Rosati's is my absolute favorite pizza place. I found it by searching Yelp and reading reviews others left. I use this restaurant exclusively for pizza. Their thin crust pizza reminds me of the handmade pizzas you used you get at restaurants in Chicago before thick doughy bread crusts became the fad! Their seasoning makes me smile and remember pizza night in High School. Pizza was a treat in our soul food home so we were quite picky about them. I just feel like giggling and kicking my shoe-less feet under the table when I'm eating a Rosati's pizza. I even have them cut it in squares the only way pizzas were ever cut when I was a kid. read more

I love Rosatis and have been eating it since I lived in Chicagoland as a child. There's nothing exactly wrong with this pizza, but when I added green peppers and onions, I did not anticipate massive chucks like this. This was saus, pepp, mush, onion, and green peppers like a basic supreme. These pieces are ridiculously sized if you ask me and totally throw off the flavor. It's tastes like onions and peppers only. No thanks. read more

Rosati's Pizza - 18" pizza Thin Crust Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin

Yeah. won't be ordering ever again from there. ordered a meal with a deep dish, pasta, and Tiramisu dessert only to find a huge clump of hair embedded in the dessert. I'm tempted to contact the health department honestly. It means whatever vendor or process they use seriously has food safety issues. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Clump of hair inside sealed dessert - Pizza Near Me - Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin

Oh my gosh !what happened ? Ordered a pizza ..soggy , yet burned . Sausage on whole pizza , which we asked for only half of it . What ..no cheese on the outer slices ? . Pizza placed in the box without the 'netting" so the inside of the box was tearing trying to get our pieces out . Yuck . I don't like cardboard in my pizza . My goodness ! I will have to find a new pizza place in Menomonee falls wi read more

I did not have a good experience with your pizza unfortunately. It was very light on cheese and the sauce was very bland and tasted like canned sauce with no seasonings. I'm not sure if it was just a bad day. I really wanted to enjoy it but I was very disappointed along with my crew. read more

I ordered chopped two salads for pick up. The chopped salads were just lettuce with a handful of toppings. The person working at the counter did not know what she was doing. read more

Amazing food and amazing service. Pizzas and salads were ready on time like promised. Deep Dish pizza and Pastas were top notch. Would recommend 100% read more

See all

Service could not be any friendlier. The pizza was ok. I enjoyed the sauce as it wasn't overly sweet. The toppings were plenty but the cheese slid right off the crust on the first bite. The crust was perfect, not to dry or soggy just perfectly in the middle. read more

Late delivery. Called me 25 minutes after latest delivery on range and had my room number wrong. Showed up and asked me to pay even though paid online. I had to show him I paid. Pizza good but Luke warm read more

Rosati's Pizza - Chopped Salad - Pizza Near Me - Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin

See all

We had pepperoni and Windy City pizza. Both the pizzas had the perfect presentation which is the final touch that makes it truly exceptional. It was served hot and fresh, with the toppings arranged appealingly. The crust was golden brown, with a slight char on the bottom. The cheese was melted perfectly and gooey, and the sauce was evenly distributed. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin

See all

Since the pandemic, so over 2 years I have been ordering spaghetti and lasagna for my wife and me as a treat. Usually the container is full, so two meals for me and three meals for my wife. Yesterday I ordered the same...but I noticed that the spaghetti container was only half full, half as much as usual. The lasagna container had a 3" x 3" piece of lasagna, not enough for one meal let alone 2 or 3. I paid $14.99 for that 3 x3 piece. I called and complained and I thought I heard him say it was a mistake and they would deliver another meal. Well, 20 minutes later I get another 3 x 3 piece of Lasagna, oh and two free sodas! Do you think $14.99 is the appropriate price for a 3 x 3 piece of Lasagna and a small piece of garlic bread? We loved Rosatis, but I can't accept their pricing. read more

Rosati's Pizza - $14.99 - Pizza Near Me - Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin

The food is amazing. From the open kitchen. I can see the use fresh ingredients and care about their food. I was helped immediately by a driver. Then watched the driver grab his delivery and deliver with such rapidness. read more

Last week we ordered a pizza for here and it was cold on deliver. So we ordered delivery again this Thursday and they said 1 hour it took 1;44 minutes and thr box was ice cold so was pizza you can take your chances we will never again read more

Terrible customer service, pizza never showed up, owner promised to credit order and never followed through. You also agreed to reimburse me and never did. Not good customer service read more

Website shows four pieces of garlic bread, but you only get two! False advertising. Won't be back! read more

Rosati's Pizza - So, the picture looks like you get four pieces of garlic bread, but you really only get two for $6.25!? Not going back. - Pizza Near Me - Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin

I have got pizza from 4 Rosati's and this was the only one I liked but after the last stop they should have given me my dried out pizzas. I won't be back to any of them. read more

Rosati's Pizza - $13 for a little pasta & two meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin

They make a pretty good pizza. But I have never dealt with a less professional group of people in my life. When patrons are the life-blood of your business I don't expect to be cussed at and hung up on ever!!! I called at 4p.m. and waited on hold for 26 minutes. thinking that they forgot about me I hung up and called back. When the girl answered, I quickly said, "I have a quick question" and she hung up the phone. So I called back to ask for a manager and she said "If you think that I'm lettin' you talk to my manager, your f#$%in' crazy!" I contacted their corporate office in Chicago. They promiced they'd get to the bottom of it. It's been better than 6 weeks and no responce. I will never patronize Rozati's Pizza (ALL LOCATIONS) ever again!!! You'd be wise to do the same. Expensive pizza, Deplorable service, Very Poor Customer service. NOT COOL!!! read more

Pizza was cold by the time it was delivered. Restaurant says they use EatStreet for delivery options (so we ordered on the app) but then when you get in touch with customer service at EatStreet (since after an hour, there weren't any updates about the order being on the way), they tell you that the restaurant is using their own delivery service so to contact them. Woman on the phone was dismissive. "Chicago style pizza" is just a very thick crust dry pizza with barely any sauce and shouldn't be advertised as Chicago style. We paid extra for ranch dipping sauce that wasn't delivered. Two stars because the chopped salad and the dough bites were good. We're from out of town and guess we didn't know any better because most of these reviews are bad too. Wouldn't recommend. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Dry, thick pizza with barely any sauce - Pizza Near Me - Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin

Ordered delivery on their website at 7:45pm. Tried calling the restaurant just to confirm the order went through and they never answered. Delivery driver shows up with my pizza at 11:30am the next day. I obviously tell him I don't want it 12+ hours after I ordered. They still charged my card the night before when the order was submitted. read more

Tried Rosatti's in the Menomonee Falls and I am so very happy I did. I called immediately to thank the staff. I am stuffed like a Pepperoni Pig. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Large thin crust Double Pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin

I have been getting pizza here for many years and it WAS good. Unfortunately, over the past year it has slipped quite a bit - here's some of the issues I've had: pizza undercooked, not done at pick up time, made wrong, refused to honor coupons I just received in the mail. And tonight - pizza was wrong size, wrong ingredients, wrong price. They re-made it which required I come back 30 minutes later, but still it's been a hassle lately. read more

We ordered three four piece chicken dinners and one 4 piece cod dinner. All four dinners were advertised with side salad and fries. They delivered on time and the delivery guy was very pleasant. I took the bag into the house and realized there were only three dinners. None of which contained a salad. I called and said we were missing our cod dinner and all four salads. This is when I was told dinners do not come with salads and that we chose fries. We did not choose fries, We weren't told about the change of menu and paid full price. Had I known it didn't come with salad I'd have ordered one as one of the five of us doesn't eat meat. Upon opening the chicken dinners all were very well over cooked. Once we peeled the burnt skin back there was dry chicken underneath as if it were reheated. The cod was mushy. So very disappointed in this location. read more

My husband and I went to Rosati's for the first time today. We didn't know it really isn't an eat in location, but they did have a couple high tops. We ordered a pepperoni and sausage pizza. It was so good!!! We were very happy with it, and would recommend it to everyone. Thank you for making great pizza! read more

Use the pickup service good pizza good service and friendly staff. Provide lunch for training best pizza in area

Yikes, Rosati's. This review is not for your food, but your service. A coworker and I ordered lunch today at 11:01am using the online ordering site. "Up to 60 minutes" was the estimated arrival. 12:35pm rolls around, and I start to wonder...it was raining, maybe it was busy? Did my order even go through? Was it even coming? So I call the store and am told "oh yeah, its coming...we only have one driver. Its been busy so its taking longer. Thats the bad thing about ordering online, it doesn't tell you that...it should be there soon." If we had been called, we would've just picked it up. But at this point, we just waited. Now it's 1:35pm. Still no food. Starving and hangry. Call again..."oh yeah, its out for delivery, should be there in ten minutes." No apology, nothing. 1:50pm, delivery arrives. Almost three hours later. Driver apologizes after we complain, and tells us HE FORGOT PART OF THE ORDER. He leaves to go back and get it. What the hell?! Needless to say, the food was 3 hours old, dry, cold, soggy. Terrible. For reference, it was just a sandwich, fries and breaded mushrooms. They didn't even remake the food, it was really bad. We called and told the manager to void the order. The manager was the person who answered and didn't apologize every time we called. I was pretty shocked to learn that... This was not okay...it was laughable how terrible this experience was. FYI Rosati's - good food does NOT make up for atrocious customer service. read more

Our work team wanted a good pizza and some folks recommended Rosati's. We ordered on line (their site encourages this for faster results) 2 hours and 2 phone calls later we finally received out pizza 11:43am ordered and 1:45p delivered. But had to literally walk to the drivers door to receive pizza!! This was an unexpected and unhappy experience. read more

I ordered a pizza and some mozz sticks there for a pick up and when I got there at the time I scheduled it for (ordered at 10:06am for 11:15am pick-up) they said the ticket said pick up time was 11:45. This was the second time this happened to me. I showed them both the text confirming the time and the email. I asked for a refund since I couldn't wait the 1/2 hour. The woman at the front desk kept telling me over and over it would be ready at 11:45. I kept repeating that I couldn't wait. She finally said they could have it ready in 12 minutes. I fell for that the first time; not the second. I simply asked for a refund so I could go get my office a different lunch. She gave me a receipt saying it had been refunded, but 3 days later I can see it has not been charged back to my card. So basically, no lunch and they stole $26.00 from me. I can say they will never get my business again, and I'll make sure my company never orders from them, either. read more

We had take out for lunch and the bozo who took the order could not put a name or what the sandwhiches were on each order so we asked how will we know who gets what and we were told to open every one and hand them to the right person. I don't want to man handle everyone's food. Why is this so hard to do ? I don't want to touch everyone's food nor do I want some one opening my food. Are people that stupid that they can't label a sandwhich WTF. Well I had to go thru and touch everyone's food and pass them out. I had the beef on garlic bread with with hot peppers and cheese. All in all it was not bad and tasty for less tha $7.00. It was a decent size for me. Would I go back ? No because they have no idea of what customer service is and the take it or leave it stand is just off putting because I can spend my money at places that can handel a simple request for a big order. By the way they didn't F***k up the order like other people have posted. read more

Its just to expensive, and flavorless, I used to love Rosati's in the 90's and early 2000's but, this was the last time, got a 16 inch pizza, it's as if they forgot the sauce, I had to open a can of marinara sauce at home LOL to add to it, Pizza is the most expensive and the least flavor, did they cut back on no sauce to save money? I don't know but, Pepinos, Alumni Club, DeMarini's even the Art Lounge ( I highly recommend) have way better pizza and cost less, I spent $32 on one of the worst pizza's ever. Not again, I think the company needs to send out reps to check on the franchises and see/taste for themselves how expensive and awful the food is. Staff is nice, but it's barley better than an Orv's. I can get better frozen pizza than this. read more

Took 1hr 30mins to deliver my pizza. When it arrived the delivery guy said he had to pay for it. I asked him why I need to sign for it then and he said he will be reimbursed in the morning???? Complete joke and the pizza was average at best read more

Rosati's Pizza - Don't order unless you can wait 90mins - Pizza Near Me - Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin

Food was 30 min late, pizza was cold and the ranch was everywhere. This is why we normally choose to order from Pepino's (just didn't feel like picking it up tonight). read more

Rosati's Pizza - Food was 30 minutes late, pizza was cold and the ranch was exploded - Pizza Near Me - Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin

I wish I could give ZERO stars for this place, but am forced to provide them with a 1. Ordered pizza online via their own web site and said it would be ready in about 30 minutes. Drive to the store to pick up our food only to be told that the order was not filled and that they were too busy to prepare it --- the woman at the front counter told me that Eat Street (the online order app they use) should have called us and we have to "deal with them" to get my money back. Will never try this specific Rosati's location ever again. read more

Always great service and even better pizza!!! They never get the order wrong and the pizza is always very hot and delicious!

I ordered pizza to be delivered to us for a friend in hospital.They were on time and very pleasant.Pizza was cooked perfect.Great flavor not burnt but crust crisp.I will definitely order from them again. read more

good service, very friendly and great pizza and appetizers. would highly recommend to eat here

The pizza was very dry with No sauce. tried to call and get it replaced or even a refund and they was not customer friendly. I'm not sure what has happened but adjustments needs to be done. read more

Very good service and even better food! Highly recommend! I love the pizza. My favorite in Menominee Falls. And they sell it by the slice so it's great for lunch! read more

The pizza was pretty good, very tasty and very hot when I picked it up. The cashier at the counter was friendly. Just under $27 seems a little high in price for a pizza. read more

Craving pizza late night? Go to the grocery store and get a frozen pizza to make at home instead. I ordered my food for delivery through grub hub at 8:17, on a Friday. My scheduled delivery time was 9:15-9:25. I called them to ask if the delivery driver had left yet with it around 9:45 and they said it "left the restaurant at 9:27". We live 5 minutes from the restaurant. Delivery driver got here at 10 pm. Gluten free crust was terrible and tasted like cardboard. The pizza boxes were soaked through with grease and flimsy. The nearly 2 hour wait was not worth $40 or the food that came. read more

We ordered through their new Slice app on 3-18-22 at 5:17 pm. Told latest delivery 6:27. Chat with slice app at 6:50 and they said out for delivery. At 8:20 chatted again and told again out for delivery. At 8:50 chatted again and told miscommunication with Rosatis and order cancelled. Called Rosatis 8:55 pm and was told we would have a 30.00+ credit. Called 4-1-22 to use credit and told nothing on record. Lost a long time customer. From the sounds of other reviews we are not alone. read more