OMGosh ... y'all ... it was delish! Not just your typical NY, or Detroit or Chicago ... but Eastern Europe all the way!! The dough was light and airy with a hint of sweetness ... the marinara was something you just wanted to eat on its own with a spoon ... rich and tomato-y ... the texture of the meatballs was great - not mealy texture but hearty. The STAR pizza is their specialty and the wrapped sides are filled with cheese - so every bite had flavor. Limited selection of seating - back area is definitely for kids. The sound could be a deterrent to eating inside vs takeaway. Place your order at the counter - almost every item also had a photo to show customers what they wanted to buy. And then food is delivered to your table. Nice area set aside to wait for your order too. When we left we ventured over to the Bakery/ Market ... I found candy and desserts I haven't seen in years - and never in America - some of the very best dessert too ... and their meat case - if you're a sausage kinda person - go check out their variety. If you find yourself on CR-210 - skip the fast food and check out this place for dinner! And I just saw they have these Wednesday night takeaway specials read more

See all

We stopped by Siena's Pizza and really enjoyed it. You order at the counter, then find a table or couch to relax while they make your food. For beverages they offer canned sodas, draft beer, and wine, which gives it a casual laid-back vibe. The pizza was delicious, especially the Meat Lovers signature pizza with the lattice topping. Definitely one of the more unique pizzas I've had locally. There's a kid-friendly area, making it a good spot for families. Service was straightforward, not overly warm, but not unfriendly either. Overall, it's a great place to unwind and enjoy good pizza, especially if you're not in a rush. read more

See all

The ads were way better than the service and pizza. Maybe it's staffing issues, but we waited longer than it took for two pizzas to be cooked. Walked in, plenty of tables available at least 6 tables and 2 bench 4 seat tables The pizza came out really quick... Almost like they were prepared before us even ordering. After waiting 20 mins to speak to the only server, the price of 2 pizza, one regular pep and one of their house special closed top pizza, both 16 in, the price was $60 with water for drinks. The pizzas came out in 15 mins max.... The pepperoni was good, and the cheese was ok. The house special ground beef pizza taste more like green peppers and halved garlic cloves than anything else. Both were mediocre at best. I can say, that I did enjoy the style of the closed top, which we may try this place once more, and try the closed top as their chicken Alfredo. Btw, the closed top cooked better the next day in the oven. Bottom and top both crisps up like it should have been initially. Overall, not worth the price, but I will try once more just to confirm. I don't live close to this place. At least a 45 minute drive. Fell for my wife's Instagram ad, which I usually ignore. read more

Siena's Pizza - Closed top ground beef pizza. - Pizza Near Me - St Johns, Florida

There is something very off about this place. I don't even know where to start, but the service was not great-staff is not friendly or helpful. The food is not very good, our pizza bread tasted like it was cooked in an air fryer. I would not go back. It unfortunate, because the location is great. read more

The pizza here was genuinely delicious, and the whole place felt warm and welcoming. Everything was clean, and they've clearly put a lot of heart into the atmosphere. My kid had plenty to keep him entertained, which made the visit even more enjoyable for us. You can tell this spot was created with real care. Will definitely come back read more

Siena's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - St Johns, Florida

Sienas Pizza Address: 150 Fountains Way, suite 13 St Johns , 32259. Siena's Pizza & Bar is the kind of casual, family-run pizzeria that makes you feel at home from the moment you walk in. They serve Chicago-style and other signature pies, along with wings, salads, and plenty of comforting favorites for both dine-in and takeout. It's the kind of place where the food speaks for itself--fresh, generous, and made with real care. Their pizzas come out hot and beautifully crafted, with dough that's clearly made fresh daily. You can taste the difference in every bite--the crust has that perfect balance of chew and crispness, the sauce is rich and well-seasoned, and the toppings are layered with intention. It genuinely feels like someone's Italian nonna is in the back, guiding each pie with love and making sure nothing leaves the kitchen unless it's just right. Their salads are just as impressive. Fresh, crisp, and customizable, you can pick your protein and build something that feels hearty and satisfying without losing that light, refreshing touch. Portions are generous, flavors are clean, and everything comes together with the kind of consistency you expect from a true neighborhood gem. The ambiance is warm, homely, and relaxed--perfect for families, casual dates, or grabbing a quick slice on the go. The staff is friendly, the service is quick, and the whole place has that welcoming charm you only find in genuinely family-owned spots. Whether you're craving a Chicago-style pie, a fresh salad, or a laid-back place to unwind with good food, Siena's Pizza & Bar delivers every time. It's comforting, flavorful, and the kind of pizzeria you'll find yourself returning to again and again. read more

See all

A surprising big place. Order at the counter and wait for your order to be brought to your table. Definitely doesn't feel like a pizza place inside. More like a coffee shop. LOL We got the deep dish. Overall, it was good. Pizza was hot. A little surprised they didn't bring it out in the pan. Still, pleased with the flavors. read more

Siena's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - St Johns, Florida

It took about five minutes before we were recognized. I was ready to leave. The seating was limited. The restaurant itself was smallish, noisy from a play area for small children. The menu did not have prices listed You have to order at the counter and find a seat. They did bring the drinks and food to the table. I ordered a 10 inch Shredded Pepperoni pizza. $30. Really for a ten inch pizza?! My wife had a Mediterranean salad $19 and a 10 inch cheese pizza with basil , $25. I was astonished by the prices. When the underwhelming salad came it was tiny but flavorful. The pizzas were a disappointment. Doughy and mushy. Two soft drinks and a tip later $80. Of course you had to pay before receiving anything. Will not go back read more

Always end up getting my pizza here. Service is Place is very friendly with kids they even have a kids corner with toys. read more

Siena's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - St Johns, Florida

Dropped in for a pizza. First impression is a clean, neat establishment. Painted concrete floors. , high ceilings. Will be noisy with a lot of people. Kid friendly with play area. You order at bar/counter and they bring you your food and drink. Ordered meat lovers pizza. Crust was crispy but not too crispy. Overall, it was good, but average. My personal preference is that the flavors pop, and I didn't experience that here. Do I recommend? Yes, try them. They serve beer and wine. You can bring your kids, let them play, and enjoy a drink and conversation, and a pizza. read more

See all

Just wanted to make sure I wasn't missing the best pizza shop so decided to try Siena's. It's located in the attractive Fountain shops which has so many dining options. Siena's doesn't look like a pizza shop which was a nice surprise. There's a sectional sofa when you walk in across from the counter. Against the wall is a comfortable banquette with wooden tables. In the middle of the room are round pedestal tables for four with a big tv against the wall. After studying all the many pizza options like open pizza, closed pizza, pizza bread , calzones, Stromboli I decided on a 10 in. With mushroom and white & red onion. My husband decided on an open pizza with meatballs. ( There were pics at the register of some of these items.) We waited a fair amount of time & then our food was delivered to the table. My husband's " pizza" imo looked more like an open calzone. I'd call it a pizza boat. It came with a side of sauce. My pizza arrived looking a little underdone & my suspicions were correct. Neither came out piping hot which was odd since there were only 2 other people in the place. Also, when things come out of a pizza oven they're always piping hot. My pie was very disappointing. It was floppy & not cooked well. It had more cheese than sauce and I could not taste the onions or the mushrooms. I feel like this pizza was not made fresh. It tasted more like a frozen pizza. Something was very off. I ate 2 slices & packed up the rest. My husband said his meatballs were good but not much flavor to the dough. He didn't finish his either and packed it to go. Our cost for this plus 1 soda was $44. I'm glad I found out I'm not missing anything. read more

See all

First time diner - my wife and I loved it. The atmosphere is great - Italian Coffee Shop feel if that exists - we had amazing food and service! read more

I ordered a margarita stuffed crust pizza. I love love love that the crust is actually stuffed well. The tomato is so refreshing on the pizza. I'm not sure about the other reviews regarding lack of flavor and what not. I thought it was amazing. If you're looking for New York style, there's a restaurant for that. Dont compare the two because they are not the same. If you're looking for NY style, this isn't the place, but that doesn't mean it's not good. Let me address the people talking about the service: I think the lady is Eastern European and if you know anything about them, you know the "coldness" is just their culture and it means nothing personal. Americans engage in small talk more and such. Yes, "we are in America", but just informing everyone that I think this is the case. I do think the prices are way too high though. read more

Siena's Pizza - Margherita stuffed crust - Pizza Near Me - St Johns, Florida

This review is solely off getting it delivered. Maybe it's better in store. But I was not a fan. I got a large white pizza. Imagine my surprise when I open it and it's covered in spinach and chicken. It was a chicken florentine pizza but named Sienas white. Very misleading but also my fault for not reading description and assuming it was going to be like any other white pizza. I put that aside and tried it anyways and it just wasn't good. Bland and soggy. Now I would've thrown in oven to try to get it more firm, however I had just burnt a frozen pizza in there prior (why I got this delivered) and didn't want this pizza to be caked in the burnt smell and then off the taste from it. For the price, I was expecting high quality pizza, like Balas or Picasso but it's not. read more

Siena's Pizza - Chicken florentine disguised as the Siena's White Pizza - Pizza Near Me - St Johns, Florida

Amazing experience! Pizza is incredibly delicious , the atmosphere is beautiful and cozy, service is great . they also have a good selection of salads, subs, wine and draft beer . This is now our favorite spot read more

See all

Pizza was good. Not full service though. You order at the counter and they bring the food to you. They only have limited drink options. Coke products in cans so no refills. Wine and beer are available. They don't check on you. There is a kids play corner and they have a stereo playing music. It beats going to a pack noisy restaurant. read more

Such a great new place for pizza. We had pizza, cheese bread and BBQ wings. Everything was delicious. Wish we got more pictures, guess we were hungry. read more

Siena's Pizza - Great pizza and atmosphere. Had the cheese bread, BBQ wings and pizza and everything was delicious! - Pizza Near Me - St Johns, Florida

The place is a cute concept but needs more attention to detail. We went last Thursday and we were the only ones there, few people came in for carry out, the condiments, salt, pepper, Parmesan cheese, crushed red pepper, we're all not filled or all the same thing on one table instead of one of each on a table. Also, we had a glass of wine and we could not keep the fruit flies away from flying into our wine. So as slow as it was, I feel like somebody could be feeling the condiment.(seasonings) making sure at the tables there was one of each seasoning. As far as the pizza, it was just OK. Would we go back, probably not!! we were disappointed! read more

I can sum it up in one word gross the sauce the and the dough gross also did not think that it was a very clean place as well plus noticed bugs in there read more

Ordered 2 large pizzas. Super tasty, quick and affordable. No one complained at home which is always a win!

amazing place to let your toddler run and play! They have a kid corner with a bunch of toys and cars! So greatful for this space! We haven't had a meal where we could eat comfortably in a year and half ha ha! Also the food was incredible! Best pizza we've had in a very long time!!! read more

See all

Gluten free crust was good, but it didn't knock my socks off. Service was mediocre but not bad. Very expensive dinner considering the 12" crust was only 10" and charging by the topping. Ambiance was odd, one large room with a few tables and a kids play area. A lot of empty space so the noise echoed. read more

Pizza is consistently good. I'm a shop owner in the complex and order the supreme pizza to go quite often. I have not been disappointed and much better that many take out chain pizzas. The Stromboli and subs are also very good. read more

The ambiance is strange. IKEA setting in a loud spacious area. A TV at high volume with no external speaker which makes the music sound like it's out of a tin can. The decorations have no real meaning to patrons, maybe it does to the owner. The pizza is average, but pricey for what you get. read more

For those who have posted negative reviews, please reconsider the impact these could have on a new establishment. Supporting local businesses is essential for community growth. I've consistently enjoyed my experiences at this restaurant, whether I'm ordering several times a week or stopping by. It's one of the better pizzas we have in North Florida, I can't believe it got a one-star rating. read more

Had a cheese gluten free pizza. Came out with raw crust. They baked another 5 minutes for me and was still undercooked crust. I was cross contaminated with gluten somehow and have been ill for two days. Never use this place for gluten free if you are sensitive. Not worth it. My family ordered 2 regular pizzas and said they were alright read more

Everyone is so nice there. The service is great. There's even a spot for kids to hang out. I recommend this place very much.

My family and I have been here a few times. We've had the Chicago style pizza and the bbq wings, both are delicious.

This is not pizza. DiGiorno's in the frozen section of your local supermarket was better. I asked for garlic power and they didn't even have that. Looked at me as if I was asking for something odd. read more

We visit this restaurant prob. once every two weeks. We typically get pizza, specifically the Chicago style. It's excellent. We also have tried the calzone and mozzarella sticks, both were very good, just a tad undercooked. 5 more min in oven would have been perfection. That said we love the place! read more

perfect service. fresh delicious food. Also try have kids area. I will definitely come again

The pizza was decent - not bad but not great. It was expensive for the size. I do think there are other options available but it was acceptable. read more

Pizza was not cooked enough, the restaurant is like a cafeteria with no ambiance at all- paper plates, condiments in packets- just not a place I would return read more

Good local pizza. Thin crispy crust and lots of cheese. Ordered the meat lovers and cheese pies.