We "accidentally" ordered takeout from here on 1/16/26. My husband thought we had Crazy Tomato…read morepizza about 10 yrs ago. He wanted to try it again. However, when he went to the place and ordered the pizza, he realized this wasn't the place he remembered! I am SO glad he got the place wrong! This is probably my new go-to pizza place!!! The pizza was DELICIOUS! We ordered traditional types, but I got a small Chicken Florentine (with tomatoes added) for myself and LOVED it! The prices were very reasonable, also. We will be back for sure!!!

I initially saw an ad on FB. They had great reviews. I decided to try them out. I am glad I did…read more Pick up only no seating inside. Great great service! I felt welcomed when walking in. Now to the food... All of the ingredients are fresh and pies are of course made to order. From the crust to the sauce all made in house. There are some really unique flavor profiles which makes them stand outside of the rest. I look forward to trying other delicious items on the menu. This is what I had: Chicken and pineapple: 10/10 signature classic pie. The grilled chicken flavor goes well with the sweet and citrus flavor of the pineapple all finished well with the pizza sauce. Crazy Rodeo: 10/10 all ingredients all play well together and create a crazy rodeo party in the mouth. The meatiness of the ingredients really shine through. I could not taste the honey. I probably should have left the olives off to take in the flavors of the pizza. It was still outstanding and one I would definitely order again. Garlic cheese sticks: 10/10 cheesy, gooey, and good. Cinnabon bread: 10/10 they did not skimp on the cinnamon and brown sugar. The glaze is gooey and delicately sweet. Bread pillowy.

My wife and I went here for our Valentine's date. Its a cute neighborhood Italian restaurant that…read moreserves food that's much better than you have a right to expect in a suburban mall. The house Manhatten was delicious with subtle adjustments to the traditional recipe. The Arancina Tradizionale is a fried ball of tasty saffron rice, stuffed with Bolognese and peas. Its a great appetizer with lots of subtle flavors. As an entree I had the Cacio E Pepe, the famous pasta prepared in a wheel of pecorino cheese and covered in fresh ground black pepper. The pasta was perfectly al dente, the cheese was creamy and mild, and the pepper nicely balanced the richness with a mild spice. I ordered shrimp on the side and it was well seasoned and nicely charred. My wife had the geilled salmon and loved it. We didn't really have room for dessert, but since everything else was so good, we couldn't resist trying the Tiramisu and Strawberry panna cotta. We couldn't have been happier with our choice. Be prepared for European style service and you will leave satisfied.

Tried this place for the first time over the weekend, and we really enjoyed our first visits. We…read morewere able to get seated right away and our waiter was very friendly. The menu I think had a good variety of entrees to choose from, and we both ended really liking the dishes we ordered. I ordered the pasta bolognese, and it was great. The pasta was cooked right and the sauce not super over powering. We will definitely be back to try other dishes. My only complaint was that seating is a little cramped, and everyone including the restaurant staff had to maneuver around chairs, etc. but other than that we really enjoyed our visit.

We actually were going to a different place to eat but they were closed. So we stopped at Roman…read moreCucina with no idea what it was like. We were pleasantly surprised. It looked expensive from the outside but it wasn't. We were seated right away. They brought us some good bread to nibble on while we ordered. The tea was a little weak but I'm very picky on my tea. We ordered parmesan and garlic bread for an appetizer. It was huge and super tasty. The dipping sauce was very good. We also ordered a spaghetti bolanase. There was so much that I ate 3 meals out of it. We'll be back.

In our opinion, the food was mediocre at best. The prices were great, but I would rather pay more…read moreand eat a good meal than leave stuffed on food that was just okay. The atmosphere was good. The sports memorabilia was really cool. Service was good enough. Definitely wouldn't return given better options in the area.

Never been here and was feeling some pizza and beer and they deliver on all counts and more…read more Leesi our server was simply amazing and helped us navigate the menu options - I chose a pie and my daughter chose a burger. Food was above expectation, full bar, and great menu. Ambiance is great. Parking lot a little cramped in front so you may have to walk a wee bit.

Tl;dr The service at this Pie Tap is consistently slower and less professional than other…read morelocations. We generally love Pie Tap. The sourdough is really delicious, and their Tuesday special and daily happy hours are solid. We've never had a bad experience at other locations. But after leaving the McKinney location this evening, having waited close to an hour for 2 kids pizzas and a veggie pizza, just asking for the check so we could cut our losses, we're done here. We ended up taking the pizzas to go. I wish we hadn't. They needed more time in the oven. This is what we've come to expect from this location. They always seem overwhelmed even when the place is half empty, and the service is consistently subpar.

10/10 recommend!…read more The thin crust pizza is crisp, light, and easy to eat. The crust has a good crunch without being dry, and the sauce and cheese are balanced so nothing overpowers the flavor. It's simple, clean, and satisfying. The Chicago-style deep dish is the complete opposite in the best way. The crust is thick and buttery, packed with layers of cheese, sauce, and toppings. It's filling, rich, and feels like a full meal in one slice. As someone whose family lives in Chicago, this place is legit. Both styles are done well, making it a solid choice whether you want something light or something hearty. By far one of the best pizzas I've had in the area. Defintely will be returning :)

The pizza is a beast, you need to hands to carry it. You have to order this about 35-40 min ahead,…read moreso it can cook through in case you didn't know it's stuffed with lots of deliciousness. The sauce is good, slightly sweet. We did half veggie and half Italian sausage,m.

Great St. Louis style pizza. IYKYK…read more We'd be there all the time if it was closer. But it's over an hour from our house and still well worth the drive.

This place is very unique because it's inside a furniture store. It has a lot of character from the…read morejazz singer statues out front to the sports memorabilia lining the walls. It's nothing crazy but a good lunch deal $9 for a 9-inch personal one topping pizza and a fountain drink. Self service for the drinks Food was ready in about 10 minutes

Holy smokes I've never ate my food so fast! It was hittin every spot flawlessly! I wish everyone I…read moreknow could eat a piece of this garlic bread because God Damn! Never in my years have I been so excited for some bread. The service was excellent as well I love the Italian vibes. This is definitely a hidden Gem that I want to gate keep but won't. Yummers!

It wasn't the best Italian food I've ever had but the prices are decent and the portions aren't…read morebad. Service was pretty fast and the ambiance was dimly lit.

This place was kinda middle of the road for me. I would say the food was pretty good, but my wife…read morewas not as big a fan. My arepa was delicious, but pretty hard to eat. We also ordered the half chicken and the ravioli and both, I will admit, we're not very good. They both tasted like something you get from the frozen isle. Just not much flavor or depth. The service was honestly on the bad side. They hardly came to the table and we had to flag them down to get our check. Ambiance is farmhouse style, but very small and cramped. That caused it to feel stuffy and cluttered. The saving grace here was the food. I think it's a bit hit or miss, but overall I would say good. For the chicken, ravioli and and arepa, I payed about $50.

Good spot.. food is homemade, service is espectacular, very good vibe. Love it…read more Sancocho made Sat & Sun. Tequeños are a must

Pizza: absolutely OUTSTANDING... plus other Italian entrees are exceptionally good. Ample services,…read morewith spices exactly as ordered. Best pizza I've had since New York! SERVICE: Timely, efficient, friendly, and attentive to table needs. Excellent service by the wait staff and also the Manager who came out to chat with us, ask about the food, and offered "extra" attention. We're taking our Neighborhood Friends back tonight. Love this ideal get-away, warm environment delight!! Dick T. 03/26/2026

My fiance loves pizza and we order from here at least once a week! Best pizza in town…read moreWe get the 16" large cheese and ask for it well done and it's perfect every time

I tried this place for the first time and man was I expressed, I really enjoyed it so much and so…read moredid my kids. I don't live that close to it but I will definitely be going back. The owner was also very nice and friendly.

I am disappointed I cant give Mr Gatti's in Allen 10 stars. I grew up eating Mr Gatti's which no…read moredoubt has the best sauce EVER and I found this gem this morning. The owner was very friendly and helpful and I ordered a Pepperoni/Canadian Bacon/Mushroom pizza and cinnamon sticks. It was freaking PERFECT! So great. I highly recommend if you are in Allen off the Exchange parkway area to please stop by and give it a try. 10 STARS for Mr Gatti's