It's sad to say that this is now my second bad review for this location. We ordered two sandwiches: a medium Georgetown which was fine, but also ordered a 16" Marshall. When the food was delivered and finally dug in the Marshall has absolutely no marinara sauce and the meatballs were as hard as a rock. My boyfriend called to let them know and all we were told was "the sauce on the sandwich is what's in the scoop".. for a 20$ sandwich you'd think a little more care would be shown. We wanted to give this place another opportunity but we are continuously disappointed by this location every time. Will not be returning again. read more

they are horrible they were 30 minutes past the delivery time and my warm subs were cold and my other subs were so soggy and nasty and they would not do anything about it. Also they have been out of the cowboy sandwhich supposedly for months now. worst sandwhich service ever and there assistant manager is completely rude and was unwilling to help... do not use this silver mine subs use the other location cause they have never done this read more

From taking my order at the cash register to making my sandwich she didn't wash her hands or glove up. After being ignored awhile I had to ask if they're soda machine was working. Asked for a knife no knives so they gave me a spoon... wtf. No lids. Asked for lids was given wrong size and the next lid given it didn't even fit. Never got one that fit. Was super rude when I was for more mayo and gave a overexaggerated large cup of it. Definitely won't be coming back or recommending it to anyone. Wish I could have done zeros stars. read more

I don't order food often, Silver Mine was one I did use. But one night I wanted to eat and I wanted something sweet. My sandwich showed up, without the cookie I ordered It was early and I asked them to bring my cookie when there driver was out. The manager couldn't grasp this concept and after several minutes, they gave me my credit and lost my business for ever. read more

Man what is wrong with places in Colorado not wanting to accommodate their customers?! I miss Oklahoma! I came here and was so glad they offered a kids size sub, so I asked the girl behind the counter if I could get a 4in sub but I didn't need the "kids" meal it would go to waste & she said she didn't have that option that she couldn't sale me a 4in sub, well then sale me the kids meal but keep the stuff that comes with it! What happened to customer service and accommodating them, aren't we why your in business anyway?! read more

If I could give a -10 I would. I have never have eaten at Silvermine subs So my wife and I decided to get a Philly steak sandwich from silver mine. After we got home it was a bitter disappointment,there was hardly any meat in the 16" I think they put the 11" meat on a 16" bun and it was not edible I had them add mushrooms and mushrooms were not cooked they were raw I spent $17 to get a bitter disappointment I will never go back to silver mine subs. And no one else should also go to silvermine subs. read more

If I could give 0 stars I would... I'm a big fan of Silver Mine... But the last 2 times I have ordered that have completely disappointed. My last 2 orders have been completely ruined by this location. It's not hard to make a good sandwich. I recently ordered a Buffalo Stampede which is the Buffalo chicken sandwich.. I asked for the ranch on the side and no lettuce. Ordered to go to take home and eat during a Broncos game. I eagerly opened up my sandwich only to find chicken breast and bread.. no cheese. No sauce....... What's with that? Then comes to my most recent order.. I thought I'd give it another shot.. got a Cheesesteak.. It took almost 2 hours to deliver to where I was working.. less than 5 minutes from this location. The sandwich was very cold... Half assed put together.. I asked for no red onions and they had put on red onions. Come on guys... read more

Girl with the pink hair refused to give me a refund! Very rude when i told her I felt bad she was working by herself hence didn't make my sandwiches after ordering but talked on the phone read more

Favorite sub place in Greeley. I think the bread seems more home made/fresh baked and the meat/cheese/produce selections fresher than major chain alternatives. Wish they would open up a location in South Denver Metro area!! read more

I ordered a chicken bacon ranch wrap and it was not good. The wrap was overall dry and had no ranch whatsoever. I would not recommend going to this place for wraps or subs ever. read more

I we t back in hopen the same guy would not be working and I was wrong and once again he was drunk and very rude. I'll never go back in there due to him. Which sucks cause I love the food. read more

Not only when I was ordering over the phone did I hear the manager ream his employee instead of having her put me on hold, when our food was delivered the hot sub and hot wrap were BOTH COLD! I'm extremely disappointed! read more

Seems pretty expensive to me for a sandwich, especially when they can't even get the order right. The only thing they got right with my order was adding sliced pickles to it. Wrong sub, wrong toppings, and wrong type of bread. Really annoying to find that out when u get ur order to go and don't open it until you're home. read more

Ordered the Cripple Creek in a wrap, it was delicious! The wrap tasted good, the meat was perfect, and there was just enough ranch. I was a little skeptical about the ranch part. I thought it would either have too little or too much, but NOPE, it had just the right amount. I absolutely love that they deliver and stay open late, super convenient! Also, had a chocolate chip cookie and it was soft and fresh. read more

The manager was rude the got our order completely wrong we order one 1 XL sub that my husband wanted and that came in a medium and the medium I had order came in the XL when confronted the manager told us she couldnt do anything about it . And the drivers dont carry change . We wont be ordering from one of what used to be favorite places read more

What a long day. I finally made it home. I wanted only some food and a nap. Called to Silver Mine Subs, ordered a Georgetown - delivery and hit the shower. Seriously quick delivery, I was completely taken off guard. On a Side Note, I've ordered from Silver Mine Subs before with family members and everyone, every time, we've been impressed. One bad, after eating the Georgetown sub I felt a little sick. Not sure what it was however I was left feeling a little queasy. It was probably me gobbling down a huge sub? Who knows? I got over it. To end on a good note: I'm a huge fan of subs and this establishment was perfectly impressive, once again. Order, Food and Delivery. (Huge Tip! - High Five!) read more

Avocados. They're for guac, right? Wrong. They're for the gd George town. I get that cripple creeks are delicious, and I agree. But if you don't eat a George town on white with no tomatoes (because who wants spaghetti plants on a sandwich?), then get out if Greeley. read more

I gave this location several tries and it's just been disappointing every time. My sandwich has been wrong every single time, and it's not like a Wheat-Chicken Bacon with extra Bacon and no Tomato is that difficult. Honestly, let's get it together. read more

Best sub in Greeley. There are so many different good choices, but the bread, meat and fact that they are a local Colorado company all put them above the 'chain' choices in town. Good value for the money. read more

Very good subs excellent delivery especially when they're coming out to an oil field site to deliver food.

I do like the "Mother Loade" sub as it takes care of that Meat craving. The other subs choices can be better.

Why the fuck is my order from this one (my only choice of delivery) always wrong? Always? Our orders aren't complicated. Also, we consistently pay for veggies (lettuce, pickles, olives, etc; have ordered 3+ times in past 3mo) that are NEVER there. My family loves the food, but not paying for food that is consistently not there. Step it up. I had a similar job yrs ago (and at a place with A LOT more combos/toppings) and it's pretty aggravating to see one of the simplest jobs consistently done so poorly. read more

An hour an a half for delivery every time...Seriously?

Waited one time for 2 1/2 hours for 2 subs. Talked to the GM said she'd give a credit for the 2 subs...only gave partial credit. Tried again....almost 2 hours. Hot subs were cold. Our pickle was warm. They told me our food had left the store over an hour ago....wow! No standards. Tried to speak with the manager and was hung up on. Had to go to king Soopers to fix the family dinner after waiting almost 2 hours. Will not try EVER again! read more

Called to place an order for delivery and the lady who answered the phone was so rude. . . . Fist time i called she placed us on hold for 10 minutes so i hung up and called back. Placed us on hold again and never came back on the line. read more

Sandwiches wrong....delivery times of 2 hours...order lost or never delivered...staff always seem unhappy with jobs...after 4 different tries im giving up on you for other sub shops... read more

Ah yes kiddos, buckle up for disappointment! I defy you to find a sandwich they can't screw up. I asked for turkey, bacon, mayo, and cheese. What did I get? One peice of bacon soaked in ranch dressing and guacamole of all things with the lettuce and the wrong type of cheese. Oh and to top it all off it was the wrong type bread. This is not the first time they have done something like this either. Save your time and money and eat at the Jimmy Johns down the street. read more