We dined there on Saturday evening (5:30). The place was generally quiet and not very busy as we…read moreentered but within 30 minutes all tables were full and the bar was packed. Despite being full the service was excellent and the restaurant was not overly loud. We enjoyed 3 courses each - mushroom strudel / goat cheese tart were our appetizers, for our meal we both had the skirt steak and for dessert my wife enjoyed the peanut butter/chocolate and I had the pistachio mousse. All of the items were delicious. Much better than we had expected and served quickly. I would recommend this restaurant highly and we look forward to going back again many times in the future.

The tuna tartare is just like the lakehouse which i love and is why i came. The clementine drink…read morewas quite literally the best tasting "orange creamscicle" drink i have ever tried. The food was phenomenal!

We had our engagement party at Bayberry and it was absolutely amazing. The staff was so attentive…read moreand made everything run smoothly, and the food was incredible, our guests are still talking about it. The ambiance was beautiful and perfect for a celebration. They even brought in Stella for our party when they don't normally stock it, which was such a thoughtful touch and really appreciated by our guests. My parents loved it so much they went back the following weekend for dinner. Highly recommend Bayberry for events or a great night out!

Very nicely decorated. Alittle on the smaller side. Went for a brunch event that was ok. Didn't get…read moreto try anything but breakfast food. Will go back to try for lunch/ dinner.

Love this place!!! Just found it this week! Awesome local…read morepub that I'm a huge fan of! Bartenders and waitresses are perfect! Fun environment and excellent sports watching spot! Food was decent. I'm a traveling salesman from CT. I'll be back definitely!

Another great meal with the family at one of our favorite places. Not pictured was the pretzel app…read moreand buffalo wing app, both were amazing. I could eat 100 wings they are so good, perfect spice. Staff was amazing as always.

If you're having trouble finding street parking keep a look out for free parking lots you can park…read morein. My friend and I were welcomed wonderfully by the staff. We got a table fairly quickly and were greeted by a wonderful waiter Dennis! He was sooo happy and greeted us with a smile! The food was DELICIOUS! The Troffolini was incredible! What made the sauce special was the sweetness of a pair. The baked clams were incredible! Not only did our main dishes look beautiful, but they tasted fantastic! A perfect place to catch up with a friend or go for a date! Thank you to everyone at Americano Pie Bar for their great service!

The food choices and when you order one of the sandwiches on a chibata roll maybe you should cut it…read morefor the customer, how do you expect anyone to open their mouth that wide ‍‍. Service was good and thank goodness for dessert

Amazing Guinness I enjoyed it and the bartenders are phenomenal! Went down smooth as hell!read more

Always a pleasure Come through for a great experience…read more Drinks are also well prepared.

Every summer I go on a hunt for the best lobster roll. I like to try new places since my go to…read moreplace decided to change their recipe. This is my third lobster roll this summer, and this the best one of the season for sure. It is pure perfection. This is a small nook outdoor restaurant in on the bay of Islip. Honestly loved the vibes and overall atmosphere. My friend always says I find the best lobster rolls. Try it for yourself, you won't regret it. Please don't change your recipe!!

The waterside view is wonderful. The rest is just ok. You order from the window and they bring you…read moreyour drinks and food. We had 2 cocktails a fish sandwich platter, and a fish sandwich. It came to $78. Paper plates and plastic ware is used. Lackluster service. The food is fine. I wanted to love it. Please make it better! I would love to love this local spot! I'd rather go to Whalers and spend my money there.

We had a small family birthday party and were disappointed. The food was delicious not an issue…read more The service was horrendous. We were promised the room at 4:15 and they didn't clear out the previous party till 4:30 and were still setting up the bar at 5:10 when our guest of honor was expected arrive. Bar service was sporadic and getting anything from the servers was impossible. They cut the cake small handed out pieces then failed to make the cake available for anyone to eat more and top it off the bartender was eating cake a huge piece at the bar. Ok so we had cake however COFFEE goes with cake it shouldn't have taken them 30 minutes after serving cake to get our guest coffee. Then to top it off the cookie platters that were included were sad. 1 red velvet cookie surrounded by 6 chocolate chip cookies 1 plate per table. I'm surprised because I've been here before and never had such a unfulfilling experience. They left us having to get up and continuously ask for refills and missing items. I'm disappointed and don't recommend them for a party. As an addition to the story after they read my review they called and apologized and fully addressed the situation to our satisfaction.

Not the best steak this time around but still a good experience…read more We needed to push the reservation one hour on a Saturday and they were very accommodating. Quickly seated, too. Our fried calamari was great and love the house salad. Just be sure to ask for your favorite dressing as they bring out a standard creamy one that I don't like. My steak this time around wasn't the best. It was definitely overcooked and my tough to cut which was a bummer as it was phenomenal last time. But my husband enjoyed his dish and my daughter enjoyed her chicken parm. The ice cream that came with her meal was fine. The chocolate cake was nothing to rave about.

Such a great spot, the Cortlands been a huge part of Bayshore and the new owners have revitalized…read morean old charm! Bob behind the bar can whip a cocktail that will knock your socks off! Super fun spot and Grateful Dead kicking is always a plus!!

Great Mixologist,still a friendly cool crowd.Everyone was having a great time and karaoke was…read moreflowing. Very clean bathroom and parking is ample around the back.

Saw this place in a local coupon book I obtained during my travels, and figured I'd check it out…read moreonce I checked their pub menu, which included the elusive Irish Scotch Egg. Tale of the disappointed tape: Mac & Cheese: the description sounded great, so I gave it a shot. Unfortunately, it missed the target, as the combination of cheeses (Béchamel, Gouda, Fontina, Gruyere, Cheddar) is bland! There is no even slightly pronounced cheese taste, not even from the cheddar cheese melted on top. I had to add my own hot sauce (Frank's and Texas Pete are my savory favorites) to liven it up a bit. Irish Scotch Egg: I'd heard about the existence of this food item while watching the British show "Broadchurch," wherein it was a running gag that the David Tennant character offers his partner a bite of his Scotch Egg, and she always refuses the offer. A Scotch Egg is a soft boiled egg enrobed in a sausage shell, rolled in bread crumbs and then either baked or fried. Sounds good, doesn't it? When I saw it on their menu I had to check it out. Unfortunately, it too was also rather bland. A soft boiled egg by itself is not exactly flavorful, but the sausage here could have been, and it just wasn't. The two eggs in the order come on a bed of shredded lettuce that had spicy mayo in it, which you definitely need to help enjoy the egg. Either that, or use your favorite hot sauce, mustard, or other condiment. I may try to make this myself, using a certain brand of sausage I've always found flavorful, and/or some chorizo. Yes, that would quite possibly work . . . Pulled Pork Sliders: three pulled pork sliders are served with your choice of sauce (BBQ or other house sauce) a dollop of cole slaw (on the slider), three slices of cucumber and a spear of lettuce. This is the only item of my order that I actually enjoyed. The BBQ sauce was decent, and well complimented the pulled pork and slaw. These I would get again if I were to return to this pub. Conclusion: pulled pork sliders FTW, but Scotch Eggs and Mac & Cheese leave more to be desired.

First time here, they have a great outdoor patio with tables and a bar and TV' s. Two bars and…read moreplenty of seating inside