I have been to Sicily multiple times and the food as well as the service is always great. I've heard people complain about the prices but the portions are huge so I think it is worth the price. read more

Sicily Coal Fired - Aperol spritz, seasonal sangria, complimentary bread - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

Oh my. This place is fabulous! The menu offers a LOT of options. We were impressed with the ingredients, the care & talents of the chef and staff. The mozerella cheese on the pizza is of high quality; not oily. The parpadelle, like all the pasta, is hand rolled. The 40-hour short rib feeds two people for a few days (well worth the price), the calamari won my husband over (and he is old school Italian). The broccoli rabe & sausage sandwich is enough for two or three people! We will definitely be back, with family and friends!! Great value for the price paid! And our server Lexi was SO genuine and friendly! GREAT dining experience! read more

Decided to go out to lunch with my friend. He is a chef and said this Sicily, and their coal food pizza is wonderful. It's funny as neither of us ended up ordering pizza. I will say this, the pizza comes in one size, no slices here! It's a fairly large place. With huge TVs that were showing opening day and other sports. I think this would be a good place to watch your favorite team with some class thrown in. We sat at the bar and perused the menu. Both of us being foodies we took a long time deciding on drinks to start. I ended up deciding on a blueberry cider at the suggestion of our bartender/server. She was right on the money. I really enjoyed it. For lunch, my friend chose the porcetta grinder. It was FILLED with meat and delicious greens. It had a nice kick of spices. I chose the Figgy Piggy. A grilled cheese with fig jam, caramelized onions, and bacon! I swapped out cheddar for the mozzarella. It's totally delicious. It came with their version of fries. Which are these fat, curly seasoned potatoes. Tasted GREAT! The portions are good size, and I had enough for a snack at home. read more

See all

Went for happy hour and had a great experience. I love the "Social Hour (4-6?) Bites" options. I really enjoyed the meatball slider and the whipped ricotta! My friend got a pizza and it looked delicious with a New Haven style crust. She raved about it and I can't wait to come back to try a pizza for myself. I had a margarita and it was excellent. The vibe is fun and I really enjoyed eating in the bar area but family friendly as I saw families with small children enjoying their meals as well. Excellent service and the kitchen is visibly sparkling clean. read more

See all

Incredible food - very authentic Italian. Huge portions so bring your appetite. Had the Chicken Parmigiana and it could have fed at least 3 adults! Salads were fresh with generous portions. For an appetizer get the Arancini - splendid! One of the best Italian meals I have had! read more

Sicily Coal Fired - Chicken Parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

It all started with not being able to talk to the person next to you because it was so noisy. Onto the service, our waiter came to the table minutes after we were seated and asked us for our drink orders. We asked him to come back as we hadn't even looked at the menu yet. He came back in 5 minutes and wanted our drink and dinner orders. We gave him our drink orders and asked him to come back for our dinner orders. When we finally gave him our dinner orders... salads and entrees, salads were brought out and one salad order was incorrect. We sent it back and when the correct salad arrived it was half the size of the original salads. Then entrees were delivered before we were not even halfway through our salads. I will not speak for the others at our table, but I ordered the Eggplant Parm. The portion was enough to feed at least 3 people and served over overcooked spaghetti with enough sweetened tomato sauce covering the dish that I couldn't locate the eggplant from the spaghetti. The drinks are overpriced and the tap beer was less than a diet coke that was ordered. Needless to say that we will never be coming back. We couldn't complain because the waiter couldn't hear what we were saying! read more

One of the best places in Middletown Ct! Located on main st plenty of paid parking front and rear lots depending on time of day and week as lots are used for local court house. Some of the best pizza I have had outside New Haven ct it to mention the extensive drink / beer menu and daily specials and extensive food menu. Large space within dine in and small patio space out front but not in the sun under a large over hang make sure it's warm out. Service is always exceptional I have never been upstairs and mostly for lunch but they are expanding into space next door to make a large wine bar! Very casual not precocious so jeans are cool. Pizza is always amazing with numerous toppings .Kutcher is open so all activity can be observed . Had the chicken parm special in this day and to say huge is an understatement! I actually ate a quarter brought home sandwich took chicken and prosciutto off and with some pasta and a little more creatine cheese adding made an entire meal for 4 out of a very reasonably priced sandwich at 15 bucks .. so if you are in Middletown what a good pizza a nice experience cool rotating beer menu and full bar with great service I highly suggest never had a bad meal yet or experience .. so enjoy .. read more

Sicily Coal Fired - Chicken parm grinder with cherry peppers and prosciutto toasted on roll like cheesy garlic bread - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

Sometimes the big showy is a red flag. Good food, yet nothing that would beg me to return. Pizza, good by Middletown standards, coming from someone who lives in New Haven. Eggplant Frites tasty but as you get to the layers underneath the top they become soggy and oil soaked. Too much lavender honey which is a nice compliment but a little can go a long way. Brussels spout dish was good. Again...food was good but nothing I would run back to. We sat in the "wine bar" side which is nicely decorated in "hey, I'm ultra Italian goomba" style. They're just missing the statue of an angel pissing into a fountain. Piano playing great music which is a nice touch to the ambiences. Misha? Commands a well run bar, yet the small touches that separate a wine bar from a bar that has a ton of name brand wines need attention. Water glasses should be filled continuously until the patron states that they are done. Wine glasses, if a bottle of wine is purchased, anytime the server walks by should automatically refill/pour a glass. In other words, the glass should never be empty. Wine pricing is all over the place. $22/6oz pour of an other wise $20 retail bottle of white wine is kinda ludicrous, but bills have to be paid and food costs are high even at the wholesale level. I get that. Otherwise, nice place to try out once or meet up with friends while out in Middletown. My cautionary tale would be, watch out that you don't become another Cava in Bristol. read more

Sicily Coal Fired - Brussel sprouts and eggplant frites - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

We been to Sicily's several times and they are constantly excellent. Beautiful atmosphere and friendly staff. Will definitely make this a place to visit when I come to Middletown. read more

Great pizza and menu. Parking is hard to get if you are just to pickup orders. Give yourself enough time to park and walk in. Pickup by kitchen gets a bit busy but helpful service. Off menu items they don't have readily made can take some time. Waited for wings and added 25mins to wait time to payout. Pizza was room temp when I got home but still not bad when you reheat on a pizza stone at home. Priced fair, but if not for the delay in pickup and parking, would rate higher. They are busy, so plan accordingly! read more

Stopped here spur of the moment, and glad I did. Grabbed an outside table on a beautiful day, and was served by Joey, the very capable Business Manager. Was in the mood for pizza, and SCFP has numerous options for creating your own, or ordering a "craft" pizza. Tough decision as so many tempting choices, but I opted for the Fig Pizza. While waiting, Joey brought out bread and a spread of fresh garlic, peppers, celery, mushrooms. The bread, baked daily, was about the best I've inhaled this side of the Bronx. The spread was also delicious. Great amalgam of contrasting flavors. Star of the show was the Fig pie. Crust was thin, but not so thin that it couldn't hold its toppings (no blue pill needed). And the toppings produced a tsunami of flavors with each bite. And I learned that "speck" is not a piece of dust when on a pizza...it's a cold-cured, lightly-smoked ham or bacon, originally from northeastern Italy. The pie was chewy as well as gooey. Overall, a great dining experience. Unlike a lot a places that make great pizza, SCFP has an extensive menu of very inviting appies, salads, sandwiches, burgers, and entrees. And plenty of libation choices. Worth stopping in! read more

See all

Tonight I attempted to dine here with a friend that I hadn't seen in over 10 years and unfortunately the night ended in turmoil. When we arrived there was a 30 minute wait, which was no problem because I could see they were busy. I sat at the bar and had a glass of wine until our table was available. We were seated about 25 minutes later & ordered our food about 10 minutes after being seated. Our appetizers came out within 20 minutes. When we were seated there was a family seated next to us that ended up leaving because the wait was too long & they hadn't gotten their food so they asked for everything to go. I saw them speak with the manager and they were given a complimentary dessert as a make good. Another couple comes a while later and orders drinks and food. Their food and drinks come out before our entrees. It's at that point that I look at the time and realize that about 90 minutes have passed and we still have not received our food. We start looking for our waitress, Gabby but I couldn't find her so I went to the hostess to see about our meals. She remembers seating us and thought it was strange that the table next to us got their food first. She heads to the back and comes back to our table with our entrees and Gabby is with her. I express my grievance that it took nearly 2 hours to receive entrees and the table next to us had received their meal before us and I would like our bill discounted for the delay. She immediately has an attitude and asks me "why" and states "they ordered a pizza, it only takes 5 minutes." I responded that my friend ordered a salad and that doesn't require cooking so that wasn't an excuse. Her and I have an unpleasant exchange, she was defensive and I told her she shouldn't be a bitch to a customer. She told me she was one of the owners and I said if that's the case it's unfortunate that an owner would speak to customer in that manner. She then reveals she's 23 & not the owner & I rebutted well at least we've learned that she's a liar. I asked to speak with a manager and at that point a girl named Sabrina comes over & tells me she can give me a gift card. I informed her that I do not live here, I'm in town visiting & after being treated that way by my server I have no intention on returning to the restaurant & would prefer a percentage off of our bill. There was a lot of back & forth & Sabrina called me entitled & implied that I just wanted something taken off my bill. At this point we are in a heated exchange and a third girl comes over to try and deescalate the situation. I asked for our food to go and to speak to another manager. While we are packing up our food, another older woman that I later learned is the owner Maria, comes to our table and is yelling at me saying I should be ashamed because I made my waitress cry in the bathroom and I said that was unfortunate. Her and I had an exchange & she threatens to call the cops on me if I didn't pay the bill. Now let me be clear -- I never once said I wouldn't pay my bill. I didn't pack up my things, I didn't even have my food covered so I was unsure where the accusation that I wasn't going to pay my bill came from. It truly felt like we were being profiled as two black women. As I'm trying to explain everything to the second manager Sal, Sabrina & Maria are still there ganging up on my friend and I, yelling for me to give them my fucking card and that I need to fucking leave or they're going to call the cops. At this point Sabrina is being extremely aggressive to the point that a male staff member has to hold her back. My friend & I are no threat to anyone as we are seated in a corner booth, surrounded by a bunch of staff being attacked all because I asked for a percentage off of my bill after having to wait nearly 2 hours for pasta and a salad. I have been to many restaurants and have never in my life been treated like this before. I've since learned that they are all related so it's no surprise to see that behavior being condoned. I couldn't have made this up if I tried. Awful experience. read more

Sicily Coal Fired - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

We had a rough experience. First of all, JJ our server was excellent...got dealt a bad hand. He let us know he was prioritizing our order several times with the kitchen, but a big and long staying party kept on getting priority. Sadly, all 5 of our dishes were unsatisfactory. The spaghetti/meatballs(2), sauce tasted like copper and the meatballs were mushy and freezer burnt tasting. Chicken parm: pasta/sauce also tasted like copper, cutlet was ok. House salad was basic. Chicken stuffed with prosciutto, just no....i don't even know what the base was, plated very nicely but so many competing flavors that didn't work nicely. We got a small cheese pizza and it was actually very good. So moral of the story, stick to pizza. read more

Sicily Coal Fired - Chicken Mozzarella & Prosciutto di Parma Stuffed Chicken Breast - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

The best cannoli around! You can't go wrong with anything on the menu. Our favorite pizza is the penne vodka and the salads are huge! Add a chicken cutlet and you can eat for days. Sicily always hits! read more

Went on Valentines day. Long time for food over 40 min. Server was great kept apologizing. Food was average. Carrots and chicken burnt. Short rib good. Overall if I came back would just get a pizza. Prices high for quality of food. read more

Pizza is great. Easily the best pizza in Middletown. The menu is kind of odd with the offerings in the prices are quite high for some of the actual full meals but if you want a solid pizza and not have to drive to New Haven, I would suggest getting a pepperoni pizza from this place for sure read more

Sal, the owner/Supervisor? Was a Real Gentleman, very Professional with his actions accompanying me we one of his "Bar worker" Dustin is what he said his name was. My friend Denis and I ordered to drinks, set them down and within 10 to 15mins were scooped up by staff possibly. We let Bearded "Dustin" know and he flat out refused to believe us and in a VERY Unprofessional manner told me to get out or be thrown out. Zero resolve from him, after threatening bodily removal I followed him to find his Supervisor Sal. I'll leave it at that for now. Needless to say we stayed, continued listening to a Great Band "Mix It Up" they were great. Motown and old school. We drove 2hrs to be here at this Great food and Restaurant. "Dustin" needs to seek other employment as he is very unprofessional and just being a prick. read more

Sicily Coal Fired - Crispy Artichokes Angry Shrimp Yummy - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

See all

I'm Back again for a night out and to listen to Timmy Maia. Today I decided to try something different from the menu. Had the seasonal sangria which was peach flavored, it was National wing day so had their wings which were very good and filling. And because I was getting full I did a side salad. It's the only one that came in a small. We met 2 older gentlemen that sat next to us and ordered the Coal Roasted Wings . He shared 1 with me and they were very good and flavorful. Definitely something I would order next time. It has no sauce just seasoned. The Octopus looked amazing, he said it was a nice like salad with a piece of octopus on it. Service is always wonderful. And we line Sicily so it's always nice to be back! Plus it great that they have GF options too. The 2nd floor bar area is where it's at , it gets busy where downstairs is more of the sitting , dining area. But they are always playing good music! Definitely great vibe! read more

See all

Great home-made food, good service, and great interior. The vibes of the wine room are beautiful.

Our first New Haven style pizza. Must say it wasn't too bad. My husband is a native New Yorker so he loves his pizza. I thought the prices were reasonable. Would definitely return. read more

Wow!! As someone who lives in New Haven, my standards for pizza are pretty high. I wasn't expecting to be blown away, but I was pleasantly surprised! The pizza was absolutely out of this world delicious. The ambiance was great, with plenty of space to spread out and ample seating upstairs that didn't require a reservation. We sat on a comfy couch near the bar with a view of the entire restaurant down below. The festive decorations, marble bar tops, brick walls, and creative lighting gave off an upscale vibe that makes this place a great option for date nights or meetups with family and friends. I can't wait to invite my work friends here! I know they will love it. We ordered a side Ceasar salad and it was plenty to share between two as an appetizer. The two sour beers we tried were incredibly fresh and delicious with tons of real fruit flavor. Some of the best I've had, and I have tried many!! Sicily exceeded my expectations by a long shot and I am excited to share it with friends in the future! Would definitely recommend. read more

See all

Pleasantly surprised and will definitely be back! We sat upstairs in the bar area due to bad planning on our part so will definitely make a reservation next time! The food was all delicious. Well prepared & seasoned but not over done in any way. I got a burger which was delish (though I did not realize it was a double patty!! ‍), pretzel & garlic bread were perfect apps & my daughter was thrilled with her chicken parm! Wayyyy too much pasta but that's a good problem to have. I tasted the parm as well & it met all of my criteria which only one other restaurant in CT has for chicken parm! Service was attentive and fast even though they were very busy. So yay, very good, will be back, accessible, easy parking (behind the church access the street) and good for all ages! read more

Sicily Coal Fired - The Sicily Chicken Parmigiana Plate (husbands salad with grilled chicken in back) - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

See all

Over an hour wait for food. No sign of our waiter. Ordered a second glass of wine and never got it.

A really cozy and intimate place if you choose to sit in the wine bar. They offer the full menu over at the wine bar and every pizza on the menu sounds incredible. The staff if fun and personable and helped make good decisions with every course. We split the gem salad with blackened chicken and the salad is plenty big to share but that chicken lives in my head rent free. So flavorful and juicy. But the pizza stole the show. We got the fig pizza and whatever cheese they use is some of the freshest I have ever had. I challenge you to have only one slice. We ended the night with the home made tiramisu and it's that perfect balance of sweet but not too sweet. read more

Went to dinner with a friend today for the first time here. There's lots of seating outside as well as inside. it looked like there was seating upstairs as well. We arrived during Social hour. We both got an appetizer I ordered the whipped ricotta. I really liked it. It was sweet and refreshing. Unfortunately, my friend did not like it. She ordered the fried mushrooms and really enjoyed them. However, I did not like them. This just shows everyone has their own taste. She had the mashed potato pizza. She said it had a lot of flavor and it had a lot of fresh cooked bacon on it. I wanted homemade rigatoni with a tomato sauce and fresh burrata on top. They were able to make this for me even though it wasn't on the menu. The portions were very huge on the pasta. We were very happy with our meal. The service was great. The style and look of the restaurant is very appealing. I will definitely return. read more

See all

Walking in to this very trendy restaurant was a refreshing change from the old school pizza places that I am used to. There's outside seating, as well as upstairs, and main floor inside seating. With tables, booths, and high tops. A gorgeous bar with a great selection of draft beer. Their coal fired pizzas only comes in one size 14 inch.We ordered a half pepperoni, half sausage pizza. It's a thin crust, slightly chard pizza that was cooked to perfection. The chunks of Italian sausage topping was excellent, and the pepperoni had a nice kicked to it.This restaurant is so much more then pizza. Their huge salads looked amazing as well as their sandwiches and dinners.Can't wait to come back to try some other items on their menu. read more

See all

First visit here after a recommendation from a coworker and we loved it!! To start, the inside was beautiful and nicely decorated. We walked in to see a bunch of Christmas decorations, as well as Christmas music playing throughout the restaurant. It was around 4:30 on a Saturday and it was decently busy, but we were quickly sat. We were surprised to see the huge amount and variety of beers on tap - we both ordered one. For our entrees, we both had pizza. My friend ordered the pepperoni pizza with hot oil, which she really liked. She said the hot oil was spicy, but not overbearing. I ordered the Prosciutto di Parma & Salad pizza, which was delicious. The balsamic glaze complemented the savory aspects of the prosciutto and goat cheese very well, and it was topped with a generous portion of arugula to bring the entire pizza together. The pizzas we ordered were thin crust and cooked perfectly. Service was very good considering how busy it was in the restaurant as well. Only complaints are the layout of the restaurant - we came in the back and we were a little confused, since there is only takeout at the back and we had to walk through the entire restaurant to get to the host stand. We also were not aware what was upstairs - after sitting we heard people saying it was a lounge where you seat yourself. We would have preferred going up there, but there's always next time! The bathroom was also near the takeout area in a small hallway - it was hard to get there with the constant pedestrian traffic and there was only one stall, so a line quickly builds outside. Was also a little pricey, but definitely worth it for the specialty pizza. read more

Sicily Coal Fired - Pepperoni pizza with hot oil - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

See all

This is a very lively Resturant that is always pretty full. It's great for cocktails and or dinner. The bar has such a variety of liquors and the bartenders are very creative. We were feeling like fall cocktails so we have a pumpkin spice martini and a toasted almond martini. The servings are quite generous which I believe it will be better to share they are that large. You can get two to three meals out of a serving. Everything is presented beautifully and the wait staff is so friendly and accommodating. No room for dessert but they had some pastries displayed and they looked awesome. Fun, lively and tasty. read more

See all

Walking up to Sicily gives me a pretty good vibe. Today it had a tiki theme outside. Inside it was hopping! Every seat at the bar was taken. We were greeted quickly and seated at a high top in the bar area. Dana our server was great. Attentive and fun. Joe, one of the managers, checked on us as well. I was pleased to be able to order a beer flight. They have a ton of beers on tap and even more coming. Joey told me they were going to have a few staples but likes bringing in the "different." We ordered a basic pepperoni pizza, which to me, is how you test a pizza place. It was the perfect size and it was delicious. I can't believe it took us so long to get here. We'll be back! read more

See all

Mars is a terrific professional server and we sat near the open kitchen fascinated by the fresh ingredients and portion size of the meals being made by a team of pros. Pumpkin martinis were outstanding and the affogato (espresso finish) was delicious. We might have gotten the wrong pie but it was wonderful too and Mars responded quickly with a side of marinara for dipping. Great spot - all the small plates and entrees look sooo good. Yummy! read more

Stunning visually. Large bar with great service and selection. Cannot wait to return! read more

The restaurant is nice. We sat at a table near the bar. The televisions were on. The house bread was good but we had to ask for butter and olive oil. The mixture that came with it would be great with garlic salt and fresh garlic. I ordered the eggplant Parmesan spaghetti dinner. The sauce, pasta and cheeses were really fresh. I expected the eggplant to be crispy but it wasn't. It was still good in between the cheeses and sauce. My friend ordered the shrimp casino pizza, it had bacon so I couldn't try it (I'm allergic to bacon). She loved it so I ordered one without bacon to go. We ordered the doughnuts and it came out flaming. The presentation was impressive. However the doughnuts were too thick and tasted like they had too much salt in the dough. They put sugar around them and I dipped one into the jelly and I wasn't impressed. My friend didn't like them. I took them to work today and my co-worker didn't like them so I wasted my money on those. I ended up throwing the rest away. I will go back I just don't get the doughnuts. I want to try the French fries when I return. They looked really good. A nice lady sitting next to me told me that they were really good. Our waiter was friendly and welcoming and he got my order right and made sure no bacon was on the pizza I took to go. read more

Sicily Coal Fired - Eggplant Parmigiana Spaghetti dinner - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

See all

This review is for the happy hour menu and a dessert only. It was a quick trip (less than an hour) on a Friday around 530. We specifically came to see what happy hour was about just to try out this place. And we were definitely happy! We got a meatball slider, the eggplant frites and a cheese pizza. All on the happy hour menu. My husband said the meatball was the best he has ever had and he was even eating the eggplant fries and he doesn't like them usually! The eggplant had honey and cojita cheese. Then we got the cheese pizza which was $6 and it was plenty for 2 people and the flavor was sooo good! One of the best cheese pizzas I've ever had. Then we ordered dessert- it was my birthday and I really wanted the creme brûlée I saw on Instagram. It did not disappoint!! It was so good and I loveeee that they give you a bunch of strawberries. Most places just give one and hard to share. Honestly this is probably top 3 creme brûlée's I've had in my life and we get one every where they have it lol For drinks I just got the happy hour Pinot Grigio which was fine. My husband ordered a mojito, granted not on the menu but it came out orange. It tasted like it had something cinnamon in it. Sent it back and got an actual mojito the next time. This is the only reason I didn't give 5 stars. I feel like a mojito is a standard drink and getting something in a small glass that was orange/cinnamon I feel like is just not ok. Server Joey was attentive and friendly. We will definitely be returning read more

Sicily Coal Fired - What was left off our eggplant frittes - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

See all

The food is pretty good but they always seem so crowded and depending on where you are seated, you are very close to other guest. Overall pretty good food. read more

In Week One of its existence, Sicily Coal Fired Pizza ("SCFP") is already in the upper echelon of Hartford/Middletown pizza restaurants. I first spied SCFP when I was sipping a cold brew across the street during the Memorial Day Parade. I immediately had a good feeling about SCFP because in my experience, good things usually follow places with "Coal Fired Pizza" in their name. Ever since then, I've been watching for the opening date, which was two days ago. I ordered a sausage pizza to go. I ate a couple pieces in my car so I could judge it at peak power. The pizzas seem to be one size, which I would describe as a generous classic Neapolitan size. The pizzas are priced accordingly. The thin crust is great. It's charred in the right places, and good chewy in the right places. The sauce seemed like a basic crushed tomato sauce, which I mean in the best possible way. No need to overthink the sauce on this style of pizza. The sausage and the mozzarella were both high quality. The pizza was cooked for the perfect amount of time so that the crust was just right and the toppings released their natural flavors. It seems I wasn't the only person to take notice of SCFP. On just its third day, business was jamming around 6:30 and the servers were hustling. I was told my pizza would be ready in 20 minutes when I called, and it was, which is a minor miracle given how busy they were. The inside is a combination of red brick, wood, tans and swirly red light fixtures. Nice, but nothing too fancy. SCFP also serves pasta, apps, salads, burgers, sandwiches and a few entrees. In this regard, SCFP's menu is broader than I would have expected and it will be hard to do all of those things at a high level. In terms of pizza, I already like SCFP better than many big name places in the area. I assume things will just keep getting better with more experience. Note: To best enjoy SCFP's pizza, I would eat there or very soon after picking it up. I think it would lose some of its best features if it travels in a box for too long. read more

See all

Looking forward to the winter menu of food and drinks again! The food is amazing as well as presentation! Service has been excellent! Ambiance is great and fun! Highly recommend you try it if you haven't! read more

See all

Went for lunch with our grandchild Food and service were ok, a bit expensive (the way it's getting everywhere) and the pizza was pretty severely burned on the bottom read more

Great service awesome food and the vibe was to die for. Right on main street such a neat place.

We've been to Sicily a few times and was looking forward to going back. We returned last night, and unfortunately, the portion of the $35 lasagna we received was 1/3 of what we had previously enjoyed. 1 slice of pasta and a lot of sauce, we ate it and all the bartender could say about it was that "we took one for the team" didn't feel to great about the experience so we wont be going back. read more

I love this place! I have been here many times, and it never disappoints. There is an open kitchen and dining area, as well as a relatively large bar. There is also an extra bar upstairs, where they have a DJ some nights. Given the high ceilings and large crowd, this place can get loud. There isnalso limited outside seating. When here, I almost always get pizza, which tells you how good it is. When dining with others, they have gotten other menu items. Everyone always says the food is on point. There is a full bar and specialty drink menu too! I can't say enough good things about this place. Whether you want to take the kids for pizza, sit at the bar for a drink, or rock out to country music on Thursday night, this place is it! Will definitely continue coming here! read more

Sicily Coal Fired - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

See all