Sag Harbor Service Station

3.4 (8 reviews)

Gas Stations, Auto Repair

Add Review

Call

Directions

Services - Sag Harbor Service Station

Routine automotive maintenance

Sag Harbor Service Station Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Sag Harbor Service Station

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Robin L.

130

7 years ago

I've seen the one Star reviews from a few years ago and I think they might have had a change of ownership. My experience was really good. I had to slap a new tire on a blown out wheel and they were able to accommodate it right then and there. They had other work too but were able to squeeze it in and get it done in less than 10min. Price was great (about 20% less than competition in the Easthampton area) and staff was much more welcoming. Too bad they only do NYS inspections at their other shop on Noyac read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Daniel B.

3 years ago

Took my van at a short notice and price was competitive and work was good. Conveniently located as well read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

David K.

5 years ago

Took care of me quickly and got the job done well. If you're near sag, this is the place to go.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

SassyT00 T.

6 years ago

3 days ago-Edit Stopped by the establishment for the first time yesterday 10/14/20 I was visiting an elderly friend who resides in the area. She asked if I could play lottery for her. I agreed although, I am a novice with lotto. I walked in, there was a short wait as there was a Caucasian couple playing lottery. The clerk assisted them and was very pleasant as well as patient. Once he was finished assisting the previous customer he left the counter leaving me standing there. After a brief wait he returned and I explained I needed to play lotto and wasn't experienced doing so. Again he left the counter without explanation, nor an excuse me nothing. He proceeded to crab a bottle of water from the refrigerator. Once returned I rattled off the first number to him. He informed me I must fill out a lottery form. At this point I'm annoyed and I said to the cashier "didn't I just observe you helping those people in front of me without having to fill out cards?" He proceeded by yelling at me "I decide who I help!" I looked at him in total disbelief and told him that's discrimination!" And I left and went to the Gulf in Bridgehampton where the cashier was pleasant, patient and had no issues. Needless to say I won't be returning to Gulf in Sag Harbor. Life is tough enough. People shouldn't have to tolerate such BS in 2020. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michelle K.

7 years ago

Great place to go when 7-eleven employee is too busy screaming to ring you up. The employees are nice and helpful and they have a great selection for such a small store. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Karen R.

11 years ago

I called here trying to find the owner after I was ripped off at his other property Greg's Garage. 2 people took messages but the owner never called or made any attempt to resolve the problem; the second one hung up on me. Then the mechanic from Greg's Garage, MATT, called and threatened to have me arrested!! What kind of business operates this way?? I've reported them to every consumer organization known to man. All the owner had to do was behave like a honest, civil, human being. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

John S.

7 years ago

It breaks my heart to see that Greg and his wife had such negative reviews previously. We had an emergency gas tank situation and they easily offered the best service in the region. We were stranded out in Montauk, and could not find an auto service center willing to help us at all. Once we were able to get towed there, they were able to help us right away, but it was a bit later in the day. Greg's wife helped us book a hotel nearby and then even drove us to the hotel! Amazing service and we really could not rave more about their amazing experience. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jp H.

12 years ago

Don't ever go here. This station is a ripoff. They are only too happy to take your repair, and then not stand behind their work. I got a rear brake job for $500. Two weeks later, the brakes were grinding and I temporarily lost my brakes after exiting the LIE in Riverhead. I was worried and pulled into a Midas Repair Center, which put the car on the lift and took off the wheels, and showed me that a part was missing on the right rear brake. I took photos, had to pay another $500 to get the original (and now ruined job) repaired. When I went back to the Sag Harbor Service Station to ask them for a refund, showed them the photos and receipt, and gave them the card of the Midas manager who would explain what he found. Instead of backing their work, the Sag Harbor receptionist (and wife of the chief mechanic) screamed at me. Then her husband, who manages the garage, offered me $107 for parts. When I said I should get a full refund since I also had to leave my car at the Midas shop and get an emergency rental for a day, he turned his back on me, walked away, and said over his shoulder, "Sue me." They don't deserve anyone's business. Stay away. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

More info about Sag Harbor Service Station

144 Hampton St
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Directions
(631) 725-8400
Call Now

Other Amenities

Does Sag Harbor Service Station have free WiFi?

Yes, Sag Harbor Service Station has free WiFi.

Ask the Community - Sag Harbor Service Station

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Gas Stations 138 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

B&B Auto Service

(69 reviews)

If it wasn't for Bob keeping his shop open past 3pm closing time this past Saturday on a scorching…read morehot day, no less, I would have been stranded. I had a tire puncture with a 2-hour drive ahead of me and Bob and his team to the rescue. Very grateful for their willingness to go above and beyond. Erin G.

Go anywhere else for your car repairs. I agree with many of the other one star reviews. You DO NOT…read morewant to be ripped off by B&B Auto service in Sag Harbor. He overcharged by a lot for my inspection and then kept me waiting. Was wrong about a repair. Not an honest garage. Don't be fooled; note that the 5 star "reviews" are more than offset by truthful one star bad reviews. My experience was terrible treatment and shoddy repairs. Very disappointed.

Exxon

(2 reviews)

local of sag harbor, never thought I'd write a bad review about a gas station but here we are. the…read moreguy who helped me was a complete asshole who had no manners, additionally choosing the wrong octane then what was told making the car jerk. just go to gulf less than a mile away, save your money and aggravation

Do not use this repair station! Charged a lot of money to fix something that was never fixed and…read moresimply said he doesn't want to work on the car and gave no refund. (Took advantage of an elderly man) After being paid more and more money, we Took the car somewhere else and they found he didn't finish repair (left bolts undone and that caused more problems). When we went back he was in another car "engaging with a woman". Ew. Just don't.

Elli's Country Store

(1 review)

Such a great place! Fantastic sandwiches and food, polite service and really good coffee! Plus,…read moreopen year round though through lunch in the off season.

Marshall & Sons Service Center

(16 reviews)

Ask for Lous if you are here for car repair. Great guy, great mechanic! Straight up.Montauk is a…read moretourist trap & the other place is awful!

Terrible shop, awful people. I have half a mind to report them to the BBB. Charges labor hours for…read moreestimates. Threatened to not release our vehicle to us if we didn't pay for the charges which we did. Threatened to charge us for parking at the gas station while waiting on the return of our vehicle which was being towed to bring somewhere else. They wanted to rip us off by replacing our whole brake system for an arm and a leg. We brought it to our repair guy at home and it only needed to have some brake hoses bled and fixed. It's fitting they're located near the ocean where there are sharks. I just feel sorry for all the folks who go there. -July 30, 2017

Georgica Services

(20 reviews)

Extremely well organized company. Expert, trained…read moremechanics. In-depth, detailed, line item diagnosis. Did I mention free diagnosis. Workmanship befitting your concours vehicle. Fair pricing. Workmanship warrantied.

Again terrific service. They do not push unnecessary repairs. Even tho check engine llight was on,…read moreadvised i didnt have to fix issue on 1998 mbsl. At my direction, were going to replace turn signal indicator. Quoted price. Found replacement not needed, just adjustment. Reduced price dramatically. Highly recommended

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Darlene J.

12 years ago

I love this station! My family and I all bring our cars here for repair. Its very hard to find a mechanic who is honest, the owner and head mechanic Greg is. There have been numerous occasions when me or my family have broken down and got stuck and Greg dropped everything to come help us. He is honest and fare. He tells me exactly what my car needs, gives me an estimate and a eta of when he can have it done and he is always right on the money. His wife runs the office and she also is a delight to deal with. There have been occasions when I couldnt find anyone to pick me up and she would drop everything to get me where I need to go. I love that this family business! They go the extra mile to help us out. I hope they are around for many years to come because there is no one else I would want to work on my cars. read more

Evelina M.

10 years ago

Got gas there and right away it stalled!! BAD GAS!! Now my BMW ruined!

Sag Harbor Service Station - servicestations - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Sag Harbor, New York Restaurants near Sag Harbor Service Station

BEST of Sag Harbor, New York Things to Do near Sag Harbor Service Station

BEST of Sag Harbor, New York Coffee near Sag Harbor Service Station

BEST of Sag Harbor, New York Car Wash near Sag Harbor Service Station

BEST of Sag Harbor, New York Convenience Stores near Sag Harbor Service Station

BEST of Sag Harbor, New York Smoke Shop near Sag Harbor Service Station

BEST of Sag Harbor, New York Store near Sag Harbor Service Station

BEST of Sag Harbor, New York Tire Shop near Sag Harbor Service Station

BEST of Sag Harbor, New York Oil Change near Sag Harbor Service Station

Related Cost Guides

Car Window Tinting

Gas Stations

Mobile Dent Repair

Parking

Registration Services

Smog Check Stations

Tires

Vehicle Shipping

Auto Loan Providers

Auto Repair

Car Wash

Oil Change Stations

RV Repair

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Sag Harbor Service Station also viewed

Springs Auto Repair

3.7

(19 reviews)

Legit auto shop. Julian is on point. Very reasonable rates and quality work. Threw on a fresh horn…read moreon my 68 SS within 5 mins and fresh windshield wipers. I recommend

Communicative and excellent work. Restored my one month old car after a hit and run, back to…read moreperfection.

Greg Garage

3.4

(30 reviews)

Very prompt New York State inspection service very nice people bring cash for expedited serviceread more

I've been taking my car to Greg's for more than a decade and you know the service is honest and…read morereasonably priced. Greg truly loves cars and knows what can be done--and what's not worth doing. His raft of loyal customers proves he's an asset to the community.

Joe's Garage

4.1

(32 reviews)

Joe's is the BEST!!…read more Honest, Trustworthy, and Professional..... I travel from Brooklyn to have Joe's crew work on my car!! They are skilled mechanics and will take the time to explain the issue and the cure! And they "cure'" my BMW every time!! I strongly recommend Joe's Garage!!

I have never used this place of business nor do I know any employee at this business, however my…read moreAmazon Prime account was hacked and used to purchase 2 battery amp chargers to be delivered to Joe Frizell in Southampton, NY. I live in Houston, TX. The order was "archived" so that I would not see it, but I received a shipping notification regarding the items. I called and spoke with Joe who denied illegally gaining access to my account and stealing from me, but it is a bit coincidental that 2 battery amp chargers were "accidentally" purchased to be delivered to an auto repair shop. Buyer beware - your card information is not safe with this company.

T & B Auto Service

4.5

(16 reviews)

I would definitely recommend! Very honest! Hank was very friendly and knowledgeable and gave me…read moreadvice to prevent wear on the tires! He even recommended another shop for a service they don't provide. I would highly recommend!

Honesty! My brakes were squeaking a bit so I took it in and they told me the brakes were fine and…read morethe noise was just some rust (my car had been sitting for months.) The gentleman said if I can live with it it'll go away on its own. Could have easily sold me a brake job. An honest mechanic is hard to fine. I won't hesitate to go to T&B in the future.

Southampton Tire

3.7

(42 reviews)

Brought my car in to replace a flat tire - in and out in 1 hour first thing in the am on a busy…read moresummer weekend. They had an extensive selection of tires on hand. If you have the misfortune of a flat tire, they will take care of you quickly and provide peace of mind.

Call and got same day service for 4 new tires for an F150 truck. Dropped off, went to lunch and…read morethen picked it up. Service was fast, friendly and transparent- all questions got answered and they provided some useful information about other work I needed.

Georgica Services

4.5

(20 reviews)

Cisneros Tire Center

4.8

(24 reviews)

Was in here last year for a tire repair; quick and perfect patch. Today came in with nails in both…read moreback tires! No appt. Team is quick, and service is great. Totally reasonable!!

My oil change was professional and accommodating to get done while I waited. Everyone there was…read morepolite and helpful.

Kalbacher's Auto

3.9

(17 reviews)

Extremely high quality service, both mechanical and body work. Timely turn around and great…read moreflawless work, competitively priced. Also a great place to buy a preowned vehicle. Did I mention the people are great?

Kalbacher's works on plenty of my cars and has a pristine storage facility. The quality of work is…read moresecond to none, especially when it comes to vintage Mercedes. The prices are very reasonable and when compared to the other local shops, a real bargain considering they have great master level techs capable of working on pretty much everything. Not to mention they have an excellent inventory of cars that they sell as well! So many hidden gems in their inventory! White glove all the way

Dietrich's Auto Repair

4.3

(15 reviews)

Extremely helpful and knowledgable staff!…read more Had some car troubles on my way into town and stopped here. Very happy I did as the staff is extremely helpful and kind. They had me in and out in a couple of hours and gave me additional insight about my vehicle. Would definitely recommend!

Great service. I have brought multiple cars for repair and Tom and his team do great work . Their…read moreexpertise and attention to detail is A++. Not only did they efficiently resolve my electrical issue, but the automotive repair team also offered their services at a very reasonable cost. Their commitment to quality work without breaking the bank sets them apart. Exceptional service and affordability--couldn't be happier! Highly recommended!

The Garage

3.6

(32 reviews)

i got a flat out here in the hamptons. The folks were more then nice if that's possible. He got the…read moretire later afternoon and fixed the tire! This man and his wife are the loveliest folks I have ever met! Very reasonable too! They do inspections and other things! Come here to the honest best place in the Hamptons!

This place used to be good. Now it's a rip-off! I was told…read more$75 for an oil change. When I picked up the car the price changed to $125 Oh $75 is for the labor! Oil is extra. I brought it in for an inspection. They didn't do the inspection. They told me I would l have to make another appointment because the inspection machine wasn't working. This is the third time I have been disappointed. Will have to find another garage repair. I have been coming here for 20 years. Sad day!

Sag Harbor Service Station

Services - Sag Harbor Service Station

Sag Harbor Service Station Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Sag Harbor Service Station

More info about Sag Harbor Service Station

Other Amenities

Ask the Community - Sag Harbor Service Station

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

Sag Harbor Service Station - servicestations - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

People found Sag Harbor Service Station by searching for…

Related Searches in Sag Harbor, NY

Trending Searches in Sag Harbor, NY

Related Cost Guides

Browse Brands

Browse Articles

People who viewed Sag Harbor Service Station also viewed

Springs Auto Repair

Greg Garage

Joe's Garage

T & B Auto Service

Southampton Tire

Georgica Services

Cisneros Tire Center

Kalbacher's Auto

Dietrich's Auto Repair

The Garage

Sag Harbor Service Station

Services - Sag Harbor Service Station

Sag Harbor Service Station Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Sag Harbor Service Station

More info about Sag Harbor Service Station

Other Amenities

Ask the Community - Sag Harbor Service Station

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

More businesses like Sag Harbor Service Station

2 Sag Harbor Service Station reviews that are not currently recommended

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

Sag Harbor Service Station - servicestations - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

People found Sag Harbor Service Station by searching for…

Related Searches in Sag Harbor, NY

Trending Searches in Sag Harbor, NY

Related Cost Guides

Browse Brands

Browse Articles

People who viewed Sag Harbor Service Station also viewed

Springs Auto Repair

Greg Garage

Joe's Garage

T & B Auto Service

Southampton Tire

Georgica Services

Cisneros Tire Center

Kalbacher's Auto

Dietrich's Auto Repair

The Garage