I'm still dreaming about the ice cream cookie sundae I had. My mom, dad, and I wanted to check this place out after seeing it on TikTok, so we stopped in here around 5 PM on a Saturday and thankfully there was no one in there and we were able to place our three orders without no other party coming in behind us (except for one woman but she was actually apart of the group that was outside eating their ice cream while we were walking in). The one woman working inside was super friendly and walked us through each step of the ordering process. It would've been super stressful for her if there was a line, with how attentive she was being with us! My mom and I both ordered the ice cream cookie sundae. She chose a red velvet cookie base, with a scoop of the rush hour and a scoop of the ultimate peanut butter brownie ice cream, along with caramel drizzle and butterfinger topping. I ordered the Reese's cookie base with a scoop of the peanut butter brownie ice cream and lemon cheesecake ice cream, with white chocolate drizzle and Oreo pieces on top. My dad ordered the brownie base with ice cream and a Reese's cookie on top! His looked massive in his bowl! The ice creams were out of the world, but the cookies were the stars of the show. My mom is a superb baker and even she was stumped on how they can keep their cookies so soft throughout each bite even with cold ice cream on top. That's how amazing they were. If there's one thing I dislike about cookies, it's when they get crispy or crunchy and they're impossible to get through with utensils. These cookies, however, cut like a moist piece of cake or brownie, they were so soft. The peanut butter/chocolate combination in mine was just what I needed after a day walking around Prescott and hiking the local trails. My mom and dad both loved what they got, but my mom wished she hadn't gotten the red velvet cookie since she wished there were fewer white chocolate chunks in the cookie. The prices were great for the amount of food you got, the service was excellent, and the desserts are literally sinful they're so delicious. read more

Shanna's Sugar Shack - Reese's cookie sundae with lemon cheesecake and ultimate peanut butter brownie ice cream - Desserts Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

See all

First time here. We saw the signs for the ice cream stuffed donuts and had to try one. Super good. Glazed donuts with two scoops of ice cream inside. Then the toast the outside. Very tasty treat. Glad we stopped by. read more

Shanna's Sugar Shack - Treat with my love. - Desserts Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

See all

A very special "sometimes" food place. One of the best desserts I've ever had. The ice cream sandwiches constructed from your choice of dessert bars and ice cream flavor are the signature item. Imagine every dessert bar is like the best version of that dessert bar you've ever had and you stick any combo of two together with your choice of ice cream. Shanna, I'm glad you set up your shack far away from my home, because otherwise my family would have to transport me around in the bucket of an excavator. read more

2 scoops and a brownie - yes please!! With a variety of both Brownie flavors and ice cream flavors, narrowing down your choice is challenging but, in a good way! It has cute patio tables inside and out but I definitely recommend outdoor seating on a beautiful Prescott, Az evening. read more

Shanna's Sugar Shack - 2 scoop sundae and a 2 scoop sundae with brownie. - Desserts Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

See all

Most amazing cookies!!! They will even ship across country! Would highly recommend and will plan to visit again!

I love the edible cookie dough. The brownie batter is so good. Today I finally tried the ice cream too and it's another winner!

Super cute and clean dessert location! It was our first time in and the owner shared about the options - so many delicious choices including cookie sandwiches and ice cream! My daughter chose a scoop of chocolate mud pie- creamy, filled with chocolate pieces and a very reasonable price for such a big scoop! We will definitely be back! read more

See all

Cute little confectionery shoppe. Customer service was really great at counter. She asked if we had been in before, which we hadn't- and proceeded to tell us about options including ice cream and cookies. It was great! We ended up getting 1\2 dozen of these giant chocolate chip cookies. Yum! Will definitely be back. read more

See all

I met Shanna today and she was so nice and friendly. She explained everything she has to offer from ice cream to freshly baked cookies. I bought a chocolate chip and a Reese's peanut butter cup cookie and my husband and myself devoured them. They were delicious. Shanna also explained she can ship anywhere. I will return. read more

The best ice cream in Prescott. Some unique flavors and good size scoops. Appreciate the friendly staff.

Absolutely phenomenal! Got the Lemon cheesecake and the O-O Cheesecake ice cream. Would definitely come back!!

AMAZING PLACE! Extremely nice and friendly staff!! I highly recommend coming here and trying their deep fried ice cream stuffed donut!! read more

Shanna's Sugar Shack - Desserts Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

Best ice cream in downtown Prescott!!!! Located in the Old Firehouse plaza next to the parking garage.

This was our first time trying Shanna's Sugar Shack and it was amazingggg!! The ice cream was perfection and the baked goods were so delicious! The service was so nice and they were so helpful in making recommendations based on our favorite flavors. Don't wait to try this yummy ice cream shop! read more

Shanna's Sugar Shack - Desserts Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

Stopped into Shanna's Sugar Shack this afternoon. Tried the single serve ice cream cake. It was delicious. We were able to meet Shanna, her sister, and the fantastic mother of these two ladies. These desert options are made with love and enthusiasm. Stop by to get your Sugar on. You won't be disappointed. read more

Shanna's Sugar Shack - Single serve ice cream cake. - Desserts Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

Wow just wow. Ice cream filled glazed donuts for the win! Great service, small shop with all handmade cookies, donuts, cake pops. Check it out! It you won't regret it read more

Shanna's Sugar Shack - Ice cream filled glazed doughnut - Desserts Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

Such a gem of a family-owned spot! I tried the Dubai chocolate waffle, and it was honestly one of the best sweet treats I've ever had--delicious! and made with so much care. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, and you can really feel the love that goes into what they do. If you're looking for the perfect way to treat yourself, this place is it! read more

Shanna's Sugar Shack has amazing treats! Cookies, Shakes, Ice Cream...you can't go wrong! Friendly local owned business in the Firehouse Plaza right behind Whiskey Row. read more

This place is sparkling clean. The service was great, polite and friendly. The ice cream was fantastic, so tasty. The price is good too. read more

Shanna's Sugar Shack - Interior of the sugar shack!! - Desserts Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

See all

Such a great place! My kiddos love the ice cream and I had the lemon bar since I'm lactose intolerant. Happy with all of the choices! The owner is absolutely wonderful, so the service was great. It's such a cute place , you must visit!! The baked goods are delicious! read more

Shanna's Sugar Shack - Ice cream & lemon bars - Desserts Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

We discover this little gem the other day. I gotta say that not many places in Prescott sell ice cream sandwiches like this. I've been living in Prescott for almost 5 years and we did not have anything like this until now. I can honestly say that this is a gem. The cookies and ice cream were so yummy! The price was fair for something like this. It's the also a cute little place. I would suggest coming here - from an ice cream lover & yes there a few things they can improve on: cookies could be a bit warm and maybe samples if possible read more

See all

We got the lemon bar with lemon cheesecake ice cream. There are so many tasty choices of ice cream and you can have an ice cream donut or cookie too! Great atmosphere. We will make this one of our top local choices. Another customer said the root beer floats are the best. read more

The owner's mother was the one running the shop while we were there and was so delightful and fun to talk to. Feels like a nice, family owned business. Really cute inside. The cookie sandwiches are huge and were so delicious. Two people can share one. So many options for flavors! This is going to be a place we hit up every time we are in town from now on! My sister went and loved their cookie dough. read more

Shanna's Sugar Shack - Ice cream cookie sandwich - Desserts Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

Cute place in Prescott! Took my girlfriend on a date here and we both really liked it! Haven't had a cookie ice cream sandwich in a while so this place really hit the spot. We both got two cookie ice cream sandwiches and the best part about them was the portion sizes. One sandwich can feed two people - two little kids for sure. They give you two huge cookies and two scoops of ice cream and you get to mix and match! And they had a large variety of flavors for both the ice cream and the cookies. I got the caramel toffee crunch ice cream with the M&M and oatmeal raisin cookies. Pretty good! Could the ice cream been a little more creamier? Yes a little. Could the cookies be a little warmer and soft? Also yes but I'm sure they can improve on that! Will definitely be back! read more

Loved this place! Really good ice cream and the shake that my wife got was really delicious. The only downside was that we couldn't sample the flavors first but in the end it didn't matter because they all looked really good. 5/5 would try again! read more

What a great gem on Whiskey Row in Prescott! I had a homemade lemon bar - amazing flavor, was moist and delicious! Hubby and kiddo both had ice cream which they thoroughly enjoyed. Lots of toppings available for ice cream and they custom make ice cream cookie sandwiches too! You gotta try this place! It's tucked away in a quaint lil courtyard but worth stopping by. read more

Best malt I've ever had! Really cute, colorful place with super sweet owner. Definitely coming back!

I searched Yelp for a sweet treat in Prescott AZ and found Shanna's Sugar Shack. The reviews had me at "ice cream sandwich ". The Monster Ice Cream Sandwich was big enough to share, but they looked so good, we couldn't resist each getting our own. So good!! Our server was super friendly and helpful. We sat outside in the courtyard and had a wonderful evening. read more

Shanna's Sugar Shack - Monster Ice Crean Sandwiches - Desserts Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

All I can say is my sweet tooth was in absolute heaven!!! Super cute decor and easy to read menu.. they also serve my favorite brand of ice cream! The lady behind the counter was helpful when it came time to narrowing down what I wanted lol. read more

Sparkling clean, super yummy and huge portions. You can taste the quality and the prices were very reasonable for such a cute and prime location. Would 100% go again! read more

I wish we stopped to take a photo of the sunday, but we were too excited to eat it. They have several homemade cookie choices as your sunday base, 2 scoops of their deliciousice cream, sauce options and toppings! Wow!! My son got the root beer float and I got the triple chocolate brownie! I'm a chocolate LOVER and it's the best brownie I've ever had. They have donut stuffed icecream options as well. We highly recommend this ice cream shop! read more

The ice cream donut was SO amazing!!! All the flavors looked so good, came here 2x in 2 days and will definitely be back for more before we leave Prescott! Definitely stop by this place if you're in the area ! :) read more

Amazing treats, great prices, and amazing owner. A great shop for everyone. The owner was very kind and gave amazing recommendations.

Shakes and cookies are fabulous. A favorite place for my grandson. This is his review he insisted on posting.

Such a fun find! Long line because it is so yummy! Great options of cookies, ice cream, shakes, and cookie dough. Hard to find, better signage would be helpful read more

I would absolutely recommend stopping in! Shanna was super helpful and kind and the ambiance was great! There are a ton of great options to choose from, we got the edible chocolate chip cookie dough and a sugar cookie, both were delicious! read more

Do not come here, the ice cream was subpar. Never will I get ice cream from this place ever again, just go to limoncello to get gelato instead.... Atleast they know how to run a business!!!! read more