Pass Key Restaurant

An overnight trip in Pueblo plus a really bad sweet tooth took me directly to Bite Me Cake, and I'm…read moreglad for it. I am rarely this far south so am unfamiliar with the bakery options around town; Bite Me was one of the closest, highest rated spots right near the hotel I was staying in. The photos and vibe looked really great based on others' reviews, so I decided to stop in late on a Saturday not to get my sugar fix lol. The atmosphere is fun, and the mish mash of sweets, games, and a downstairs bar I think is super unique and also makes this place more appealing for people that want to bring kids around earlier in the day. Despite going late (I think it was around 8?), the arcade was pretty full of people, which was a great sign. The bakery case and menu is at the back, and there was one very sweet girl (no pun intended lol) running the counter. Even for the time, there were lots of options that all looked like they were pretty good and not obviously stale or old from the day which I really appreciated. There is also ice cream and a refrigerator case of goodies in addition to what's shown here, as well as various beverages you can purchase. I decided to splurge on a cherry cupcake, a cheesecake cookie with cherries, and a brookie. The total was around $12 or so, which was pretty reasonable. I took my treats back to the hotel to enjoy them while watching a show, and they were all delicious! Definitely satisfied my craving for something sweet after a long day. I think this place would be very fun for a date night or a small family outing during the day, presuming it's isn't busy inside as it seems like it can easily feel crowded. Parking is available on the street and may be a bit of a challenge depending on the day and time you stop in, but the downtown area is pretty walkable and more parking accommodations can be found further away. Stop in if you get a chance! I probably will next time I'm in town.

Our whole family absolutely loves, bite me cake! We discovered them a few years during their annual…read moreKrampus pictures, and they have become a staple for birthdays and celebrations in our house. Delicious cupcakes, and cakes, and affordable. The staff is always fantastic, and the atmosphere when you go and hang out? My husband and I love it and so do our teenagers. Bite me cake is a win all the way around!

Outside

See all

Milkshake

Sweet Ella's

4.7(26 reviews)

2.5 mi

Great customer service, great bakery items, and the owners are very sweet, no pun intended…read more They explain how their desserts are specific to their purpose and plenty of flavors to choose from. Very cute and pleasant environment. Love this place

Incredibly delicious treats without worry of reaction. Their family story is sweet and…read moreheartwarming. They're menu is always changing and they're helpful making choices. The store is small and attached to a fitness facility. They do have a walk up window but it's easier to make choices when you can see the display case inside.

Sweet Ella's Pastry Assortment

Chocolate Brownie Cheesecake

See all

Street view of Sweet Ella's

Schusters Banquet Bakery

4.1(47 reviews)

1.9 mi

My favorite! Glazed donut's!! Yum! Always someone there to wait on me, clean and efficient. My…read morefavorite bakery ever. A gem for Pueblo in the Mesa Junction.

Great old fashioned donuts. There pies are also good. There is not indoor seating. It is a drop in…read moreand leave kind of place. Some of the staff can be a little curt sometimes. I think they have worked there so long they might be bored with us customers. I think it gives the place unique kind of charm. I frequent this place often.

Easter basket cake stale and crumbled to crumbs

See all

Storefront across from library

Hopscotch Bakery

4.0(71 reviews)

2.3 mi

Ordered a custom birthday cake for my daughter's 10th. she wanted a Hamilton theme, and Nathan at…read morehopscotch did a awesome job! my daughter was so excited when she saw it. It was beautiful and priced extremely well for the piece of art he received. 10/10 would recommend!! the whole team went above and beyond my expectations!!!

Always stop here when I'm down on Union. The shortbread cookie is my go to. Always fresh…read more Overall, this is a "gourmet" bakery. Service is good, walk in and there is someone behind counter. Small space, no tables. Pretty pricey.

Shortbread cookie.

Cupcake Love at First Bite

See all

Brues Alehouse

4.0(673 reviews)

2.7 mi

My husband and I came here for dinner and honestly a 4.7 rating is perfect. We came here in part…read morebecause they claim to be the best green chili in Colorado. So of course I was excited. Pros: Walking in the hostess was helping another couple but did acknowledge us. She went to sit the couple and another staff apologized and said that she will be right with us. We were sat outside and immediately were given water. Our waiter, who I can't remember his name, talked to us and took our drink order. My husband ordered a beer and me an iced tea. He gave us a few minutes before coming back to take our order. We started with the green chili fries and when they came out they were very good. I do wish there was a little bit of spice to it, but not a con. I even ordered a cup of green chili with my shrimp tacos. And my husband ordered the slopper. I loved the shrimp tacos, that I got the lettuce instead of a tortilla. I would highly order and recommend. Husband loved the slipper. He said if you don't see the fries or bun, assume your eating it all. Our waiter is very knowledgeable and was quick with his recommendations. He answered a burger question when asked and took his time with us. We did not feel rushed. My husband also ordered a beer flight and found some he enjoyed. All the staff worked together and matched our personality. Well, my husband's personality. We ended up ordering 3 cups if green chili with their chips. The salsa had a nice kick, mild kick, because they added green chilis to it. It tasted home made. When we had a minor issue with the bill, our waiter took charge and without hesitation took to fix it. We of course had to order dessert. Our waiter came back within minutes to inform some of the desserts were sold out but offered a replacement. I got the peach pie and my husband got the chocolate cake. The peach pie was a perfect mini size Cons: My husband was surprised the manager wasn't walking around ensuring everything ran smoothly. I honestly don't see it as a con. Also, the parking lot is small and when it gets busy I can see walking from another block over. There are 3 spots for the hotel and 4 spots that are a 2 hour limit. Recommended? Absolutely yes. Great food and excellent staff. Everyone here is friendly and seems excited to help the customers. We will definitely be back. And maybe stay at the hotel and walk over to enjoy a hamburger or more shrimp tacos with a cup of green chili

We stopped by Bye's Ale House hoping for their green chili, only to find it wasn't on the brunch…read moremenu. Since we hadn't been here in five years, I mentioned to our waiter how much I was craving a bowl, and he went out of his way to make it happen. That level of service alone made the visit memorable. I also ordered the Velvet Smoke mezcal cocktail, and wow, it was exceptional. Smooth, perfectly balanced, and not too strong. The smoky notes were present but not overpowering, and the nixta slate liqueurs, or heat and bitters brought everything together beautifully. Great service, great drinks, and a team that's willing to go the extra mile. Definitely worth the stop.

Brewery Concert Hall

Look at the meat perfect prime rib

See all

Nick's Dairy Creme

3.8(22 reviews)

3.4 mi

We stopped by Nick's Dairy Creme and ordered four Arctic Swirls--one Butterfinger, one Cookie…read moreDough, and two Oreo. Even though they were busy, our ice cream came out quickly, and everything was delicious. It was the perfect way to cool down on a hot day while supporting a great local small business. We'll definitely be back

Best place to get ice cream! I've been there like four times and it's amazing, the only tiny…read moredrawback is their Reesie's cups were too frozen, but that's a tiny thing I'd highly recommend this place to anyone!

Menu #1

Menu #2

See all

Menu #3

Craft Cones

4.0(5 reviews)

2.6 mi

After a horrible experience at Taffys in Pueblo, I have been looking for someplace for ice cream…read more So happy to find Craft Cones! Yes, they are a bit pricey 6.50$ for a single scoop cone, but that is WAY BETTER than the other place that charges over 5$ for a double scoop cone (but their scoop was literally no more that a tablespoon!). HIGHLY RECOMMEND CRAFT CONE! It is far superior in customer service and flavor!!

WHAAAAAAT??? An Arnold Palmer ice cream! A little bit of tea, a little bit of lemon and you have a…read moremasterpiece. I had it as a milkshake and wish I could have more right now. The owner/maker was more than accommodating; cheerful, happy to be where he was and what he was doing. This made for a great space to serve and enjoy some of the tastiest tasty I've had in a while. Cozy space just for ordering.

Green chili S'mores

See all

Perfect ice cream! Cherry blue cheese!

Whippy Cakes

5.0(1 review)

2.7 mi

A deliciously pampering treat... yes it's pampering for your tastebuds!!! No flavor is missed,…read moreincredibly delectable!!! if I lived closer it would be DAILY I ate a bite, a slice, oh who am I kidding, the whole thing!!! So try the minis when worried about pants sizes but don't miss trying every flavor!!!! Holidays or just because there is no need to declare it anything but a good day when you're blessed with a Whippy Cake Cheesecake!!!

Taffy's

4.2(30 reviews)

1.9 mi

Cute little candy and ice cream shop with plenty of flavors to choose from. Splits and malts and…read moremore available! Counter service was quick and courteous. If you don't know a flavor they will give you a tasting spoon full of it. They were rather patient as we tried to figure out what we wanted from their yumaliscious selection. Will be back to pick up some tasty treats to give away to friends.

I have been going to Taffy's for popcorn for at least 20 years! They give you a choice of open or…read moreclosed box when filing and always put just the right amount of butter! Also have had, on occasion, something sweet; gummies or ice cream. This place is Pueblo history in Mesa Junction!

Group shot with Misti

Freeze-dried Skittles!!

See all

Easter caramel apples

3Birds Coffee

4.3(120 reviews)

1.9 mi

Super sweet baristas, great coffee, and amazing gluten free pastries! Taylor and Anna took good…read morecare of us and got us caffeinated 5 minutes before close. The place is cute on the inside and feels warm and welcoming, great stop!

Great once again! The seasonal rose cardamom chai is delicious. Little sweet but the cardamom rose…read moreflavors are lovely. The lox bagel is quite tasty as well. Instead of cream cheese these was a pesto dill lemon vinegaret sauce and I really enjoyed the lighter take. Love this area of town for the big library, walking and this coffee shop fits right in the quaint old town feel. The barista greeted me immediately, took my order as soon as I was ready and had my drink and food our quickly. Will absolutely return. Only negative is seeing the eye sore that is the gross establishment called Rudy's right across the street.

Old school piano where the creamer, spices and sweeteners are located.

Lox bagel

See all

Their awesome upstairs. Very comfortable to work in. Wi-Fi is awesome too.

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Mercedes B.

0

3

0

5 years ago

Excellent service and excellent food! One of the best restaurants in town! Would definitely recommend to anyone.

B T.

0

7

15

1 year ago

Rude service. Very expensive for the food ambience horrible. Never going back again. Got drinks and left

Derek G.

0

1

0

9 years ago

Shitty green chilly who made this or i accidently asked for a cup of water on my burger idk

Pass Key Restaurant - desserts - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Pass Key Restaurant also viewed

Pass Key Restaurant

3.7

(104 reviews)

If you're in Pueblo and you don't eat a Pass Key special, I'm convinced your trip doesn't legally…read morecount. This isn't just a sandwich -- it's a rite of passage, a regional flex, a meat-forward love letter to Southern Colorado. The Pass Key sausage grinder is gloriously simple and absolutely unhinged in the best way. No frills, no fuss -- just perfectly seasoned sausage that tastes like it was handcrafted by someone's Italian uncle who doesn't measure anything and judges you silently while you eat. The bread soaks up every bit of savory goodness like it knows its purpose in life Now listen closely, because this part matters: Order the Pass Key Special with DOUBLE MEAT. This is not the time for moderation or self-reflection. Add green chilies -- not because it's trendy, but because Pueblo green chilies are a sacred obligation They bring just enough heat to remind you you're alive and enough flavor to make you question every sandwich you've ever loved before this one. This sandwich doesn't just fight hunger -- it wins. It hugs your soul, humbles your appetite, and connects you to a Pueblo tradition that's been quietly outperforming the rest of the country for decades. You'll leave full, slightly smug, and possibly plotting when you can come back for another. Five stars. Ten napkins. Zero regrets.

Fast and friendly service. Clean and homey dining area. Simple, but tasty and satisfying meal. It…read morehit the spot.

Bingo Burger

4.1

(624 reviews)

Went in while on vacation. Looked really good online, and it ended up being really good. Late…read morelunch, I got a build your own bacon cheeseburger regular style beef patty, with fries. The burger was really good, fresh vegs, big slices of bacon. Tall burger, but I smashed it down enough that I could eat it without cutting it up. Not a brussel sprouts fan, but someone got an order, and they were the best I've ever tried. I ended up eating about half of them. Fries were good, lotta food, couldn't finish it all. Would return again. Inside and outside patio dining. Self service drink machine. Friendly and quick service. Food arrived pretty quick, but it wasn't busy when we went. Small private parking lot.

First time here and my first impression is very good. A ton of options to decide from. Beer is…read morefrom local vender and it was delicious. We got the Blood orange is a German style ale and on the lighter side. Soda machine is also local and not filled with popular commercial options. Hamburger, amazing; sweet potatoes, perfect. Brussel sprouts, awesome. Service was great and the restaurant was clean. It's a little pricy but very good.

Fuel And Iron Food Hall

3.8

(67 reviews)

Fuel & Iron Food Hall in downtown Pueblo is such a great find! I stopped in while visiting my…read moredaughter and was genuinely impressed. I had the chicken tikka masala from Bollywood Bites--absolutely delicious, full of flavor, and perfectly cooked. I also grabbed a couple of drinks from the bar, which were just as good. What really stood out was the atmosphere--lively, welcoming, and very family-friendly. There's something for everyone, and all the food portions we saw coming out looked generous and worth it. It's the kind of place you can relax, try different foods, and enjoy the vibe. I'll definitely be coming back next time I'm in Pueblo!

This is a review for the bar at this food hall. Stopped in here on a Saturday afternoon. Wasn't…read moresure what I wanted so I checked out the menu and decided on the Espresso Martini. The description on the menu says "Vanilla Vodka, Luxardo Espresso Liquer, Simple syrup". Sounded like a pretty standard Espresso Martini. The glass arrived and it was the color of chocolate milk. I asked the bartender of it had Bailey's or something in it and she said, "yes". I pointed to the menu and noted that the menu didn't say anything about Cream. She said, "That's the way I make it." I asked her if she could make it like the menu and she said, "Yes, but it won't taste good." I asked her if she could make one with just a little of the cream liqueur, and she said, "Are you going to pay for other one?" I was like, "What the hell?!?! You make the drink different from the description and you expect me to pay for it?!?!?" I don't know if that's a Colorado thing or something, but I wanted to just walk out. This bar sucks.

Two Sisters

3.8

(66 reviews)

Really good food and service, staff was incredibly friendly and their pancakes and bacon are really…read moregood. The atmosphere is also pretty nice

Family owned American and Mexican food items. The French fries are excellent. Fresh homemade pies…read more Fun relaxing no pressure.

Mill Stop Cafe

4.4

(196 reviews)

Came in for lunch. Place was packed. Was greeted right away by a nice man. Table came open and we…read morewere seated. Very nice server came by and took our order. Food came out quick and was very good. An older gentleman came by and said hi and thanks for coming in. Would we go back?? Yes we would. Friendly owners and staff and good food!

Hubby and I live in Colo Springs but this is our go to spot every time we're in Pueblo. He ordered…read morethe special, beef burritos and I ordered the Avocado and pork burrito both smothered with the green chile. This place is clean, friendly staff and delicious food. Thank you for always being consistent..

GG's BBQ

3.6

(105 reviews)

lean beef brisket is oil brisket soup . pay for a pound of…read morebrisket, you will receive some meat in a container full of oil ! This is not BBQ !!! THE worst version of smoked meat. Unless you like your meat oil soup.

The ribs were really dry. My brisket was crumbs and all the spices was just too hot. I like hot but…read morenot hot all the time and the cashier treated me like crap. First time experience horrible.

Cakes By Marie

4.4

(63 reviews)

Marie's is a great place to stop for a slopper and fries!! I add ghost pepper cheese to my slopper,…read morethat always adds a little extra kick! Nothing that a little ketchup and crispy fries can't help cool down.

I Door Dashed a cheeseburger with fries. It said it came with lettuce, tomato, onion, and…read morepickles. No tomatoes, the red onion ring was the size of a quarter, there were 2 pickles (1 was a standard round and the other was a sandwich stacker), and the lettuce was old and brown. The fries were excellent but all in all it wasn't very good..

Mozo's Great American Heroes

3.9

(18 reviews)

Ordered "The Navy Seal" through DoorDash.. received it piping hot and was delivered super quick…read more The roast beef and Au Jus was incredible. Highly recommend

Delicious sandwiches, fresh and high quality ingredients! Friendly staff and reasonable prices! I…read morerecommend Mozo's highly! I love the diversity of the hero's pictured on their walls!

Steel City Deli

3.7

(3 reviews)

The staff is friendly and prepare a decent sandwich. However, when asked about their meats she said…read morethey use Boars head. There is absolutely no signage to verify this. The sides were not good. Pasta overcooked and not seasoned properly. I had originally wanted a meatball sub but they don't make the meatballs in house. Maybe I'm expecting too much, but they don't have corned beef either. Corned beef is standard fare in any decent deli.

I had the special roast beef French dip It was very…read moreflavorful and was a rather large portion for the price I'll return to try some of their other daily specials soon!

3Birds Coffee

4.3

(120 reviews)