I got a large pepperoni pizza, meat lasagna that came with cheesy garlic bread. I really didn't have the highest expectation of this place, but have to admit, I was surprised how good it was. Crust on the pizza had a great crisp, and was light. Pepperoni and cheese ratio was really good. The meat lasagna had a great flavor, and had a really generous amount of meat and cheese. Lasagna came with cheesy garlic bread, and was good. Casual to-go orders. Order was ready when it was anticipated. I definitely will be coming back. read more

Shelby's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza and Lasagna. Lasagna comes with cheesy garlic bread. - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

I ordered via delivery for my first experience. I was craving pasta after a rough day but on a tight budget. Shelby's popped up and had what I was looking for plus it was under $30! The food was fine. Stellar? No. It has alright flavor but plenty of cheese. The chicken parm is just breaded chicken strips under marinara which isn't bad. It was fine. I satisfied my craving and enjoyed some fairly good cheesy bread (tho some of the bites had some not-so-melted cheese.) But the Alfredo was creamy and it was plenty of food for a few meals. Well worth the price for pretty average food. read more

Only had hand tossed crust and sausage on order. Crust, reg sauce, cheese, and sausage are excellent. Reminds me of Pizzeria Uno which I like. read more

Recientemente tuve la oportunidad de visitar este restaurante de comida rápida y no puedo dejar de recomendarlo. Opté por la pizza de vegetales con carne, y debo decir que fue una experiencia deliciosa. La masa de la pizza es uno de sus puntos fuertes. Es ligera, sube pero sigue siendo crujiente, lo que le da una textura increíblemente agradable. El queso está perfectamente distribuido, sin ser ni mucho ni poco, logrando un equilibrio ideal. Los vegetales eran frescos, lo que le daba un toque muy natural, y la carne estaba muy sabrosa, acompañada de unas aceitunas que realmente elevaron el sabor de la pizza. Además, las porciones son adecuadas, ni demasiado grandes ni pequeñas, lo que permite disfrutar de la pizza sin sentirse abrumado. El restaurante ofrece varias opciones, por lo que si te decides por esta pizza, seguro que no te arrepentirás. ¡Una excelente elección si buscas una comida rápida pero sabrosa y de calidad! read more

Shelby's Pizza - Veggie Lovers Create Your Own Pizza - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

Accidentally received this cheese pizza ( wrong order ) , but was pleasantly surprised. The cheese pizza had great flavor and really didn't require any other toppings ! read more

I have really tried to like this pizza, but it just isn't good pizza. The crust is undercooked on the bottom. The top is nice and golden and it looks like it is going to taste delicious, but it tastes like cheap pizza with cheap ingredients. The pepperoni tastes like they are using off brand instead of name brand. It's not good, don't waste your money. read more

Shelby's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

See all

We've been ordering pizza from here for last three years. We all look forward to our Shelby night because the pizza is always on the point. It's delicious, good quality toppings, sauce and cheese is perfect. We've pretty much tried every pizza on the menu and all the pasta dishes. Verdict: we've yet to be disappointed. Darn Shelby, you don't have a weakness lol. read more

Food - After glancing over the local establishments with great ratings, I chose this pizza spot because it was a short drive from Prosper. I'm glad I made that decision as we ENJOYED pizza that was hot and fresh. We tried the Aloha and BBQ chicken pizza. I chose to pickup, though they deliver, and otw home, I shot two quick pics, as I could barely resist the temptation to grab a bite. Both handmade crusts were light, soft and not greasy (yay!), which complimented the toppings perfectly. My favorite was the BBQ, with my husband stating both were delicious. Service - I gave a four because the service was mediocre. Basically greeted me with a flat affect and a hello, passed me the pizza and that was it. Not saying that was a big issue, but I'd already pre-paid and added a tip. Since it didn't matter either way, I would have kept it, especially since I picked up the order. Maybe I'm asking for a lot but no one has to tip, but great customer service is everything when looking for repeat customers. Ambiance - nice, clean establishment in a relatively new strip of stores. read more

See all

This is our overall favorite place to get pizza. We always get a large veggie pizza and a large works pizza. My husband will not let me get pizza anywhere else now. read more

This is my updated review ---- Although they had to raise their prices so did all restaurants BUT I think the food has gotten better I love the Shelby's Philly I sub the chicken for pepperoni and sub bell pepper for extra grilled onions . I also get extra Alfredo sauce on it and do the hand tossed crust . My husband gets the thin crust carnivore and they always pile on the meat. We are lucky to have this amazing little place it taste like the pizza from a fancy restaurant! You won't be disappointed read more

Shelby's Pizza - Shelby's Philly no chicken add pepperoni No bell pepper add extra grilled onions Extra Alfredo sauce on hand tossed crust. - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

See all

Pizza is always good. However, allowing an employee that interacts with guests to wear a shirt that says Playboy with the Playboy logo is offensive. Care about your customers more. read more

The best pizza in town!!! I highly recommend Shelby's Pizza. We ordered a few pizzas, all delicious and fresh by the way, to be delivered for a party and they went above and beyond expectations. Not only did they deliver on time, they also didn't charge me for an extra pizza I had ordered last minute because I didn't think I ordered enough. This pizza place is a gem and I'm so glad we decided to try something new instead of papa John's or some other chain. We will only get Shelby's from now on. Thank you for a successful pizza party! All our guests raved about how good the pizza was. read more

Just ordered delivery via Uber Eats. I don't post many reviews. Forgot say I'm really impressed. Ordered medium works. They don't skimp on the toppings and all topping very fresh. I've been searching for a pizza like a mom and pop we had back in Wichita Ks called "Jacks Pizza Planet" for 30 years and boom! This is it. I should have ordered it with green olives and it would be exact. I will order again for sure. Decent prices too. You're killing the competition with this level of quality. Nice job! Oh I should also say I know pizza. I was in the big corp pizza business for 10yrs. read more

Yummy and super delicious crust. My go to place for pizza and I love the pasta too! Must try! read more

Pizza was amazing and halal. the staff was amazing. and food came quick.and atmosphere was super clean.

One of the worse pizzas I've ever eaten! So overdone my grandson wouldn't eat the pepperoni. Being a New Yorker I am very particular about my pizza. I went on the reviews for this place and was so disappointed. read more

The pizza is always good but needs to be more consistent. At times, it's extraordinary; other times, it is just average; the wings are not worth ordering dry, and there is almost no flavor. You would think atomic would be at least a little hot, but NO. I'm not sure the pizza is worth the price for the consistency. read more

We wanted a traditional, what I call "American style" pizza. A pizza that was similar to the ones we ordered when I was growing up - good toppings, yummy crust, with the dough cooked enough to hold the toppings. This is surprisingly hard to find but Shelby's ticked all the boxes. We ordered a custom veggie pizza and the veg was fresh and evenly distributed, there wasn't too much sauce or cheese, and the crust was cooked to perfection. We ordered through door dash and it arrived hot and on time. Will definitely order again! read more

Best pizza we've had in a long time!!! We ordered a small cheese overload pizza, a small mediterranean pizza and a Greek salad--both pizzas were fantastic!!! We are so full from the pizza that we're saving the salad for lunch tomorrow. Thank you to the folks at Shelby's Pizza~ and to our delivery guy, Samar, for not giving up on finding our address!!!! read more

See all

Awesome Pizza!! I would definitely order from here again. We did an olive pizza and one of their specials.

At first glance, this pizza is goals: fluffy crust and generous toppings. The staff was also friendly and had our order ready super quick. Sadly, it fell a little short at first bite because the bottom of the pizza lacked firmness (kinda limp) and my husband thought it may have been undercooked. We tried putting it in the oven for a few more minutes which helped. I also prefer my pizza to have a thiccc crust cuz I love my carbs but I respect that thin crust lyfe too. Overall, I'd give this place another shot to see if that first time was just a fluke cuz they had only opened recently. read more

Shelby's Pizza - The works pizza (large, 8 slices) - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

See all

One of the best..had multiple takeouts in last 6months And the pizza never disappoints..even the sandwiches they offer are good Give it a try esp their cheese overload read more

Shelby's Pizza is delicious! I love that you can get your pizza whatever thickness and style you prefer. Fresh! Yummy!

Please go visit Italy or NY pizza, John's or Joe's. wings just cooked wrong, dry and over cooked. pizza is Digiorno. If you're feeding kids great. Adults..NO WAY! It is horrible. wish no stars was ok. read more

We just moved to the area and found this gem of a place! OMG. WHAT A DEAL! We got the 2 pasta/salad special and a 2 topping pizza and I cannot believe how much fantastic food we got for the price. The ravioli is AMAZING, my daughter devoured the fettuccini chicken Alfredo, the salads are quite large for such a deal and the pizza is great with FRESH toppings. I know it sounds like they paid me to post this but seriously, I just moved here last week and don't know diddly Shelby's, you've got a new regular. Thank you!!! read more

See all

Food is...wow! I'm so glad we found this little hidden gym just driving around! This pizza is so good. They're a little short staffed at the moment so your food will take a tiny bit longer but they do everything they can to make your wait comfortable. I had even started feeling lightheaded due to the heat and the girl at the counter handed me a soda and made sure I was ok. So sweet! So if you're wanting to taste some great takeout pizza this is the spot...just make sure you're not in a rush. ;) read more

Placed an order over the phone, very attentive and super nice. We got 3 pizzas, Philly Cheesesteak, the works and bbq chicken. Crusts we're great (thin, thin and crispy, hand tossed) prepared very well. Meats/veggies were good. I'm a saucy gal and the sauce felt non existent. Sauce is everything for me so Maybe next time I ask for extra sauce if I try again. Wings we got hot and spicy and Asian sweet chili. Sweet chili was hands down delicious. I'm read more

This pizza is by far the best in town. Ever since discovering it, we've ordered this pizza once weekly. The cheese they use sets in apart from the others. Not sure if it has a mix of provolone or something but it's PERFECT pizza cheese! The flat bread is so good too that I get it every time! Our order is also accurate, taste is consistent and delicious and toppings are a plenty! The only feedback I may suggest is to motivate and inspire staff to be more upbeat. The employee that answered the phone for our most recent order sounded like he would rather be anywhere but making pizza. I almost thought it was a joke and maybe we were being punked but nope, he just couldn't be less thrilled to help a customer. I will not take away a star for one bad apple but hopefully it is something that gets addressed. Maybe he just had a bad day. Anyway- go to Shelby's. Enjoy this amazing pizza. Save some for me! read more

Man Shelbys seems to be the best pizza in town but its not very known about . Seriously the pizza is good . You will never go back to pizza hut , or dominos again. The pizza is so thick with Harty ingredients. We always order to go but the set up is nice and to the point . It is a little on the expensive side but we worth it. The motzerella sticks definitely tasted frozen but who cares we c not me for the pizza. My family of three ate one large . read more

We tried Shelbys Pizza and were so impressed! Prices were reasonable and both hubby and I loved what we got. He ordered lasagna and I ordered their Mediterranean pizza. Perfect date night in, including dessert for only $20! Just wanted to give a shout out that will hopefully give them some well deserved business! read more

Shelby's Pizza - Mediterranean pizza - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

See all

Cannot say enough good things about this place. Their food is always epic with fresh ingredients and we did not have one bad experience since they started. And we order a LOT of pizza!!! They are super prompt and always friendly. Do try them if you are in the area... read more

..not good. The cheese completely separates from the crust and leaves a weird artificial aftertaste. we couldn't even finish a medium supreme pizza between the two of us. The mozzarella sticks were very thickly breaded, and fried every hard- almost like nearly burnt panko. I was told the wings are all right. read more

Today was sons birthday and got pizza and chicken wings. pizza was very good. chicken wings are tooo bad. it was tooo salty. kids could not even eat one . called and gave feedback they it was just like okay so? no apology. they don't have any bad feeling when i said the we couldn't eat it was tooo salty. i don't recommend wings from here. **update: **i got call from owner and she was very apologetic for what has happened. she is going send back the gift card for the order. Sometimes money don't matter as we willing to spend when we plan party. Very very talking to owner. Thanks for taking feedback seriously and acting on it. read more

Excellent pizza at an affordable price. Kids loved the cheese overload. We had the carnivore and the works. Both where amazing. Wings and baked ravioli are also a great choice. Haven't found a bad dish yet. Highly recommend this place. read more

So much better than the usual chains. It's become our new favorite pizza place. The deals are pretty good as well.

Awesome. Been going a least once a week for months now. Tonight I found my new favorite. Forget the name but it had grilled chicken, pesto sauce, artichokes and diced tomatoes. read more

Shelby's Pizza - Sooooo tasty!!! - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

See all

Good: Pizza is very good Bad: Limited seating Overall: Nice addition to neighborhood options I have visited twice on a bike ride with my daughter and her friend. Both time the food was very good. I am not typically someone who ventures outside of established pizza restaurants, so this really is high praise. There is a hightop table that can seat about 3 at the window so this really is more of a to-go option. However the food was very good so I would recommend trying if you are interested in something to go. Am interesting tidbit is that one of there toppings is cashew. I've never even contemplated cashew on my pizza. However I am now considering a return visit to give it a shot. read more

This is a local place and I highly recommend you try it out. I am so happy to have a place with such yummy pizza!! We ordered 2 medium pizzas and a salad and everything was delicious. Their pizza creations are different from your regular boring place but they also let you create your own, if you're not into trying new combinations. These pizzas are full of flavor, unlike your fast food places. The lady taking our order was very friendly. Also, they are open till late!! We needed a place open late, not that we should eat so late buuut sometimes you're hungry and well, you just gotta eat!!! I highly recommend you try this place!! read more

Shelby's Pizza - The works pizza - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

Great pizza and wings. We tried the hand tossed crust and the thin crust. The thin was too thin for us but it did have great flavor in the toppings. The hand tossed crust is the way to go! They put a seasoning on the crust and it has a great finishing. We also got the boneless wings, hot and spicy and sweet Asian chili and ranch. We loved the wings and even ordered again just the wings because we liked them so much. Ranch is pretty good too. Wish the ranch came in a bigger size. The specials were pretty good too-check them out! Definitely will be ordering again! read more

Shelby's Pizza - Boneless Wings - Pizza Near Me - McKinney, Texas

Pizza is good but delivery times are never accurate. Tonight the email said pizza would be delivered by 6:05. It's 7:15 & still no pizza. I called at 6:45 & was told our pizza was on the way - we don't live 30 mins away. Every time we order we predict at least 30 mins past the stated time but this is ridiculous! read more