Sanibel's has great seafood in a variety of different styles and different cooking methods. We love the food, the atmosphere, the staff, the menu options, the friendly service staff and everything else that we have experienced so far. We have been loyal customers for many years now and they have never let us down. The prices are about the same as other restaurants that serve the same type of food. Always delicious and we always leave with full bellies for their portions of food are very generous. 5*'s ALL THE WAY!! We HIGHLY recommend Sanibel's in High Point, North Carolina!! If you've never been to Sanibel's, you're missing out!! So just GO & enjoy!! You won't be disappointed! read more

Good ol Carolina calabash fried seafood at its best. This place has been around since the early 90's. The service is always great and then restaurant is iconic. The restaurant is clean and makes you go back in time. read more

See all

We were very pleased with our most recent visit on Friday, January 23. Sanibel's must have some new cooks because the food was on point. Everything came out hot and fresh and was cooked as requested. The service was prompt and efficient and the restaurant which is always clean has remained at that standard! read more

Sanibel's - Small combo Popcorn Shrimp & Flounder - Seafood Near Me - High Point, North Carolina

See all

The food is always good and fresh. Sometimes the food is overcooked. The service is great. You don't have to wait home. The atmosphere is good good waitresses, and very safe. read more

Sanibel's Seafood: Disappointing Experience After Three Years I hadn't been to Sanibel's Seafood in three years, but my husband and I were in the mood for seafood and decided to give them another shot. Unfortunately, our experience this time was disappointing, and I feel compelled to share the issues we encountered to help others make an informed decision. We placed our order right when they opened at 3:00 PM and were told it would be ready in 15 minutes. My husband arrived to pick up the food at 3:15 PM, but he was informed that the order was not ready yet. He didn't receive our food until 3:30 PM, which made us expect it to be hot and fresh, especially considering they had just opened. However, as soon as we unpacked our meal at home, I noticed it was only lukewarm at best. Initially, I thought it might have been the condiments cooling things down, but after touching various parts of the meal, I realized everything was barely warm. For a $31.92 takeout order, cold food was the last thing we expected, especially right after they opened. When my husband called the restaurant to address this, we encountered customer service that only added to our frustration. The woman on the phone repeatedly referred to us as "honey," which felt dismissive and unprofessional. She informed us that if we returned the uneaten food, they might "possibly" replace it--an offer that felt more like an inconvenience than an apology. In my experience with other takeout establishments, if there's an issue, the manager usually assures you that they'll make it right, even if it means taking your information for a future replacement. But at Sanibel's, they refused to let me speak with a manager, and the response we got was, "I just work here." Not only did they fail to make it right, but the dismissive attitude made it clear that customer satisfaction wasn't a priority. In addition to the lack of customer service, the restaurant's setup adds to the inconvenience. The parking lot is small and difficult to navigate, especially during busy hours. The inside pickup area is also very compact, and although they do try to get customers in and out quickly, it doesn't leave much space or comfort while you wait. Despite the limited number of people there, the experience felt rushed, and we were left with an impression that efficiency mattered more than service. I understand the challenges of inflation and increased costs, but when you're paying nearly $32 for a takeout order, you expect hot, fresh food and courteous customer service. It's not always practical for everyone to immediately return to the restaurant, and many customers might not have a way to reheat their meal at home. That "just microwave it" approach is unacceptable when ordering food meant to be eaten hot and fresh. Sanibel's missed the mark not only in the quality of our meal but in how they handled our concern, and their reluctance to stand behind their product is disappointing. I had hoped that Sanibel's might still be the great restaurant I remembered, but this experience proved otherwise. I won't be returning, and I'd caution anyone considering Sanibel's to weigh these factors before spending hard-earned money here. read more

See all

service from the waiter was fine...issue was the size of the oysters...please advise the customer of how small they are before ordering....not to mention the manager was completely nonchalant and said I don't know what I should ... and I nicely replied don't worry I'll take my money somewhere else and not return here. read more

Sanibel's - My key fob to show just how small it was - Seafood Near Me - High Point, North Carolina

See all

NC fried seafood is a must have. The staff here is always nice southern roots, you have to love it. Let's get straight to it, seafood platter me. All the food here is delicious. I go for the flounder, popcorn shrimp and scallops. It was cooked to perfection and came quickly. If you're local you already know, and for anyone visiting you need to know. read more

See all

no wonder it's got such low reviews. Have you seen how nasty the owner treats customers? I just got out of the hospital and wanted a healthy meal so broiled salmon is good for you. But the food was raw ( I guess because when I called five minutes after picking it up and telling them about it, the woman on the phone said the store is closed now but the manager will replace it or refund you just bring it back tomorrow, so I did! That owner yelled at me and accused me of lying and (it was a very small portion to start out with) snd said I ate most of it and it had not been touched!She screamed for me to leave and I left my take out box there! I paid $20 for some coke slaw and 2 hush puppies! She must be desperate for money because I feel like she stole from me! I am an elderly woman living on a fixed income and it's sad she took advantage of me! I would not support this business ever again! I thought she might want to keep me and 12 of my family and friends as customers but I was treated so bad! This place has gone down hill anyway! I don't know who is cooking the food but it's not even fresh. My salmon tasted old and it smelled not fresh and tasted " real " fishy. I had to spit it out! Caveat Emptor! They won't be in business long treating customers like that! Save your money. Go to Greensboro... there is a great seafood place on High Point Road has the name Tide in it. That place is exquisite and the service and food is excellent; very fresh and large portions. You get what you pay for and they treat you kindly! Save yiur gas and money don't ho to a place that mistreats the elderly and tries to get over on them! read more

A very casual, very affordable, typical fried fish house. For North Carolina, it is a solid 4 stars. What I ate was previously frozen fish. They were out of clamstrips. For my friends from New England, you would be deeply disappointed and rate this place a 2. What's with these silly clam strips? Where's the bellies? Where's the fresh seafood? read more

Nice friendly atmosphere, waitress was exceptional. The food is decent, nothing gourmet. Good food at a decent price. I forgot to take photos, but I'll be back and update my review with photos. read more

They don't have clam strips, which is disappointing. The other seafood I have eaten there was very good though.

everything about it was horrible!!! bad attitudes from the staff and the management! save your money , don't risk food poisoning!!! don't get ripped off!!! read more

The best Calabash style seafood in High Point. Be specific in your ordering -- i.e., "fried light", and you'll get good results.

The food is always on point. I never eat in so I can't speak on the dine in portion. The service is good but they are shorter busy on Fridays so you have the plan ahead. read more

Sanibel's - White Fish, fries and hush puppies. - Seafood Near Me - High Point, North Carolina

When I think about how to rate a restaurant on Yelp, I ask myself two questions... What is this restaurant trying to be? And How well is it executing on that mission? In the case of Sanibel's, they are trying to be a no-frills, just good food for the family, seafood restaurant that fills your belly with delicious golden fried goodness at an extremely reasonable price. How well are they doing? Well. I have been coming here since I was a very young child, and very little has changed. They still pack the house, they still make great seafood without any worry by their customers about the freshness of the seafood, and they still operate like a well oiled machine. That is five stars if I ever heard it. They aren't trying to be the best seafood restaurant in town, or push the envelope on ocean fresh cuisine. They just want to give you literally multiple meals worth of seafood that won't ding your wallet. In my time coming here (30+ years), I have probably ordered every combination of the seafood available. You can't go wrong, and a small is enough for two meals for any ordinary person. Small = large, and large = meals for the week. I love their cole slaw. I order extra each time because it compliments their popcorn shrimp so well. It would be right at home on a hot dog too. I usually go baked potato instead of fries, because face it, you have plenty of fried stuff in your meal. The hushpuppies are the ring style and are always enjoyable. I hear many people order extra, but again, you wont hurt for portions here. Sanibel's is known to all the locals, and a certified "high point institution" if you will. These folks won't let you down. Give them your business! Be prepared to call several times for takeout, the line gets busy on friday/saturday evenings. read more

See all

Every North Carolina town of a certain size needs at least one classic fried seafood joint. In High Point, Sanibel's fits the bill. This is the kind of place that looks untouched by time. But you don't go here for ambiance or innovation. You go to a Sanibel's because you want cheap, plentiful fried fish that won't make you sick, and by that measure, Sanibel's delivers. Sanibel's occupies a largish space up North Main with plenty of seating and parking alike. There is a separate entrance for take-out orders, which is what I opted for. I called in ahead, and everything was ready at the time of pick-up. Though the menu offers steaks, salads, and pasta dishes, seafood is the main draw here. You can get it broiled or fried, in single items or in combinations. My wife and I each went with a small fried combination platter, which came equipped with slaw, hushpuppies, and a choice of potato. We came away with flounder-perch-baked potato and shrimp-clams-fries respectively. By and large, the food was tasty and satisfying in a predictable, comfort-food way. Everything fried was well-breaded and crispy without excess grease, and there were zero freshness concerns. The popcorn shrimp were tiny yet addictive and won the approval of our begging cat as well. While neither the fries nor the slaw was anything special, the onion-ring lookalike hushpuppies were a standout. Sanibel's represents an exceptional value for the money spent. For under $12 per, each "small" combination platter yielded two generously portioned meals' worth of food. One shudders to think just how much a "large" would include. I cannot attest to Sanibel's dine-in experience, and I'm in no rush to find out if they do broiled seafood as well as they do fried, but takeout from this place seems like a smart bet for anyone with a fried fish craving or simply a few mouths to feed. read more

Sanibel's - "Small" fried combination platter with shrimp, clam strips, and fries. - Seafood Near Me - High Point, North Carolina

See all

Got the Broil Flounder with crabmeat and it was delicious. Ordered take out. The order was correct!! The folks are hard workers and were very polite. Always my go to for seafood!! read more

Ventured into this hidden gem last night. Driving to the location we never noticed the building. I'm a big fan of fried catfish so that was what I was aiming for. The energy from staff and guest was really good. The decorations made it feel like a legit seafood restaurant. Service was fast felt like as soon as we ordered it took no more than 10 mins and food was in front of us. I have the salt and pepper fried catfish and shrimp combo. My wife had the flounder special that they have on Thursday night. The fish we had was really good flavorful had a nice crunch and flaky. It came out super hot and fresh. The portion size was huge almost as if you could just split the meal. Overall great experience and we will be back in the future. read more

Sanibel's - Salt and Pepper Fried catfish and shrimp. - Seafood Near Me - High Point, North Carolina

Lots of fried food options - Senior menu options. Service was very good. Ambience is typical diner type of seating.

Sanibel's is our favorite place to get fried and broiled seafood. They have a popcorn shrimp special that we get most of the time when we go. read more

Went there with some friends that had never been there. Pleasant experience overall food was great service could've been a little bit better. Me and my wife shared the three item combo with a baked potato and salad. Our friends tried the salmon. They said it was excellent and it looked excellent. We'll probably try that next time. read more

I really enjoyed the two times I've eaten at Sanibel's. We were seated immediately, even though their parking lot was nearly full. Our server greeted us and got us drinks quickly. She kept my soda refilled throughout the meal and was quick to grant special requests like extra lemon. There were a lot of tables in the space, so it did feel like more of a community dining experience. The first time I ate there, I got the small combo platter, and chose the fried catfish and the clam strips. Their portions are huge, so I had enough food to have several more meals. The second time I went, I just got the small clam strip platter. Even though their menu says no substitutions, my server offered the option of extra hushpuppies when I asked for no coleslaw. The food was good, and not amazing. The clam strips were cooked properly and not chewy, which is a problem I've had at other fried seafood restaurants. The value for dollar spent here is exceptional. If you're looking to get a nice and affordable meal, Sanibel's is a great choice. Did it make a lasting culinary impact on my life? meh, not really. But I had a nice meal and enjoyed myself. read more

Sanibel's - The SMALL clam strip platter. - Seafood Near Me - High Point, North Carolina

awesome portions awesome flounder /catfish... awesome staff... tho i love the seafood fried... time to go to broil/bake... w/ibs.. better option... but... best in high pt read more

This place is always so busy so we dropped in on a Friday night. It looks like a small place but once you go in it's a pretty big dining room and all seats were filled. We had to wait a few minutes to be seated but they were really attentive, friendly and it really wasn't that long. They have a lot of options but it's mostly all fried seafood platters. We ordered the shrimp cocktail which my husband liked, they were large shrimp pieces. For my entree I ordered a small platter with both fried scallops and a white fish (I think flounder). It came with a baked potato, hush puppies and since I don't like coleslaw they let me get more hush puppies. The hush puppies are delicious and I liked my fish and scallops but I just wish there had been some kind of lemon or sauce on the side or even seasoning on the breading. But overall it was a decent plate of food and service was nice and quick. My husband got the large platter with popcorn shrimp and scallops and it was a pile of shrimp. Even the small platter is a lot of food so we both had leftovers that will be heated up at home for lunch. read more

Outstanding Flounder and Popcorn Shrimp combo. Haven't tried anything else because my wife and I are hooked on these two items. You definitely get your moneys worth and their prices are reasonable. read more

Came back in town and saw that they were open for take out. Absolutely excited. We ordered a huge amount of food for 6 people and man was it torture to drive back home and smell the delicious fried food in the car. If you order over the phone right now, they are CONSTANTLY taking orders, so please be patient. When we went to pick up our food. We saw 3 people waiting and 10 more people came and went before we left with our food. So they are a busy place. Portions are still huge and delicious. Staff was super nice. And even the patrons were helping each other as we waited for our food. read more

Sanibel's - SMALL 2 fried choice basket. Popcorn shrimp and clams. - Seafood Near Me - High Point, North Carolina

See all

Whenever I'm in High Point I MUST have Sanibel's. I love the family casual atmosphere of it. The waitstaff is always friendly and polite even when it's SUPER busy. The menu never changes and it doesn't need to! Fried, and broiled platters served with slaw and fries or a baked potato cannot be beat. The seafood is always fresh and fried crispy. I like that you can order the flounder, white side only. Oysters, clams, jumbo shrimp, scallops....it's all here at Sanibel's. I prefer to dine in but carry out is awesome too! This is the only seafood I eat while in NC unless I buy and cook my own. read more

Sanibel's - Sanibel's Platter - Seafood Near Me - High Point, North Carolina

This place is always great! I love places that are consistently good. Those places keel me coming back. Good food, and lots of it! The small portion is huge, and the large portions are ridiculously huge...in a really good way;) Staff is always friendly and down to earth. Food comes fast! You can order ahead for take out or dine in. If you dine in, just know that they fill up fast, always. You may have to wait 20min, sometimes more depending on when you come, but it's pretty worth it. read more

See all

its Sanibels. its what you go for; hot. delicious, fried seafood! wish they had fried clams back though!

Food is always good and service is efficient. A bit expensive but it is seafood ... on the whole, the best "fish fix" in the area

Absolutely my favorite Calabash style seafood in the triad! The food is always fresh. I've had the flounder, shrimp, oysters, deviled crab, grilled salmon, and I've even had the grilled chicken. All fabulous! The slaw is awesome which is very important to me. Not too mayonnaisey which I like. Service is always great. Many of the same folks who have worked there for 20 years. Restaurant is clean and decorated very nautical. It is very reminiscent of true Calabash style restaurants at the coast. Love this place. It's one of my staples for many years and is always the same... tasty! read more

OMG, I am so disappointed. When I called to place a takeout order as usual, my husband ordered a oyster and scallop combination and was charged $2.00 more for the oysters that was no problem til we opened the box once we got home. 6 small oysters and six of the smallest scallops I've ever seen. That combination was $18.00 plus tax, I'm wondering wth is goin read more

Sanibel's - This oyster and scallop combination was $18.00+, unbelievable, I was furious. - Seafood Near Me - High Point, North Carolina

If you like seafood like me, Sanibel's is one of the best seafood restaurants around the triad area. I live in Greensboro, but I drive to High Point to eat at Sanibel's. Alot of my church family and myself often to go after church on Sundays to eat. the food is always piping hot, and I have never been disappointed with the staff or the service they provide. My family has gotten takeout and a drive of 20 minutes home and still the food was still piping hot. You should give them a try. read more

Awesome seafood place. Great service and huge platters. Love going here during the furniture market

You're lucky if they answer the phone. IF they answer the phone you're lucky if they don't lay the phone down and not come back even luckier if don't place you on hold and not come back. You give up and go in person with only one person to help you. However the phone situation has happen to me when they have had two or three people working the take out. They said they was doing the best they could. Never had this problem at other fish houses. They definitely need some Competition in High Point. Rather than be stressed out with their customer service I'll just go up to 66 or market Street not that much further. Evidently Sanibel's is getting so much business they cannot handle it so I'll help them out and get somewhere else. read more

Good food, good portions and good customer service. My dad loves this place and I thoroughly enjoy it when I visit. Kudos! read more

Sanibel's - Fried Sanibel Platter - fish, calms, scallops, popcorn shrimp, fries and hush puppies! - Seafood Near Me - High Point, North Carolina

I've been coming here for the past 3 years, every since I moved to High Point from California. Food is decent portions large, down home and by down home I mean white family owned restaurant that's been in business for umpteen years. I usually dine alone as it is all of 2 minutes from my home. Today will be the last time I patronize this place. The staff seems to be on their own time and the customer or at least this customer comes second. My food was late and luke warm. The waitress never came back to my table once I received my drink. I had to catch another waitress to find out where was my food. I could go on but it only gets worst. Upon leaving myself and some other patrons had to wait for the cashier to return from her lunch break and when she finally decided to mosey on up her and another staff person thought it okay to engage themselves in conversation totally ignoring that long line of people waiting to pay I'm sure my little review will do nothing to deter the locals but if you're visiting I suggest eating somewhere else. read more

Sanibel's - Baileys Restaurant in the Dominican Republic - Seafood Near Me - High Point, North Carolina

My family and I drive from Winston-Salem to eat here. Love Sanibel!!! Fave is the grilled tuna steak with veggies, baked potatoes, hush puppies and coleslaw. Best ever!!! Love their tartar sauce too!!! read more

Delicious! I had the large platter with fried shrimp and scallops. The portions were hearty and the service was great. Even though it was a busy Friday night, we were seated right away. read more

Sanibel's - Seafood Near Me - High Point, North Carolina

First time visit was horrible. Shrimp not cleaned properly. I returned the first shrimp order and asked for jumbo shrimp, since informed that is the only deveined shrimp in the house. Ate three jumbo shrimp, but left the rest when I saw it hadn't been deveined. It was also over cooked and tough. read more

Sanibel's - Overcooked and not deveined shrimp cocktail - Seafood Near Me - High Point, North Carolina

See all