Went in for the pizza. It did not disappoint. Excellent crust and sauce and toppings. Highly recommend. Super friendly staff.

I would never expect to find my favorite vegan pizza (I had the cheese removed) in the small town of Rye, CO, but I did. The restaurant is adorable and the staff are sweet, helpful and knowledgeable of the area. Everyone in my party of 6 loved their food, especially the Mac n cheese Give them a try. It will be worth it! read more

Rye Cafe - Rye Cafe...fabulous food - Cafes Near Me - Rye, Colorado

Good food and great service. We went for breakfast and had the burrito with bacon I like crisp bacon and had ordered my burrito with crisp bacon, it wasn't crispy at all. I know that sometimes the waiter may not communicate with the kitchen staff but that's my only complaint otherwise the food was good. read more

A hidden gem that is worth the detour if you're going this way! Friendly staff and the best pizza you'll ever have read more

Rye Cafe - Make your own pizza - Cafes Near Me - Rye, Colorado

See all

Our family has a cabin in Rye, and when we visit, we usually eat in. Today, we decided to try the Rye Cafe, and we are so glad we did! We didn't have to wait to sit inside. We noticed that we could have eaten outside, in the back or front. We liked the ambience inside - great old pictures and decor. Cheryl was our waitress and she was terrific. Everyone else working at the cafe was also friendly and efficient. My niece ordered the chicken salad salad. It was made fresh - all of it. I had the chief salad - it was also made up fresh. Husband had pizza - half pepperoni & sausage for himself & half pineapple for our great niece - who stayed home to work, so we brought her half home after we finished eating. Everything was delicious, and we appreciated the personal attention to each thing we ordered. Cheryl brought out each meal as it was made, which was fine for us. Husband raved about the pizza, by the way, and this is the 3rd time in 5 days he's had pizza. This was the best yet. We paid and left, full and happy. We hope to return soon and try other menu items! read more

Rye Cafe - Love the open kitchen! - Cafes Near Me - Rye, Colorado

Rye café is a gem. With no other restaurants in the town, you'd think it would be mediocre but that's just not the case. The food is exquisite. Excellent pizzas, as well as a host of other great options. Brunch, lunch, dinner- pretty much everything you could want. We stayed at an Airbnb less than a block away so we ate there several times during our stay in Rye. Staff is phenomenal, friendly, and on top of things. read more

Rye Cafe - Pineapple ham pizza - Cafes Near Me - Rye, Colorado

See all

I was there and it was great I will be going back. Awesome pizza and love the cheese bread. Best around. The owner is friendly enough to make me want to go back. Great owner and great food. read more

Love this place! So friendly and helpful. Delicious food and the cobbler is to die for!

We discovered "this gem" on Facebook while traveling to Colorado City. Rye is a charming small town 13 miles to the west of the Colorado City exit on Interstate 25 . We ordered the carved turkey sandwich and the chicken salad on croissant. Both came with potato salad. Both were so delicious. The cafe is inviting and comfortable. Diane greeted us so warmly that we felt like it was our hometown restaurant. She and our waitress let know that the last piece of homemade peach cobbler was still available, which we eagerly ordered with ice cream. We were not disappointed! It was the best peach cobbler ever! We look forward to traveling this way next year and plan to make the Rye Cafe our dining choice. read more

Great breakfast, great pizza, great friendly service! XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX

I wasn't sure what to expect being the only place in town to eat. Wow the food is amazing!!! The pizza is the best in CO & honestly the best I've ever had anywhere! Excellent service, clean & just a really great little place to eat. read more

Best pizza I've ever had! And the delicious BBQ Beef sandwich comes on bread baked right there! The salads are always fresh and crisp! The service is awesome and owner and staff are excellent at making sure you have a positive experience. Definitely a great place to eat! read more

It was a wonderful spot to stop and enjoy delicious pizza. The team working there were friendly and fun to be around after a long journey. Gorgeous surrounding area to appreciate while driving up there. read more

Rye Cafe - a sign for hand tossed fresh pizza - Cafes Near Me - Rye, Colorado

We stopped at the cafe after visiting Bishop's Castle. The staff was extremely friendly and our mac and cheese with bacon was delicious. We also had the cobbler (both blackberry and the peach) It was a perfect end to a delightful experience. I love blackberry cobbler! read more

Good service, good food, friendly atmosphere. The pizzas are absolutely delicious, seriously filling for one.

Great restaurant off the beaten path. Staff was extremely friendly and welcoming. We had our dog and sat on the back patio. Super peaceful. Food was great. We ordered the Slopper burger and the Greenhorn pizza. Loved the crust on the pizza! For dessert, we ordered the brownie delight and fresh peach cobbler. YUM! Definitely worth venturing off of I-25 and into Rye for this meal! read more

Rye Cafe - Fresh peach cobbler and ice cream. - Cafes Near Me - Rye, Colorado

A great fun find in a very small community. Great scenic drive and very good food. We enjoyed the BLT and fried chicken. Wish we could have had pizza too, it looked delicious. read more

So cute and cozy pizza is beyond yummy and the people there are so kind and welcoming

Food: amazing. Service: outstanding. Decor/cleanliness: perfection. We vacationed there from Arkansas. We ONLY close small mom n pop restaurants and we're not disappointed. We hate chain restaurants. We will be back. read more

Good food. Nice clean place. Nice small town. People very friendly Would go back next time in town.

This place is amazing. Best pizza in Colorado possibly the USA. Staff is always friendly and attentive. Clean and welcoming.

Wonderful people! Great desserts!!! They were so accommodating and asked us when we were coming back so that they can be prepared for any menu that we want!!! read more

Delicious food and amazing service! Came in for coffee/breakfast and got the omelette and their famous biscuits and gravy-so good we decided to go back for lunch! For lunch we got to choose from a newly updated menu full of tasty items. We picked one of the new salads that Cheri recommended. I was a crunchy fresh bed of locally grown lettuce and micro greens (sunflower shoots, pea shoots, baby arugula) topped with tender grilled chicken, pecans, bell pepper, crisp apple and feta served with a side of raspberry vinaigrette that you could add to your liking! Huge salad but so fresh you won't feel bloated after! We heard that some nights (not sure which so call ahead and check) they do prime rib and steak for dinner, but you need to call ahead and reserve a meal because they book up fast! They have other options for dinner as well, BBQ chicken and Ribs etc... Will definitely be eating here a few more times during our stay! read more

Rye Cafe - Cafes Near Me - Rye, Colorado

Local eatery with delicious pizza and sandwiches and breakfast. It is not on the main highway so you need to watch for the signs. Friendly and cozy. read more

This place was amazing! It's super cute and clean inside. Staff was incredibly friendly and the prices are on par with any other place. And the food? Absolutely perfect! You can taste that each and every item is fresh. Salads were top notch and the pizza....ahh.....the pizza! Spot on! I was so thankful I had leftovers so I can enjoy the pizza again tomorrow. . My only regret was not taking any pics. Looks like another day trip to the area is in our future. Don't pass this place up! read more

Had an awesome lunch at Rye Cafe! The food was excellent, and the staff incredibly kind and accommodating. Just when we thought things couldn't get any better, realized they also served homemade blueberry and peach cobbler...worth stopping by just for the cobbler!! read more

Very disappointed in management. They will never have my business nor gift cards to family. Would not recommend this place to anyone and I am local. read more

I didn't have the opportunity to eat, but it sure smelled good. I stopped in for a coffee to go. The service was excellent and friendly and they brew a mean cup of joe. Stop by when you're in town. read more

Amazing!!! I absolutely love this place. The food was exceptional, the service was delightful, the feel of the restaurant and the overall experience was worth every second and dollar spent. I wish you guys the best and I would recommend everyone and anyone to visit this place. Definitely worth the half hour drive from Bishop Castle. I had the chicken panini with feta cheese, a grilled cheese and my wife had a deluxe burger. We both enjoyed everything very much. Even the sweet tea was awesome! read more

Rye Cafe - Deluxe burger with fries. Meat was super fresh and tasty, along with all the condiments! Best burger I have had in a while. - Cafes Near Me - Rye, Colorado

When I imagine a small town cafe, this is exactly what I envision, great food and friendly smiles. I stumbled upon this place while on the road and needing to find a place with Wi-Fi to take a call. Everyone here greeted us with a warm smile, was very welcoming, and accomodating about customizing the veggie panini to be as vegan friendly as possible. The cafe is large and very clean, full of locals, and a very relaxing place to unwind with yummy food during a road trip! read more

This is a great place. The food is really good, very reasonably priced, and served by excellent wait staff. We love the breakfast omelets, waffle, and more. It's worth the drive to scenic Rye. read more

Had the Ruben, it was really tasty, but kinda small. I didn't like the potato salad. It was really sweet. The place was nice and clean and the staff very nice. It was really hot in the building though. The price for lunch was kinda high. The people that were with me had salads that looked really good, and they were cheap. read more

Wow. This place is awesome! I had the best BLT I've ever had. You might think one BLT is just like every other, well there's was better! We will definitely be doing one of their fancy Friday night dinners one of these days. read more

Great little cafe in Rye, Colorado. Not much else here so it's a good addition. We stopped by for lunch and we're pleasantly surprised to find the food very good and the onchee to die for! A New Zealand treat. Unfortunately we arrived the next to last day for the current owners. They've sold the restaurant and I have no idea if the good food and ambiance will continue. I surely hope so as we will be back thru rye. read more

Valentine dinner at Rye Cafe was wonderful. Cheri and David are gracious owner/hosts and the wait staff is so friendly. The food very good with an excellent price. Highly recommended. We love breakfast and lunch on normal days too!!! Thank you Rye Cafe. read more

I don't know about you, but when a place labels itself a cafe you'd think they would actually make coffee... not here. My partner asked for a cup of decaf coffee and was handed an empty cup and a packet of instant coffee. For a minute he thought they were giving him a UA test kit.... bahahaha... no thanks!!! read more

Biscuits & gravy are super good. And I dream about the Oohnchee slice, it's the best baked goodie I've ever eaten. My husband does not care for sweets and he loved it too! read more

For a small town Café this place really rocks, good food, decent prices, and great atmosphere. The new owners have done a great job of bringing this place back to life, a very fun and cozy place to hang out. read more

This is a great place to eat. The food is excellent as well as the service. The cafe is very clean. I would highly recommend this cafe to everyone. Oh, did I mention the service is phenomenal?? read more

I had the green chili which was spicy and great. I also had the biscuits and gravy. Outstanding. I will be back soon.