Cancel

Open app

Search

Secatogue Brewing

4.3 (49 reviews)
ModerateBreweries
Closed Closed
Updated 3 months ago

Secatogue Brewing Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Secatogue Brewing

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Only beers left on tap...but they're pretty solid!
Josh G.

Grow up on Long Island? Used to hearing and reciting interesting names for different places (ya know, like Patchogue and Ronkonkoma)? Well then maybe you're like me in that when you hear/heard the name Secatogue Brewing, you probably started to say "where out east is that town?" What you really should be asking is how can I get there to have some of their solid brews. I've visited twice (two slightly different experiences) that encompassed an easy four stars with potential for more. Okay, let's drop the name game and let you know Secatogue may sound like a village you can visit on LI, but it's actually located in West Islip. Taking roots from the rich Native American history of the area brings us this name along with a quality location for craft beer. You know Secatogue put some time (and money) into their brew spot when it encompasses a whole building. With a food truck, tap room, seating inside and out (with great style I might add), and their own parking lot, Secatogue starts off on a superb aesthetic note. What didn't jive so nicely the first time I visited was their lack of...well, beer. It had only been a few days/weeks since their opening and so what was initially brewed had mostly come and gone leaving only a handful of beers to choose from on a board that looked like it could hold so much more. In a way, this could be viewed as a big-picture positive in that their beer went so quick because people were loving it. For me, it was a mild letdown in the moment. I did sample what they had (Floral Incandescent Porpoises, a DDH NEIPA was their only semi-standout), though nothing entirely blew me away. Then came round two, a few weeks later (on Father's Day to be exact). Here's where the suds situation started to right itself. A fresh tap list filled their board (well, 9/10 slots, 8 being their own). A wheat ale, a blonde, enough IPA varieties to cover your mouth in bitter goodness for a week, and an aptly named Irish stout (The Darkest One We Have). That last brew mentioned was probably one of the better dry stouts I've sampled and may have been my favorite of the afternoon (along with the super subtle yet fruity The Grasshopper Lies Heavy and the Imperial DDH NEIPA Lengthy Island). The only downer was Keep Off The Dunes, a pale wheat that did nothing for my tastebuds in any satisfaction. Even with this one clunker, the rest of the selection made up for that first round of minimal options. Overall, Secatogue Brewing is a formidable new brewery for this lengthy island (I do like to say that so don't anyone think I stole the saying!). With a mostly memorable beer selection along with a happening tap room and a nice feeling of local love, I'm positive Secatogue will only grow as a brewery worth visiting when beer hopping around the island. It will also do well in continuing to confuse beer-goers as to just where it is and how to say it. But hey, if you're not from Long Island, it's fun to watch.

Tiara B.

This is my favorite brewery on Long Island hands down! The staff and owners are really nice and the beers are great. The beer names are always cool and they have a lot of beers on tap. They collaborate with other breweries sometimes and you'll see those beers on the list as well. The beers can be ordered in different size options from a 4 ounce taste, 8 ounce and a 16oz. The prices are all up on the beer list board. The brewery itself is nice and has a great vibe. There's always a food truck as well.

Joanna K.

Drink Local! we happened to be able to come in opening weekend, beautiful place, friendly people, owners and atmosphere, and they have a food truck!!! This place I would describe as a chill, chic and relaxed brewery! The outside is just as cool as the inside! The beers are even better! Never even tasted anything like them! I personally love floral incandescent purposes which is a DDH NEIPA. Below is what's currently on tap weekend of 5/10-5/12! Come down and enjoy you won't regret it!

Brianne S.

New Brew Review!! So, I finally got to check out Secatogue Brewing and let me tell you, it did not disappoint in any way! First off, the building is gorgeous and the outside area is filled with tons of plants which really makes looking at the road a little more appealing. The inside is equally as nice; super clean, with a simple but comfortable look. There's plenty of seating both inside and a couple of tables in the brew room. On a Sunday it was mostly families but if you've got a baby in diapers, keep in mind there aren't changing tables in the bathrooms. It got a little busy by the time we left and never once did I feel cramped. They have 10 beers on tap, mostly IPA's which we liked but there were also other styles available. The IPA's also ranged from DDH DIPA to fruity so naturally I had to get a flight and try as many as I could. I didn't have one beer that I did not like. We went on a Sunday so there was a food truck there serving up some delicious eats. I'm not sure how often they have food trucks but probably on the weekends. I was so happy I was able to make my way here and already told my friends we have to go back! Keep up the good work Secatogue!

THIS WALL
Diana M.

So this past Saturday I was looking to see if I could find a brewery close to me that I haven't hit up yet, which I though was impossible, Turns out Google referred me to this gem that opened up this Spring. I have to say, the venue is very impressive, inside and out. All brand new, white and clean, with South Beach Miami vibes. I couldn't resist taking a picture against the palm tree wallpaper wall. The beer was delicious, my favorite being "King of the Sea" their summer ale. They also had a banging food truck outside that day (they rotate trucks and post the truck of the day on their insta, this day happened to be "Concrete Jungle"). They don't allow any outside food but do allow the food truck food inside, which was totally fine because Concrete Jungle brought it with the flavor. Can't wait to come back for more. Good luck guys!

When man has been given the gift of flight.
Michael S.

Love the look of the place, friendly staff. Beer was real good. Did a flight all were good. Will try the food truck next time. Definitely will go back and try other beers. Ciao for now.

Trying out their very first bingo night!
Kaylin P.

This brewery is super cool. Great beers and atmosphere. They always have a food truck on deck which comes in handy. If you live in the area or are just looking for the next move, come check it out!

Gotta get the glassware!
Jude R.

Absolutely love this place. Some of the best beer I have ever tasted. Their dark beers are excellent. They are always friendly in the brewery and have the outdoor seating available now. Heading over tonight for the first time in a while, can't wait for a Darkest One we Had and an Agave Trigo. Loved the Cherry Emoji, but my favorite is Lei'd Up! Hope they brew that again soon.

Secatogue Future Flavors: The chocolate flavor is just right.

See all

6 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0
Photo of Dr C.
0
38
7

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Grew up in West Islip. Loved visiting this brewery and cannot wait to come back! Me and my husband loved the Swell Taco truck and the beer.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Secatogue Brewing

Review Highlights - Secatogue Brewing

As far as their place on the grand stage of LI breweries, they've yet to land that signature beer.

Mentioned in 4 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Post Office Cafe - Freshly made, fully enjoyed.

Post Office Cafe

3.9(568 reviews)
1.4 mi
$$
Full bar
Takes reservations

Cute for lunch with good food! Came with my friend, we walked right in with no wait on a Saturday…read more I also had my son and they were very accommodating. I've only ever been here at night when out bar hoping in the area, so this was nice to come during the day and enjoy the restaurant itself!

Post Office Cafe is a classic stop in Babylon Village that I often forget. We were in town trying…read moreto get 3 teens and myself to agree on a place to eat. Pizza? Nah - the boys just ate that. Chinese or Asian fusion? We just had that the other day. Diner? Nah. My daughter remembered Post Office Cafe and we went. It was very loud in the front and we almost walked out but figured we'd give it a try. They seated us way in the back (I had no idea this place was so huge!) where it was quieter. I ordered a chicken salad of some kind with avocado and salad. My son ordered the mac and cheese - it was the highlight of dinner! Absolutely delicious. His friend got the Thai calamari which was decent until he got to the bottom. It was soaked in seasoning and too sweet. My daughter got the buttered pasta - children's portion. I'll let the photo speak for itself. It was drenched in butter. On the bright side - service was great, most of the meals were excellent, waffle fries on point. I mentioned the pasta and showed our server the pool of butter. He took it off our bill without even asking. So ... 4 stars - 5 stars for local business service and just lost the one star for the less than stellar meal and app. Will probably be back!

Photos
Post Office Cafe - The building's architecture, with its well-maintained exterior and vintage signage, pays homage to its former life as a bustling post office

The building's architecture, with its well-maintained exterior and vintage signage, pays homage to its former life as a bustling post office

Post Office Cafe - $10 Wings - Choice of Boneless or Regular available throughout the  2025 - 2026 NFL season.

$10 Wings - Choice of Boneless or Regular available throughout the 2025 - 2026 NFL season.

Post Office Cafe - Made fresh. Poured perfect.

See all

Made fresh. Poured perfect.

Secatogue Brewing - breweries - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...