Order: Shrimp Po Boy, Blackened Fish Tacos
Price: $39
Positives: There's a really nice view
Negatives: The food it just wasn't good. It was super oily, very expensive for what you got, and pretty bland.
tldr: I wouldn't really recommend Rum Runners to anyone. There food was so oily we didn't finish it all, and there was really almost no flavor to try and help. They do have a good view, but it's Saint Croix, there's great views anywhere.
Thoughts: Rum Runners had been high on the list of suggestions both from Yelp and from a few people we talked to. It also happened to be Christmas day so a lot of other places were closed and so we ended up here. We arrived early enough that it was a late lunch, because we assumed that things were going to very busy for Christmas dinner. We grabbed a seat and ordered the blackened fish tacos and shrimp Po boy. Service was pretty quick and we got our food within about 15 to 20 minutes. Unfortunately that's really where the good news about the food ends. The shrimp for the Po boy was so over-breaded I couldn't have guessed what it was supposed to be. It was more like deep fried breading than fried shrimp. To make it worse the breading was pretty dried out and didn't really have any flavor. The fish tacos were just as bad. They were unbelievably oily. Like, when I bit into one side of the taco, oil ran out the other side onto the plate. By the time I had finished eating my tacos there was practically a puddle of oil on the plate. And the fish didn't even have any flavor. I genuinely think the only thing that both the Poboy and tacos tasted of was oil. For $40 I definitely want more than A bland fried sandwich and two super greasy tacos.
If there is any good news about Rum Runners it's the view; the view really is fantastic. You sit only a few feet above water level at the bay in Christiansted and the water comes almost right up to your feet. You definitely won't get wet, unless maybe it's a very blustery day, but it really is a great view and feels like you were eating practically on the water. But that's it; and to be honest, you're on Saint Croix, so there are great views everywhere.
I'm really not sure how or why Rum Runners has such high reviews. I wouldn't give it a one star review, because we didn't walk out of the restaurant, but I would definitely never go back. In fact during a different day on our visit to the island, Rum Runners was one of the only places open when we needed to get food. Rather than go back to Rum Runners we instead opted to to get sandwich supplies from a grocery store. read more