Very god pizza. My construction crew had worked a very long week, so as a thank you, I ordered 12 pizzas from even odds. I ordered them for pick up at 1115. Mind you, they open around 1030-11. When I arrived, there was no wait..I got my pizzas and took them back to the site. The guys loved the pizza and asked me where I got them from. Long story short, my men loved the pizzas and not a single slice was left. read more

We've been ordering from Even Odds Pizza for some years. Always great pizza and the absolute best sauce!

Even Odds is our families go to for carryout pizza. They have great options and my family loves to order the Detroit style pizza as well. I wish their salads were a bit more interesting but they get the job done nonetheless. I love the crust here which is what makes or breaks pizza in my opinion! read more

The pizza and garlic bread made here is absolutely delicious... I would order it again every time I place an order for either pick up or delivery... I have ordered it several times and I have not been disappointed with the delivery service or the from the original order taker... Well done from the initial phone call to the delivery team... Well done Even Odds Pizza... From a very, very pleased customer DeeDee read more

Fantastic pizza & customer service! Try the Detroit Reuben Pizza, it's amazing. Some of the best pizza in Ozaukee County.

Called in a pizza order and got the pizza within 20 minutes! It was fresh and tasty! Thin crust with a nice sauce and plenty of cheese. $13 for a medium with 3 toppings! Two meals for me! Would definitely order again. read more

Even Odds Pizza - American Hand Tossed or Rustic Thin Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Grafton, Wisconsin

Admittedly, I'm a pizza snob. I can't help it, I was born & raised in Connecticut, which happens to be the Pizza Capital of the USA. So trust me when I say that Even Odds Pizza has the BEST tasting pizza pies, not only in Grafton, but all of Ozaukee and Milwaukee Counties. It's seriously the closest thing to the apizzas from back home that I've found outside of CT. Everything, from the dough/crust, sauce, cheese and toppings, are *chef's kiss* delicious. Fresh tasting, cooked perfectly, and they're the only pizza place out here that will cut the pie into TRIANGLE SLICES (as they should be!) and not squares. My favorite Even Odds order is their rustic thin crust BBQ Chicken pizza. They load up on the toppings but you don't have to worry about it falling apart on you. That rustic thin crust is solid and holds up well. No floppy, gloppy crusts here! Their classic hand tossed pizzas are phenomenal, as well. It's the only place that my daughter will eat the crusts from. Another thing about Even Odds that I love is that they're very involved in helping the community. They are involved in all the "Dine to Donate" fundraising events held by local schools, non-profits, and other local programs. If you're considering pizza for any occasion, whether it's a kid's birthday party, employee appreciation party, or casual night at home, consider ordering from Even Odds! You'll be glad you did! read more

Food is always great but the hours posted online and on the door are wrong. I've frequently attempted to order via phone and online but the employees are closing the business earlier to go home sooner. Modify the hours where they're posted instead of letting customers waste their time. Bad business practice. read more

This pizza is amazing. The delivery is great. My pizzas always arrive early and hot! The flavors are great. The ingredients are fresh and abundant. Portions are worth the money! This is a great pizza -- like I remember pizzas tasting when I was a kid. So worth waiting for!!! read more

If you are a hand-tossed pizza crust fan, do yourself a favor and try Even Odds Pizza in Grafton, WI! So fluffy with so much texture, I enjoy it immensely! Not a piece of cardboard plate to hold the sauce cheese and toppings together! Pricing is very reasonable! read more

Very good service and delicious food. The Detroit style pizza is top notch. Easy to order and getting your food is quick.

Food was good, but one pizza was supposed to be thin crust and came as hand tossed. Able to order ahead on line for pickup. Convenient. Would order again, especially the bacon onion cheese sticks. read more

The pizza tastes like a frozen pizza from the store. The garlic bread is good though.

Always have a good experience with Even and Odds! The delivery is great, and how we usually order online. The pizza is delicious every time - we love the meal deal for the variety of Detroit style and pan tossed - so good! And you have to get the cheese sticks! read more

As good as it gets on the pizza front! I don't live in this area, so I've never been to Even Odds or tried any of their food. Over the weekend however, my family ordered takeout from here, and it was perfection. I'm not much of a pizza person to be honest, but dang this stuff was good. Among the many pies ordered, I most enjoyed the Big Veg. This za was packed with broccoli, spinach, cauliflower, carrot, corn, mushroom, and artichokes. The crust was the perfect combination of dough and crunch and the cheese was a great blend. I also tried to BBQ Chicken that was ordered. It was bursting with sweet, tangy flavors. Let me tell ya, we ordered a lot of pizza and there wasn't a single piece left by the end of the night. Even Odds also does salads, desserts, wings, and garlic breads. I would look forward to ordering from here again next time I'm in the Cedarbrug area! read more

Even Odds Pizza - BBQ Chicken + Big Veg - Pizza Near Me - Grafton, Wisconsin

Ordered a BLT pizza delivered at 6pm less than a mile from restaurant. Got home at 550pm to a cold pizza on my door step and it was not the BLT. See the picture. This is the 3rd chance i have given this place. read more

Even Odds Pizza - Anyone see lettuce and Mayo? - Pizza Near Me - Grafton, Wisconsin

We were randomly looking for a pizza place at 9pm on a Monday night in our air bnb. Found this place on yelp and used their website to order. My mom wanted mostly veg and their website was easy to navigate. We added all the veggies and it said a 45 minute wait for delivery. It was maybe a 30-35 minute delivery. Delicious! Fresh! The delivery guy was very nice. read more

Even Odds Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Grafton, Wisconsin

We were craving pizza but my go to place is closed on Monday's. Unwilling to wait until tomorrow, we decided to try Even Odds in Grafton. They only have pick up and delivery, no dine in. This was fine with us as we had a show we wanted to watch. We decided to go with their XL rustic thin crust, pepperoni, corned beef, onions and pineapple. Don't judge, some people like pineapple on pizza! Something about the salty and the sweet together. The corned beef was my sons idea as he loves corned beef and it's an option for toppings. They said it would be ready in 15-20 minutes. Yay because we were starving! I arrived there in 17 minutes to pick it up and it was ready. I got stuck at a red light and decided I needed to sample a piece. I opened up the box and was surprised by just how thin the rustic thin crust was. It was thinner than a cracker. I grabbed one of the corner pieces and quickly scarfed it down. It was delicious! The crust was thin and crispy. Despite being so thin, it still had enough structure to support the toppings. My son snagged a bunch of pieces before I could get a pic, but I assure you it was pretty. More importantly it was tasty! The sauce was flavorful and the cheese was plentiful! I will definitely be back! read more

Even Odds Pizza - Quick dinner - Pizza Near Me - Grafton, Wisconsin

Very good pizza, great service and clean place. Prices are not bad and we will be back!

Mmmmm best pizza in the area in my opinion and all the delivery drivers are so nice. Would highly recommend. read more

Even Odds Pizza - pepperoni, peppers, and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Grafton, Wisconsin

The young lady at the counter and taking the orders tonight (don't know her name) was extremely friendly, and courteous. Smiles from the moment I walked in! This person deserves a raise!! Pizza is great also! read more

SUPER STOKED to have found this place. On a whim we gave it a try and damn... Where have you been hiding this place?! I have gotten the Detroit style pizzas a few times and they're good, but they need to make room for the pepperoni rolls because holy cow I want to live on those. It's basically a garlic knot, except it's stuffed with cheese and pepperoni!!! plus it comes with marinara sauce for dredging. I don't know what the pepperoni flowers are but if they're like the knots, they're great. Even better about this place I'd say I'd the price. Extremely affordable and piled high with the goods. My wife doesn't eat cheese (I know I know) but they make pizza for her without cheese and she LOVES it! The crust is vegan so if you're looking for a solid vegan pizza that you can add some vegan cheese to later, this is the place. Oh and they deliver but when I did pickup over the phone they told me 15 min?! That's what I'm talking about bay bay!! Pizza is life read more

Always on time. Delivery folks very friendly. Excellent pizza. Buffalo chicken a favorite. Thank you. read more

Food was excellent! For those Detroiters that love Buddy's pizza like we do this filled the bill. Some of us thought better others said a tie. Excellent service! We know pizza and no Mequon area pizza is better or comes close. read more

Great Detroit style pizza. A double with two toppings on each half was $16.49 (no tax!) - leaving two modest eaters with leftovers. A little crisp in the bottom (keep the pizza warm on a sheet once you get it home), carmelized cheese crust on the side and soft chew of the bread in the middle. Good topping options with artichoke as well as bratwurst without upcharge - just simple single pricing on all toppings. Also nice is that half toppings are charged as half toppings unlike some pizzerias we've been to. read more

Absolutely delicious pizza! Fast and courteous service. This last sentence is just to meet the posting requirement.

Take out or delivery to our surprise. When we talked in we asked for a menu-kid at the counter said TVs are turned off and we don't have any menus maybe go to our website to see a menu We went back to the car figured out our order and called it in. 1/2 hour later we got cheese bread!!!! And a sausage & mushroom hand tossed pizza. Fair prices. We went around 5-6pm and it was extremely busy read more

I have to tell you as a New Yorker I wasn't expecting much, but it was delicious! Got a personal pizza, beautiful flavorful crust and loved the sauce pleasantly surprised!!!! read more

Great Pizza and always arrive at or very close to the time they delay they will for delivery.

We are new to the Cedarburg area and found this pizza delivery restaurant. We got a pretty plain pizza with just red onions and pepperoni but it is very good. Their cheese bread is also delicious. I am excited to try some of their specialty pizzas! read more

Even Odds Pizza - American Hand Tossed or Rustic Thin Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Grafton, Wisconsin

My Wife and I have been ordering Pizza here since they opened. Have always been very happy with the quality and friendly service. 12/17/22. Ordered pizza this evening. Heard in the background from one of the staff "Tell Him No Fucking Way". Really? Really? Needless to say I'll find my Pizza options elsewhere. Not happy at all. read more

Always consistently good and they have lots of deals making their pricing very reasonable. Friendly staff and prompt delivery.

This used to be the olds Pizza Hut location, but I'm sure glad it isn't anymore. Even odds has the best Detroit style pizza in the metro Milwaukee area. Whenever I'm in grafton or have the time of the day I always make sure to stop here. Hands down best pizza! read more

Even Odds Pizza - Detroit Meatomme - Pizza Near Me - Grafton, Wisconsin

Sauce has always been my favorite part of a pizza. As far as I'm concerned, the more sauce the better. The Detroit style pizza at Even Odds is perfect for this. I've never heard of Detroit style pizza before going to Even Odds, so on my first visit, I went with hand tossed. It was good, but if you're not getting Detroit style here, you're missing out. Detroit style is kind of like really good cheese bread with toppings and a huge blob of sauce on each rectangular slice. Normally I prefer my sauce on the spicy/tangy side. This sauce tasted a bit sweet to me but eventually it won me over. I've only ever ordered pepperoni and sausage as toppings but they tasted good every time. Make sure your group is hungry if also ordering cheese bread. It tastes amazing and you might fill up on it before you even get to your pizza. I have to go here almost every time I visit Grafton. read more

Even Odds Pizza - Single Detroit with pepperoni and sausage. - Pizza Near Me - Grafton, Wisconsin

I have really enjoyed this place since it opened, but lately I have been disappointed. Last night I ordered carryout from here and estimated delivery time was 60 minutes. At 1hr 15 minurs I called and was told the pizza may not be out of the oven yet and that they were sorting through them now. The person on the phone was nice but I felt she was condescending. Anyway, when the pizza finally arrived it was barely warm. I had asked for extra cheese, but that didn't seem the case. Very disappointed. It will be awhile before I order from there again. With all the choices in Grafton, I have plenty of choices. read more

Ordered ahead to pick up pizza for a family event. The pizza was ready to go when I arrived, but it was hot like it had just been taken out of the oven. As far as taste, definitely above average. Using the website was extremely easy and I really liked that I could place the order online in the morning and know that my pizza would be ready to go much later. Will definitely be back! read more

Decent pizza for the area. Reminds me slightly of Jets with a similar crust but Even Odds has better ingredients and thus a better pizza. Kinda saucy, tasted similar to a place in chi town that's decent, Beggars Pizza. Guy waiting on me was very kind and gave me a coupon for money off and a free single can of pop. Pizza probably a 3+ but two extra stars for bend over backwards service. As I attempted to back my car out of parking space, a delivery driver, young guy in an obvious hurry started to back out of space next to me then stopped and rolled down his window saying... Im sorry, why dont you go ahead first. I thanked him and left. Service like that is unparalleled! Put that with pizza at a more than fair price and its 5 stars in my book. read more

I have always enjoyed Even Odds pizza, since they first opened in Grafton. I love what their owner did, and the chances he took. Their pizza is incredible, great crust, great sauce, great fresh toppings. I recently had an issue with a pizza that was delivered to me, talked with them, and within 20 minutes they delivered a fresh, new pizza. Now THAT is customer service !! Great job ! Awesome !! Couldn't recommend any higher read more

This is my favorite pizza in Cedarburg. There are a fair number of very good pizza places in the area, EvenOdds is the best

I totally recommend this place for pizza..especially the thin crust..so delicious and hot...great service and great delivery..we live in saukville..great staff very friendly read more