I gave the same number of stars as previous reviews however I have not tried the baked goods....yet. I just wanted to inform everyone that this is not a store front. This is a business run from the owners home. You can not just stop by to check out or sample. The address is for the picking up of previously placed orders only. I sadly drove out there to satisfy my sweet tooth and found this information out. I will update my review to include my take on the desserts as soon as we have an occasion to order. read more

Amy's cakes are fabulous and so delicious. First off, Amy was so kind to have my cake ready on such short notice. Communication, kindness, and extra effort was top notch. Now, on to the cake. It was so fresh, delicious, the best carrot cake I have ever had. Loved every bite. Made our birthday celebration fantastic, thanks to Amy. Can't wait for our next celebration so I can try more yummy cakes! read more

Amy's Cottage Bakery - Amy's carrot cake. Made with cream cheese frosting and toasted pecans!!! - Bakeries Near Me

Our family ordered our son's 15th birthday cake (Chocolate with Vanilla Frosting) from Amy, and we were absolutely blown away by how amazing it was! This lady knows what she's doing. The frosting was delicious but not too sweet, the cake was rich and dense. It was even better a day or two later as it quickly disappeared. Amy herself is extremely personable and we will not hesitate to drive up from SD to get her wonderfully baked goods in the future! read more

Amy's Cottage Bakery - Cross Section of Chocolate Cake we ordered from the Wonderful Amy! - Bakeries Near Me

See all

First and foremost, Amy is a national treasure and I will fight Nicolas Cage to the death to keep her safe if I have to. So, keep away, Nic. Now, onto the experience. I ordered a cake for a Friend's bday, and like the occasional train wreck I am, I waited too late to order it for the actual day. That said, Amy could not have been more helpful (I mean that as literally as possible) or kind during the ordering process. She is so sweet and endearing, that the fact that her cake was, and I quote: Holy. Crap. DELICIOUS A+!!!!! The whip cream is PERFECT makes her the cherry on her perfect whipped cream. I would like to note here that my Friend is also a professional baker, and has been for many, many years. So, this praise is from someone who KNOWS. I sadly did not get to enjoy the cake, but will be remedying the situation next month for another Friends bday celebration, which will thankfully be in my home. I'm really looking forward to eating my way through her menu. Thank you for existing and being exactly who you are, Amy. You're magical! read more

Amy's Cottage Bakery - Strawberries & Cream Cake - Bakeries Near Me

We ordered the Ding Dong cake for my boyfriend's sons 30-something birthday. It was a major hit. The cake was delicious and just chocolat-ie enough! Pair it with ice cream or a huge glass of milk and you will be in heaven. Amy was very accommodating and pleasant. Absolutely no issues on my end!! read more

Great experience! We were vacationing in LA for my dad's 70th birthday and I contacted Amy for a cake for his special day. She was very professional, responsive, and even delivered to our hotel! Delicious, moist cake and I couldn't be happier with this shop. read more

Amy's Cottage Bakery - Birthday Cake - Bakeries Near Me

Amy's Bakery is great! I texted her telling her exactly what I needed and she was super sweet, professional, and walked me through her process. She had the cake done right on time and it was very convenient to pick it up! I got the ding dong cake for my mom because my mom loves chocolate. Presentation was very nicely done, and the taste was even better! It was moist, chocolatey, and sweet. We've also had her banana cream pie for my dad's birthday and it was very good as well! I'm very excited for her to bake my families cakes in the future. If you're thinking of ordering a cake with Amy, don't hesitate and try her out. You won't regret it. read more

Came in from San Antonio contacted Amy about having a pineapple upside down cake ready for pick up once we arrived. She was awesome with communication and made a delicious Pineapple upside down cake! Would totally recommend read more

See all

Beet chocolate cake ever. The smell is amazing. I wanted butterscotch frosting and it was perfect. Very subtle and balanced. Not too sweet. And the smell was just...unbelievable! Amy gave me so many options it was great. I will be back for more. :) read more

Just had the butter cookies (raspberry). I cannot believe these tasty treats. Soft, just sweet enough, perfectly filled with raspberry and so different from anything I've ever had. I bought a bag of four and ate them all. No stomach ache, no heaviness, just a satisfying soft delicious cookie. I must order more. Highly recommend. read more

What a wonderful cake Amy baked for us: a gluten-free hummingbird cake. The hummingbird cake is my wife's favorite cake of all time, and we have a daughter with gluten allergies. So, we've never tried this combo, and Amy just knocked it out of the park. Wonderful texture, great frosting,; it really made my wife's birthday so special. Plus, she was kind enough to have it ready in about 24 hours, and even brought it out to our car. We will be going back often to her cottage bakery. Many thanks, Amy! read more

If you are looking for pies!! Look no further. I ordered two pies from Amy.. key lime pie and blueberry both were exceptional. I will be ordering more soon I wish I had photos to post but everyone ate them so fast read more

What an absolute gem of a business! Our gluten-free daughter was arriving the next day for a birthday visit and I realized I didn't have time (or the energy) to make a cake. I reached out to Amy and she made her coconut cake gluten free and it was ready for pick up the next day. I couldn't believe it! Plus it was the most delicious, wonderful, beautiful cake! Our daughter was so touched. We all were. Thank you, Amy! read more

Amy's Cottage Bakery - Gluten-free coconut cake -- delicious! - Bakeries Near Me

All I can say Omg the Best!! So happy I found you! We can't wait to try more! Yummy Thank you again Amy read more

See all

I found Amy on Yelp when searching for the best chocolate cake for my mom's 70th birthday and I and so thrilled we chose her. I ended up getting the Chocolate Peanut Butter Cloud cake (chocolate with peanut butter cups since that is my mom's fave) and she said it was the best cake she has ever tasted - which says a lot because my mom is a connoisseur of fine cakes! I added a dozen chocolate peanut butter cloud cupcakes as well to make sure we had some leftovers. The presentation and professionalism Amy displayed was top notch and her talents as a baker speak for themselves. The cake was not overly sweet as some can be, texture and icing was delish, and overall everyone was very pleased. We will be ordering from her again! read more

Amy's Cottage Bakery - Bakeries Near Me

See all

I have to start with an apology that I didn't take a photo before this amazing Pecan Pie was devoured by my family. I was in search for the "best" pecan pie in the Los Angeles area and Amy came up in the Yelp search. I am bias because I am from Texas and Homemade Pecan Pie is a staple where I'm from. Amy did not disappoint! A pleasure to talk to and very warm and friendly when I picked it up. The only sad part was I only was able to enjoy 1 small piece because the family took the rest. Amy, you were a Hit! Thanks again read more

The short of it is that the cake Amy baked is the best I have ever had and I cannot stop thinking about it. I considered making a picture of it my phone wallpaper but I don't need to fuel the obsession further. I asked if Amy would make a German chocolate cake though it isn't one of her usual offerings. She graciously agreed and I am so glad she did. The buttery coconut topping tasted like high end butterscotch candies and the chocolate cake was the perfect complement to the topping because it wasn't too sweet. Sometimes that's the trouble with German chocolate cake... it's tooth achingly / brain chillingly cloying. The texture of the whole thing and the proportion of cake to topping were fantastic, too. This cake was for a birthday but I am debating getting another one just because. read more

Ordered a cake for my bonus son's bday and it was delicious!! I ordered the 9" ding dong flavor and it was a hit!!!! I highly recommend read more

Amy personally bakes every delight. Make sure to call about a day ahead so she can make you what you need. She put together a gorgeous and delicious 10" pumpkin cheesecake for one of my employees. Communication was easy, product was ready for pick up as promised. read more

My husband and I have an elderly neighbor who has always been so kind to us. One day he mentioned that he was craving "one of those old fashioned pineapple upside down cakes." I quickly considered and dismissed the idea of making it myself. Next I looked around at some area bakeries but no one had pineapple upside down cake. Finally I searched Yelp, and success - Amy's Cottage Bakery popped up for me! I called her on Thursday to place an order and it was ready the next day on Friday. My neighbor was thrilled and loved it! Amy texted me today to see how my neighbor liked the cake. Great service and good vibes. Thanks again Amy! We'll definitely see you again. read more

A perfect Pineapple Upside Down Cake! Amy is now my go-to baker. I highly recommend this bakery...

I meant to take a picture of the cheesecake and the chocolate cake but was too busy with birthday preparations.The family had excellent comments about both cakes.I liked the cheesecake best.Amy was easy to do business with.You won't be disappointed. read more

I ordered an apple pie from Amy and it was amazing. We usually buy our pies from Republic of Pies or Susie Cakes but they had none available. I'm glad that happened because I would not have found Amy's Cottage. Best believe I'll be ordering from her from now on. Thank you again Amy!!! read more

The desserts are really delicious. You must check it out. If you're in the Burbank neighborhood or community, please drop by you will not regret it. read more

Wanted to have a specific pie made for a special someone. The pie was impossible to find at bakeries and then bam Amy to the rescue! Amy was so positive, cheerful and happy to give this new england chaos pie a spin and she did wonderfully! Communication and pricing was great and Amy was so flexible and easy to work with. The pie was ever so tasty and craftfully made, I mean just look at that gorgeous pie pic ! It didn't hurt that I earned lots of brownie points with the gift so many thanks to Miss Amy for making it happen I will very happily commission her for future work and highly recommend that you do too! read more

See all

Doing business with Amy was a great experience, and the cake she prepared fully met expectations! I really appreciated the quick turnaround with only a couple days' notice--as well as her openness to addressing my specific requests. The cake was perfect, and Amy is personable and professional! read more

Amy's Cottage Bakery - Cake - Bakeries Near Me

See all

Wow what a lifesaver! I recently got a coconut cream pie from Amy for my fiend's birthday. It did not disappoint! Perfectly balanced flavors. I do suggest if you are wanting one of her delicious treats, that you please place an order in advance because Amy makes them fresh from scratch! I cant wait to try another creation soon. Here are some photos of the outside. We forgot to take pics of the inside because we were distracted with stuffing our face with deliciousness :) read more

Amy's Cottage Bakery - Coconut Cream Pie - Bakeries Near Me

See all

The carrot cake Amy baked for my girls birthday was amazing! Probably the best carrot cake we have had in LA in a long time. Easy to order, easy to pick up! I highly recommend Amy's cakes and will order again. read more

Amy's Cottage Bakery - Delicious carrot cake - Bakeries Near Me

It's my husband's birthday. And I needed just the right pie to celebrate. See, we're pie fiends. We've tried pies all over the country, but Key Lime pie really does it for us. The usual places were either still closed because of Covid, or required a two-day minimum for orders. So, I hit Yelp for "Best Key Lime Pie" and up came Amy's Cottage Bakery. She's pretty close by, and was totally willing to help a fiend out. We ate the pie for breakfast, then some of her sinful raspberry and dolce de leche light-as-air butter cookies she kindly threw in for lunch. We immediately deemed Amy's Key Lime as the Emperor of Pies. The pie was fluffy, gorgeous, just the right amount of sweet and tart with a crust you'd knock over a liquor store for. Amy's entire menu is totally insane. Cakes, Pies, Cookies. We'll both be starring on the My 600 Lb. Life by Christmas. We love you, Amy. You're darling, kind and the best baker in LA. Everything anyone could ever want in a sugar dealer. read more

I found Amy on yelp and have been looking for a good carrot cake for my partner's bday. Amy's carrot cake didn't disappoint. So far the best I've had in LA! I live in Sherman Oaks, so it was a bit of a drive, especially midday, but I'd do the drive again since it was super yummy. The cake received multiple compliments, even from the non-carrot cake lovers. Thanks Amy! read more

Amy's Cottage Bakery - Carrot cake with pecans - Bakeries Near Me

The best Pineapple Upside Down cake!!! Soo moist and delicious. Not to mention the great service. I had a VERY last minute request and Amy's Cottage Bakery was able to make it happen. Great communication as well. I knew once I read her reviews it was worth the 45 minute drive one way. Definitely will be a repeat customer. Thank you Amy's Cottage Bakery read more

Amy's Cottage Bakery - Pineapple Upside Down Cake - Bakeries Near Me

Great stuff! The Suzy Q's/Whoopie pies were Devine. Fun birthday surprise. She was timely & very professional.

Excellent pies! Amy is very professional & sweet. Excellent banana cream pie -- very fresh and light -- . We give it a thumbs up read more

Finally had a chance to order Amy's Pineapple upside down cake and Nutella Banana twirl muffins to bring to a gathering of relatives who have high standards when it comes to baked goods. They all love what Amy made and I know they are not just being polite because these people are the kind of people who are not shy about speaking their minds. Added bonus is with Amy being nice enough about accommodating me when I run more than half an hour late when picking up the goodies read more

I ordered a strawberry lemonade cake and wow, was I impressed. Not only was it gorgeous, it was divine! Amy was super communicative about everything, even down to meeting me at my car with the stunning cake. Next time I need a cake, I'll go to Amy. Plus, I love supporting small women-owned businesses. read more

I tasted Amy's cookies at an event my friend was hosting. They are addictive! I wish I could buy they somewhere close to home - we live in Ventura read more

My daughter was kind enough to go to the trouble of finding a fresh boysenberry pie [my favorite] for my birthday. Amy came to the rescue, and it was just delightful! I can't even imagine where she found the berries, and they were sweet and plump. Thank you Amy for offering a wonderful product! read more

We ordered a pineapple upside down cake last minute and she squeezed us in and it did not disappoint!!!! Moist and delicious land can't wait to try other things. read more

The Coconut Cake was delicious! Everyone at our party commented on how great it was and I appreciated how swift Amy was in her communication as I ordered so last minute. I know that's not always a realistic possibility but I appreciated her being able to make it work. Pick up was also so easy and overall I'm just really happy. I can't wait to order pies and other things in the future read more

Good food pricey and not convenient I think she works out of her house Very nice and cooperative however read more