Great as ever! Have tried more menu items and all are top-notch. I keep bringing people here and they are delighted! They also do catering so party on! Latest rave is the eggplant pizza. Best of the genre! I always ask for my slices/pies to be "extra-crisp." Chicken wings are excellent as are their choices for sauces. They deliver so no excuse not to experience this delicious food regularly! read more

Solid Italian food, pizzas, and unique salads. Have been ordering quite a bit of takeout of late, and everything has been very tasty and fresh. Rye Beach salad is one of my favorites - also love the chicken entrees. Nice seating area as well for a no frills, quality dining experience. read more

See all

Very disappointed! We've been long time customers. The delivery person was shameful in his interaction with me. Very aggressive and rude. Not the usual gentleman who delivered previously. When I called to speak to the owner he would not get on the phone although I heard him ask what the conversation was ... So unnecessary and such poor customer service especially to people who made sure to patronize the establishment during the pandemic. read more

Me and my husband order here every week, and have for a while now. Reasonably priced, consistently good quality food that tastes like you expect it to. They are good at making adjustments based on requests in online order notes. Approachable and considerate customer service. The older reviews with low star ratings were accurate at one point, but something changed because the quality of both the food and physical location/ website increased dramatically. (We decided to give it second chance.) read more

Valtori is true old school Italian food with nothing but fresh ingredients, a perfect variety of food from what feels like an old school 1940's true "grandma made" food selection that is simply amazing. You can get almost any food that you would expect from a quality restaurant, served promptly and after many visits it has yet to disappoint. Owner Anthony is almost always there, seven days, and will prepare things the way you like with a simple call or email. if you are entertaining his catering menu is perfect and can be done for large or small groups. Even can be done at the last minute with a few hours notice. Also very reasonable on the wallet. If you live local and haven't tried, it is a must you will not be disappointed. Also for us New Years resolution trying to trim down, MANY healthy and tasty dishes where you will not eel like you are dieting. read more

We stop here on our trips up to CT. Third time here and never disappointed! Always have pizza by the slice available and they're delicious. read more

Valtori Pizza Kitchen - Pepperoni, margarita, sausage, peppers and onion pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rye, New York

Stumbled onto this place while traveling for work. It was late, deli next door was closing, popped in for a sandwich. I ordered the chicken chipotle wrap to go. Staff was friendly, wrap was great, food quality was amazing. Great job! read more

Stopped in for a regular slice and a grandma slice. I thought they were excellent. Better than anything else I've had in this area.

About a year ago, we stopped in for lunch and had a delicious meal. Tonight I realized they delivered to our area and couldn't wait to order. We ordered the sourdough pizza (my favorite of the evening), a regular sausage pie (a step up from regular take out pizza), a kale Caesar wrap (perfect way to get some needed greens), a meat Stromboli (which I assume was delicious by the speed and silence my son ate it in). We all voted it the best delivery pizza we have had. read more

Pizza is amazing!! Fresh topics and great salads!! Also one of the best GF pies around. Something for everyone to eat. My favorite is the sweet potato pie! Great crust. read more

Fresh, great quality food. Consistent and delicious. Love their salads and Sicilian particularly.

It's ok. Salads are better than some places. Pizza quality does not hold a candle to Pizza 2000 or the quantity of the other local places. These guys are either going to go up market or focus on quantity. Otherwise, it'll be a long cold winter. read more

Ordered catering from Valtori for our rehearsal dinner and everything was delicious! So happy we had leftovers so we could continue eating it all week! read more

Consistently super good pizza and calzones! Named after the Italian Vampires from Twilight I think!

Tried this new place in the area for delivery. What a waste. Pizza was cold, thick and flavorless. Got the wife some chicken parm and some pasta since some people wrote that it was the best. Well it's was very far from that. The chicken was like rubber and the sauce was very watery and needed salt. They get 2 stars for getting the delivery to the house inside of a hour. read more

The salads are the bomb , and the chicken Parmigiana is to die for ! Got to go to Euro. Plus BOGO on both ...............bam read more

Valtori Pizza Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - Rye, New York

Ordered an avocado and chicken sandwich. It was basically lettuce, tomato, and pieces of dry chicken. I had 2 or 3 bites with any avocado in it. There was a short black hair in the plastic container also. ‍‍ read more

Pasta fagioli was like homemade. Broccoli rabe/grilled chicken Stromboli was delicious...and my wife loved the eggplant parm sandwich. I appreciated the curbside pickup too. read more

Delicious beet salad, tasty pasta and great delivery. Very pleased with Valtori - will be ordering from them again in the future!

Really good pizza and even better pasta dishes. We always get the garlic knots and baked ziti. Taste just like the ones in Brooklyn without leaving Westchester. read more

What a disappointment TWICE!! Ordered dinner for my family and two hours later it shows up incomplete and over salted !! Try anywhere but here!! read more

Pizza was soggy, the cheese completely came off (regardless of the temperature of the pizza), and the sauce was watery. Better places in Rye to order from read more

Best pizza in the area. High quality ingredients and perfect crust. My toddler even loves their salads which is saying something!

I've seen the great reviews and I'm a fan. Great taste and ingredients. Sorrentino is fantastic!

Powerade is 4 dollars very overpriced but still worth it because Powerade is good. otherwise decent food. Too much sauce on margarita slice got all over my yeezys crust is a bit thick. Some like some don't. Please respond antonio. read more

They left off one of the three items I ordered but, what made matters worse, was the pizza pie that I ordered came ice cold and when I called them to explain they apologized and sent over the missing item and offered me a free pizza. I told him that wasn't necessary and they came and delivered the free item. While the free pizza wasn't necessary they certainly could have thrown something in the delivery to apologize for the bad service. To make matters worse, the pizza really wasn't that good either. Unfortunately, I won't be going back. read more

You have to try this place, Valtori's has a family friendly atmosphere and the pizza is delicious! I recommend trying the Margarita Vodka Sauce Pizza. read more

Finally a terrific restaurant moved into this space! They have delicious food that is fresh. Pastas, pizza, sandwiches, Stromboli's, and everything else on the menu is really good. Highly recommend! read more

This greasy spoon is a gem. Good good cheap prices friendly staff. I order chicken parmesan almost every night for dinner. Hard to find a good spot to eat where I live So I really treasure this place. read more

The price was great for a pizza, mussels and antipasto salad. The mussels were delicious but a third of them were empty and none at the bottom of the container. The pizza was cold and it arrived a half hour late. read more

I love Valtori's! It's the best pizza in Rye! They have amazing salads as well as açaí bowls. I would recommend to anyone looking for a family friendly, yummy pizza place! read more

The pizza is perfect!! Especially that Caprese. The owner is very nice and We have been here with the kids many times - we always enjoy the food and atmosphere. The stracciatella soup is also one of my favorites here. The best pizza in town seriously! read more

Best margarita pizza I've ever had! Also really good chicken Francese! Tony and his crew make the atmosphere an awesome place to eat if you don't want to bring it home! Also they're really fast which is a plus! read more

I used them for after a sporting event at Manhattanville College, the food was delicious, hot and on time. They delivered right to the field! Definitely our go to place! read more

Never dined in, but had pick up orders multiple times. Love the Sorentino pizza and eggplant rollatini. The person who takes orders was always friendly. Would definitely recommended for a pizza night! read more

Pizza is pretty bad. Crust is thick and tastes like card board. Not sure where good reviews are coming from. Like frozen Elios

Fresh and delicious salads sets this restaurant apart from your neighborhood pizza parlor. Kids love the pizza and crispy French fries!

Zero stars - Euro Pizza management refused my 14 year old son use of its bathroom because he wasn't a paying customer (today). My son reminded me that their pizza was not the best, and "we won't go there again." We prefer and recommend Al Dente and Sunrise Pizza in Rye. read more

Used to stop by while Planet Pizza and today found out they changed the owner (again), not a problem till I try my favorite pizza, meat lovers. Totally disappointed. Looks like a pepperoni pizza with a few pieces of meet around. The menu says gourmet pizzas, not at all...The crust is ok, pricey for what they offered, don't think will drive from Eastchester to have pizza there anymore. read more