Always a pleasant experience. Pizza sizes are very generous and delicious. You always have a choice of 6 or 7 different pizza varieties. It's always best to pay by cash since there is a substantial Surcharge when paying by Credit/Debit Card. Parking can at times be a bit challenging as Street Parking is Limited and the Private Parking can only hold 6 Cars Comfortably. read more

Ordered from here on Uber eats. I got a pepperoni slice and my boyfriend got a chicken parm sandwich. Next day we both had the runs but thought nothing of it. Ordered again a couple weeks later and we both had food poisoning. Will never eat here again read more

The food is so good and the pizza looks and tastes amazing and the service is good and I recommend a pizza chicken Parmesan

Whenever I get back to Port Chester, NY I inevitably have either lunch or dinner at Antonio's Pizza. Their pizza is 'par excellence', the restaurant is remarkably clean and the staff is outstanding! You definitely DO NOT have to dress up... just bring your appetite & enjoy! You won't be disappointed! read more

I am so disgusted. All I ordered was wings, hot and fries wings sauce on the side. They were so slow. My first DoorDash left the second one basically threw it at my door. My bag was ripped. There was blue cheese dressing all over the bag and no buffalo sauce on my wings or on the side will never order from here again it's disgusting. read more

I love there food and service is amazing. I recommend people to eat here and feel the hospitality and service that they provide to their customers and their staff read more

I was never expect to have very beautiful pizza and very yummy pizza like this .Perfect tase ! On time And temperature is perfect to eat. Recommend ! This is bacon ranch pizza with pepperoni and french fries. read more

See all

Love the regular cheese pizza here, and the pepperoni and sausage slices are damn good too. Antonio's pizza has have everything you want in a NY style slice; beautifully crispy crust, copious amounts of good cheese, and just a little bit of sauce. Result? An all around delicious and well structured slice, which is always fresh no matter when I've popped in. Give it a try! read more

Antonio's Pizza - It's f***ing beautiful man!! - Pizza Near Me - Port Chester, New York

See all

Horrible experience at Antonio's Pizza in Port Chester recently ! While I and others were inside having some pizza, Antonio's parking attendant was placing boots on our car wheels, so we each had to pay $70. by credit card to have them removed. No apology from Antonio the owner. To make it worse, the pizza was lukewarm and preparation area did not look clean. I won't be going back ! read more

Grate food fast delivery . Thanks I enjoyed my Ceasar salad very much came right on time food was fresh bread very delicious. Chicken breast tender read more

Antonio's Pizza - a salad with chicken and lettuce - Pizza Near Me - Port Chester, New York

I've been ordering from them for years. Not bad for a large ( 18 ") cheese pizza for only $16!!!! Pizza isn't too salty or too bland. It's just right. Never was I delivered an overcooked or undercooked pie. Dough isn't too soggy and drivers are very friendly. I am not buying pizza anywhere else. read more

The pizza by the slice at Antonio's pizza is all on display under glass cases. When you order your slice (either to go or to stay) you must squeeze between those glass cases and the soda fridges. This includes squeezing past all of the other customers who have ordered pizza and are standing there at the glass case as if that is going to make it come out of the oven any faster. As Ludacris' song says "Move, 6!+ch, get out the way, get out the way, 6!+ch get out the way!" The pizza is pretty good though. On my first visit, I had the white veggie pizza. It was good. The veggies (broccoli, carrots, red peppers) were well done. The mozzerella was so gooey. Although I had to ask for a little marinara sauce for dipping. My second visit was better. I had the buffalo chicken pizza. It was chock full of spicy chicken tenders cut up into nice size hunks. Although the cheese was minimal, the crust was perfect. I did wish for a side of ranch to dip the pizza in but refrained due to calories and lack of motivation to get up and do all the squeezing past the new crop of customers who had entered. Anyway, I'm sure I'll return. It is pizza. I love pizza. Second visit Sunday, March 9, 2014 read more

Antonio's Pizza - Buffalo chicken pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Port Chester, New York

Had a four star chicken Parm, it was pretty good if I may say so. i see some good reviews, bad reviews, meh, call them what you will. to be honest, i wasnt expecting too much, but to their credit it wasnt a crappy chicken patty, sauce was good, bread good, cheese good. its good. i suppose if you are in the area and/or staying at that courtyard and looking for something quick (and cheap 7 bucks for a large chicken parm? in this area!?) its good value. read more

This was not only my first time trying Antonio's Pizzeria pizza, but my first time trying actual New York pizza! I wasn't disapointed! Their large IS large! And they don't skimp on the toppings! Another plus... My husband is an OTR truck driver, and we ran out of driving hours so were stuck at the place we got loaded at, it was ether make Ramen on the truck, or order pizza. I did a lil internet research on pizza places that delivered. Antonio's Pizzeria had very good reviews. So, I ordered, and they delivered right to our truck! If we're ever stuck in this area again, we will definitely order from them again! I want to try their eggplant parmezan dinner! read more

Looking for a quick bit to eat before a show at the Capitol Theater, my friends and I ordered a couple of pizza's from Antonio's Pizza. They delivered to the Courtyard Rye within the estimated time, pizza's piping hot and still fresh. Purchased one large cheese pizza and a small ham pizza for about $28... but both were incredibly large!!! The so-called small ham pizza was crammed into its tiny housing, the crust upturned in one section to accommodate the overflowing portion of our anticipated dinner. It is hard to describe just how large the slices are served. I was able to easily fold my slice in half and still it was larger than your average sized triangle of doughy cheesy goodness. The cheese itself had nice flavor, the dough quite thin with minimal sauce (my kind of pizza as a very picky eater). I skipped the crust on most of my slices, it was a bit hard and difficult to manage but it was no matter due to the aforementioned portion sizes. There was nothing that particularly stood out about the pizza itself but it certainly served its purpose as I was quite full before the show. With 3 people stuffing themselves, we still had an entire pizza left following our gorging. I can say, my belly was happy to munch on this dinner turned late night snack much later in the evening. Just as good cold as it was hot. Not the best pizza I've ever had by far, but definitely "a-ok" in my book. read more

Good: Huge slices...great pizza...awesome prices...great service Bad: inside looks like it hasn't been updated since the early 90's read more

This place is sucks because the pizza is so gross because my son had to go to the hospital because his stomach was hurting him so bad

Holy cow. I ordered a medium Hawaiian pizza...original pie, not Sicilian. Crust is what you would expect of a New York style pizza...thin and eminently foldable. Light sauce, wonderful cheese. Crust is good, but not the best ever. Taken as a whole, however, definitely a great pizza option, especially when staying at the Courtyard Rye as I am. 25 minute delivery, and they take credit card. Boom. You'll be satisfied if you order a pie from Antonio's. read more

Antonio's Pizza - This is a medium Hawaiian. A MEDIUM. The soda bottle is there to give you the scale...you definitely won't go hungry. Holy cow! - Pizza Near Me - Port Chester, New York

Best pizza in Port Chester. I have been going there for over 20 years.

I love Antonio's Pizza, I had their baked ziti bolognese and it was absolutely delicious, it went perfect with the bread they give you as well. I also had the New York cheesecake and what can you expect? It's cheesecake. It's gonna be fantastic, and it was. Overall Antonio's Pizza is consistently good all around from their wedges, to pizza, to strombolis, to garlic bread, to pasta it's good. And often the portion sizes are large, their food usually lasts me about three whole meals. The delivery time can take a little while longer sometimes (most likely when the restaurant's busy) but it's completely worth it when you can dig in to their delicious, savory mouthwatering goodness. This is definitely my go-to restaurant for when I want to eat out. It's not over priced but not underpriced either. I highly recommend definitely going to check Antonio's Pizza out. read more

For years growing up, this was my neighborhood pizza shop. I learned alot here- about pizza, and about life. It is located on the train tracks, the other side, on the far corner of the Pathmark Plaza, across from the Projects. Some memories- There used to be daily service in the parking lot consisting of drinking "holy water" and other drug use. The parking lot was always a hot bed of interesting goings on to a 13 year old. If you were lucky, the guy playing tennis in official handmedown tennis gear would be impersonating Pete Sampras- slice in one hand, other hitting the ball against the brick wall The pizza- a decent NY style slice- always slightly burnt, cheese always staying in firm contact with the rest of the slice. Some of the best foldability and BIG very big. Walking home the friendly neighbors would hound me for a slice- "Pizza man, gimmie dat slice pizza man"- this is when I learned to ignore the beggars around me. When I'm in the area I stop in, reassured by the same Spanish guy at the counter, I get a slice and sit and eat- and notice many of the people are the same and will never leave Midland Avenue. read more

I passed Antonio's walking to my car and went in for a soda. However, the aroma was enticing and I bought a slice. This is one of THE BEST pizzas that I've enjoyed, and I'm from NYC. I work nearby and started to order for delivery. Baked ziti is very good, and the Italian sausage is fantastic! Their Buffalo Wings are incredible to say the least. The seasoning in deep fried into the thin, crunchy batter. The wings are huge, with lots of meat on the bone. Be sure to order the Stromboli because it is superb. Prices are surprisingly low, delivery is lightning fast and I am sure you'll find that Antonio's serves up incredible value alongside their delicious fare. read more

Best pizza I've ever had! I've been ordering/dining here since i was little and I have yet to find another place that serves as good of a pizza as they do. Their grilled chicken salad is amazing as well! The chicken is so tender and has such a great taste you can even eat it without any dressing. Despite having low prices their portions are HUGE! Delivery is always right on time and they give you a discount if you order directly from their website! I love Antonio's and the people working there are very friendly. The only downside is that they do not have any desserts at all (I believe there are some ice cream bars near the fridge though) and yes as others have pointed out their place is old and hasn't changed a bit since I was little but that won't stop me from giving them 5 stars. It's actually quite nostalgic. I have some great memories there :) read more

Decent pizza option in the area. Honestly, it was almost identical to another delivery place I had recently. I was wondering if they were actually the same place behind the scenes. :-) read more

No complaints here. Excellent New York style pizza. Thin and greasy, just like I like it. Went with the pepperoni and Italian sausage. Sliced Italian sausage is a plus. Delivery was accurate and quick read more

Antonio's Pizza - Large pepperoni and Italian sausage - Pizza Near Me - Port Chester, New York

My office ordered 4 grilled chicken slices and 2 salad slices and one plain slice and we were charged $62.50 when got the order we got 4 grilled chicken salads the rest of the order was right we called the restaurant and after arguing with the guy on the phone we sent someone to pick up the right order and got a refund. But to our surprise someone from the restaurant sent a gentleman to pick up the salads that we got . I would think with COVID you would bring food back to your restaurant the service was awful. read more

The absolute worst pizza ever. Don't bother with this place. My delivery order took over an hour and a half -- to a location literally 5 minutes from the restaurant. The pizza arrived cold, soggy and tasteless. Don't bother calling Grubhub -- they can't help because this place uses its own drivers, who apparently take long breaks before delivering their awful pizza. Never again. read more

I am Antonio's pizza customer since 2000. I love their food especially Stromboli which is a type of turnover filled with various Italian cheeses and cold cuts. In many occasions I have use them for catering and their prices are very affordable and the food is delicious! read more

Best pizza in the area... My favorite pizza shop. They are also very reasonable priced.

Wow. Really. Hole in the wall unsuspecting pizza place with AMAZING pizza and Cesar salad! Had half white with broccoli and chicken pepper pizza... Out of control. Fresh, bursting with flavor and their Cesar salad was the greatest I've had for a restaurant like this. Totally recommend for quick bite or take out! read more

Absolutely the only place I know that makes a proper broccoli roll. I know people who don't even like broccoli that much who love it. Good bread to cheese ratio and stuffed with perfectly cooked broccoli. Been coming here since I was a little girl. Get the broccoli roll!! read more

There's not one person who understands the essence of customer appreciation. Their deliveries are always TWICE as long as promised ... and when you ring up, they act miffed that you're a bit edgy over their incompetence. This has happened three times ... and it will never happen again. Call Frank's or pick up your own pie up @ Sunrise in Rye. This place is a joke. read more

My favorite pizza place in Port Chester.The sicilian... holy. shit. Try just the cheese. Doughy, crispy, heavier than 3 slices of pizza combined... be prepared to lose your dignity. read more

Ordered the chicken roll to go. The flavor alone of the roll along with the side of marinara sauce gave this place 3stars. What would it take to get 5? Friendlier customer service. As much as I enjoyed eating the chicken roll, the attitude from the guy behind the counter won't make me return to this place. Customer service is a big part of running a joint. In case they didn't know. read more

It's not terrible, but it's far from great.... I just tried this place after finding all the raving reviews on yelp. They must have down sized because the slices I got delivered were FAR from BIG. We ordered 3 different slices, the sicilian slice was good, the other 2 were maybe just decent. I probably wont order from here ever again unless I can't find better at my new office location in port chester. I am curious of all of you guys who wrote "best pizza in the area" and "my favorite pizza", are you for real? You need to get out more. read more

Staying at the Courtyard with two grandchildren, YELP reviews suggested this as a good delivery option for Italian food. While the delivery was very quick, the food was very - blah. We didn't do the pizza, which may be better, but all the pasta was overcooked, the sauce just looked like crushed tomatoes out of a can, and the meatballs were mushy and flavorless. All of this at 6:00 on a Saturday night, so hard to blame on anything but the restaurant. So, if you want something delivered quickly and don't care what it tastes like, this will probably work for you. read more

Horrible pizza it was cold and hard to chew my teeth hurt after eating. not what we were expecting long ass wait. we will never be ordering from there again. read more

I ordered from Antonio's for delivery. Although they were very nice on the phone and when they delivered, the food was awful. I had a burger that was completely inedible! The pattie was over cooked and hard as a rock. The hamburger roll was stale and also hard as a rock. The whole thing was like a brick and went right into the garbage. It was unfortunate b/c the people that work there seemed very pleasant. read more

Awesome food - great price- wonderful customer service- fast delivery- I try to order every other week- love them

Me and the hubby's go-to place for a slice. He likes the meat-lovers pizza. I like the white pizza with broccoli. We are literally here once a week. read more