We had an excellent evening! We sat at the bar, because it was a full house, and met Angela. Every one of her recommendations were spot on, from the Seafood Bouillabaisse, the Kale Caesar salad, the house blend wine and the crème brûlée for dessert. Great Birthday evening! read more

FOOD POISON ALERT!!!DO NOT ORDER THE LOBSTER!!!! BEWARE!!!!!! Keisha The Manager Could Careless.. They Had a dirty house fan blowing smoke and fumes from the cooking area in our face.. Came for a birthday party.. Ordered the 8 ounce lobster with mashed potatoes and asparagus. Halfway through the meal, it was discovered that the lobster was Raw and uncooked. We told the waiter and he snatched the food up when he came back. He advised us that they will take it off the order. No apologies or nor did he ask if the customer wanted anything else to eat..The person that ordered the lobster only ate a small portion, but they mistakenly ate some of the Raw Lobster..So they were still hungry and nothing was done. Mind you it was a party so everyone ate except for this young lady. The manager never came over to apologize nor did the waiter apologize. After the meal was done I had to call the manager to the front. Keisha came and was very short. I advised her that raw lobster carries parasites and bacteria that can cause food poisoning. I asked why she never came to the table to check on her customer.. Keisha advise she lets the server handle those type of problems. Keisha's attitude reflected the raw food that was served. When I ask her for her card she refuse to give me any kind of information but her name..Not only did they serve a customer raw food that contaminated the whole plate.. The customer left Hamilton's hungry and woke up having to vomit.. Didn't ask us for contact information or give us any. All they will do is any this review which doesn't fix her eating RAW food , not being offered anything else to eat and not caring that someone eat an contaminated meal with no information to contact them..Horrible leadership..Horrible food...Horrible People..Do Not Eat At Hamilton's...This review will also be posted to Facebook.. read more

Hamilton’s - The still managed to take a 20% tip even though the served raw contaminated for to the party..Leaving the party member hungry and sick.. - American Near Me - Christiansted, Virgin Islands

When you manage to get a reservation here through IG, you won't be sorry. When you get there, however, take a breath and settle in. Service is great, but they are not at a frenetic pace. It's kinda like you're the passenger in a ride in the countryside and they have the wheel. Which is a good thing! Let go of your A-type personality and let it happen. Again, you won't be sorry. One of the reasons it is more of an experience is the chef is making the meal perfectly. I had THE BEST STEAK. I would rank it in the top three I've ever had. Cooked perfectly. The ambiance is casual. We dressed up a little because (collared shirt and long pants for me). I'm glad I did. The place had a little bit of an upscale vibe. read more

See all

Great food, ambience was very refreshing and sophisticated,our server was phenomenal. Service was exceptional. Love this place.

5 star dinner experience! Upon walking in you are graciously greeted for your patronage. Staff is extremely friendly, courteous and attentive. Open dining room concept with neutral colors and warm lighting. Food is amazing! We ordered the Surf & Turf, Seafood Pasta and Open Shrimp Sandwich on home made crostini. Costs are moderately higher than other restaurants but the prices matches the quality & portion size of the dishes. Service was impeccable and the choices of desserts were delectable. Restaurant is both cozy, casual but can be romantic for that special occasion. Big Fan! read more

See all

Hamiltons came highly recommended so we decided to make a reservation for our first night in st. Croix. The service was great and they were accommodating with our lateness due to flight delay. I didn't order drinks, only food. The food was disappointing as there was no flavor. I ordered the seafood pasta and I continuously had to keep adding salt. My bfs dish was the same, cooked well but lacking seasoning. Because of that, we did not feel this was a good bargain because it is rather expensive. read more

This place was remarkable. The experience was amazing like none others I hadn't had in a while. I was trying to make a reservation prior but was unable to since I'm so used to OpenTable so when my daughter and I arrived on Sunday for her birthday dinner before we left the island we were told there was no availability however when we went to exit the angel of a manager Dwayne made preparations for us to be seated and served for that I am so grateful. The waiters Kevin and Alex were so nice and courteous continuously checking on us to make sure everything was to our liking. Also their bartender was so sweet and funny though I didn't get his name. The atmosphere was great I absolutely recommend. The art and history was beautiful. You must go to this restaurant if you visit experience 10/10 with great pricing as well! read more

See all

Service left a lot to be desired! One meal came about 10-15 minutes after the rest of us were served! My meal was cold before I got to eat it! One person sent back his lobster as it was too tough to eat. No apologizes or visit from a manager! The place is quaint inside, but I'd pass! read more

Wonderful ambiance. Great service. Spectacular food. My husband had a 16oz steak that was cooked to perfection. I normally wouldn't write a review about a salad, but their caesar salad was one of rhetorical best I've ever had. It has the perfect amount of dressing! I would say given it's a main course, the salad wasn't that big, but it worked. read more

Hamilton’s - American Near Me - Christiansted, Virgin Islands

See all

Food was good but service was slow. The biggest issue was that the open concept kitchen does not have good aspiration and the smell and the fumes are all over the dining area. The few AC units are not enough to cool the rooms as well. read more

I understand that the meat dishes are good, but I tried a bouillabaisse that had zero flavor, effort or taste. This should not have left the kitchen read more

We made reservations here for a party of 13, the night before my son's wedding. The food, drinks and service were excellent! I would definitely go here again if I am ever in the area. read more

Amazing food! We sat at the bar for dinner twice while on the island and had a fantastic experience both times. The seafood pasta is standout and so is the mahi with curried couscous! Great wines also! Don't hesitate to dine here. read more

The food at Hamilton's in downtown Christiansted, St. Croix is always spot on and the servers are clearly trained well. Definitely fine dining with a relaxed and casual atmosphere. Drinks are great, too! read more

Hamilton’s - Surf & turf. - American Near Me - Christiansted, Virgin Islands

We went based on reading some reviews and it did not disappoint. We had truffle Mac and cheese, a burger and mushroom risotto and the best French 75 I've ever had. 10 out of 10 read more

Higher end ambiance with a true passion for service and scrumptious food. Everyone is so friendly, helpful, and this is a must dine experience. Excellent selection of bourbons and wines. Did I mention the food is super yummy?!? read more

Come for the Cocktails, Stay for the Food!!! And the ambiance is top-level as well, especially the art work that brightens up the walls. Trust me, Hamilton's will not disappoint. A visit to St. Croix isn't complete without experiencing Hamilton's or, as was my case, three visits in a week. read more

Waited 20 mins to get a bottle of sparkling water, even though the waitress walked past our table about 10 times before deciding to multi-task and bring a bottle in her hand. The open faced shrimp toast appetizers were over-salted, and served on horrible bread that was stale & tough. It took over 30 mins to bring our appetizer. The mains were so-so. My ribeye steak was barely room temperature, and I had to send it back for re-heating. It took over 45 mins between finishing our appetizer & the main course coming. Not once did a wait staff come over to check on how the meal was. And the food was not great. I've eaten at Hamilton's many times in the past years that I've been visiting St Croix. Incredibly disappointed... read more

I've been eating here since it first opened about 4 years ago. Consistently good food and they have a wonderful wine selection. The Spanish Gin & Tonic is the best on the island. The only negative I can see is the menu is limited if you're a vegetarian, consequently it's not my wife's favorite spot. read more

Tried several ways to get a reservation. Left a voicemail. Sent an IG message and even stopped in in person. No one ever contacted me to tell me yes or no. Decided to give it a try at the bar. Cool, contemporary but yet still laid back atmosphere. The young lady at the hostess stand was polite and friendly as was Akevie at the bar. Excellent craft cocktails. Goat cheese salad was terrific. Tuna bite appetizer special was mid. The fish was a little on the dry side and a few pieces were fishy, as though it wasn't as fresh as it should have been. I might go back if a friend really wants to go. But there are definitely other places in Christiansted I prefer. read more

This is our, I couldn't even tell you how many times we've been already, trip to Hamilton's! We absolutely adore everything about this restaurant! The food is always spectacular, and the servers and hostess are always such sweet, courteous people! The filet is one of our go-tos. The meat, the presentation, and the little garlic butter candle lit on top are just perfect! Specifically, this past visit, there were multiple birthdays celebrated all on one night from different guests in the restaurant, and each time 'Happy Birthday' was sung, the energy boosted, and the entire restaurant clapped, cheered, and whistled! Everyone who works there has a vibe that's just on another level, and it feels like some other beautiful world inside! Our server tonight, Victor, was the most amazing, genuine, sweetest soul we've met on island! Victor was so attentive to us and wanted to make sure we had the best experience, as my partner and I celebrated our anniversary recently, Hamilton's is always on our list of restaurants on our tour around the island. read more

Hamilton’s - Filet - American Near Me - Christiansted, Virgin Islands

We've been loyal customers of this restaurant for over 5 years and have always enjoyed the consistently great food and luxurious atmosphere. Unfortunately, today was the first time I left disappointed and questioning whether we'll return. It was uncomfortably hot inside, and when we politely asked if the air could be turned down, a woman (not our server) came over with a noticeable attitude and said, "It's on 68--you're just hot because you're by the kitchen." I've sat in that same seat at least 20 times before and have often felt cold, so her response felt dismissive and unnecessary. I would've appreciated honesty or at least a more courteous tone. The food was great. However- To top it off, our dessert took about 20 minutes to arrive, which added to the overall frustration. What used to feel like a high-end, welcoming experience didn't feel that way today. I really hope this was just an off day, but it was disappointing enough to make me rethink coming back. read more

Loved the atmosphere! A truly beautiful restaurant. The decor was very impressive! Every detail was considered: down to the lime in our cocktail being branded with their logo. We were able to get a same day reservation by eating at 5pm, when they open. We had the entire place to ourselves, except for 3 people at the bar. The wine options are extensive, cocktails are limited, but beer selections were poor. According to our server, she said they only had Bud and Bud lite in a bottle. No drafts. Nevertheless, the food was well presented and tasty. We had the lobster tail, mahi-mahi, and brownie for dinner. Best cuisine on the island for this type of eatery. Giving it 4 stars because the service was disappointing considering we were the only ones for an hour! read more

See all

fantastic! from appetizers to salad to main dish to dessert to adult beverages. this place got all the details. victor was a terrific waiter who was attentive without being intrusive. we had the mussels, more than I've seen on an appetizer and really delicious. also had the arugula date salad, perfect with just the right amount of zing. bouillabaisse was amazing! hubbys chicken with blueberry could have used a bit more blueberry zing but the chicken was flavorful. desserts- crème brulee yummy as well as a berry lemon sorbet so delicious. this was the BEST restaurant we found in st croix read more

Had a fantastic experience at Hamilton's this evening. Service was fabulous and the food was great. We will definitely return on our next visit to St Croix! read more

The island has a few excellent places that are perfect for date night or a great dinner at the bar. This is one of the top ones. It's a nice, elegant spot with a great vibe. I've been here a few times on various trips now. Food is top notch, I usually get a special... especially if Tuna is on the menu. ** My only complaint is the bar service gets a little slow as the tables fill... . This is true for a lot of nice restaurants serving a lot of mixed drinks, so I didn't ding them on this. read more

Three couples enjoyed dinner at Hamilton's recently. We made a reservation and our table was ready when we arrived. The service was excellent. Victor described the specials and answered questions about other entrees. Among our group we ordered the lobster, filet mignon, chicken, seafood pasta and the mahi. Everyone agreed that their meal was delicious. Salads and clam chowder were also good. Truffle mac and cheese was so good. We shared the crème brûlée for dessert. This was one of the best meals we had on the island and we look forward to returning here! read more

First time visiting St Croix and we were told this is a must visit for an above average dinner on the island. They did not disappoint. Just be prepared to spend some money as this is not a beach bar style and the meals are very good. Our waiter Alfred was great. Very attentive to the table. Great personality and easy to joke around with. The GM greated us at the door (forgot her name) and was very friendly and welcoming. She was actually opening the restaurant as we arrived. Unless many fancy high end locations the portions here were plenty big enough. All four of our meals and the apps were delicious. The lobster tail was cooked perfectly, the steak and seafood the same. If you are a bourbon fan, this place has the stuff you can not find anywhere else on the island. read more

Great spot good menu good service very convenient to the boardwalk and in the heart of old Christiansted

While I applaud the attempt to bring another fine-dining choice to Christiansted, the execution leaves a lot to be desired. Nice open-kitchen concept and a good-looking menu leaning toward steak and fish. It took 2.5 hours to get through our meal, and it tasted like my mahi entree might have been cooking that long. Couscous was so salty it was inedible. Arancini appetizer was wonderful and goat cheese salad was nice. Mushroom risotto was an enormous portion of overcooked paste (not a typo for "pasta," this was paste) with maybe three mushrooms included. Oddly, hostesses made other diners sit at the bar despite 90% of the tables being empty even after our lengthy sitting. read more

Enjoyed a delicious dinner and drinks tonight - House Paloma, Caesar salad, Cioppino, and a mango, guava &berry dessert that tasted like the island in a glass! A lovely restaurant with friendly, attentive staff! read more

Hamilton’s - American Near Me - Christiansted, Virgin Islands

Food was excellent, and the service was outstanding. It wasn't crowded the evening we were there. Very much enjoyed the ambience.

Excellent food and atmosphere! My wife and I came in as walk-in and they were able to accommodate us (they'd just opened for the evening). We enjoyed a Rib-Eye special and the Lobster tail. Both came with an exceptionally well prepared asparagus side. Definitely worth going out of your way to visit for an upscale dinner for two or lager groups. Definitely make reservations when you can. read more

See all