Amazing place to grab a slice of pizza! I got a Sicilian slice and wow it was great! Super thick and fluffy and had a great cheese and sauce ratio! The staff were super friendly. Lots of pizza options as well as other baked goods!! Will be coming back again for sure! read more

Silver Lake Pizza - Sicilian Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - West Harrison, New York

I've come here a few times, maybe 6. The pizza and other food looks great, the staff is helpful and friendly. Always busy, a real neighborhood joint. So what's the problem? The food is always just ok. Not bad. Not something that I would never eat. But it certainly doesn't taste as good as it looks. We have always gotten stuff to go... Subs, slices, chicken parm rolls, cookies. But by the time I get home it's just bland and old tasting. We live 12 minutes away, not that far. I'm sure I'll be back, it's a convenient spot after dropping the kids off and perhaps try eating in. The stuff sure does look good though. read more

Really solid pizza & italian spot in a cool little area! I loved the margherita slice, while the plain slice was just good (without being great). It wasn't too greasy, but it might have been too dry (same with the crust). Again, the marg slice was great and so was the penne. Also, they did a good job on the salad, if you ever saw the family guy clip about ordering salad from a pizzeria, you know what I mean. I'd def swing by again to Silver Lake. read more

Silver Lake Pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Harrison, New York

See all

Another stop for The Pizza Beast, this time at Silver Lake Pizzeria in West Harrison, NY--and this one's got real character. From the moment you walk in, it's got that old-school Italian feel: an old Italian guy in the back, apron dusted in flour, working the dough like he's been doing it for decades, while a Mexican pizza guy up front keeps the slices flying and the energy high. The crust is great with a satisfying crunch, the sauce-to-cheese ratio feels balanced, and every bite gives you that authentic New York flavor. The interior is tight and cramped, definitely more of a quick-slice joint, and parking is nearly impossible, but that's part of its classic city vibe. The Pizza Beast verdict: authentic, flavorful, and full of personality--7.8/10. read more

Silver Lake Pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Harrison, New York

I stopped by for a few slices because I hadn't been this way in a while. There was plenty to choose from and I chose a grandma slice, a lasagna slice and a margarita slice. We loved them all! The grandma slice had really good quality mozzarella cheese on top which I appreciated. The lasagna slice had great ricotta and a nice,rich meat sauce. All in all, everyone is really friendly and the pizza is delicious! I will be back! read more

See all

Stopped by for a few slices before catching a flight back home. So many different options! Slices were huge and prices were good! read more

Silver Lake Pizza - White Pizza, Lasagna Pizza, Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Harrison, New York

Food was wonderful. We will return Service was better than you could imagine. Comfortable table & chairs. We went there with another couple & they along with me this place is a must go to. read more

Fast delivery and the pizza was amazing! I love the variety offered for out if towners to try.

One of the best pies I ever had. I ordered an anchovie pie with extra cheese. It was perfect. No oil dripping. A solid pie. The sicilian slice is a meal by itself. It was so huge. I actually have never seen such a large piece. The salad was on point. Will order from them in the future. read more

Great pizza and great customer service. I messed up my order online and they replaced it for me when they didn't have to.

The BEST Pizza and Service! My Family eats at least twice weekly here and it's always fresh and delicious! Delivery is always quick can't say enough. Happy customer Lara read more

The workers behind the counter/register are always smiling and so friendly. It's nice to walk in somewhere and feel welcomed. They have a nice assortment of speciality slices/pies to choose from. Everything I've had here so far has been delicious. Regular pizza, pepperoni pizza, penne slice, Caesar salad, etc. read more

Silver Lake Pizza - Specialty Slice Pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Harrison, New York

The food is delicious. The pizza is delicious too Not soggy or burnt. This pizza shop makes great pizza with meatballs on the slice read more

Amazing pizza. We bought by the sliced pizzas to try a little bit of everything and everything was delicious. Everyone is stuffed and super happy this place is truly authentic Italian pizzas that are delicious. Recommend this place to everyone definitely hands down one of the best pizza place I've been to. Amazing pizza so delicious read more

I ordered an extra cheese and meatball pizza. It arrived early, hot and absolutely delicious!!! I haven't had NY pizza in 20 years, and oh the memories! I folded my slice, a dream come true! Thank you, Silver Lake Pizza! read more

Delicious food Always delivered warm And fast Nice park across the street Easy to find parking read more

I came here purely out of convenience, not expecting much; I left very impressed. First, the counter people were nice and attentive. You didn't have to get anyone's attention, they just kindly ask what you want (They were busy too). Whenever you try a new pizzeria you have to try their plain slice first, it's a law. The crust was paper thin, tasty, crunchy, and soft. I rarely eat the whole crust but this time was an exception. I also tried the grandma's. The tomato sauce was the perfect consistency and delicious. They used real fresh mozzarella with an olive oil/ basil drizzle. Great pizza spot over in Silver Lake. Affordable prices, great staff, and delicious pizza. Definitely check this place out. read more

Silver Lake Pizza - Plain Regular Slice Pizza and Grandma Roma Pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Harrison, New York

Brought my in laws and daughter to Silver Lake Pizza for an impromptu Monday night dinner. I saw that the grandma pie was recommended on Yelp, so I selected that to share with my daughter. We added an order of garlic knots. My mother in law got the broccoli rabe and sausage and my father in law got the chicken scarpariello. Both of their entrees came with a nice side salad. (Or pasta but they are being healthy) They were both happy with their entrees, the portions were good and it was served nice and hot. There's already something special about a pizza fresh out of the oven, not a reheated slice or a pie that's been driven across town, a fresh out of the oven pizza. This was a masterpiece of a pizza. I've had a number of different "grandma" pies over the years and this was one of the best. The thin crust made it not overly "bready", the fresh mozzarella was high quality, the San Marzano tomatoes had the perfect balance of sweetness and acidity, a pop of basil sealed the deal. A truly great pizza! My daughter had her slice and I kept going until the other 7 were gone. The garlic knots were also quite nice. The gentlemen working behind the counter were all pleasant and made sure it was a pleasant dining experience. Definitely worthy of a return! read more

Silver Lake Pizza - Delicious Grandma Pizza! High quality ingredients combined to create a pizza symphony! - Pizza Near Me - West Harrison, New York

My team and I were feeling pizza today, so I decided to treat my staff to lunch. The question then became where to order from - there are many pizzerias in White Plains, but we all wanted to try one we had not before. Silver Lake Pizza had been sitting in my bookmarks for a good while - and since they had an expansive menu we decided to order from them. I was pretty impressed with their menu selection - typical pizzeria offerings plus dedicated sections for specialty pies and grandma pies. I've really gotten into grandma pies over the last couple of years, mainly because I love thin crust pizza. I decided to order two pies - a medium (6-slice) with half pepperoni and garlic and half chicken cutlet. I also got a grandma pizza supreme which had sausage and broccoli rabe on it. The traditional pie was good - I'm a sucker for garlic so I was living my best aglio life. The crust on was slightly thicker than my personal taste, but I wasn't mad at it. The grandma pie was good too, but again the crust was slightly too thick for me. I'm used to super crispy, skinny legend crust and this was slightly soft and a smidge too thick. Toppings were generous though (on both pies) - and flavors were there. Service was great - the guy who answered the phone and took my order was very friendly and totally accommodating to my requests. Overall, I had a good first experience at Silver Lake Pizza. With their large selection of traditional, specialty, and grandma pies, I wouldn't hesitate ordering from here again. read more

Silver Lake Pizza - half pepperoni and garlic, half chicken cutlet - Pizza Near Me - West Harrison, New York

See all

Best pizza place around with the nicest staff. Last weekend I ordered a bunch of things for me and my friends. When I went to go pick it up and they were running a little behind which is totally understandable. The guy who packed my stuff must've not put the cover on correctly. When I called, they offered to deliver a new dish. Following week I came in and they remembered and were beyond accommodating. Have been going for years and will continue. read more

This might just be our new favorite pizza joint. Grandmas pizza stole the show with apparent quality ingredients, fresh herbs, and a great sauce. Word of advice- splurge the extra dollar & add mozzarella to the garlic knots... you won't be disappointed ..... you're welcome read more

Silver Lake Pizza - Grandma's pizza was way better than any pizza my grandma ever made! - Pizza Near Me - West Harrison, New York

Decent slice of pizza. Sauce, dough and portion of the slice size is excellent. Low yeast taste! Only things I didn't like about it, pizza is too soft/floppy and cheese was a bit too much for me. Really enjoyed the crust, delicious. read more

I order from SLP at least every other week, THE BEST Sicilian pizza I've had, also the Grandma's Shrimp Fra Diavlo is a nice different treat. All pizza is fantastic, top shelf ingredients and their food is also wonderful, pastas and chicken. They have also done catering for me at my job and their food got rave reviews. Delivery is always prompt. Well done SLP, keep up the good work. read more

This place was good! I ordered cauliflower pizza from here on Christmas Eve. They were one of the only places open. The service was speedy and my pizza was delivered in a timely manner. The pizza was yummy and delicious. I hadn't gotten the cauliflower pizza before, but it was good! I'd definitely order from here again (and try the regular pizza)! read more

Silver Lake Pizza - Cauliflower pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Harrison, New York

See all

Just ordered Delivery from Silver Lake as usual. The delivery was prompt and we accidentally over paid the delivery guy without realizing (this was aside from the tip) . We were pleasantly surprised when he came back in 1 minute asking us if we had accidentally overpaid. Such an honest decent man. We would have never known and he had no need to come back but he did. Sadly my husband did not ask him for his name. In todays world where everyone is out to make a quick buck, here was a delivery guy making the effort to be honest read more

I ate at this place two times in a row. They DO NOT go light on the toppings! Which I admire because I enjoy the toppings more than the crust itself. I also got the vodka pasta with meatballs and I got 3 GIANT meatballs. The salad was also loaded with topping and it was all super good. They sent bread and butter and 2 silverware with my to go order- that never happens! 10/10 read more

See all

Ordered 14 wedges for a party of 25. Frank was so helpful, cordial and professional. He had the wedges cut into 4ths and there was plenty for all to share. Everyone loved the wedges, buffalo chicken, chicken parm, sausage peppers onion, meatball cheese. Order was for 5:30 PM and was prompt and HOT! The staff at Silver Lake is always friendly and efficient. Will definitely be ordering again for large groups. read more

GREAT place for fig pizza and various chicken meals. Staff and son Frank da best for customer service . happt they are there instead of franchises . read more

I will start by saying a really great place for pizza/food. I wonder if you plan to order make sure you ask for it to be 15 to 20 minutes after the time you want because they're always early. Having people over and getting the delivery earlier than expected can be annoying bc it doesn't stay hot then. read more

Only gave one star because zero isn't an option. My husband called in a pizza and went to pick it up last night. He left his phone on the counter when he set the box down to pay and accidentally walked out with the pizza leaving his phone on the counter. He came home, which is a 3 min drive away, and told me he couldn't find it. I called Silver Lake and asked if he had left the phone there, if anyone had seen one or turned one in. The guy on the phone yelled out "has anyone seen a cell phone?" and told me no, there was nothing there. He clearly didn't bother to look as it was right in front of him on the counter; We tracked it and it didn't move the entire time it was there. My husband went right back and the phone was still on the counter, directly in front of and within the sight of the guy at the register. He said "this is my phone right?" and the guy just nodded. I was calling it nonstop too and they never answered to say that they had the phone in their possession. It seems they either could not be bothered to look directly in front of their faces and let me know that the phone was there, or were planning to keep the phone for themselves. So we'll never be ordering from this place again and I'll be sure to tell everyone in the area about their shady business practices. read more

have had them deliver to Purchase a number of time. pricey but delicious pizza. the slices are thin, good sauce, a little soft (not hard crust) but really nice mouth feel. generous sizes make up for the price. the delivery drivers are friendly and delivery is always fast. they're also very consistent. have never messed up one of my orders. read more

Silver Lake Pizza is in my top three favorite pizzerias in the greater White Plains area. I've ordered several times, and each time the pizza has been wonderful. Their wrap sandwiches are great too; their soups are a hit or a miss, but this is a pizza shop, not a soup shop! :) Highly recommend their grandma pie, which is like a Sicilian pie, but with a thinner crust. I'm not sure which is my favorite pie--it's a toss up between the Grandma Pizza Supreme with broccoli rabe & sausage, or the Lake Street with chicken cutlet, basil, cherry peppers, tomato & onion. These two pies are truly wonderful. Everything from the bottom up, the crust to the generous & delicious toppings are all high quality. Highly recommend! read more

Pizza was ok. Had Vodka Sauce Pizza but pizza needed more sauce. Also ordered Shrimp Diablo. Sauce was good. Staff and management very friendly. Wouldn't run back other pizza places in the area are better. read more

Silver Lake Pizza - Vodka Pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Harrison, New York

See all

This local pizza spot is one we visit once a week, either to pick up or after a game. Their old fashioned pizza is a staple in our home on pizza night! The staff is efficient and always polite. Also, they have an easy online ordering platform and up to $10 rewards - which is a plus in my book! 100% Recommend! read more

Pizza was good but was lacking in sauce. There's an option on the online order form for extra sauce, but one shouldn't have to pay more for an average amount of sauce. read more

Food is always fresh and cooked well. Service is handled well, my food is always ready I'm in and out. Thank you guys for all

Within recent months, the delivery quality has gone severely down. The food quality is still good, but I had ordered twice from this place within a month and had 2 terrible experiences with delivery. ***Please note that we have ordered from them in the past multiple times, have had better delivery service, and they have our address on file. 1. A few weeks ago, I had called to order a pizza pie. When I recite my phone number they read the address back to you; that's the standard protocol at this business. I noticed it had been about an hour and the delivery car wasn't there. I get a call from the driver asking about the address (he used the name of the street). I told him what landmarks to go by. It wasn't until 10 minutes later into the call that I even thought about the possibility that the driver wasn't even in the same town as me. Turns out despite having my address, he was in a different town. Eventually got the pizza. It was his first day so I tried to not be harsh with him. 2. This was this past Friday. We ordered a pizza pie. We realize an hour and a half later that we never got the food. We call the place and say it was delivered. Turns out the driver went to the wrong apartment AND when the people there said they didn't order a pizza, the deliverer insisted they did and left! They made us a 2nd pizza without charge. It took another hour to get to us. So for that one I blame the deliverer AND the people who took the pizza. I hate knowing I live in the same building as a food thief. In short, please teach your drivers and deliverer better etiquette and please train them better. Call the people who made the order, have the address written down correctly, and DON'T give someone else's food to people who didn't order it! Thank you. read more

Absolutely the best! Pizza and food is consistently excellent. Friendly staff, good prices. We absolutely love the chicken parm. Dinners. Pizza with meatballs and peppers is also a favorite Len read more

I ordered for the first time from here via Uber Eats. The driver accidentally gave our order to another family and their order was given to us. I was so upset and frustrated because my fiancé and I were both hungry and tried to be patient as things were being figured out. I ended up speaking to Frank, after we figured it out he kindly took care of us and had a fresh order sent to us I ordered the penne vodka with grilled chicken and my fiancé ordered the bolognese with spaghetti and meatballs. Everything tasted amazing! Not only was the food nice and hot, but it was actually worth the wait. The penne wasn't over cooked or under cooked and the vodka sauce was creamy and pink like it should be. The meatballs were nice and tender at every bite. We were both genuinely happy with our food and we are forever thankful to Frank and his patience :) customer service is important and he went above and beyond for us! Can't thank Frank enough for taking care of us! We'll be ordering again soon :) read more

Food and service are incredible! Had the meat lovers pizza and a Cobb salad. Both were delicious. If you're in the neighborhood, I highly recommend stopping for a meal. read more