Rosati&#x27;s Pizza

Great place. Great service inside is a typical pizza parlor Great during Covid. With curbside…read moreservice and delivery's

If you're on the hunt for real New York-style pizza in Southwest Florida, look no further than…read moreAnthony's New York Pizza in Estero. We first heard about this place from one of the co-owners at the Bonita Springs flea market, who assured us it was the real deal--and let me tell you, she wasn't exaggerating. From the moment we sat down, we knew we were in for something special. We kicked things off with the meatballs and ricotta appetizer, and it was outstanding. The meatballs were unbelievably tender, with just the right amount of cheese mixed in, and the sauce was perfection--rich, flavorful, and just the right balance of tangy and sweet. For the main event, we went with a classic cheese with half pepperoni pizza, because if a place can nail that, you know everything else will be great. And wow--this was everything a New York-style pizza should be. The crust was super thin, crisp, and perfectly cooked, holding its shape beautifully when folded (because that's the only way to eat NY-style pizza). The sauce was spot-on, the cheese was high quality, and every bite was a perfect balance of flavors. Located just down the road from Coconut Point Mall, Anthony's New York Pizza is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic New York-style pizza in the area. We'll absolutely be back, and if you love great pizza, you need to check this place out.

Indoor seating

Half meat, half spinach artichoke chicken pie

See all

Mamma Anna Trattoria

4.6(100 reviews)

1.7 mi

This place is amazing!…read more First off, the service is on point, the food comes out in a timely fashion, and the vibe is like old timey Italy (or how I imagine it lol). 3 of us went and got a pizza, gnocchi, and a calzone. All 3 were fantastic! Really authentic, homemade Italian food. The calzone was the biggest I've seen in the area too! Highly highly highly recommend checking this place out

We are here for dinner and it was great! It was a great mom and pop restaurant. The pizza was…read morecrisp. The meatballs were tasty. We got the ravioli and ziti. Definitely a solid choice. I want to come back and try the specialty pizza. Hopefully this will put it to 5 stars.

Outside tables

Chicken Parm and Chicken Capricossa

See all

Interior was warm & clean.

Pezzo Pizza + Bar

4.3(70 reviews)

1.4 mi

The food at Pezzo is excellent and very much authentic Neapolitan fare. Seems to me everything is…read morecustom cooked to order and three of us loved our meal. This is one of many times we have eaten here and two diners ate the summer special meal we considered great value for the price. The rigatoni was cooked al dente, perfectly, sauce thick, rich and delicious. The meatball was huge. Service was great and I think our servers recognized that one of us oldsters is dealing with memory issues and the were very patient and polite. If we had any issue at all it would be a little softer on the music.

Every time I order a pizza from Pezzo's, I am reminded why it was voted 2025 Gulfshore Business…read moreBest of SWFL best pizza of Estero and the 2026 Open Table Diner's Choice award. The SAUCE. We ordered a classic Margherita to-go to enjoy a little pizza with our sauce. The San Marzano tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil were the perfect flavor combination. If you are a fellow tomato addict then run, don't walk to Pezzo's. Their crust is very thin and does not hold up super well, but is great when folded over. Our order was accurate and ready a little earlier than estimated. Only thing I did not love was that some portions of the crust were more burned than I would have liked. Other than that, tomatoey cheesy perfection.

Cannoli

See all

Fresh berry salad

Luigi’s Pizza è Pasta

4.1(27 reviews)

2.3 mi

Visited Luigi's Pizza E Pasta with plans to grab lunch shortly after their posted opening time of…read more11:00 AM. I arrived early and waited patiently. At 11:10, I tried the door--it was open. Upon entering, I was abruptly told to wait 20 more minutes and asked to leave. I politely asked to look at the menu while I waited and took the menu on my way out the door. Shortly after stepping outside, the door was promptly locked behind me. Another customer nearby witnessed this and immediately remarked, "Wow, that guy's grumpy"--which confirmed it wasn't just me. It's understandable if prep was running behind, but the interaction felt unwelcoming and unprofessional. There was zero courtesy or customer service. But more importantly, basic courtesy costs nothing. This kind of attitude drives people away. I won't be back--and based on what I saw, I doubt I'm the only one.

Ate at Luigis this weekend. We ordered a large pizza half pep and half cheese. The wait time was…read morearound 10-12min. Besides the pizza we ordered a fountain drink and two water bottles the total with tip was around $30. The pizza has great flavor and is perfectly thin with not too much sauce . They offer pizza by the slices here. The inside is small with a few tables. The outside area has a few tables too. The location is next to a kids playground and a small rock climbing area. It's the perfect place to grab some quick food with quick a service.

Catering Event

Eggplant Parm

See all

Patio Dining

Lombardough's Pizza & Beer

If you want a family-friendly atmosphere, GREAT FOOD AND BEVERAGES AND SERVICE, specials, a great…read moreplace to host parties, all at a price that fits the budget, then you will find that at Lombardoughs! And they have gluten-free pizza---the best I've ever tasted! The crust is delicious, the toppings are fresh and portions generous! Currently they have a lovely and festive outside dining and game area experience. And, by this time next month, they will have opened their indoor dining area. We were given a tour of the new area by the manager, Ian. We look forward to coming together dining room grand opening, sometime in May 2026. I hope to see you there!

Went for pizza and was blown away by the wings!!! Tuscan garlic wings I will be back for more..read more

Outdoor area at night. Order at the kiosk not window

Pepperoni XL

See all

Vegetables Arrosto

Tony Sacco's Coal Oven Pizza

3.6(242 reviews)

1.5 mi

Stacey. Very friendly. Great job helping us…read more And delicious pizza. Very happy they're opened late on the weekends.

Food was extremely delicious and the appetizer was amazingly fabulous. The service was quick and…read morevery pleasant. I've never been a fan of Florida Pizza being from New York but I truly enjoyed this pizza. The ambiance was just fine even though it's in a large mall. I strongly suggest you try this neat coal fired food. It's quite a gem of a place. Unfortunately the pictures were accidentally deleted but this is a place I can't wait to go back to!!!!!!

See all

Marco's Pizza

4.5(51 reviews)

3.5 mi

We have ordered twice for our large party the month we have been down in Florida. Both times the…read morepizza was good and service was quick. Not top notch pizza, but still pretty good.

It was very tasty and reasonably priced with coupon. A great quick meal for when you're hungry and…read moreneed something to eat right now.

See all

Marsala Italian Ristorante & Pizzeria

3.5(229 reviews)

2.6 mi

Food was good. Service was awful. And the guys in the kitchen couldn't care less. There was…read moreliterally no one there as I sat waiting for my check and a box for the leftover pizza. Done with this place. The last time I was here I found hairs in my spaghetti with meatballs. No one to blame but myself, I guess. After the hair experience, I should not have come back.

Average at best. Portions were large but quality was not at all impressive. The signature dish,…read moreveal marsala didn't have much taste.

Inside

Chocolate cake to go

See all

Antipasto Salad

Divieto Ristorante - Estero

There's only one thing to say! Food Excellent, Antipasto…read moremisto,Bruschetta Grouper scampi and the terimisu. Service by Jay Excellent very professional. Ambiance Excellent. pricing for a bottle of Pinot Griogio wine and a cup of Americano and for the whole meal Excellent. Do not pass this place up,best italian food! What could I say Excellent!!

Food was good, plentiful portions. Presentation excellent. Like most restaurants these days, steak…read morechoices were pricey. This restaurant does however let itself down (and its score), for two reasons; Dark as a cave in there, & So noisy. We couldn't hear our dining mates over the din. And what's with the darkness, what are they hiding? I'm not sure which was worse...

Pumpkin Spice White Russian to cheer during the holidays

Pumpkin Spice White Russian

See all

Pumpkin Cheesecake for the season

Oak & Stone

4.2(183 reviews)

1.7 mi

Love me some oak & stone. Theres not one thing on the menu I haven't eaten or tried. My husband…read moreis a die hard pizza eater and he gets the same one each time. I try to eat something different each time. This place has great beer selections, some ciders and wines. Staff is always kind and on point.

On the advice of the really nice man at the car rental, we stopped here after our flight. I wanted…read morebreakfast. He wanted lunch. Kids weren't very hungry. I got avocado eggs on everything biscuit. Outstanding! He ended up getting the breakfast burrito (last minute change of mind). Kids got a mini waffle and fruit bowls. Loved it! A great place to eat when no one knows what they want! Oh, and they have a lot of different beers if you're into that.

Selection of tap beers

GRIDDLE BURGER

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

12 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Kathryn M.

6 years ago

Most disgusting place I've been!!! I sat and watched the tanked owner and son just acting like a$$ holes! We're appalled at the behavior of owners who would be so blatantly rude to their customers! Bartender s bringing people shooting darts behind the counters and in the back! No one washing their hands after handling money other people's glasses! We will never be back to this place again! Too much video to post! Nothing but drunken butt heads in this lame place!! read more

Jim S.

11 years ago

I'm from the midwest, and it's hard to find great thin crust pizza down here. I tried Rosati's yesterday for the first time, and it was fantastic! Perfectly thin, crispy crust; good quantity of very well-seasoned sauce, and ample amounts of very high-quality toppings. I've tried almost every pizza place in southwest Florida, and Rosati's is now one of my favorites. read more

Valheriee R.

8 years ago

Eat here all the time. The thin crust pizza is awesome. My favorite is with pepperoni, bacon, onion and tomato. Chicken parm is excellent. Their salads are always fresh and crisp. Great service too! Everyone is always so nice. read more

Sue L.

3 years ago

This is our choice for pizza! The food is good, love the salads, and the mushrooms. The employees are friendly and efficient. Pick up is always on time. We have been customers for years and will continue to do so! read more

Mr C.

8 years ago

Also born and raised in Chicago and this is the best pizza I found after many years. Great and clean service. Try large thin with onion and italian beef...love this place! read more

Debbie N.

10 years ago

Amazing Pizza. Hot fresh and very tasty they deliver fast and it's hot when you get it. Would highly recommend it. Also have great sandwiches! read more

Ron J.

3 years ago

Come on! With the five stars I gave Rosati's, no further explanation is required. The place is that good! read more

Alanna B.

4 months ago

Alanna will spit in your food, very rude terrible customer service she's always on drugs

No T.

5 months ago

Alanna Bradley loves sleeping with older men as a minor, she will give your pizza aids

Ian S.

5 years ago

The food and drinks here are amazing! The wait staff is friendly and attentive.

Stephen D.

5 years ago

Great food. Great service for pick up. Very nice people to deal with

Rick C.

9 years ago

Best pizza I've yet to find in the area.

Rosati's Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Rosati's Pizza also viewed

Rosati's Pizza

4.3

(36 reviews)

When it's good it's great. When they are on, I'd give them 5 stars but this location seems to lack…read moreconsistency in order accuracy and/or final product quality. The only thing consistent is that they are always inconsistent. We always order double dough and double sausage. Sometimes you get double some times there is hardly any sausage on the pizza, even though you paid for double. Last night we ordered and paid for 2, 18" double dough pizzas (nearly $100 with delivery cost) and when the delivery came I noticed the pizza boxes were very light... turns out they gave us thin crust. This pizza is very expensive and worth it when it gets done right but very frustrating to pay almost $100 for 2 pizzas that are not made correctly. This is a frequent issue, I feel like we are gambling every time we order. It may be great, or maybe not...

My co-worker is from Chicago and he is always raving about Rosati's. I decided to give it a try and…read moreboy was I surprised. The deep dish pizza is out of bounds great. Cheesy with the right amount of sauce and buttery soft crust isn't even fair. They are definitely fishing with dynamite. I had the pizza delivered so I cannot comment on the store itself, but the service was spot on. The pizza comes with a sheet of aluminum over the top to keep it piping hot. Definitely one of the best pizzas in Naples

Rosati's Pizza

4.1

(298 reviews)

I Have been to Rosatis in Illinois before so knew what We were getting here…read more It didn't disappoint. We were able to get a table for 7 easily. The server was a bit slow but we got everything we ordered. The regular pizza is great as is the deep dish. Typical pizza place. Nothing super fancy, but good food. They have tables and a bar to eat at.

We luv this pizza. If you haven't been in a while go! The new owners took over like 6 mos ago…read more It's legit cuz they are from Chicago. My family gets the tavern style and always get extra for leftovers later. My hubby loves the Italian beef. It's authentic with a ton of meet and they will dip it in the gravy too. Jorge always waits on us and he's super cool laid back and efficient. It's just nice that even tho Rosatis is a chain that it's family owned and they care that the product they are putting out tastes like my hometown. Thank you. We will be back in the area in September. Appreciate your dedication

Tonys NY Pizza

3.7

(212 reviews)

Pizza was very good, excellent crust. Staff was nice and the…read morebeer was cold....LOL Would definitely stop by again.

I'm in Fort Myers working for 4 days and I felt like pizza so I asked Google, pizzeria near me and…read moreTony's NY Pizza appeared. I sat down and it took a good 15 minutes for a server to show up. A young lady came to ask me what I wanted to drink, then after bringing my drink I ordered my dinner. I ordered a pizza with mushrooms, black olives and pepperoni. The pizza was good! But the service was so and so. The ambiance was that there was no ambience, the restaurant is clean with a terrace outside.

Il Primo Pizza and Wings

4.0

(54 reviews)

Just did a take out order & i kid you not, this is one of the best pizzas i have ever had. called…read moreto make an order & staff was friendly. when i went to pick up, everything was clean and spacious for whoever does dine-in. also, best ranch ever.

Being from Brooklyn I love the pizza I love the wings extra cheese sausage pepperoni grande cheese…read moreexcellent

Pizza D-LUX

4.3

(137 reviews)

My husband and I Love this Pizza. The crust is so fresh so good .We go once a wk. Pizza is the Best…read more! Everyone there is so nice.

Pizza is very very thin. The pepperoni and sausage was minimal compared to the onions. Pizza was…read morepretty tasty overall, but $26 for a 14" pizza is a little high in my opinion for such a thin pizza. No where on the menu, or in the restaurant or around the register does it menu the charging for use of a credit card, otherwise I would have paid with cash. Nor do you see an itemized bill. Only after it's all done you see tax and fees and a total, but still don't know. Of the cc fee. Very frustrating. Sounded like you place food order at counter and then take a seat. Kid at register didn't have much pep in his step. 4 ppl in line at the door and showed no desire to pick up the pace or have an ounce of personality.

Pine Island Pizza

3.8

(59 reviews)

Great food, super friendly staff, and great prices !…read more We really enjoyed the meatball app and the savory pig pizza is bomb! This is our go to pizza spot when we are on PI.

Told by a Cape Coral local guy to try this pizza spot in Pine Island near Matlache. I passed by it…read moreseveral times and noticed that the front of the building advertises pizza slices, so immediately it drew my attention. My pet peeve are pizza joints that are against slices. The pizza maker advised that one slice and a soda is $3.00, which is a fabulous deal. The slice per my request was cooked well done. It was placed into a box and I grabbed a Coke and left to eat in my car. The sauce was NOT zesty with a decent layer of cheese and the crust had a perfect crunch in every bite. Not an oversized slice with an above average taste at an insanely good value.

Joe Daddy's Pizza

4.2

(128 reviews)

Updating my review. Must rate 5 stars now. Since my last review my family returned on 2 more…read moreoccasions and ordered several more pies including peppers and onions. Very pleased that the add-on ingredients we paid for had the proper amount of peppers and onions this time. Perfect and delicious. I ask that in the future please inform the customer if you are low on ingredients . That gives the customer an opportunity to order something else and not be disappointed. Thank you!

My new addiction! Since the new owners took over in April, Joe Daddy's has really upped their…read moregame. I'm a transplanted New Yorker and their pizza and subs are spot on! Their pizza also reheats to perfection at home. Crust stays crispy and delicious. Highly recommend!

Friend's Pizza

3.4

(77 reviews)

Excellent food! Clean restaurant and friendly staff. Good prices! We had the white pizza.read more

The restaurant was clean, the staff was friendly and attentive, and the food was amazing…read more Definitely will come back again

Leoni's Pizzeria

3.3

(94 reviews)