The pizza is excellent. I have ordered on many occasions and have never had a bad pizza. I have tried both the regular cheese pizza and the white pizza. Have occasionally ordered chicken or veal Parmesan. I live nearby so I pick up when I order so I can't comment on delivery. I definitely recommend this pizzeria. One thing, it is primarily for takeout as there are only a few small tables. read more

I feel qualified to give an opinion on pizza having grown up in Brooklyn during the 70s to the 90s. Tony's pizza reminds me very much of the pizza I grew up in. Crisp crust, tasty sauce and cheese. In my world, it doesn't get much better. Order and enjoy from them! read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Assorted pies - Italian Near Me - Irvington, New York

See all

Have ordered delivery service. Food is always delivered timely & warm. One time Tony didn't have anyone to deliver to me so he said it would be a while & about 2 hours later he delivered my order himself. Food is 1st quality & delicious. I order about 2x a month. read more

The food was amazing. It came very quickly. The fries were great. The pizza was amazing and try the Zeppoli's.

Tony's makes great pizzas in the traditional New York style. No dining room to speak of but perfect for to-go or delivery. I get the cheese pie and the arugula salad and put the salad on the pizza. read more

The good: Tony's offers a classic, extensive menu of pizzeria staples -- everything from pizza and pasta to veal and wedges. The penne vodka was average; I've had (much) better and worse from other nearby pizza/pasta shops. The location is also quite convenient (the small shop sits at the top of Main St) and delivery is available through Grubhub/Doordash/Uber Eats/etc. Also, they're open pretty late. The bad: The service!! The crazy wait times that many have complained about is no joke! The first time I ordered from here, service was quite prompt. Turns out I musta been lucky, because the next several times I ordered the wait (even at off-peak times) was unusually long. Finally, the side salad I received with one of my entrees was disgusting; vegetables clearly old, dirty, and not even cut up properly. The tomatoes had stems! C'mon...that's a rookie mistake. read more

See all

Been wanting to try legit NY pizza and I think I went to the right place! Place is super small but that's the only negative I found. Got 2 slices of pizza, one cheese one pepperoni and both were perfect! Bottom was crisp but not overdone, nicely seasoned crust, cheese and sauce was just right. I was very happy! read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Pepperoni and cheese pizza slices - Italian Near Me - Irvington, New York

Very good pizza. We were coming home from the Yankee game and this place gives you NYC pizza without having to trek into the City. Not many tables, more of an informal spot, but the owner is right there cooking delicious Brooklyn style pizza. read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Pizza - Italian Near Me - Irvington, New York

Tony's has the best pizza in the Rivertown. On top of that, the salads, sandwiches, soups, and pasta dishes are top notch. I have never had a bad meal there. Best of all is the customer service. Tony knows his customer, and he goes out of his way to take care of his customers. It's always easy going into Tony's. I highly recommend Tony's. read more

Was visiting from California with my family for a medical conference and looking for a true NY pizza experience. I wasn't expecting much, being outside in the suburbs, but let me tell you Tony's absolutely delivered. The pizza was EXCELLENT, service was above and beyond, and the owner went out of his way to make sure my 6yo daughter, who is in a wheelchair, was accommodated with the seating. I will say there was only enough seating for a family or two, but we were lucky enough to secure a table. We also got some warm, fresh cookies for the hell of it. Also delicious. Loved this place so much I am leaving a review over a year later. If I ever get back to New York, I'm heading here ASAP. read more

2/21/2024 Absolutely horrible. waited 2 hours for my food, had to call after 1.5 hours for them to say, " it was on the way". 30 minutes later it arrived everything was cold; the burger bread was soggy from sitting the patty was cold. My fried raviolis were cold as well. and I never got my coke. I called back to ask for a refund and was denied, so $30 went right into the trash. please if you read this don't waste your time. The Owner should refund me, but whoever was running the place that day, failed at his job. read more

I hadn't had much to eat all day and was eager to get my late night food fix on a Sunday. My usual pizza place was closed so I ordered delivery from Tony's. Their homemade mozzarella sticks were great. Usually, mozzarella sticks are basically a commodity; you can't go wrong with melted cheese and fried dough, but they are nothing to write home about. Tony's version definitely takes this dish up a notch. I loved the extra crispiness and accompanying marinara sauce. I also ordered a plain personal pizza. For a personal size, the pizza was quite large. It had classic New York style slices. I enjoyed it. The penne vodka was also very good. It included onions and had a slightly smoky flavor to it. Good size portion as well. Very grateful this place was open for my late night feast! read more

Delicious pizza. The best service. I ate almost 1.5 pies for 5 nights straight ........ M read more

Tony's, located in the quaint town of Irvington, NY is everything you'd want in a good NY pizzeria! Their cheese pie is to die for with an excellent dough, quality cheese, and a nice sauce to top off a great pie! I'd also recommend anything meat on their pies as the meats are salty and a nice quality! The quaint location of Irvington, NY begs for a visit if nothing else! read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Irvington, New York

We are sad we live so far. Otherwise Tony's would be our go to for authentic New York pizza. We are glad we stopped for a slice on our road trip home. Both my pepperoni and my husbands chicken ranch were perfectly cooked. The only downside was there was no bathroom for the travelers! If you are looking for no frills , perfectly cooked pizza Tony's is your spot! read more

Ordered delivery to a local Marriot hotel. Delivered on time by a nice fella. Had a large cheese with sausage mushroom and onions. It was soooo good! Also ordered hot Buffalo wings with extra bleu cheese. Wonderful taste and spice. Although the wings weren't Buffalo style with the crispy skin the wings had nice hotness and had a breading of sorts that really captured the sauce. Nice! I recommend highly. read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Large Cheese pizza with Sausage Mushroom and Onions. Single order of hot Buffalo wings with extra bleu cheese! - Italian Near Me - Irvington, New York

This place is a good pizza spot. Just moved out of NYC and needed to find a good local spot. Tony's checks that box. I will be a repeat customer. Got a Buffalo chicken pizza since I'm always searching for the best Buff chicken pizza. Not the best I've ever had but it's up there. Many more pizzas to try. read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Buffalo chicken pizza - Italian Near Me - Irvington, New York

See all

Tony is super nice and makes great pizza. Ask for the donuts and salads too! This is my son's favorite pizza.

Recently moved in to The Village of Irvington. Was told by some neighbors to try Tony's. I was not disappointed. There aren't very many places I have found a Chef Salad on the menu these days and Tony's was Fantastic. Full of fresh meats and cheese. Black olives, Egg and cucumber with nicely chopped lettuce. The Pizza and wings are Great as well. I love to support local and am so happy I have a neighborhood pizzeria that checks all the boxes. Very friendly staff made me feel welcome to the Village. A Must try when you're in the area. read more

We used to love this place and we used to order from them all the time. But lately, delivery and the food has been subpar. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza and what we got was a half pepperoni pie. Delivery has been slower as well. What used to be a quick delivery, now takes over an hour. I'm so disappointed read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Large pepperoni pie... apparently. - Italian Near Me - Irvington, New York

It's so easy to find GF pizza dough, or make it, yet most places don't offer GF pizza or buns. More importantly, not everyone can make one that's tasty and can hold up to a good sauce. I have to admit, vacationing here for a month, 15 days in, I'm super impressed with all the gluten free, and grass-fed beef options. This however is the first time I'm getting pizza. Realizing that Yom Kippur Havdala ends at 7ish on the West Coast where my Synagogue is, and that meant 10PM here, I was not prepared and NEEDED a meal waiting after fasting the last 25ish hours. (I had one tea to support my teaching at 9am, and only sips of water all day.) Not only was my 10 inch pizza enough, the sauce and toppings were generous and my crust held up like a champ!! And here's the coolest part - I needed my pizza to arrive within a 15 minute window between services, and it did!! Now I would not expect that every time; traffic, volume of orders could have easily got in the way. What I was really impressed by was the intention! If they were 15 minutes late, would could I do - it's Pizza!! And well with it! I may have another before I leave at the end of the month! Thanks biz owner and my friendly driver! read more

Really good NYC slices with reliable and fast delivery. I just moved up here and the pizza at Tony's is better than the place I used to go to by my old apartment in Brooklyn. Honestly, what else can I say? read more

I enjoyed their pizza. Their delivery service was good. The price is right also. Saved me, feeling malnourished because of health issues and wala ... nutrition delivered. Thank you read more

Went out looking for late night pizza and this definitely satisfied all cravings! Food was made fresh in front of us, even made us a special slice to try (BBQ chicken & Mac-n-cheese). Amazingggg read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Irvington, New York

Amazing food and services was fantastic and fast. They were so accommodating to fit a party of 9.

After living in NYC for a year and having easy access to the best pizza around, I was really not excited about getting pizza up here in the burbs. I'm definitely no pizza connoisseur, but I just thought why waste time on pizza that isn't the best? Normally I'm not into plain cheese slices, but boy am I glad we ordered regular plain old cheese pizza. Also, the chicken tenders (or tendies as my bf calls them) are also fantastic. And they have exactly the type of French fries I love. We've been ordering from these guys all covid long, and that isn't going to stop anytime soon. Also, their tiramisu is on point. As are apparently their Philly cheese steaks (haven't tried it myself, too busy filling up on tendies and pizza). You know how some people gain the freshman 15? I may end up gaining the covid 19 due to this place... read more

We paid extra for a margarita pizza and we got a cheese pizza with chopped basil on it. While i was waiting i saw them take my pizza out of the oven, put it in the box, left the box open and answered the phone for 5 mins until someone else had to come and finish the pizza. By the time we got home we had to reheat it. Disappointed and frustrated that we didn't get the pizza we expected. read more

Delivery was on time, hot, & fresh. Pizza was good, extra sauce came as ordered. A large cheese pie was$15- a little pricey. Surprised the cheese calzone was only $5, but was not my favorite.. $6 for a very small side salad-the ranch dressing was delicious though. Overall 3 stars read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Large cheese extra sauce- tasty - Italian Near Me - Irvington, New York

See all

We were staying nearby @ the Sheraton - Tarrytown. Front Desk Associate - "Edouardo" suggested that we order from this place; Not to many options existed. (1) Fast - Great Delivery Service; (2) Fresh / Tasty - Everything Arrived Hot & Fresh; (3) Our Pizza Tasted Great! Would definitely "Endorse" as options seem scarce in the "Region" - Nonetheless, they deliver "High Quality" - Pizza! read more

We love this place. The chicken fajita pizza really rocks. Everything is great. Great customer service.

The vodka pizza is fantastic. Delivery was on time. And they have gluten-free crusts.

We opened a new Irvington business/studio (antiques) in May about a block from Tony's. I'm a 5th generation NYer from the same BLOCK in Manhattan...pizza is in my blood. Tony's is a GEM. The pizza awesome, everyone is always friendly/smiling, and yes sometimes THEY HAVE FRESH COOKIES! The MAC slice? Dear God, that slice is delicious. I'm also a youth track coach and I couldn't help but notice all the kids who wrote letters/drew pictures for Tony...it speaks volumes to the type of community person he is. I'll be here twice a week indefinitely... read more

Ok.... so this was an order for delivery and I was disappointed all the way around. I chose this place based on the high rating but it did not live up to it for me. To start, the order took more than an hour to be delivered and we were a quarter of a mile away. It probably would have taken longer so thank goodness we called and then we were told it's about to be on its way. Food would have probably been good if not barely lukewarm. Cheese on chicken parm sub was already no longer melted. Sub was huge to be fair. Pepperoni roll also needed reheating. Marinara sauce was the best part. This was a one time try because I would never order delivery here again. read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Chicken parm sandwich - Italian Near Me - Irvington, New York

Absolutely the worse pizza I've ever tried. Ordered a chicken parm hero and 2 slices of regular pizza and threw out everything. Both sandwich and pizza had no taste and was poorly prepared. I have no clue how this place got such high ratings. Complete waste of money. read more

Not sure what happened to this place. It used to be pretty good for a slice. But the last few times I visited I was sadly disappointed pizza was not fresh and tested like dollar pizza .I recommend they keep the pizza fresh even if that means tossing unsold pizza after hours In The window.cmon Tony your better than this. read more

This great little pizzeria has friendly staff and can make an amazing pizza. They were more than happy to make exactly what I wanted despite my allergy. They have an amazing product and a clean restaurant. This is one place I will have to try again. read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Dining area - Italian Near Me - Irvington, New York

See all

To excel in the shadow of the defunct Romeo's Pizzeria was no small task, but Tony has done it in spades. Tony is a generous business owner, the kind you like to come back to, and his pizza is the best in Irvington. On top of that, they carry Gifford's Ice Cream, which is one of the best brands out there not many people are aware of. On top of carrying the standard pizza selection, Tony's always got something unique brewing, including the mac & cheese BBQ slice which...well, you can only imagine the joys that brings to my taste nodes. This pizzeria location (in its many forms) has always maintained an environment for kids to come in and hangout. In a small town like Irvington, that is pretty important. Tony's has kept it going and middle schoolers are always coming through to sit at his bench-style tables and enjoy his larger-than-life slices. Delivery is also a big plus, that's hard to find in the area. Tony's is a HIT! read more

Updated review: I won't be ordering from here again, unfortunately. Second to last order came TWO HOURS past estimated delivery time, almost cold. Gave it one more shot the other day for my son's birthday. Actually PRE ORDERED a pie to be delivered at 6pm. Didn't show up until almost 7pm and was again, almost cold. Shame. read more

This place was awesome. For a reasonable price you can get really good food. We ordered the jalapeño poppers, eggplant focaccia sandwich, and zeppole and everything was delicious! read more

This pizzeria experience was a large delivery order. Making the order was quick and easy online. I made a call to inform them that my location would be in a basketball court. The call was easy. They accepted the change of location with no issues. The delivery estimate time was a little over an hour. Which makes sense. It was an order for 12 people, most of them men with large appetites. The order arrived within 45 minutes. Being that it was my first time ordering from this restaurant I was unaware of the tipping process. So I was going to tip the delivery man in cash, he was honest and made us aware that he would already be tipped being that it was charged in the order. This was the best large order experience I've ever had. Somehow all of the food was hot and delicious. The food was packed neatly and accordingly. Thank you Tonys Pizza! For such a great experience. read more