Sicily Pizza & Restaurant

Stopped by for a few slices; Definitely worth the stop. The Sicilian reminds me ALOT of L&B Spumoni…read moreGardens of Brooklyn. The slice has a good crust, but that light sponge like dough your teeth just sink into. Many sicilians are too dough-y chewey for my liking. This was spot on perfect. This was my FIRST Pennsy Tomato Pie slice It's definitely different, in a good way. The sauce has a sweetness to it, like it should be served with seafood. This would be the perfect slice for a light lunch or even as appetizer. Very impressed. Will definitely be back to Pizza Jo soon.

Slice was not very good. Cheese was tasteless and the sauce was mediocre at best. Pizzas looked…read morelike they were sitting there awhile. Service was slow. No smiles on staff.

Catering Menu. Amazing Food!

Menu Front

See all

Menu Back

The GOAT Pub & Pie

4.3(135 reviews)

2.0 mi

Stopped by for dinner when traveling for work. It's a cozy neighborhood pizza and bar spot. It was…read morerelatively busy but not packed on a Wednesday night - full of locals. Got the motz sticks; they were rly good. I'm NOT a fan of Detroit style pies.... But this was Detroit style without the depth. Rather than having a lasagna on a crust, it was a properly thick pie with really great flavor. I got the GOAT Pie - if they're including themselves in the name, it must be good right?! It was soo good. It was a white pie with apple and goat cheese, and the square shape crusted the cheesy corners perfectly (shoutout to my corner piece brownie lovers)! Service was really friendly without being overbearing. Wish they had a spot like this closer to home, but may have to come back later this week before I head back.

Visited twice. Solid food and decent prices. Service attentive at both visits. Had been…read morerecommended and now I recommend lol.

At the bar

Chicken sandwich

See all

Outside sign

Moonlight Pizza

4.7(35 reviews)

8.6 mi

We have been frequenting Moonlight for years. Lived out here for 5, been coming that long, or…read morelonger as a visitor. As a NY'er- I have been around pizza. This is not your typical NYC thin stuff, it is rustic, and more akin to the old school stuff you get in Dyker Heights, but has that nice herb sauce you find more commonly in Queens. The crust, sourdough, is amongst the best I have ever had- the black char bubbles are a highlight. If you want wimpy and flavourless crust- go to one of the yokel spots- not even run by Italians - disgusting. The cheese to sauce ratio is perfect, and if you add toppings, they are well thought out. We have had most of the offerings, and I would place the Cheese & Greens varietals on top of my list. These pizzas command respect, and I also commend them for the way in which the business is run- it's quirky, and permits them a home-life. Support them during the slower Wednesday/Thursday. Deal with the phone calls! Get a salad- you won't be disappointed- they are always interesting and freshly made. Mrs Moonlight is in charge of those. I have never eaten in, but it is cozy appearing. Too much whinging about silly things on this website. 'Waaaaaa- I couldn't use social media to do something.' Come off of it. I would not change a thing with Moonlight- you guys are doing this incredibly well. Saluti from a longtime Loyal!

THEE best pizza I have ever had in 26 years of life. Should be sold out daily. This dough is…read moreinsanely good!!!

Fluffy dough

See all

Tonys Pizza

3.8(9 reviews)

2.2 mi

Having to carpool our 10-year-old grandson to soccer practice my wife and I decided to grab a bite…read moreto eat at Tony's. Our friendly waitress Priscilla helped us navigate the menu easily, noting that we should save some room for Tony's bread, which is baked in the restaurant. Little did we realize just how good the bread was, we almost ruined the entrees. Consumer alert...order the bread it is excellent! Our chicken marsala and veal parmesan plus salads were outstanding. .

I ordered a medium pizza WELL DONE. I received it soggier than ever. There are much better places…read morein the area for pizza.

Food

See all

Perfec

The Catty Corner

4.1(25 reviews)

0.3 mi

I've given this place multiple chances, and this visit officially ends it. The food is overpriced…read morefor what they serve. My Reuben was small, greasy, and completely flavorless -- the kind of sandwich you regret ordering halfway through. But the real disaster was the so‑called "homemade chips." Easily the worst chips I've ever been served. Some were burnt into charcoal, others were undercooked. When I mentioned it to the waitress, she just shrugged like it was normal. And somehow I was upcharged for that garbage. The place is obnoxiously loud, uncomfortable, and absolutely not worth driving to from anywhere. I rarely hand out one‑star reviews, but this place earned every bit of it.

Hidden gem unless you are visiting Martin guitars which is located just across the parking lot!…read more Great pub atmosphere with a welcoming staff and good looking bar. The food was delicious, priced really reasonably, and the portion sizes were huge. We ordered their chicken wings, chicken club, turkey sandwich, and small Stromboli, which was humongous! All of us really enjoyed our lunch, and the service.

Wings with old bay dry rub, fried green beans , crab fries (eh)

See all

Exterior

Tuscana Pizza & Pasta

3.6(64 reviews)

1.1 mi

Very rarely do I give 5 stars but this place was amazing. Not your normal amazing but Uberamazing…read more I am from out of town and wish we had this where I came from. It was a cold February night, about 5:30 and after googling the restaurant and seeing good reviews on Yelp we went to go to Tuscana Pizzeria for dinner . Upon arriving it was a clean well kept pizzeria/restaurant. The menu was huge with a plethora of choices that looked amazing. We started with garlic knots. Now I have had garlic knots before but these garlic knots were off the chains. So much garlic, fresh moist knots. So much garlic that no vampires will even think of coming around me for weeks. Then we ordered a Sicilian pizza with meataballs. This was the true treasure of the whole night. It came hot and streaming. The cheese was melted and waiting to ooze. The meataballs were large and these balls were good. The crust was cooked perfectly and the sauce was sweet and not acidic. That sauce, oooooh so good. The service was great as well. I highly recommend this establishment. My daughter even said "This is the best pizza I ever had!!!!!!" I personally would put this in the top 5 pizzas I have ever had and I have had many pizzas in my many years on this earth.

Ordered two Chicken Parm subs. If there was one breast on the two it would be surprising. Horrible…read moreand called the restaurant and they were not helpful and told us we could come down and pick up two new ones. We payed for the delivery....lol The Chicken was about 1/ 8th of a slice thick, overcooked, very tough and not eatable. It was covered with cheese and not much sauce! Not recommending them!

Garlic knots

Hawaiin with jalapeños

See all

Pizza box

Andrew Rogers’ Pizzeria

4.7(11 reviews)

10.0 mi

So, so, so good. The owner and pizza maker is a one man show and he does it all and with a huge…read moresmile on his face and kindness. Pizza was delicious. Loved the atmosphere and hanging outside the front of the bar the truck is beside watching people inside line dance. The whole thing was fun and yummy and I would definitely recommend!

We hired Andrew for our party at our house. We had around 100 guests show up. He did an excellent…read morejob everyone loved his food. Nobody left the party hungry. Andrew is great to work with and knows how to make great pizzas! We would hire him again.

Outdoor area

Margherita pizza

See all

Outdoor area

Anthony's Italian Restaurant and Pizza Shop

4.4(34 reviews)

6.4 mi

I often get a slice or two of Sicilian, plain cheese or veggie pizzas and am impressed by how good…read moreeverything is here. The team is friendly as ever, happy to take orders on phone and keep things ready on time. For a medium sized establishment, they have ample space for dine-in, anytime you go. The clean, spacious interior is of a welcoming medium sized Italian restaurant rather than a pizza takeout place. An important highlight: they serve possibly the best garlic knots in all Lehigh Valley area.

Order there all the time for years, always good food and service, staff is great and the garlic…read moreknots out of this world

Garlic knots

Anthony's Pizza

See all

Garlic knots with mozzarella cheese

Gambinos

4.3(62 reviews)

5.2 mi

Excellent food & staff! Food made to order. They always make you feel like family there.read more

Food - 3/5 Service - 4/5 Ambiance - 3/5…read more Garlic Knots - tossed in a blend of olive oil, butter, and garlic, then sprinkled with Parmesan cheese and parsley. While the flavor was good, the inside was tough and chewy rather than soft and airy. 7.7/10 Fried Mozzarella - made in-house daily. It was definitely on the blander side, but their flavorful marinara helped bring the dish together. 7.5/10 Calamari - the menu describes it as "lightly breaded," but these were chewy and heavily breaded. It was one of the few times I didn't finish my plate. 7.3/10 Vodka Chicken Parmigiana - crispy edges, melted mozzarella, and a rich, creamy vodka sauce. Now this, I'd come back for! 8.3/10 Penne Alla Vodka - solid. 8.1/10

Provided wine glasses & table linens

Garlic Knots

See all

Fried Mozzarella

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

5 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Bernadette D.

15 years ago

I love the pizza, its the best around. eggplant parm is the best. I went there with a few friends and one of them was allergic to msg and tomatos so I asked them if they could make pasta with garlic and olive oil add spinach and grilled chicken and it was done. she was amazed how good it was and how they take care of you there. you become part of a family when you go there its great. read more

Ben M.

12 years ago

Great pizza, homemade soups and they make an awesome calzone. I highly recommend. Pizza Joe will always be my favorite for Pizza, but Sicily's is a very close second. read more

Sarah M.

7 years ago

Best Pizza in Nazareth, it usually looks beautiful too, these pictures are not what the pizza looks like

Alyssa D.

15 years ago

Best pizza in Nazareth!

Aaron F.

12 years ago

Sicily Pizza & Restaurant - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Nazareth, Pennsylvania Restaurants near Sicily Pizza & Restaurant

BEST of Nazareth, Pennsylvania Coffee near Sicily Pizza & Restaurant

BEST of Nazareth, Pennsylvania Parking near Sicily Pizza & Restaurant

BEST of Nazareth, Pennsylvania Desserts near Sicily Pizza & Restaurant

BEST of Nazareth, Pennsylvania Things to Do near Sicily Pizza & Restaurant

BEST of Nazareth, Pennsylvania Breakfast near Sicily Pizza & Restaurant

BEST of Nazareth, Pennsylvania Shopping near Sicily Pizza & Restaurant

BEST of Nazareth, Pennsylvania Dinner near Sicily Pizza & Restaurant

BEST of Nazareth, Pennsylvania Burgers near Sicily Pizza & Restaurant

BEST of Nazareth, Pennsylvania Thrift Stores near Sicily Pizza & Restaurant

Best of Nazareth

Things to do in Nazareth

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Sicily Pizza & Restaurant also viewed

La Bella Pizza

4.1

(44 reviews)

Great German Pies. In Florida they do don't know what they are. Always been very good.read more

We just had another birthday party at LaBella's for two of our grandchildren. The staff are very…read moreaccommodating and friendly. The food is always great, making it our favorite place to celebrate! Thank you LaBella's for being such a great family restaurant!

Bruno Scipioni's Italian Ristorante & Pizzeria

3.8

(127 reviews)

Back again, this Wednesday, because our power was out and that large Sicilian pizza left a great…read moreimpression from a previous visit. The highlight of our experience was our server, MASON, whose service was on pointe with a gauged continuum that was refreshing and easy. He mentioned he spends a shift or two in the kitchen helping the cooks with preparing orders. This young man has the right qualities to be something special one day and kudos to his parents. The open dining room is narrow but the table setup worked well in that space, allowing several 4/6 top tables for small groups. Anyhow, the sauce on this pie is the draw because it's very similar to what I ate growing up courtesy of my Nonna and my mom's homemade cooking. The crust is baked just right, topped with quality cheeses and the red pizza sauce was abundant and delicious. As we were waiting for our pizza, we took the opportunity to view all the other entrees served to get an idea what the menu items look like and that frutti de mare is next on my bucket list!! Thank you to the kitchen staff for laboring to serve great food! See you soon.

Another slice of Americana!! here in PA!!..Stopped in for dinner last night and shared some Apps…read more Everything was filling and great! Service was excellent. I will return!

Pizza Chef

3.1

(35 reviews)

food came out fast and tasted fantastic service was nice and was just amazing. I had just the…read moreapitizer so far and it was fantastic the BBQ wrap was amazing as well. I recommend this place for their chicken

Pizza Chef restaurant is known for their really good pizza but it also has a nice dining room where…read morethey serve really good Italian food. We have eaten there many, many times and returned recently for dinner. The owner, who is extremely friendly, waited on us because the waitress was very busy with a large party. It's a BYOB so he brought us wine glasses & ice water right away and returned a few minutes later to take our order. I ordered the Chicken Francese which is served with Angel Hair pasta and comes with a house salad and homemade bread which he brought over a few minutes later. The bread was warm and very tasty. The salad fresh and crisp. The Chicken Francese was tender, juicy and delicious, some of the best I've ever had. I highly recommend this restaurant for really good food.

Casa di Franco Pizzeria

4.0

(22 reviews)

Long overdue review. Casa Di Franco. My family's go to for dinner during the busy week and lazy…read moreweekends. Quality ingredients, consistent every time and most importantly, the Taste! Just cannot say enough good things about this restaurant. You wouldn't refer to it as a pizzeria after one try though the pizza is good. Several of their dishes are our favorites all around. We are Bonafide locals and have had it all in the area. Chicken Caesar Salad for my daughter, burgers for my son and everything for me! It's my goal to be a master of this menu one day. Not sure if they cater but if they do.. it's stellar food.

So I'll start out by saying the food is great. Being from New Jersey, we pride ourselves on two…read morethings: Pizza and Bagels. I'll be the first to say that this is our go-to pizza spot in the Easton area when it comes to your typical takeout "pizza night". It's affordable, staff is friendly, and the Margherita Pizza never disappoints. On the other hand, they seem slightly understaffed. We live a walk away from the restaurant, so when we call ahead for takeout they always say 20 minutes or so. I leave right at the 20 minute mark and get there in about 2 minutes, but still have to wait roughly 10-20 minutes sitting there for the pizza to be done. Probably not your ideal sit-down restaurant for a night out, but solid for takeout. I just wish it wasn't a 40 minute wait for 1 pizza.

Antonio's Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.3

(112 reviews)

The service was superb! The atmosphere was authentic old school New York style with the traditional…read moreItalian music, delicious scratch made food! Portions were well worth the price! Local residents/clients were very friendly and inviting! Hope to get back in town to visit again soon! Ciao!

The "pepperoni roll" is just a stromboli. Nothing rolled about it. Tho good quality i wouldnt have…read moregotten it, too much cheeese. The rice balls were microwaved right in front of me. Overall kindof eh.

Sal's Pizza

4.3

(115 reviews)

*Disclaimer -not a review*…read more I'm here because of Dunder Miflin, the Scranton branch! Your menu is in the kitchen on the show "The Office". If I ever make it to Scranton, I'll have to stop in for a bite!!

We got into town hungry so we searched Yelp for a restaurant that delivers. Yelp showed us Sals so…read morewe decided to try it. I got the spaghetti w\meat sauce and my friend got a cheesesteak. Both pretty good. The delivery was quick. The pics of the menu were not updated by the business so the prices were higher than the last menu updated.

Slice of Italy

4.1

(205 reviews)

Very good pizza enjoyed the chicken BBQ slice while in Allentown Pennsylvania I will return…read morewhenever I'm in town

First time visiting Allentown. I found this place on Yelp and it was near my hotel. Wow--the…read morestaff as very friendly! Definitely had a local vibe. It was sweet seeing the staff connect with the regulars and yet they always made me feel welcome. I had the lasagna vodka special--outstanding! I also had the cannoli--delicious. Highly recommend this place.

Armando's Express Pizza

3.4

(68 reviews)

Ordered delivery from here just now because it's Friday and I don't feel like cooking…read more Anyway, I ordered a small white pizza w/ pepperoni and a Mediterranean chicken sandwich. Bangin'. Pizza was hot, crust was crunchy, cheese was delicious. And the sandwich? Mm. Fresh mozzarella as stated, chicken seasoned well, warm toasty and fresh bread, and the balsamic vinegarette gave it just the right zest of flavor. Delivery took an hour for a small pizza and chicken sandwich but it did come earlier than the ETA and I had nothing to do anyway while waiting, all good with me. Will order from here again.

I ordered a calzone and a meatball parm sub. The calzone was pretty good, but the marinara sauce…read morewas horrible, I don't think marinara sauce should be orange. The meatball parm had decent meatballs, and a generous amount of cheese, but almost no sauce. Which, considering how bad the sauce was, might have been an unintentional mercy. Three stars is because the calzone was good, if they had good marinara sauce, it would probably be four. The service was decent ( I got mine to go so I really didn't interact that much) and the ambience is pretty much the same as in any small pizza shop.

My New Place Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

3.8

(30 reviews)

This is an addition to my previous review! I absolutely…read morelove the food at My New Place. Always very friendly, prompt and eager to give great service, to match the great food! Don't be mislead by the star rate from Yelp! If you haven't tried this restaurant , I highly recommend that you do! Great food, prices and service.

My New Place has redeemed their shameful service with much improved quality of service. The buffalo…read morechicken wrap is now fantastic and doesn't come in soup form. My son gets their California cheese burger and says it's delicious

Fratelli Pizzeria & Cafe

4.3

(146 reviews)