This is my Go-To Pizza joint for when I want a Buffalo Chicken slice/pie. Small in size, with your typical pizza counter w/a few small tables ambiance, the employees have always been pleasant & professional, and the prices very fair. If you're a Buffalo Chicken fan def try a slice or two here. Ask for extra Buffalo sauce on side & either drizzle or dunk as you go. Heavenly! read more

Yea this pizza was worth it not like other spots this pizza had a crisp edge and a really nice cheese pull. I also got me a Philly cheesy steak. Freaking beautiful. Fresh wedges the bread was nice and soft definitely worth the stop read more

Went for Pi day, naturally, and it was delicious. Sausage pie with cheese. It was probably the best we had in the area. Not a lot of parking but the order was ready very fast so we were able to get in and out. I will drive out of my way for pizza here. read more

Honestly not my favorite place for pizza... however, they have AMAZING WINGS. We have some very critical foodie family and friends (including ones from the south) and they too loved the wings. You honestly can't go wrong with any of the flavors, but our favorites are the garlic parm and bbq. In fact we've ordered wings so much from here over the years that we haven't properly explored the rest of the menu. We also recently discovered a yummy summer salad and very good garlic knots read more

Just an update since it's been a while... I can't say enough about the sauce. The grandma is just pizza perfection. Every ingredient in this pizza is perfect. It's become our go to pie. The fried zucchini is delicious and, added bonus, it comes with more sauce! The medium order is more than enough for two people. We were sad that we couldn't order delivery anymore when we moved because we were just out of range for the Slice app, but found out that GrubHub will deliver over here and that made us very happy pizza people! We ordered delivery on Sunday and it was a very happy cheat day! read more

I've never been to San Gennaro's even though I live just a few towns over. Was at a kids' birthday party at a local MyGym however, and this was the catered in option. Apparently the pizza was just for the kids, which was a memo I had not gotten (probably my fault). I was getting increasing hangry by the second. Ended up stealing a slide (screw those kids) which of course was cut up into the obligatory half slices. This pizza was good for all that pizza ought to be good for. It was a good balance of sauce, cheese was melty, and the crust stood up despite the hack job cutting. End crust was light and airy. Impressive stuff for up here. I have 2 good options by me in Tarrytown, however I would find this place if I was nearby as it was good shit at time that I needed it. read more

Stopped in to get a buffalo chicken wrap and a sicilian both really good and the other pizza in case all look good.

Here I am in Dobbs Ferry, NY which in and of itself I don't remotely understand why - but here I am! It's lunch time and my wife and I are looking for a sandwich shop to bide us over until dinner tonight in Tribeca. Low and behold San Gennaro's pops up. We ordered a pretty bodacious Turkey Club Wrap. It was quite good. We both couldn't finish this wrap. It came with crisp french fries that were also pretty damn good. When we have traveled in the past, choosing a restaurant is pretty hit and miss. I guess between Yelp, Eater and Thrillist we have moved that pendulum way towards the hit side. San Gennaro's definitely fell in "The Hit" category. read more

Placed an order for delivery for my son's bday party in Yonkers. Pizza was fresh and delicious and guests raved about the wrap & chicken finger platters. Courteous service and on time delivery, highly recommend! read more

Great pizza! We always order the grandma pie and it does not disappoint but the garlic knots and even the caesar salad are very good. Delivery is fast and reliable. Honestly we're so happy to live near this place ... there's nothing better than letting your groceries rot in your fridge and ordering a pizza after a long day : p read more

Excellent NY pizza. Mic drop. When you want the real deal, huge slices and fair prices- this is the place. The service is great at this tiny gem. But my entire family goes for the best NY pizza in Westchester. Possibly in the world. read more

Wow amazing food, we had to order more and then took some home and the employee was very personable

We tried 4 different slices and LOVED each one! The store employee was really friendly and welcoming. Definitely recommend!

Excellent pizza! Huge selection of types. A bit tight inside but worth it! Great selection of rolls also. read more

San Gennaro's - Sausage slice - Pizza Near Me - Dobbs Ferry, New York

See all

Delivery was horrendous. If you place a call and they make you wait you for over an hour without any call of advance, it's a very unprofessional service and not worth spending money. I suggest reconsidering a more efficient pizzeria. read more

Was just here with my husband, Loved the food we ordered a grandma slice, a pizza slice with meatballs, and a spinach and cheese roll. All were delicious. The crust on the pizzas were perfect. The workers very friendly. The ambience was not bad. We will definitely come back. read more

Ok I love this place, probably my favorite pizza spot in westchester! Service is good, fast and efficient. Try the white slice, you won't regret it! read more

If you order for delivery the time estimates are not even close. Have a 45-60min window 2 hours and multiple calls later it got to me. Food? Might have been good if even resembled warm. I was looking forward to the Mama's pie. But cold pizza that has lost all its life was just terrible. Cheese would not even stretch. read more

Be prepared to wait 2hrs for your cold pizza. Service is terrible. I've been calling every 15 min for the guy to keep telling me 15min the pizza will be here read more

Good local Italian, big portions, fresh bread, really good desserts, and fast delivery.

I got to try their combo slices here, and they are amazing as well! The crust is chewy, thick, and filling, and the toppings are so fresh - the veggies and meats delicious and look like they have just been picked fresh from the garden! read more

All food is excellent. I really like their white pizza and fettuccine carbonara. I have ordered several times and the delivery has always arrived promptly. read more

Nothing too extraordinary pizza wise since there are a ton of pizza joints in the area. Prices are about average as are slice sizes. Typical pizza variety and good taste but nothing to wow me much read more

In the almost 5 years since I started riding the buses in Westchester County, I've seen the sign on Ashford Avenue in Dobbs Ferry saying "best Pizza" more times than can count. Today, I was granted the gift of a need to transfer buses on this block at lunchtime. Knowing I would have this opportunity, I got the chance to see if the pizza lived up to the sin's promise. Short answer? It didn't. And it did. This isn't the best slice of pizza I've ever had. this isn't the best slice of pizza I've had in Westchester County. But it's quite possible this is the best slice of pizza in a radius of anywhere up to 5 miles. Given the number of pizzerias in Southern Westchester, that's no small statement. I can't say this definitively, because Yonkers, a few miles south of Dobbs Ferry, has a lot of good pizza. But I'd still match a slice from here against a slice from anywhere in the area. Here's why. The standard NY (Neapolitan) slice here has a crust that's the right thickness to hold the cheese and sauce firmly in place without the need for folding. The cheese pulls apart cleanly when you bite into it, with the very enjoyable occasional exception when strength of the cheese resists the bite, and a long, thin strand of cheese pulls away as you bite it, the way you expect fresh mozzarella to, either when freshly rolled or once baked onto a pizza. The sauce is applied in the right amount to balance the flavor of the cheese and the crust, without overpowering either, giving consumer (of the slice) the flavor blend you expect of a good NY slice. And when you've finished cheese and sauce topped portion of the slice, and are left with the end crust, you get the flavor of really good toasted Italian bread with a hint of olive oil you expect when eating a pizza slice - the mild wheat flavor of durum semolina flour brushed with olive oil and baked to a golden toasted brown. The first slice was good enough that I bought a second. My only regret was that I forgot to take my bottle of Diet Coke with me when I left. C'est la vie. I did have just enough to wash down two slices and thoroughly enjoy them. I don't know when or if I'll have the chance to go to San Gennaro again. This was my first chance in almost 5 years to try them, and now going back, versus trying other places in Westchester I've wanted to get to, with limited time and being limited by the bus system, means making hard choices. If I don't get back, at least this is one item done on my Westchester bucket list. On a closing note: they're quite busy during lunch, another testimony to the quality of the food, and many of the customers who passed through in the 20 minutes I was there seemed to know the counterman, and he knew the customers. That loyal following certainly looks to be well earned by my taste of their pizza. read more

Beat Pizza in Dobbs. BUT, they don't tell you if its 2 hours for the Pizza. It would of changed my mind about ordering, Yelp to GrubHub totally slowed them down. Kind of sucks. Google them. Call direct. Call for pick up. I'm at church now. I couldn't wait. Call direct, they'll be honest about delivery time. David S. read more

Found this place during the pandemic and their to-go game is excellent. We get their calzones which are huge and well priced. I've had their baked ziti before too and everything about this place is just what you want in a local take away Italian joint. They even have good salads. Nice enough service, good pricing, solid menu and tasty food. read more

This review is based solely on a takeout order. Was in the area recently and we decided to order a large, plain pie from here. I've passed by this location over the years, but never had a chance to try them until now. The pizza was pretty good, though not the best I've ever had at the same time (and I've had them in quite a lot of different locations). People's tastes for pizza differs and despite what some people say, not all pizza is made or tastes the same. The pie was soft in the middle, which made each slice dangle loosely until it was eaten off. The crust was very good. Overall the pizza was tasty and certainly warrants a return. I'm a real stickler for calzones - because much like pizza, not all calzones are made equal or the correct way. Based on some of the other reviews, I will need to try a calzone from here for sure. It's a small parking lot with 2 entrances/exists. This places shares the space with a deli and a wine & liquor store. read more

Nothing worse than waiting for pizza you ordered only to have it arrive with a wet glob of cheese and most of it falling off the thing. As a lifelong NYer I know the cheese is supposed to stay in place, even if it's extra cheese. So now I have to navigate cutting slices without having the cheese slide off and without serving an "ewww" looking piece to my picky kids. Look on top right of pic, cheese isn't supposed to do that. read more

San Gennaro's - Cheese sliding off pizza - epic fail - Pizza Near Me - Dobbs Ferry, New York

Did not like the slice. Ordered plain and I had trouble enjoying it. Really didn't like it.

My favorite pizza in the Rivertowns. There have been some delivery snafus but, always promptly fixed, and certainly not worth going elsewhere. read more

LOVE this spot! Their portions are great and they have some of the best garlic knots around, I've ordered from here several Times and they never get it wrong. read more

We ordered delivery and maybe that was the mistake but, here goes: 1) the food arrived cold. Not just not hot - cold. We had to reheat everything. 2) they charged 1.50 for 3 slices of bad tomato. 3) they also charged 1.50 for a handful of frozen spinach 4) the calzone looked more like a part of left over pizza pie they folded in on itself I'm not usually one to drop such a negative review but wow - hope they take the opportunity to fix a few things read more

Pit stop on way to Scenic Hudson... so glad we did! AMAZING pizza! Queens native here so we have extremely high pizza standards. Classic taste, great crisp crust and super huge slices! Great place to fill up before and after a scenic bike ride read more

Very nice local pizza place. The food is good portions are large. My favorite is the penne alla vodka and their Sicilian pizza. Not a lot of room to sit and it gets crowded so I would recommend take out. Also the place hasn't been updated since they opened probably 20 years ago but if you're looking for a good affordable place to eat dinner or lunch this is it read more

Amazing pizza and massive slices for only around $4.75. You're getting more than what you paid for. Any complaints about people not getting amazing service is just overly high maintenance for no reason. This place rocks read more

Terrible service, All employees except for one have a terrible attitude. You can wait in front of the counter for 10 to 15 minutes and not even be asked if you've ordered already. There is a mob of people behind the counter call instantly doing absolutely nothing while people are waiting 10 to 15 minutes for a slice. But... With all this being said the food is incredible. read more

Great pizza. Probably the best in the area. Their Chicken Bacon Ranch; White pie; and Regular pie are favs of the family. I'm not a huge garlic knot fan, but my sister is, and she says this place has the best. If you're gonna order salads, order the dressing on the side, otherwise they drench it all over the salads and it's practically soggy and inedible by the time it comes to your house. Ordered a few main dishes before but not overly impressed. Stick to their pizza. Delivery is usually always on time, but there were some occasions where they took forever. I've been inside only once- small, nothing fancy, like a regular pizza joint. Good desserts- tiramisu and cannolis are great. My brother in law ordered the cheesecake recently and enjoyed it immensely. Give them a try. I don't think you'll be disappointed. read more

This is our go to for pizza and we have tried them all. Their chicken parm pizza is my wife's favorite. I love their pepperoni and sausage pies. The salads are always good and good value. I finally broke down the other day and ordered a sandwich and I was very pleased. For your every day pizza needs this is the best place in Westchester. read more

The pizza here is good, they make a large assortment of toppings for pizzas , I'm gonna def go back to try some hot dishes

I have just 1 word. DON'T. We ordered takeout. When it was delivered we were told there was a problem with our credit card so we offered to pay cash. We called the credit card company and they said The merchant never attempted to put the charge through. It seems obvious they just wanted the cash. They also forgot half the order. I requested spaghetti with my dinner and I got linguine. When they went back to get my husband's pizza and returned 40 minutes later the pizza was cold. If this had been put through on the credit card like we attempted we would've had some kind of recourse. But because they forced us to pay cash there is no recourse.They did not offer any credits for the mistake in their delivery and the fact that they sent us a cold pizza was unacceptable. read more