverton Diner. Had a peasant omelet which is sausage, onions & potatoes... I had them add Swiss cheese & put my eggs on the side...really cooked perfectly.. my wife had a Belgian waffle with bacon & low calorie syrup... overall everything is good here including the attentive service. read more

Silverton Diner - Diners Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

So, so place to eat. I have eaten here twice and will not go back. Upon paying for our meal the hostess asked how was the food. I informed her the meal I had was not very good and did not eat it. She only discounted the meal I had which was less then the meal. Find another establishment for food Open face turk read more

Silverton Diner - Pool - Diners Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

The Silverton Diner is your prototypical small town diner. Booth and table seating, local wait staff, and small town regulars. I came in early on a Saturday morning before a small rush. I was greeted and seated quickly. The waitress asked if I'd like coffee. The coffee arrived and my order was taken, the food arrived quickly. I ordered pancakes, eggs and bacon with wheat toast. The eggs and bacon were fine, cooked to order, and not overly greasy like some diner food. The pancakes were underwhelming in both appearance and taste. They looked and tasted overcooked and chewy. The flavor just wasn't there. I'm also not a huge fan of pre-packaged containers of syrup and butter. I like it to be served on the side or in a reusable container. The coffee was below average but I'm a coffee snob so it's unfair judgement. For the service and food quality I was surprised by bill was $13 for what I thought was an $8 breakfast. Pros: Fast and courteous service Family owned and operated Cons: Below average food Average atmosphere read more

Silverton Diner - Diners Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Today is 6-13-2023 I took my very hungry 93 yr old mom and I to this place and I've been there before but never again . Today we both had sliced turkey on a chefs salad, and a turkey Dagwood sandwich special for my mom . Within 30 minutes we were both with diarrhea I called them as soon we both were sick to tell the cashier and she took my phone number and said she would get back to . Nothing not a word it's been several hours which no response . 5 hrs ago to be exact . You suck and so does your bad food . It's not clean and the coffee we got was cold had to have them make new coffee and my moms turkey sandwich was ice cold which it wasn't supposed to be and the waitress returned it the correct way only to get us both sick . Nice customer service NOT read more

Never again. We ordered "breakfast for dinner" for a quick meal. HAH! It took 25 minutes to get our meal and the coffee never came. No refills on the water. Potatoes undercooked. Toast cold. One customer brought a dog in and it appeared to be eating out of her plate! Music was early 1950's....happily barely audible. Never again! read more

Atmosphere: The diner has a huge sign that can't be missed. It's located in a shopping mall.   The interior has several booths, tables, and a bar. It's a big space but nothing special or unique. Coffee: The coffee was brewed hot and fresh with plenty of refills.  It was good coffee. Food: The Silverton Diner has plenty of options. There are several breakfast, lunch, and dinner specials. I wasn't sure what I wanted. I had a migraine, and I wasn't that hungry. I decided to order the pebble peaches salad with chicken. It was a small salad with greens, canned peaches, nuts, and chicken, crunchy noodles. It was topped with balsamic glaze was tasty. It was a good salad for what I wanted for the day, but it wasn't my favorite ever. If I had been more hungry, I know I would have been more disappointed. Service: Even though the diner wasn't that crowded, the waiter took a while to come back. He seemed disconnected from the table and his day. He was nice, but it seemed like he didn't want to be there and forget Cyds soup and brought out the wrong dressing. Overall Thoughts/Would I come back? It wasn't a bad diner, but it wasn't my favorite. It was right in the middle as far as diners go. read more

Silverton Diner - Diners Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

My first time coming to this diner, enjoyed my food. The waitress was nice and welcoming to me and my mom. 4 stars!

We recently went back, and these guys continue to do a nice job. Pros: a) The stuffed flounder remained great! b) Excellent soups. c) Wonderful variety. d) They are great putting together to-go orders. e) The nice friendly vibe in the atmosphere remains. Cons: a) I spoke with the owner, and they still don't have wi-fi. He explained it was coming. read more

See all

I loved the Jersey Benedict. The only thing was the eggs were over cooked. I liked that they used the larger English Muffin to accommodate the pork roll. The Hollandaise says was excellent. It was much better than Taylor Sam's version. read more

I've lived in town for over 20 years, just never ventured over to eat here. My best friends family is a staple there for 20+ years and I absolutely see why! My fiancé got us sandwiches for dinner and I work late so mine was refrigerated for hours. It was absolutely delicious!!!!!!! I couldn't imagine how great it was fresh and honestly I'm pumped to go back and get it fresh! We had the Reuben and some type of amazing roast beef with caramelized onions that was seasoned with angels prayers and genie wishes. Thanks for such a great dinner and we can't wait to return sooner than later! read more

Absolutely love this diner! When they check you in at the front they ask what you want to drink and the waitress brings it right over to you. Food comes out quicker than most restaurants and the prices are very fair! read more

A friend of mine turned me on to this diner, since I live in Monmouth County (someone please get a good diner up here!) and probably wouldn't have tried a random diner in a strip mall in Toms River... I'm glad she did! I've tried a few things from here and nothing has disappointed! The lobster bisque is always my go to. Recently, I had the Blue Claw salad and that crab cake could stand up against the many I've had (including ones I've had in MD and in many seafood restaurants). Fish and chips are also really great! The quality of food here is definitely beyond what you'd expect from a diner! read more

Silverton Diner - Blue claw salad. - Diners Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Had lunch with my parents and kid the other day. Coffee was good and we constantly got refills. My mom's parents were delicious and our paninis were excellent, service was good and the owner even came by and said hello and cleared off our table. Would definitely go back! read more

This diner is a little hidden gem in the area. There are many other large over-the-top standard looking diners in the area, but this little diner, tucked into a small strip mall, is really actually quite good. I haven't tried any of their dinner options -- been burned too many times in the past ordering actual dinner/meals at diners. But we've had plenty of breakfast and plenty of burgers and they are all consistently delicious. It's just basic diner food, but that's what you order at a .. DINER. And even though it is basic diner food, I've been in way to many in the area that can't get even that right. The burgers at the Silverton diner are really fresh, and they use an awesome kaiser bun. Eggs and home fries are always good. All in all, when I am in the mood for diner fare, this is the ONLY diner near Brick that I will continue to visit. read more

Food is delicious but the service is very slow. Takes forever for the food to come out. If you ever need an extra napkin or drink it will take a lot of time. I went during lunch and it wasn't even busy. If you have a lot of time to spare then come by. read more

The food is always delicious and hot here. The staff always go above and beyond to make sure everything is right. The price is great. You really can't beat it. read more

SILVER crowd, TON of bad reviews coming. So we were hungry and it was convenient to what we were doing. Not crazy about the CARPETED floors (never a good thing in a food place) or the straw wrappers under our booth but we were starved. Bathrooms older and in need of makeover.I have literally used better bathrooms in the NY Port Authority and those aren`t great. Food is something akin to what I imagine they serve up in assisted living dining rooms= bland basic food. Freezer fries,and nothing I can`t whip up at home.Usually,while not expecting gourmet fare at a diner I do wish it is elevated past what I can do at home. Refills were hard to come by even when not so busy at 2pm. So many other choices around- RUN from the Silverton read more

I just spent seventy seven dollars yesterday 8/9/22 and the diner I order came with a free dessert .So I ask if I can take my rice pudding home with me. I watch the. waitress scraped the last of the rice pudding out of the pan .She told the cleanup man I have to get a new pan of rice pudding.well I got home and the rice pudding was sour. thank for tell me not to stop there again.It used to be worth a trip not anymore. read more

The food is good. Service was very good. The ambiance was a problem. Fox News on two tv's. Nice music would help.

Vanessa the manager is rude. She answered the phone rude, and snapped at my husband when he tried to place a pick up order. When he arrived to pick up his food, other customers came into the diner behind him, she shoved menus at them and told them "go sit down over there". Items on the menu they said they don't make and never heard of. Sides for the takeout were packed into the same container. Items for the order were missing, and when called to ask about it, we were told, "you have to ask for them" even though they were on the menu. Then when he was leaving with the take out order, she demanded to know where her tip was. Never going back there, or recommending. read more

Silverton Diner - Diners Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Silverton Diner is my all time favorite diner. I've been coming here since I was a kid. The food is much more than typical diner fare. The lobster bisque is better than ones I've gotten at seafood restaurants. The blue claw salad has a crab cake on it that could be served in Baltimore! A diner in a strip mall shouldn't have such good food! The servers have always treated myself and family with such kindness! I live in North Carolina now but when I visit, they all still know me. I'm not sure why this diner has such a poor rating but please don't let it stop you from giving Silverton Diner a shot! read more

Silverton Diner - Corned beef hash omelet with ketchup doused home fries - Diners Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

The worst service ever waitress said dinners special were done when they're wasn't the lobster biscuit soup was nasty and I had to ask for crackers and breakfast are over priced read more

Been going here 4 many yrs but never thought to write a review....don't know why?? Guess cause it's "a diner"; but, actually this place is so un-diner-like it's ridiculous! The food is A-MAZ-ING! (And, this is coming from someone who has always thought thta diners are for Breakfast - PERIOD! (OK,maybe lunch) So, my husband ordered a cup of the Lobster Bisque (b/c he was really hungry & couldn't wait for the Hot Open RB he ordered to be served) AND it RIVALED the better Seafood Restaurants in the area (and since this is the Jersey-Shore, that's really saying something! .....NO BS! The Calamari, served with 2 really incredible dipping sauces (although not listed on any online menu(?), is a MUST-HAVE! And, OMG, the Eggplant Fries served w/ a scrumptious Southwestern Ranch sauce, are 2 die 4! As a Fanatical Chicken Salad Aficionado (I've had it EVERYWHERE...in & outside the States and there's is THE BEST! ) The Silverton doesn't much seem like a "diner" -- the owners should have went with a "Bistro" as they have all the ingredients! (Except the staff) UNFORTUNATELY, most of their servers are HORRIBLE! It's a sad statement when one can say that the servers are as consistently bad as the food is consistently delish! read more

Fast friendly incredible food service caring long term establishment 10 stars dedicated to excellence !!!!!!!!!! The last of what matters pride love and devotion to patrons and staff Family read more

This place is great, the food came out quick and was delicious! The service was quick and daily OK. The place could use a make over to be quite honest. read more

Very nice ambience. Very spacious placement of tables - not crowded, although we came at a slow day so not a lot of customers. Waiter was very attentive and professional. Food was average as far as diners go, but otherwise a very nice experience. read more

I have been going to this diner for quite some time. Tonight my sister and I took the kids there for dinner. Towards the end of our meal the black hair hostess behind the counter began giving us dirty looks because my 20-month-old niece was being loud, she did this a few times and when we finally spoke up about it she gave another dirty look and said "can't you keep her quiet?" we are trying but she's a little kid, to which the woman replied "well people are complaining" The proper thing to do would have been for her to come over to us and say something, not stand behind the counter and give dirty looks. I am seriously considering not bringing my business there ever again! read more

We eat here at least two/three times a month. It is comfortable, can't beat the service, and there is always a good cup of coffee, chicken soup or rice pudding to put a smile on your face. Highly recommend the onion rings too!! read more