I love this place. It is my go to when I'm in Williamsville/Buffalo area. The food is incredible whether it's a wood fired pizza, the special or something from the menu. Pastas are great, fresh seafood (I prefer the halibut) or a steak or braised rib. The staff could not be more wonderful. Welcoming and friendly. I usually sit at the bar where Angela or one of the other bartenders takes excellent care. Highly recommended for dinner with friends or business. read more

I always amaze coming to this restaurant. I came here couple days ago. Had wonderful time! As a starter we had chicken pate, mozzarella . I had filet mignon was unbelievable. We also had pork chop with spinach & finger potatoes on the side. Of course it's a summer night we wanted to have White wine. Vermentino! I had this wine before when I was in Sardegna and this is even better then I had it. It was aromatic, floral notes, citrus fruits, white fruits and a nutty quality. Very summary and refreshing. It was a very good pairing. I would recommend this restaurant everyone. Felt like I am in Europe. read more

See all

Always delicious. I went to Sienna on a Friday evening and the place was crazy busy. I could only get a reservation at 5:30 pm and while the dining room started off chill it be became crazy over our 2 hour dining. The food was delicious but I wish restaurants would offer a smaller portion for 1/2 the cost I ended up taking home my appetizer as well as my entree. I was able to eat for lunch the next day and it was just we delicious read more

We've been coming here every year when we drop our daughter off at college. Siena's restaurant is always a great choice. As someone with quite a few food allergies, they are always accommodating, and the chef is always kind about it. The waitstaff takes care of you if you have an issue with a dish, they're very apologetic and correct the situation. read more

Siena Restaurant - Salmon prepared with sun-dried tomatoes in a cream sauce - Diners Near Me - Snyder, New York

Fancy restaurant where you definitely want to dress up and you're paying extra for the experience of fine dining and walking by a giant block of cheese for grating fresh. What drew us to the restaurant was the wide variety of gluten free options. Not all are listed on the menu, but upon asking, the waitress let us know which dishes could be made gluten free and recommended her favorites. We got the penne romano and white pizza and they were good, but the crust on the pizza was quite burnt. Upon looking around the restaurant, it seemed they all were and it wasn't just the gluten free crust. It was impressive that the waitress could say where each ingredient came from, like the lamb from Australia (I think), but unless your palate can taste fresh ingredients (unlike mine)... It's just a nice story and experience for decent food and drinks. Also, it's very convenient they have their own parking lot and you don't have to deal with the parking situation in Williamsville for similar experiences. read more

Siena Restaurant - Diners Near Me - Snyder, New York

Only thing that knocked off a star for us was that they put us at probably the most claustrophobic table in the whole restaurant. It was very crowded and we literally couldn't move our chairs in or out or we would get elbowed by the table behind us. The waitress even kept bumping into my husbands back trying to serve the tables around us. As for the food, it was fantastic. No complaints there. Very fresh and flavorful and did not wait long for it. read more

I wish they sold the amazing everything crackers Love the ambiance Love the service Love the food Perfect for a night out! read more

The service was wonderful from the time we got there until the time we left. They had diverse drinks to choose from and a nice variety of appetizers. We got the charcuterie board and the stuffed peppers. The peppers were very spicy so we were glad they brought bread to start. They gave us enough time to enjoy those before they brought out the entrees. We got the short ribs, the chicken & sausage and the rigatoni Arrabbiata. The portions were just right and they all were flavorful and delicious. We saved just a little room for dessert. the peanut butter pie hit the sweet spot and ended the meal perfectly. The price was great for all the food we had. The waiter and staff were wonderful and made sure we had everything we need and we never felt rushed. Will definitely recommend to everyone! read more

See all

Really enjoyed - party of 8 drinks were great, food was delicious, service top notch, a very active/busy place but enjoyable. Our server, Sandy, knew we were there as a family and made our birthday celebration special. Our son attends UB and we were visiting - made us feel at home! Every dish was well prepared. Bread service - exceptional Mussels, octopus, artichokes - delicious Lobster capellini, veal cutlet, chicken, rigatoni arrabbiata, filet mignon (seemed expensive but delicious) Brought a birthday cake, there is a cutting fee but well worth it. They were very professional with presentation and again made it a wonderful occasion. Thank you so much! Can't wait to return! read more

Sadly, very few upscale restaurants in the suburbs are open for lunch these days. Sienna happens to be one of them though. We wanted such a place for a special celebration. The food? Actually quite good but took a very very LONG time to get. The downside? Our older female server was impatient, RUDE, and did an amazing job ruining the moment with her superior and flippant attitude and inattentiveness. She was additionally clueless about wine service. Everyone has a bad day now and then but after reading other recent reviews posted elsewhere, the way we were treated may be the norm here. Majorly disappointing experience that will be remembered for a very long time. The table we were seated at was very cramped and chairs uncomfortable. Unlikely we will be returning any time soon. Food? 3.5 stars, Service? 1 star. Parking? Challenging. read more

The food came out steaming hot! Our steak and breaded pork chops were so so. The server had quite a flat affect and was a bit odd. The clientele of the restaurant were not particularly diverse and were a bit older, including a few gentleman smoking outside that gave us sort of a weird once over. The tables were a bit crowded together and it was quite loud even after 8PM. read more

I came here for my one year anniversary with my boyfriend. They had us seated quickly and it was very busy. The tortellini en brodo was okay, but not amazing. I enjoyed my pasta entree but I don't know if I'd get it again. The real thing for me to write home about was the dessert. It was absolutely delicious! Overall it wasn't amazing, but it was pretty good. read more

See all

Service was so bad the food became irrelevant. I couldn't get out of these fast enough. Will not return. Zero stars.

My mom won a dinner for 8 from donating at a local school's fundraiser. This was a chef's selection tasting menu so we did not order off the usual restaurant menu. The courses were huge! Each course had a delicious wine pairing. We started with salad with fried goat cheese on the side. The breading on the cheese was crunchy and delicious, and the cheese inside was so soft and creamy! Next up we had shrimp scampi which was also delicious. I loved the butter wine sauce it was in. The main course was surf and turf. The lobster tail, veggies and barley were amazing. The steak was great also - however they called it a filet and it was quite stringy. The meat was good I just wouldn't consider it a filet. We finished up with a brookie - a brownie and cookie baked together with ice cream! So delicious. The wait staff was amazing - kind, knowledgeable and very attentive. They made sure our party had a wonderful experience. I hadn't been in years, and would definitely go back soon to order off the menu! Perfect for date night. read more

See all

Excellent service! Excellent meal. Started with a Mediterranean Bliss cocktail that was very good. The bread, olives and cheese they bring to the table was warm and tasty. The margarita pizza was delicious. The rigatoni arrabbiata was delicious. Can't say enough about the outstanding service. Highly recommend. Will definitely be back!! read more

Siena Restaurant - Rigatoni Arrabbiata Pasta - Diners Near Me - Snyder, New York

See all

(4) ~ very good overall food & service. Note: Reservations recommended. DRINKS: ** Water (tap) = (4) very good, must be filtered;) ** Chianti (Sangiovesi Blend) = (4) very good ** Espresso = (4) very good FOOD: ** Braised Short Rib = (4.25) Very tasty ** Bread w. Olive Oil (free) = (4) very good ** Beet Salad (special) = (4) very good ** Brookie w. Vanilla ice cream = (4) very good & shareable read more

Went for dinner to celebrate a friends birthday. Food is always wonderful! Staff were professional, attentive and friendly. We ordered a charcuterie board, the small, for 4 people, and doz and a half of oysters, delicious, and beautiful! Dinner was seafood scampi, pork shank, sausage and mushroom porcini, and short rib with wide noodles! Everyone was happy and satisfied. Absolutely delicious. We absolutely love when they bring us the olives and aged provolone to taste before any food comes out. One minor issue was they did not bring out a dish or bowl for the oyster shells. No big deal! We live going there! And the desserts were outstanding. We shared key lime pie , a something called a brookie. Delish! Thank you for a fun evening. read more

Siena is one of our favorite restaurants. Service is always exceptional. The food is always top notch, too. I had the chicken cacciatore which was on special and it was absolutely fantastic. It was an extremely busy night and we were a larger table, but always felt like we were checked on and orders came out in a timely fashion. There was a slight issue with one of our orders, but the manager was sweet and took care of it right away. Also, if you're a larger table, use Venmo. Don't be extra and make a scene if their computer system can't accommodate separating an itemized bill (also stay home if you're going to be that knit-picky) . Witnessed the entire thing with Rita R's post and she should check herself because she was the rude one. read more

Used to be our go to but no more. The LAST time we were there we were overcharged TWICE in the same night--first at the bar where they added an extra drink and then at dinner when they added an additional entre that no one ordered. When I go out I do not want to have to worry about my bill. I've heard a similar story from my dentist. read more

Siena is a Buffalo classic. It's a romantic, intimate restaurant located in the heart of Snyder. They do not take reservations for groups under 6, which results in a wait of usually 30 minutes on the weekend. The Italian food is top-notch; it is one of the best in the City. They have a variety of options from traditional pasta dishes to pizza to meat-based entrees. I tend to order the chicken cutlets parmigiana, because it's delicious. The pork chop and pizzas are also good choices. The small charcuterie board is worth the price and is a nice start to a fantastic meal. read more

See all

The waitress was so rude and militant about how she served us. She kept telling us how busy she was which was very inappropriate. Food was so so and not worth the price. The money was not worth it and I will not return. read more

I still love this place. Even with all the new options around town I find myself back here often. Even for dinner sometimes. The menu changes every so often, but not too much. The staff seems very consistent - usually the sign of a "good place to work". I love to see that. You can eat at the bar, which I've done. I've also eaten at tables, I prefer that to be honest. While I love a "bar stool", this bar can get busy and it's easier to be at a table, especially if you want to talk to your companion. There is more parking around the back. They are moving soon I think, just down the street. Hopefully they won't be closed for long. 8/U read more

Upscale vibes but not so much that you're uncomfortable showing up in jeans. Very attentive service - I don't eat seafood and they had no problem modifying my salad and entree. I had the Arrabbiata which had the perfect ratio of sauce to pasta and just spicy enough. A nice selection of breads instead of just the standard Italian which were all good. Im not sure if the dessert was homemade but still good either way read more

Siena Restaurant - Peanut butter pie - Diners Near Me - Snyder, New York

See all

Today is my last day of work and my supervisor took the staff out for lunch! The food here is amazing! We got here around 12:15ish and it was PACKED. We got two pizzas for appetizers and it was amazing! I only stick to foods that i know, but i was encouraged to try new foods here and I'm glad i did. The wine is tasty as well. For my meal (I'll update my review with what i ordered) it was okay. It was not as good as the pizza. For dessert i had a Brookie and it was nothing less than delicious. One star is taken off because our waiter was not as nice. She started being friendly in the end, but in the beginning she was really not that welcoming. Overall, I recommend eating here! read more

First walking in the ambiance was dark and moody, I instantly liked that. The restaurant isn't very big and the bar is small. It is clearly a place you'd want to make reservations. Very tight place to stand and wait. We didn't have to wait long as we did have a reservation. The wait staff was knowledgeable and took our drink and food orders promptly. The food was ok, we weren't wowed! Higher priced and smaller portions which was expected. Was in town on business. I'd recommend for a date night or a nice occasion. read more

Plenty of menu items to choose from.Enjoyed the Sicilian white pizza, however i like my crust thicker.I felt the tables were too close together, felt cramped. Friendly staff, warm atmosphere. read more

See all

Sienna has been consistently excellent for a very long time. I am never disappointed with this restaurant. The menu and service are great, it has a cozy little bar, and their pizza is especially good. Stop in. read more

Lots to choose from on the menu from spaghetti to pizza, I ordered the salmon, dinner includes complimentary bread.There is a bar inside, they have an extensive wine list and there's indoor or patio dinning. read more

See all

Overrated and overpriced restaurant. Stained paper menus. Service lacked polish. Sauce was less than stellar. Would not return.

Food was good not exceptional Service food- Nina was excellent very helpful Manager very can not even describe without swearing There were five of us they would not give separate checks or divide it separately on one check after dinner it was a major mathematical nightmare Manager was rude but the waitress was extremely helpful We drove all the way from Rochester for dinner and I found the food average, the waitress excellent and the manager rude and obnoxious read more

Good social distancing and cleaning during the pandemic, and the food itself remains very good. It's not cheap, but if you want a treat, Siena is great. Good ambience and service too. read more

See all

My husband and I had lunch there during the work week and we absolutely loved it. There were only a handful of other people there, my only complaint here in the past has been it can get very crowded on evenings and weekends. I started with a Caesar salad to start I have a seafood allergy so dressing options were limited but whatever they used maybe a lemon vinaigrette was phenomenal. Best salad I've had all year! Then I had the spicy chicken cutlet which was delicious, perfectly seasoned and not too spicy. My husband got the Italian tuna which was absolutely huge and he really enjoyed. We ended the meal with a brookie which we absolutely did not need because we were already so full but it was sooo good. I highly recommend to for dinner or 3+ people it was a little rich for us mid-day. We'll absolutely be back! read more

Siena has a nice patio for nice summer evenings. Consistently excellent menu choices. Servers are always pleasant and knowledgeable. A plus experience consistently. . read more

Delicious, everytime. Wait staff is fantastic. We loved our cocktails and wine. Try the blood orange mule for an Italian soda spin off that's SO good. We got tuna tartare, buratta and caesar salad for starters. Their caesar is a step above the rest to be sure, perfectly coated and with prosciutto! My pesto orrechiette was delish and my table mates enjoyed veal milanese and an arrabiatta pasta. Wish I'd taken pictures but we were too hungry! read more

Well let's start with a steak for $67 pricier than Lucia's on the Lake with a view and very salty. Barmaids very nice . Waitress good also. We also were sat right by the door that connects the patio and waitresses and people walking in and out was not ideal. Pretty place food is ok but so pricey we don't frequent . read more

We went here for a date night dinner after a Sunday matinee. I am so glad we came here!!! Honestly, the group of restaurants this belongs to (800 Maple, JT's on Elmwood, etc) we're the only places open on Sunday! If it wasn't for that, I don't know if we would have ventured out here, but I am so happy we did. The food was excellent and the service was great. I ordered two desserts because I couldn't choose between two! The pasta was definitely home made, and so were the sauces. Our portions were generous but not over the top, which I prefer. If I didn't have someone to "help" me finish, I would have had leftovers. I would definitely go back here for sure. read more

Well how do I begin. Watery drinks, had to ask for bread after antipasto delivered, main course no flavor. My son's 25th Birthday says to me let's go to Sienas on Main St, we liked it last time. I made reservations of coarse theses days, we had to separate our party of 5 no biggie. I ordered the Frutti De Mare and ask to have it kicked up, still waiting for any kick, taste, flavor. My husband order a veal chop, stated nothing special, my brother ordered Salmon said it was good but didn't knock his soxs off. I have no problem paying for good food that makes my mouth happy but Sienas didn't do this for my family and I tonight. Price to value was NOT there. I don't think I'll return any time soon. read more

See all

Our evenings at siena are always fantastic, this past night was phenomenal. Our server Nina did a fantastic job in every aspect. Also, the food was incredible and we'll definitely be back soon. read more

Great place! I had the Berkshire Pork chop it was amazing. The oysters were weak at best, but everything else was great! Been here several times, never disappointed. read more

Siena Restaurant - Best pork chop ever!! - Diners Near Me - Snyder, New York

My wife and I both had an afternoon off just before Christmas, so we decided to have a lunch and art gallery date. She had been to Siena around Thanksgiving and had a good experience, so we were excited to try it together. Honestly, I was a bit disappointed, for several reasons. Firstly, the service was very slow, they only had two wait staff on during a busy lunch hour. They didn't have the salad on the menu that my wife enjoyed the last time she was there. For an Italian joint that prides itself on wood fired pizza, the Margherita that we ordered was over cooked and slightly charred, and they skimped on the toppings. The artichoke appetizer, however, was absolutely amazing! It was baked to perfection, cheesy and delicate. If I could have just eaten that, I would have been much happier. We are in no rush to go back. They are planning to move to a new location in Snyder this year, so hopefully that will help them get back on track. read more

See all