Love coming here, always the first stop on my trip home. Cesar salad pizza is my favorite, but they have so many options that look amazing. The napkins have been changed since my last visit to paper thin, so thin the air conditioning was blowing it off my table if I didn't put the salt shaker on it. But the quality of the food and the quickness of service make this my favorite pizzeria. read more

Broadway Pizza - Pizza Near Me - White Plains, New York

See all

My co worker recommended this spot to me last summer and I been coming here since, We ordered a penne Vodka pie for the game it was delicious! read more

Broadway Pizza - Penne Vodka pie - Pizza Near Me - White Plains, New York

The food is so good. Especially the pizza. The service was great too. My brother wanted olives on his pizza and the chef went out of his way to make it special for him. The wait was 5 minuets. Amazing! read more

Tried the regular and margherita slices. Prices seemed steep for what the slices were. Margherita slice was pretty good. Big glops of cheese, which I didn't like as much. But the bites of sauce and cheese together were pleasant. 4/5 there. Basil was really just garnish and didn't have a real presence on the slice, which was a bummer. Plain slice was pretty good as well. Just your standard slice. Bread/crust for both lacked flavor. Wouldn't consider this my go-to, but it gets the job done if you're hungry or need a quick bite during lunch. read more

Have always loved Broadway Pizza! Best pizza around! Love their white pizza and chicken Parmesan pizza! Its so good. read more

Broadway Pizza - White pizza and Chicken Parmesan Slices - Pizza Near Me - White Plains, New York

Always a great meal here! I got the salad pizza and an eggplant Parm wedge. Don't know which I like better! Salad pizza was great, crunchy crust with lots of veggies. Really delicious. But the eggplant Parmesan wedge was perfect on a nice toasty Italian bread. Crunchy and delicious. Everybody's very friendly and nice here. Can't wait to try the other wedges! read more

Broadway Pizza - Pizza Near Me - White Plains, New York

See all

Grilled chicken Cesar salad slice is my favorite. I really like the ambiance and little tables. It's a quick grab and go pizza. The service is quick and staff is really professional. read more

People were very nice and patient with our order. We didn't ask how much each slice cost, but simple math lands around $5/slice for a pretty large slice! Thus far on our Westchester pizza journey, this place's chicken bacon ranch beat all our previous visits! Kid approved! The penne vodka was tasty and kid approved. Sesame chicken was too sweet for us, but if you like sesame chicken it tastes just like it (on a pizza)! Placed next to bbq chicken (probably since both are sweeter pizzas). Hubby liked the chicken caesar one (he likes caesar salads) - I can't get over the "salad on pizza" concept though (a carnivore through and through). We feel the buffalo did not pack enough heat for us. Would come back for a full CBR pie! read more

See all

Local pizza shop near my job. Good slice, buffalo chicken slice was flavorful and plentiful. Service is just ok and prices are a little steep, but it's convenient when you forgot your lunch lol read more

Broadway Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - White Plains, New York

Super solid pizza place! Very good buffalo and barbecue chicken slices. Their sesame chicken slice is unbelievably good. Maybe a bit pricey but nothing terrible. Only thing that throws me off is whenever I go in, theres like 5 employees always eating in the booths. Not that this is that weird, its just EVERY time haha. read more

Their margherita pizza and haley salad are the bomb. Staff is friendly and laid back. Feels comforting whenever you walk in.

Decided to get takeout as I've been craving chicken piccata. Our other Italian spot closed. Thankfully this place exists lol we got the chicken francese dinner and chicken piccata. Both dinners came with side salads. Everything was delicious. We'll definitely order again. read more

Broadway Pizza - Pizza Near Me - White Plains, New York

Best pizza ! Always great quality. Never disappoints us everything is delicious ! 10/10 recommend

The buffalo chicken pizza is one of the best buffalo chicken pies I've had. They put a generous amount of buffalo chicken. The pie is nice and crispy with a firm slice. It was also delivered. This pie was ordered through GrubHub, and one of the workers from Broadway was here promptly. If you haven't tried this place I highly recommend it. read more

Service 5 star Food 4 star Food was delivered on time with no mess. Questions were answered to the point. read more

food is good, BUT service is awful. employee I spoke with was very rude. Do not recommend - you will loose your appetite read more

Everyone loves pizza but it's unusual to find a pizzeria that has truly exceptional pies. We have friends who have been raving about Broadway Pizza on North Broadway but thought that it seemed pretty crazy to drive a few miles for a pizza. Well, guess what? The pizzas we had at Broadway Pizza was so exceptional that we plan on making it our absolutely FAVORITE PIZZA place! We visited their restaurant on a Sunday afternoon and they had a constant crowd of customers picking up pies and ordering slices. I met Francisco who is one of the owners and was impressed with his pizza making skills as well as his charming personality! I'm a fanatic about pizza that has a great crust and I think you'll agree that Broadway Pizza has the best crust in Westchester! read more

See all

Story time - After moving to white plains two years ago we tried most of the pizza places around the area and decided that Broadway Pizza was the top place in this area. We keep our order pretty simple- a couple pepperoni square slices and Penne alla vodka "No prosciutto". We also order pies or trays of pasta for almost every small family function. Today we ordered our regular. After we finished our slices (that tasted great) we moved on to the pasta. After we started to eat the pasta we found a foreign item in our food that does not belong there. I rinsed it off to get a better look without if being covered in sauce and I hadn't the slightest idea of what this could be. I called Broadway and the talk to the owner who initially tried to offer me a credit for pasta in the future (As if I would ever get pasta from here again). I went back to the location to see if the owner or chef could figure out what this is. They both had no idea what it was so I simply requested my money back only for the pasta. Moral of the story - only get pizza from pizza places. I can't say I won't ever go there again because again this is the best PIZZA place in THIS area. But I will keep it limited to slices. Those are made upfront where the customer can see step by step. Who knows what goes on in the back of the house at this place . read more

See all

Get the Hawaiian! We are not in hawaii or some don't like pineapple, but do it! Every one of their pizzas is delicious, plentiful and heartwarming l! No wonder they've been in business for over 40 years, and I hope they stay for many more! read more

Broadway Pizza - Our Hawaiian pie - Pizza Near Me - White Plains, New York

There are three ways to try out a pizzeria - delivery, takeout, and eat in. While this applies to many restaurants thanks to a variety of delivery services, pizzerias have food that consistently reflects on the restaurant through all three methods of service. A pizzeria pizza is among the best reheatable foods you can buy that will be as good when eaten the net day as the moment you purchase it, and that is what makes a good pizza a great meal. The real test of a pizzeria, aside from its pizza, is its entrees and hot sandwiches. Which leads me to my most recent visit to Broadway, when I got a chicken parmigiana wedge and had it to stay. Because how well they execute that is a measure of how good the food will be across the board. And this wedge did not disappoint at all. The hero roll was perfectly crisp and lightly toasted outside. There was a generous layer of melted mozzarella covering all the contents underneath. Then, when biting into it, large chunks of breaded chicken cutlet were mixed with a very well balanced sauce that was not too sweet or too salty, nicely seasoned with no flavor sanding out, but highlighting the tomato. Getting the flavor combo of the chicken, sauce cheese and toasted roll together - this wedge is as good as a chicken parm wedge can be. It' a standard other restaurants should aim to match. read more

Broadway Pizza has always been my favorite pizza place. They're quick, and the food tastes amazing. The pizza goes without saying, but my favorites are the penne vodka and pasta alla Luigi. *chefs kiss* The staff is always friendly and proactive, the whole experience is quick yet, it doesn't feel overwhelming. The best of both worlds. I always recommend everyone to come here, this is my favorite pizza place. read more

One of our favorite places for Italian takeout. The pizza is very good and we love the hero sandwiches.

Please do better with flies flying around inside of the pizza case. I told the man at the counter but he didn't respond. If this is what is happening in front of my face, I can only imagine how the kitchen looks. read more

Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Square Pizza - Order it! Just Order it!! Its perfect! So delicious, every bite has a delicious flavor, the crust is so crunchy and even the oil on it is full of garlic and flavor!! And the lumps of sauce on it, what? Why do I feel like its a different sauce then the regular pizza? Its so unbelievably tasty! Thank you for making this pizza! read more

Other than their Plain Marinara (Square), White, and regular Slices-that I eat, Broadway Pizza is really more than Pizza. It's the neighborhood joint up in North White Plains serving good entrees- nothing over the top, just decent. On evenings that I don't want to cook and want something straightforward, Broadway Pizza has been my other emergency go-to. Shrimp Scampi is my favorite pick and their chunky cup or bowl Cream Of Broccoli, is dynamite. Mr. Man either goes for their Chicken Marsala or Parm, with garlicky Broccoli Rabe or Broccoli- as sides. Entrees all come with a salad, pieces of Italian bread and pasta (which I equally pass- sometimes). The bottom line is that service is personal here and has remained a staple in these neck of the woods- with a real casual and comfortable feel. read more

Broadway Pizza - Cheesy Pop... {Marinara Slice~To Go} - Pizza Near Me - White Plains, New York

See all

Best pizza in the neighborhood! The Grandma slices and the classic margarita slacked never disappoint.

Ask for the pie well done with extra sauce and you will get some of the pizza around. Do not buy slices that are sitting around. Unless the pizza is fresh from the oven, it is not good. The people working there are very accommodating, polite, young and trying very hard to please. Just have them make as I wrote above and you will have an excellent pizza experience. read more

A beautiful pizza that is certainly in the upper echelon in White Plains. Everything here reminds me of the small family owned joints I grew up eating at. Having said that, do takeout if you can. This is a busy shop and it's not unusual for delivery to take over 90 minutes. read more

Always delicious and arrives on time and hot. A regular customer for years. Love this place.

Born in Manhattan, raised in Brooklyn and Queens. We know pizza, The Gloria's, Original John's, Ray's etc. Broadway Pizza is the real deal. Cooked just right, thin crust crispy, flavorful, and fresh! If you are new to the game, or not a "foodie" don't bother reviewing! The pizza here is the best in Westchester and the service is great to boot. read more

Ordered for the first time during the pandemic and I'm satisfied! Our order came within 30 mins. We've tried so many pizza stores in White Plains that were all disappointments. What we're looking for is a NY style, thin crusted pizza with classic flavors and Broadway's hit the spot! We ordered a large Margherita Pizza ($20) which was really delicious!! And they threw in two orders of garlic knots for free because they were closing (4 for $1). Garlic knots are great, not overly large or dried and tasteless like other places. Unfortunately they did forget the soda but said they'd credit us back. Will order from here again! So far it's our favorite White Plains location. read more

Broadway Pizza - Large Margherita Pizza with 2x garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - White Plains, New York

I love Broadway pizza and often find myself driving from mamaroneck ave to here for lunch. Broadway always has interesting slices ready to be served. During my last visit they had slices ranging from caesar salad, bq chicken, portabello mushroom, and veggie pizzas. This past friday we ordered their tuna pizza due to lent. Wow, was I impressed. It is served cold, and came with salad dressing. My office and I devoured it within minutes. Even a coworker who does not like tuna enjoyed it as well. The only reason why I am no giving broadway is due to the over cooking of their plain pies (this has happened to me on two seperate occasions). In their defense, broadway is not about the plain pie, it's about the specialty pies which are amazing! read more

Broadway Pizza - Tuna pizza! - Pizza Near Me - White Plains, New York

Very good pizza and wedges. Fresh salads too. The Barese pie is to die for. Light,airy and full of flavor.

I have been coming here since I was a kid and it is by far my favorite pizza place in the white plains area. They have the best & most creative slices- my favorite is the chicken Caesar slice. Always so fresh and delicious. Today my boyfriend and I were craving Italian comfort food so ordered delivery. Delivery was super fast! We got the chicken parm meal, chicken piccata & mozz sticks. The sauce was EXCELLENT and so addicting. read more

First & last time here. We ordered 2 pizzas one cheese the other cherry peppers, onion and garlic and a meat Patty. Short and simple the pies tasted fine but there was barely any peppers on the pie, looks like they cut up one pepper for the entire pie. $46.00 total....a rip off! read more

By far the best pizza in white Plains. I just wished that they would deliver to the south side of white plains.

I always have my staple places when I'm in the White Plains area, but my sister let me know about this spot that she tried when taking my nephew to the Kumon next door. It's a small place, but there is indoor seating and street parking. They have a large selection of ready to go slices so it's perfect to stop in and grab something if you're in a hurry. They have a salad pizza and a rigatoni pizza by the slice as well. Since it was my first time I decided to try a bunch of different options by the slice. I had the margherita, classic cheese, salad, white, and rigatoni slice. They were all delicious! The crust is perfectly thin but has the tender crunch all the way to the crust. The sauce is so light and savory with a hint of sweetness and the slices were a good size. My favorites were the rigatoni and margherita. The rigatoni has just the right amount of pasta on top with a light sauce and didn't eat down the crust. This is a must try place with fast and friendly staff. As tradition I always fly back to LA with pizza in my bag and this is what came back with me. read more

See all

REALLY REALLY GOOD!! The cheese on the pizza made the pie!! Good quality and delicious!! And the people that work there?? So polite and nice on the phone. Can't wait to order again!!! read more

Delish ! From the chicken sorrentino to the eggplant parm and pizza, it all tastes like homemade Italian comfort food. We love it! Take out and enjoy it at home. Enough for leftovers too! read more

Every time I call on the phone to order they are putting me on hold multiple times and rushing me off the phone. This is the 4th time I give them my business over the phone and the same exact scenario. Their attitude was go somewhere else if you want, gee was just trying to leave a tip on the card before he was going to hang up. I need to find a new place :( I sincerely hope the owner fixes this issue. I don't want anything from them except good manners and a little respect over the phone to a paying customer. Not much to ask for. Very disappointed. read more