We absolutely LOVED our dinner here--and that's saying something for our crazy party of seven! It's the first place we've visited in Orange Beach where everyone agreed they loved their meal. We ordered the lasagna, chicken parmesan, walnut cranberry salad with chicken, chicken alfredo, cheese bread, spinach dip, and a pepperoni pizza, and every dish was a hit. We sat outside, which made for an absolutely delightful evening. Even the music playlist was great and had us all humming along. The service was friendly and attentive, and the prices were very reasonable compared to other dinners we've had in the area. Overall, we highly recommend this place and would happily come back on our next trip! read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Sampling of our appetizers - Pizza Near Me - Orange Beach, Alabama

See all

I visited this restaurant during a girl's trip with my bestie to Orange Beach. It was conveniently located near where we were staying. We were quickly seated after entering. Our server was friendly and patient while we looked over the menu. However, service was rather slow and the restaurant wasn't really crowded. We weren't in a hurry so we waited patiently on our drinks and food. We each ordered our own small pizza since we wanted different toppings. She ordered the bacon cheeseburger pizza, I ordered the garden Alfredo pizza. Both pizzas were good, but I liked hers better. My toppings looked like they had been thrown on the pizza without regard to where they fell. We agreed that we had eaten better pizza but overall, it wasn't bad. The star of the evening was the chocolate chip brownie. We enjoyed this decadent dessert! The ambiance was cool and bustling and I could see it being family oriented, good for date night or a good spot to catch a game on tv. I would return on a future visit to the area if I were in the mood for pizza. Try them out. Happy Eating! read more

See all

Food was awesome!!! I got a calazone and...damn it was good!!! Went during the slowish time so only few employees but service was good. Decor was like a sports bar pretty cool!! read more

Incredible service and quality of food tonight from this location. They were absolutely slammed with it being ncaa tournament; spring break; and a Saturday at that. Not only did they get the order done early, it was perfect. read more

Went here to get a pizza for my family of five. The pizza is apparently Detroit style, so it's cut into squares and is fairly small. That being said, after eating one slice, I had already felt like I'd eaten two slices of a regular pizza. It was good, though I don't prefer it. The garlic bites were mid, but the marinara was DAMN good. I could eat a bucket full of it. Anyway, I got it to go and had my mom pick it up so I am unaware of how the service is. I'm unsure of the ambiance as well, but I'll just assume both were decent since my mother didn't complain. 7/10, would come again. read more

We picked a very busy night to order pizza to go and had a wait 30 minutes past our pick up time but well worth it!

Great carry out service and pizzas were delicious! Also, great help with quantity when I called to ask how many pizzas to order for 26 people!! read more

Excellent pizza - we ordered on their website - three personal pizzas and the cranberry walnut salad. The only disappointment was that when I arrived at the projected time, the pizzas weren't in the oven yet. And there didn't seem to be any function for their online ordering system to let me know of the delay. read more

Rotolo's was AWESOME! We got one of the Large Combination Pizza's, highly recommend. Great service as well. When we are back in the area, we will definitely go back. read more

Our server was very nice and the food was tasty as always. The wait time, however, was very long. We got 8 wings and a large pepperoni pizza and waited 45 minutes for this. They weren't busy at all, especially considering we went at 5pm. We normally order to go and we will probably stick to that in the future, because we do enjoy the food! read more

Rotolo's was one of our favorite stops. The garlic Parmesan bites were a surprise hit--crispy and delicious! The Meats pizza was also really good. Only downside was the very slow service. Another server offered an explanation, but it didn't really add up. Still, the food made it worth it. They have large TVs which helped somewhat with the wait for the food. read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Meat Feast Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orange Beach, Alabama

Our group came here for dinner our last night in Orange Beach. We were seated quickly, which was a blessing after a weekend of waitlists. Food was really good; we got two pizzas, a sandwich, wings, pasta, and two appetizers. However, our waitress seemed to be having a really difficult time. The service was genuinely super awkward, and it took so long for her to get a sentence out. She also kept getting our order wrong while taking it, and I think it took about 10 minutes for all 5 of us to order. If we're in town, I wouldn't mind takeout because the food was pretty solid! read more

Yes it's a chain restaurant, but they serve quality pizza. Large dinning room that can accommodate families and large groups. We often visit this restaurant when we're at the beach. Our server was not the best on this last trip but was still adequate. Management was helping the servers to make sure needs were met also. The salad and pies were yummy. One of the better side salads we've had in a while. Crust is a little thicker than the brick oven places, but had good chew. Several specialties, or can choose your own toppings. read more

See all

I thought the pizza was alright. It would pass for an average pizza but nothing over the top about it. The staff was friendly. The ambiance of the place was meh. It's probably few decades old and no one updated the interiors. Good thing they do half and half pizza cuz if we got 2 pizzas it would be no hood. read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Under carriage of the pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orange Beach, Alabama

See all

Vacation stop! Well worth it! Family talked about it rest of vacation. Service was weird and waitress gave off the impression she would rather be sitting on couch somewhere. But pizza was awesome! read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Orange Beach, Alabama

pizza was good other than the fact that there was not one, not two, not even three, but four hairs in my pizza.

Pizza was very good. Cheesesticks were amazing. They are a must get. Service was decent

The pizza looked exactly as pictured and was hot and very tasty! We would definitely order again!

this place is so homey and the service is great!!! prices are so reasonable and the food felt home cooked :) 10/10 recommend for quality and comfort!! read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - spaghetti and meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Orange Beach, Alabama

Food was ready when ordered. Remember the pizza lunchables .. that's what the pizza sauce tastes like. Was skeptical of it looking at reviews. I would pass read more

If you like sweet sauce, you'll like this place. Nice atmosphere, decent pizza. Served hot and fresh. Great weekday specials. read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Specialty pizza deluxe combination. - Pizza Near Me - Orange Beach, Alabama

Food is good but this place is poorly managed. Quote an hour for pickup pizza on a Saturday in October. I get here after waiting the hour just to be told sorry it's going to be another 30 minutes. The poor lady in front of me was just denied food because they can't catch up as is. Stop taking DoorDash as first priority and take care of the customers in front of you or you won't have any Edit: I finally got my food after waiting another 30 minutes making the grand total 2 hours and 3 minutes to make 2 calzones, 8 wings and a small salad. Several people got refunds and left without food, others were told "you're in the oven now, it'll be 20 minutes" and legend has it they are still waiting 20 minutes. I won't be back because I was told that tonight was the best they can do. If that's the best you can do, find something else to do read more

We craved pizza, and they came thru. I downloaded their app and ordered easily on it. We drove and picked it up. The inside was nice, so I think next time, we will eat there. read more

Tried a bunch of stuff today, all was excellent. The Meatball Appetizer and its gravy were incredible. Same for the Detroit Style Pizza. Love that stuff! read more

This was our 1st time here as we were in a rush to get home. This place is a little pricey & for the taste vs price we will not be going back. Service & the location is great! read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orange Beach, Alabama

Very busy ! Stood up front for a few minutes but then seated. We ordered garlic Parmesan bites, they were cold and hard. Waitress was too busy so we didn't bother to say anything. Pizza was delicious & very fulfilling! Very clean place. Friendly staff! read more

We stopped here for dinner so our son could get some pasta and we could check out the pizza. The cheese bread was really good and came with really good marinara. We got the supreme pizza and it was also really good. The server was attentive and the inside was super clean and it was pretty busy but not a long wait time. Highly recommend it if you are in orange beach. read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Orange Beach, Alabama

See all

TO ALL THE PIZZA, WINGS, AND CHEESE LOVERS!!!! If you're in the area, you need to come try this place! 1. I ordered the 8 piece wings as an appetizer. The flavor is called "Sweet Heat". I like spicy however, on a scale from 1-10, I would say the "heat" is a 2. Still very flavorful, crispy on the outside, tender on the inside. 9/10 recommend!! 2. The cheesesticks ordered were the original. Can't go wrong with these. You can add jalapeño or pepperoni, however, we wanted to try it as is. The cheese is not overwhelming, it paired better with ranch than with the marinara in my opinion. Try it with both! 8/10 recommend!! 3. THE PIZZA!!! We ordered the deluxe and added jalapeños and pineapple. (Yes, pineapples belong on pizza). I've been to places where the pizza is extremely soggy and the cheese just falls off. This is NOT the case here. It's filling and tasty in ALL the right ways!! 9/10 recommend!! This was my FIRST time here and I will say the service was exceptional considering there were only two servers and it was busy. Super family friendly atmosphere. I will 100% be coming back!! read more

See all

Worst pizza I've ever eaten from a restaurant. The pizzas lacked flavor and were so overcooked we werent sure which pizza was which (cheese or pepperoni). It was hot and ready 15 minutes earlier than promised so I'm glad i was there early. It was as fresh as possible as our condo was right next door. read more

Went here with friends after looking online for a pizza place nearby. We were greeted & seated right away. Casual atmosphere & sports games playing on several screens. A girl came over & took our order right away. Our salads came quickly. We had the green salad with walnuts, cranberries & feta with a creamy raspberry dressing. Very good! However, two of us were sharing one of the salads & the salad was not split & our waiter said she'd bring us a plate....never did, so we took turns eating the salad. By the time we finished our salads, our drinks had still not arrived. Finally, I got up and found the woman who seated us and told her our waiter had not brought us our drinks. She said she'd take care of it. About 4 minutes later, our waiter brought the drinks. Right after that, she brought our pizza. We ordered the Popeye pizza. We ordered the Large 14" size. The pizza had cheese, red peppers, onions & spinach....not a lot on it, but a very good pizza & dough is delicious!! We had to ask for drink refills & our waiter did offer "to go" refills & lids (which we took her up on) when she brought our bill. I'd definitely go back even though our particular server wasn't great. read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Popeye pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orange Beach, Alabama

Ordered to go. Busy place! The staff member handling the orders was ON IT! She was polite but no nonsense and kept staff moving. My pizza was done on time and it was a very tasty pie that we had for several meals. read more

Great service on a busy evening. Almost all the tables were taken inside but you wouldn't have known because we didn't wait for anything. Tasty pizza and the daughter loved it! read more

Pretty decent. The calzone was off the charts. I've seen complaints on here that there wasn't enough cheese or toppings but I got to admit that this was pretty damn good. It had the right amount of everything and well. Yeah it was a little doughy. I was pretty happy with it. The hummus was OK, however, the dessert pizza left a lot to be desired. It really just felt like a super high profit add on and didn't really have much taste or flavor. read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Hummus - Pizza Near Me - Orange Beach, Alabama

See all

Gave a Rotolo's a shot on my last trip down to Orange Beach, and overall if you are in the pinch for a pizza craving there are far worst options. The deep dish pizza was freshly made, but a tad on the dry side so take advantage of the sauce the give you. Their cheesesticks, an afterthought at some restaurants, were far and beyond some of the best I have ever had and I highly recommend them! Ordered out, so can't speak to the atmosphere within the restaurant itself, but the service could use some improvements; first, they took my phone number wrong on my order and if I hadn't had gone on a hunch the food was finished I wouldn't have ever known it was ready. They were very friendly, but just a tad too carefree. read more

Absolutely the best pizza!! The toppings were fresh. The pizza was cooked perfectly and the crust was delicious! The only negative is that the service was terrible. They did give us cool plastic to go cups which we now use a lot at home. read more

Staff was helpful and courteous. $25 large Deluxe pizza was so-so : dry (not much sauce,) ingredients were sparse and lots of dough... Not good enough for the price. read more

Susan was very nice! Bayou BBQ Chicken pizza was very good. I'd get more BBQ sauce next time. read more

Our last day at the beach and wanted to try a new restaurant. After some online research, we decided in Rotolo's. I downloaded their app and got $5 off our first purchase. Hubby had their lasagna and said it was very good. I fad spaghetti with marinara sauce, and it was also very good. Nice and friendly staff. Glasses tried it. We will go back the next we are in the area. read more

I was looking for a place to take food to go and found the reviews off of yelp for this place. I sat at the bar and ordered a pizza and Caesar salad to go. As I waited, the bartender was really attentive and kept checking on me while I waited. The drinks are pretty good and the pours are not on the lighter side. Haha. The pizza was amazing. We decided to get a half and half order of pepperoni on one side and then pepperoni, bacon and jalapeño on the other half. If you want delicious pizza, I recommend stopping in. You won't be disappointed! read more

This is one of our favorite spots when we go to Orange beach. They have one of the best pizzas in town. They're reasonably priced, great atmosphere and as always greeted with a smile. It's definitely a popular spot. read more

See all