I ordered a variety of Easter treats for Easter the cookies were amazing the lil individual egg cakes were really good. But the Easter basket cake were terrible they gave me old cake that crumbled and very stale and disappointed. I'll just stick to buying cookies and donuts cake is not like it used to be. Lesson learned what not to waste money on. read more

Schusters Banquet Bakery - Easter basket cake stale and crumbled to crumbs - Donuts Near Me - Pueblo, Colorado

See all

Very good products and prices. More whole grain products would be nice, but might not sell well.

I will never step foot in this bakery again. The women working behind the counter were absolutely rude and acted put out. I left without buying anything after a simple request was denied by them. Absolutely ridiculous, wouldn't spend a penny here ever again. read more

We walked in... took a look at the baked goods in their case.... and walked out! It looked that BAD! We are from out of town but we'd NEVER come back! read more

Ordered a half sheet birthday cake ,very disappointed I love Schusters Banquet Bakery . The donuts are the best everything is usually very good. However the cake was dry as if it had been frozen and defrosted then decorated. Like I said very disappointed read more

I love shusters bakery i have been going for a while now and they ar great. Remember DO NOT JUDGE A BOOK BY ITS COVER. while the people may apear diffrent they are awsome wholesome people. read more

The best chocolate on chocolate donut, maybe ever. The prices are very low we want to try a pie the next trip. The only thing that could make the place better is if they served coffee. awesome donuts though read more

Never been there in person but I've tried these donuts in several occasions - so so good! Probably the best in town.

We went to get donuts and everything was delicious! We admittedly ate the whole box in two days. Will definitely be coming back!

Wonderful pastries!!! This is my favorite Pueblo bakery for donuts and such. They do a very brisk business and can get quite crowded, but I'm willing to wait for the best. read more

This is THE BEST hometown bakery ever! Their shortbread holiday cookies are my favorite! I can eat an entire dozen! Also, one of the few bakery's to have Boston Cream. Always fresh, always real. Also their potato rolls are the best. Make great sandwich with leftover ham or turkey for the holiday's. read more

Delicious donuts!!! Old school bakery, with so many great choices.... Real cream filling!

This has been my favorite bakery my entire life! My grandparents used to get pies and pastries from here. They've been gone for over 20 years! I live in Los Angeles, and I come to visit often. I never message Colorado without stopping here first! read more

This is a wonderful local bakery. When we were kids, it was a special treat. So when I visit Pueblo, I make sure to stop in. I get their delicious powdered pecan sandies (like wedding cookies), frosted sugar cookies, donuts, and cream puffs. For Christmas and Easter they have Potica (Slovakian nut roll), a local tradition which everyone should have in their lives. The prices are super reasonable, and the people are really nice. read more

Schusters Banquet Bakery - Storefront across from library - Donuts Near Me - Pueblo, Colorado

Tried to order a birthday cake for someone and prepay (don't live in the area). Not accommodating at all. Called another bakery and they were very accommodating. read more

I had decided the night before we would get some donuts before going to our son's game to share with all the parents and spectators we watch our son's game with. So I did some doughnut research prior to taking off to find a shop that was located at the half way point of our drive. Schusters popped up, so we decided to give it a whirl. So Schusters doesn't just do doughnuts, they do all kinds of baked goods and different stuff throughout the day from what I could tell when I was there. I called ahead to make sure they would have three dozen doughnuts available since I knew they would be a smaller shop, I didn't want to put them out when we got there. They certainly had enough, so we just got a mixed bag of whatever she wanted to give us. Well we got to the game and started sharing with everyone. Someone was like "you went all the way over to that side of town for doughnuts, you know there is a Dunkin Doughnut off the highway"... The two don't even compare, and someone else stated "these are much better than anything from Dunkin". They were absolutely right! I do not eat doughnuts often, hardly ever really but these were amazing. Fresh and hand made. I highly recommend this bakery, and I really want to come back and try some of their breads. People were in there asking what time certain styles of bread would be ready, etc... So it has to be good if people are getting there early to see what the selection and times are going to be. read more

You know how you go to a bakery and everything looks delicious and incredible but when you dig in it's all pasty frosting, heavy flour based items and breakfast cereal toppings? This is not that place. Unassuming, well run and reasonably priced. Quick service and lots of options. Not many labels but the staff with guide you through the fillings and flavors if needed. Three filled long Johns, half a dozen assorted doughnuts and two small valentines cakes was under $15 with tax. It's hard to control your gluttony here but it won't hammer your wallet if you have a momentary weakness. Don't touch the glass!!!!!! read more

I have been there twice now, first time it was a little past noon and they had only 2 types of donuts left. Got a dozen of them. They tasted amazing. And staff was friendly. Second time I was there was a bit past 11am and they had a good selection. I got a dozen with a lot of variety. And my family loved the donuts. But the staff member that waited on me this particular time wasn't pleasant at all. Seemed like she didn't want to be there and was even more displeased I was there. None of pleasantries and willingness to help like the first time I was there. She is a middle aged Caucasian lady. Thought about going in there tomorrow for donuts but might just shoot over to the National name brand chain instead. Would have rated 2 stars instead of 3 but the donuts are really good when they are available read more

went to get something from the bakery at 4:15 on a Thursday and they were closed. supposed to be open until 5:30. I guess not???

this bakery deserves more than five stars the price is so inexpensive it blows my mind, id pay triple for the quality of their products. i know damn well this was made w love ... or crack some thing addicting (KIDDING.... abt the crack) read more

Amazing, I was craving donuts and my partner told me about this shop that he would go with his Dad. I had to order one of each. Orange chiffon cake Banana bread cinnamon bun topped with chocolate a couple donuts too The place is clean The staff was super friendly I plan to come back here. read more

Schusters Banquet Bakery - They make the best cake, pies and cookies here - Donuts Near Me - Pueblo, Colorado

See all

Delicious donuts and pastries at a great price! Don't let the line outside the door fool you, it goes quickly and worth the short wait.

Took an orange chiffon cake, cookies and donuts to a company Christmas meeting/party which was a life saver for me to not have to cook. Everyone liked everything. I have had the orange chiffon a couple times now and I just dont like it but I know others do. I imagine that it is one of those cakes that people grow up on so it is familiar to them but to me it just tastes like sugar, and not in a good way. The donuts were super fresh and the cookies were decent. read more

I was already hearing the hype about Schuster's from the locals around town so I threw the fam in the car and headed over. Ordered half a dozen and as soon as I left was already regretting not ordering 6 more! Got home, poured myself a cup a joe, grabbed my bag o goodness and wow! The glazed doughnut is always how you tell a place has skills and these glazed were delicious, sugary circles of heaven! I also loved their chocolate banana cake doughnut and raspberry sugar doughnut. Price was very reasonable. Def be back and ordering a dozen next time! read more

So glad that there is at least one place in Pueblo that enforces social distancing and mask wearing! Great baked goods, too!

Wow. A yummy old fashioned shop that prefer over all the new fancy donut shops! So so good! The powder cake ones are perfection! Crispy with moist cake so full of the perfect flavor! Then the powdered sugar all over is beyond tasty! The prices you can't beat either!! read more

Delicious donuts and baked goods at great prices!!! Parking is a little tricky but super fast and friendly service

doughnuts were good but not much of a selection.. they also don't have doughnut holes and it didn't seem to know what they were.

Delicious. Very affordable. Very friendly. We had doughnuts, turnovers, and sour dough bread. Highly recommend!

This is by far the best bakery and doughnuts ever!! I recommend!! Yummy!. I can't wait to get some more.

Schuster's Banquet Bakery is an absolute staple of Pueblo. I grew up visiting this bakery for weekend treats and they've made many celebratory cakes for my family for birthdays and graduations. If you're stopping in, I would recommend picking up long-John donuts, cupcakes, frosted sugar cookies (OG are pumpkin and shamrock cookies) and an orange chiffon cake. I've never been disappointed in any item from this classic bakery, but these are my go-to staples, my favorite being the frosted sugar cookies! read more

I love this hometown Pueblo Bakery. I have called several times for frosted sugar cookies with a special design and they have graciously accommodated our personalized cookies every time. The bakers are talented and the staff very pleasant! Thank you for making Pueblo sweeter! read more

I bought potica. I grew up having my grandmother and aunts make Potica and it was wonderful. I spent $20 and can't eat it. It is all sugar. Such a shame. Since Steve died, it has not been the same. read more

First time there and it was great. Food awesome staff friendly and helpful. Will be back very soon and often I am sure. Prices a great as well. read more

Schusters is most aptly comparable to the Soup Nazi on Seinfeld. Their product is amazing, but their customer service absolutely sucks. It's not a single employee- it's an institutional/cultural thing. They don't need to be good at serving clients because we will keep coming back again and again regardless. In a city with little to no competition, this business model works. If there was any other decent place to get a birthday cake or iced cookies, I would go there and would immediately rescind my loyal patronage to this spot. But for now, for each birthday, Halloween, and grad party, I will keep crawling back to my abuse lover, Schusters, who treats me bad most of the time, but has the most amazing icing ever. read more

When my husband and I moved to Pueblo back in January, we never thought we'd find a place like this. We were asked to bring dessert to a party at the last minute. I had no time to make something, so I yelped bakeries around. First we went to another "trendy" bakery... but I wasn't about to pay 1.50 a cookie or 20 for a cake. I'm SO glad I wrote down the address to Schusters. Not only did we get two dozen cookies but also some donuts, and didn't even break the bank. I've been craving donuts since last July. But, there is a big difference between super processed donuts and the ones they make. When I got home and my husband and I were diving into what I call an Eclair and they call something else, idk, that I was disappointed that I had only bought two of them. I wanted like 10. This place is such a gem! read more

A nice little bakery in Pueblo! Looks like it is straight from the 60s or something, and the people working there are also nice like they are from the 60s. Price is very affordable, which is good (because you can buy a lot without draining your wallet) and bad (you have the tendency to buy too much around the holidays...and therefore eat too much!). This place is highly recommended for any of your bakery needs! read more

The baked goods are awesome--I will give them that but the customer service sucks! I offered to PAY THEM to decorate a small round (anniversary) cake and they REFUSED. I was told I had to buy a SHEET cake for any type of decoration... They did not and would not take my money to put a LEAF on the cake... On another ocassion, I went to pick up a cake I had ordered (at the agreed pick up time) and they told me that "I should KNOW that the cake decorator doesn't even arrive at that time so how could I expect the cake to be ready?" She also "suggested I make a note of the cake decorator's schedule so next time I call to set a pick up time I don't set it outside of those hours" instead of saying WE WILL INFORM OUR STAFF of the PICK UP TIMES that are AVAILABLE. Then, she would NOT take my money so that my sister-in-law could pick up the cake at a later time (since I had already left work early to go pick up the cake and could not leave again). I only go because my husband grew up in this town and he LOVES that place. I like their goods but boy do they need some customer service classes. read more

Not only can you not depend on this place to get your order correct, you can't even depend on them to make your order at all. Horrendous customer service. We put in an order of sugar cookies for my niece's birthday (three weeks in advance) that the manager told us they "never got." We'll take our business elsewhere from here on out--in fact, Jake's Cakes has great baked goods and stellar customer service. read more

I ordered cookies to send to my daughter in another state. I was never given a time to be there to pick up and they called an hour before close to see if I still wanted them. Of course I still wanted my order. I didn't make it in time that day, went back to pick up my order the next day and was told they already sold them. After speaking with the owner, she was completely rude and had nothing to say other than "sorry". Next time I'm ordering from Hopscotch bakery. read more