We literally had to plan in advance when to get this pizza. Like we ordered it a whole day in…read moreadvance to pick up at 5:30 PM the following day because it's such a popular place right now. Even before the barstool review this has been on my list to try just from the tons of positive Google reviews. The people that complain about the wait time are missing the point - it's that popular and in demand and a small pizza shop. If you have any ounce of patience, use it and order ahead so you can try it. It's on the expensive side. All said, it's still well worth it. The pizzas are huge and very authentic New York. Hamilton county has tons of pizza places with brick oven doughy crust, but not like this New York style one. It's crusty and thin, but not doughy. Super airy and flakey - by the time you get to the last bite of the crust it's honestly messy and crumbs are everywhere. You could scrape the bottom of the pizza and hear that crackle.The tomato sauce seemed like true tomatoes, not a sauce with a bunch of additions. The Parmesan on top gave it some saltiness too. We had onions, sausage, and pepperoni toppings - they don't overload them, it's like the right amount to be able to appreciate the pizza as a stand alone and the toppings. It's locally owned too and from the interviews I've seen, you can tell they just care about making great pizza and keeping it as simple as that. Overall, I'm impressed. I'd recommend if you're a foodie and appreciate good food.

Brooklyn Style Pizza - can't say that I've ever had a Brooklyn style pizza...until now!…read more Apparently a Brooklyn Style Pizza is characterized by a thin and crispy crust. Crust edges are "sturdy" so it's foldable and the toppings don't fall off. Slices are cut so each is very large - to fold of course. The volume of toppings are "balanced" to not dominate the taste nor appearance. The sauce is designed to be more tangy and less sweet. Lots of fresh mozzarella cheese to pull everything together! This Sweet Pig pizza was delicious! The sweetness comes from a honey drizzle. It is aided by the sweet fig jam. Applewood bacon provides the "pig" flavors. There aren't many other toppings by design. The pizza has a nice bed of mozzarella with dollops of ricotta cheese. The crust is almost wafer thin and crispy - if you like that. I ate my slices straight up without folding them. Overall...a Brooklyn style Sweet Pig pizza was really good! The cheese sticks were outstanding. A thick stick with a slight buttery-garlic baste. It's baked to a slight crisp. The inside is stuffed with deliciously stretchy mozzarella cheese. The garlic knots are very similar. Just smaller and no cheese filling.

Consistently good. Love the crust on their pizzas. My favorite pizza place. Their friendly staff…read morealways answer the phone with a smile.

Good little pizza place ! Tried it for the first time today and my order was right on time. The…read morepizza is super thin and crispy (option to order it that way) if that's what you like. Order the wings too and it was all so yummy!

Think it is safe to say this is the best bier garden for activities! The space is huge and has…read moreeverything from a playground to a dog park. The kid playground and sand tires were perfect for my toddler. I will come back again and again just for having this available for families. Both of the fruit beers were out today so I didn't try any. My husband had 3 different ones and said they were fine. He said out of all the breweries around he would never recommend this one specifically for beer, but would for their space. We also did the jerk chicken pizza and the queso with chips. I like the unique pizza offers. Such a great set up!

I like that you don't have a server so you can hang out as long as you want. The wings are big and…read morejuicy! The cheese curds aren't heavily breaded which I also appreciate. Lots of beer options, and flights unless it is a busy time. They had live singing the last time I was there which was a nice add to the evening!

What an excellent local pizza place! The breadsticks are absolutely addictive. I'm a breadstick…read moreconnoisseur and here are some of the best I have found anywhere. Pizza is delicious too. The toppings are really piled on, with a generous amount of cheese. No skimpy pizzas here. Service was very friendly. This place does a huge amount of business but they manage to get the pizzas out at the quoted times. Highly recommend stopping by when you are in the area. Actually it is worth a road trip too.

I had some free time on a Sunday, close to noon, and drove from Westfield to Cicero to check out…read moreBronko's. From the Yelp photos I've seen, this seemed like my kind of place. Service and ambiance were both fantastic. I was one of the first customers of the day, and I dined-in. My server was delightful and attentive. There are a very small number of tables and booths available, but that's perfectly fine for a small-town pizza joint. As much as it pains me to say this, I found the pizza to be underwhelming. I was a bit surprised at the overall lack of bold flavors. The price point is great, and you get a lot of pizza for the dollar, but I was expecting much more of a flavor explosion. I had high hopes, because visually this pizza closely resembles my hometown favorite pizza as a kid (Volcano Pizza in Elkhart), but it just didn't live up to the expectations. I'm sure I'll give this place another try at some point, and maybe experiment with some other pizza combinations on the menu.

Visited Colosseo Pizzeria for the first time. The atmosphere is very casual. There were only seven…read moredining tables, or seating for about 30. A very small dining area. The menu consists of Antipasti, pasta, salads, and pizza. They also have desserts of tiramisu, cannelloni and cheesecake. We ordered the Amanti Della Carne pizza. It consisted of mozzarella, pepperoni, homemade sausage, signature, tomato sauce, ham, and mortadella. All pizzas are 12 inch and thin crust. Our pizza was $17. We also ordered the spring salad for $7. It consisted of spring mix, tomatoes, and homemade balsamic vinaigrette. The spring salad was good. The lettuce was fresh and nicely seasoned with the dressing. We really liked the homemade balsamic dressing. The pizza was very good and had a lot of toppings. As mentioned there is no variety or choice of size. The pizza only comes in a 12 inch, which was eight slices. Also, there is no choice of crust thickness. It is all a reasonably thin crust. Not a cracker thin crust, but thinner than most pizzas. We really liked it. The table next to us ordered pasta. They said it was delicious. They asked our server if the pasta was made fresh in the house. The server replied that it was. Service was very good, friendly, and prompt. It appears they do a big takeout business as while we were dining we saw several people come in and pick up pizzas to go. We recommend if you were in the area

Ordered from here a while back. Originally tried it after seeing their pictures on social media and…read moreit looked great. I went super basic and just got a cheese pizza, as I am a pretty basic eater. When I walked in, I was greeted happily and they were super helpful. I took the pizza to go, but there was plenty of nice seating inside. The pizza was cooked very well. Crispy but not too crispy. The sauce tasted great. All in all, I thought this was a very solid option for true pizza in Fishers and hope this place does great!

While I haven't had anything but the brunch pizza (available Sat-Sun), I love Pies & Pints! The…read morebrunch pizza is so so good! I could eat it every weekend. Pickup is always so quick and the service is friendly!

This place is cool. I loved the window into the kitchen where you can see the pizza spinning…read more In addition to pies and pints, they do also have a good variety of sandwiches, salads, and desserts. I went with the Cuban pulled pork sandwich. It was good, it just wasn't at all what I was expecting. I loved the fresh jalapeños in the sandwich. I was also surprised by the pizza skins appetizer. I was expecting a potato skins-type dish but it was actually a potato skins flavored pizza. It was really good and came with the biggest gloop of sour cream I've ever seen. My brother had the draft root beer and said it tasted exactly like those root beer barrel candies. I liked the option to upgrade to a salad instead of chips. It was super fresh and nicely dressed. They had a pineapple upside down cake pizza on special we didn't get a chance to try, but it sounded so good. Our server was friendly and checked on us often.

After an afternoon of shopping, I decided to stop by Greeks for a pizza. The restaurant was clean…read moreand welcoming as soon as I walked in. I was greeted by Wyatt, who was friendly and helpful while taking my order. The prep time was quick, which was a nice bonus. I ordered a supreme pizza along with garlic sticks, and both were fantastic. The garlic sticks were loaded with buttery, garlicky flavor, and the pizza was absolutely delicious, fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. Greeks has always been one of my favorite pizza places, and this visit definitely reminded me why. Great service, great food, and a consistently solid experience. Of course I'll be returning!

Always consistently good pizza that's prepared fast. The ingredients always taste fresh and…read moreflavorful and the staff are friendly and helpful. The last time we picked up pizza I'd already paid online but they charged my husband when he came in, so hopefully they work out that kink but otherwise, no complaints.

I have already reviewed their incredible pizzas with flying colors…read more Yesterday I was extremely happy with my choice to try the Tuesday special which was wonderful!! The steak pappardella pasta is a real delight. Broad flat egg noodles in a rich creamy sauce with mushrooms and topped with sliced medium steak. Bonus.....Tuesday is half priced wine! Topped it off with espresso martinis was another bonus. You will love it. Sam the owner is a great guy.

I grabbed lunch with a friend and we both really enjoyed our meal! We started with the bruschetta,…read moreshared a salad and the Angelita pizza. For dessert we shared the mille-feuille. Overall, every thing was really delicious. Service was quick and friendly. I look forward to coming back and trying more items!

Ordering though app has very good deals. Pizza is very good and management is great. Bread more

We were driving up the road. We saw Marcos Pizza and turned around and went in. We ordered a pizza…read moreand bread sticks. I have to limit my meat type, so we ordered ground beef on one side. The other side was sausage and pepperoni. They got it right. It was delicious. We really enjoyed the pizza. We took the pizza home and had it there. They do have eat in if you want it. It was wonderful.

Crafters pizza and Drafthouse is outstanding…read more We like to order pick up from this place and when you get there, it's always ready. The staff is friendly and helps you get your order quickly. The orders are always right and everything is as it should be and it's a great value for the money

I've had two recent experiences here that have been rather disappointing. In our group of six…read moreseveral were not happy with the food and we all thought the service was poor. Three members of our group ordered Chicken Alfredo, and all said that it was very dry with so little sauce that it looked like no sauce at all. Two requested extra sauce from our server and one just didn't eat hers at all. It took quite some time for someone from the kitchen to bring the extra sauce, by which time the others had finished eating. They were all charged for the extra sauce, even though it had been missing from their entrées. The server hadn't checked back with us or offered refills. Two in our group ordered salads, and they were happy with them. I observed two employees sitting on a bench, having a conversation while it appeared that tables needed to be bussed and cleaned. We waited a long time for our server to bring our checks, and then longer for our payments to be taken. I also had a recent experience with a carry out order where some of the items I had ordered were missing when I picked up the food, even though I had been charged for them. I was picking up an order to take to work so I didn't have time to return and pick up the items missing from the order. Crafters has a great atmosphere but improvement is needed in both food and service.