The pizzas are take and bake. The pizzas are made in front of you as you order and wrapped with instructions for cooking. We got the mac & cheese and pepperoni pizzas, as well as the cheesy garlic bread. Business and food prep area is clean. Our pizzas were good. The garlic bread could def use some more cheese, and would love to see marinara sauce to be offered to take with for the garlic bread. Definitely will return read more

The New York Deli pizza was fantastic! Take n' bake for the win tonight. Plenty of toppings and great taste with convenient online order ahead. read more

....love the pizza and the new location. The pizza is as good as I remember it was when they were downtown West Bend!

Amazing quality take and bake pizza- Recently moved to the area and this is an asset for a quick dinner- Crust cooks up thin and crispy, just how we like it! Enjoy the small items for sale in the store also! Great party mix! read more

The pizza is wonderful, and very quality ingredients! Generous portions at a fair price The staff is super friendly, and helpful and efficient Best place ever Not salty pizza like some places I love there menu of very unusual choices of pizza read more

I'm still trying to support local businesses even if not in my town in these hard times so I stopped by because I love the great variety of fresh take and bake pizzas. The place is in a strip mall with plenty of parking. The place also has frozen take and bake items like pizzas, wings etc etc. I chose a small masterpiece pizza with traditional red sauce on the thin crust as my first pizza to try. It's fresh extra sausage, extra mozzarella with mushrooms, black olives, green peppers, onions and tomato's. This is a very fresh pizza with great looking fresh toppings including the fresh mushrooms, I hate pizza places that use slimy can mushrooms. The pizza looked very good for take and bake I must say. I can't wait to cook it up and taste it. Wow what a delicious pizza it ended up being with a crispy crust, I ate the whole thing. read more

See all

Growing up in Oshkosh, Eaton's has always been a part of my life with locations in Oshkosh and Fond du Lac. When I moved closer to the Milwaukee area, it saddened me to learn that West Bend had a location at one time, but it had closed before I moved. I don't have words to describe how happy I am that West Bend has a location again. It's much more convienent driving 20 minutes to West Bend than 40 minutes to Fond du Lac when I have a craving for a cheese lovers or meat lovers pizza or a build your own sub with roast beef, corned beef, and Italian beef (good luck finding another sub place with all three of those on one sandwich). I may be biased given how long Eaton's has been a part of my life, but hands down they make the best pizza and subs in the world. Please frequent this location. It would be an travesty for West Bend to lose Eaton's again. read more

See all

Delicious take and bake pizzas. Not shy with the toppings ! Went on a referral, not disappointed.

Take and Bake! Good pizza and GF optional crust at a reasonable price. I had the Badger. My wife built her own with a GF crust and liked it. Blame it on a lot of eat ins being closed right now or my own stupidity, but we didn't know it was TAKE AND BAKE until they brought it to the car. Would be helpful if it was a little more obvious on the website. read more

The pizza was ok, nothing to write home about. I have a gluten allergy. the gluten free crust, it was not the greatest, yet there is not that many that are. Personally, I would prefer dominoes gluten-free better. The rest of family had supreme, they said same thing "it was ok". We all did agree the toppings were free, but the spices were kinda bland. read more

Very happy to see Eaton's return to the area. The shop is small, efficient, and clean. The pizzas are tasty, and very reasonably priced. The take-and-bake format is an excellent way to have solid, restaurant quality pizza without having to to pay as much or spend time sitting in somewhere. The sauce is simple, though tasty, and the portion of cheese is always quite generous. The crust is something akin to a cracker crust, but a little thicker and less crisp. Toppings are good, though hit or miss, with some of less quality than others. I generally stick to pepperoni and sausage, both of which are of a great quality level. Happy to see them back and will continue to frequent Eaton's when in town. read more

Best take n bake EVER! Always fresh and delicious and awesome service! Love this place!

Super clean and Covid-conscious which is so important right now! Absolutely incredibly fresh and generous toppings. I personally recommend paying the extra dollar for the "thicker" crust as it's closer to a normal pizza crust, but the thin crust tastes amazing too! I personally added extra cheeses to my pizza but I wish I wouldn't have because none of the other cheeses melt well and the mozzarella is amazing by itself. The fresh sausage is so delicious. The prices and quality by far surpass papa Murphy's and any hot pizza you can get in the area. The only sucky part is waiting the 20-30 mins for the pizza to cook This is definitely our new and only pizza place we'll be getting from now. So glad to have finally found something good after trying literally almost every option in the area. read more

Awesome to have Eaton's back in west bend! Stopped in today for the first time on my way thru west bend. Owner and staff talked to me in depth about food choices and helped me order! So happy they have gluten free options! Such a nice place! I will be back!!!! read more

Only giving 2 stars because the staff was super friendly and helpful. While the pizza toppings were plentiful the crust was a premade frozen mess, I've had better from the frozen food section of the grocery store. Can't say the price was great either. Took a first time gamble and lost,won't be back. read more

We were excited to hear that Eaton's had returned to West Bend. We did not have the pleasure of trying it before they left the first time, but have many friends in the area who gave us great reviews. I called in and ordered our favorite pie combo. Sausage, Canadian bacon, fresh mushroom, and black and green olives. When I arrived to pick it up, it was ready and waiting. The service was friendly, and the place was busy. We brought the pie home and cooked it to the instructions on the receipt (375F for 20 to 30 min) but found 22 minutes was just right for our oven. Really enjoyed the flavor! Price is comparable to other take-and-bake places in the area for a custom pie, but for us, tasted better. Moving forward, this will be our place of choice when we want to bring a pizza home to cook for ourselves. read more

Love their pizza! The ones you have to wait for are delicious, but at a higher price than the frozen, which makes sense. So yummy!

For some odd reason Eaton's Pizza came to mind one day and I did a search and low and behold it was back in West Bend. I was shocked. I wasn't even aware that they had other locations all these years. In my younger days I recall definitely enjoying it as they had a great thin crust pizza. Well while my memory doesn't serve me so well as to remember if it's exactly the same, it's surely very close. I tried Eaton's a few times now before writing this review and I have to say that I'm thrilled their back. I only make it back to town visit my folks, but it's great because you can grab one to take with you. I like both their thin and thick crust pizzas, in fact I'm not sure which I prefer. They also have other food options including garlic bread options and even breadsticks, all of which you can make at home. The location itself while on the corner of town is pretty nice inside. I was really surprised by the slick tablets they have where you can easily place your order. Customer service has always been quite welcoming too. I've trade the big take and bake chain once or twice in the past, always because someone else ordered it, and I never liked it. Eaton's however is a winner. I'm guessing I'm not the only one who thinks that either considering how busy they were on my visit last week. read more

I love the many choices for both pizzas and subs. I have been here many times and have never been disappointed. They definitely do not skimp on toppings or sandwich ingredients. read more

Eaton's pizzas & subs are phenomenal all around - but what's more amazing is that they offer a KETO pizza crust for us low-carb eaters and It. Is. Awesome! Thanks Eaton's! read more

This is one of my favorite pizza places in town. Variety of made to order pizza are always fresh and delicious. I also love the that they have 8 to 16 inch to choose from. My wife and I always get are favorite and add an 8inch of something we have not tried yet. This place rocks and they staff is so friendly. You will are guaranteed to love their pizza. Puts murf on check. I am 60 and this is definitely a pizza to talk about. My grandkids love this place also. They each order there own small. read more

Pizza is exemplary! Customer service always top notch! Ordered a pizza enroute and it was done by the time we arrived it was done! (Less that ten minutes!) Great pizza of the month offerings! read more