Updating my review. Must rate 5 stars now. Since my last review my family returned on 2 more occasions and ordered several more pies including peppers and onions. Very pleased that the add-on ingredients we paid for had the proper amount of peppers and onions this time. Perfect and delicious. I ask that in the future please inform the customer if you are low on ingredients . That gives the customer an opportunity to order something else and not be disappointed. Thank you! read more

My new addiction! Since the new owners took over in April, Joe Daddy's has really upped their game. I'm a transplanted New Yorker and their pizza and subs are spot on! Their pizza also reheats to perfection at home. Crust stays crispy and delicious. Highly recommend! read more

Joe Daddy's Pizza - Lunch Special: 2 slices and a drink - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

Tried this place as its close to our new home, and while admittedly we have aspirations to try other places, we tried Joe Daddy's, and its a dam good, dam tasty pizza with a fantastic crust. Good sauce, and plenty of cheese. read more

I'm a repeat customer I personally think it's the best in the area. I'm from Chicago for what that's worth...

I sound like the epitome of a snob. (Sorry.) Unless the recommendation is made by someone from NYC, or someone who has had NY pizza -- not pizza from Oshkosh that promotes itself as NY -- I'm not likely to run out for a pie. Or a slice. (I already said I'm sorry!) When T, a southerner who grew up with Pizza Hut, said Joe Daddy's Pizza is great, my snotty answer was "I'll be the judge of that!" (I think it's human nature to gravitate to what we had as kids.) Son-of-a-gun, I agreed with him! (And apologized.) While not quite 5 stars, it's pretty darn good, with the right amount of cheese, the requisite fold of the crust, an acceptable amount of grease. I was pleased. And for what it's worth, they don't even tout themselves as NY style. If you were a fan of Joe Daddy's before, but wary of returning with new management, you might want to give 'em a go. Next time we're gonna get a Sicilian pie, which I haven't seen in many places since I've moved. read more

Joe Daddy's Pizza - A large pepperoni pie - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

This is handTV s-down, the best pizza I have had it while living in Florida! The cheese is real mozzarella, not that fake stuff and the crust is so good too! I'm from Chicago so pizza is something I am very picky about I know this is New York but I also know New York is awesome pizza too! If you haven't tried this pizza place you need to highly recommend! read more

This is my 3rd review of my favorite pizza place in all of SW Florida. I eat here are least 2 times a week. To me, their NY style cheese slice is a must due to it's addictive flavor and textures. It's an amazing craving for me. Say hi to Clarence, the owner, pizza maker supremo. read more

I absolutely love this pizzaria. Reminds me so much of New Jersey/New York style. I always get take out and my order is always nice and hot. They make everything so perfect. Absolutely LOVE this place. Very highly recommended. read more

Not as good as it used to be. I'm not sure if it's the same owner but the pizza doesn't taste like it used to. The sauce had no flavor; it tasted like they opened a can of tomato's and just put it on the pizza. read more

You guys seriously make the kind of pizza that dreams are made of. The pizza is always so good, super fresh and full of flavor. Definitely one of my go-to spots! read more

Joe Daddy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

the meat lovers pizza is so good and the prices are amazing!! the staff is very kind as well

Not too impressed.... The best thing I could say is the dough/crust was very good. Very light and crispy. Customer service was also very great. The pizza though was very mediocre. We also ordered garlic knots that tasted old and hard not soft like fresh knots. And the chicken parm sub was very soggy and mediocre there was not a lot of attention put into the making of it. Also as you can see from my picture they had some trouble boxing my pizza, very bad presentation. read more

Joe Daddy's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Pizza is good , sold by slice or pie. Salads are huge !! Service in general is good friendly staff. A very familiar atmosphere. I believe it is under new administration. Go and give them a try.. read more

Joe Daddy's Pizza - Cheese Slice - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

I ordered a large all meat pizza, it was ready within 15 minutes and was really good I like the crunchy crust and the toppings, which seemed a little light but was actually plenty. Give them a try, I don't think they deliver though, check to be sure read more

Joe Daddy's Pizza - Large all meat pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

The mozzarella sticks are the only genuinely good thing I've had here. The service is great but the food quality is sub par in my opinion. The wings taste like dominos spongey wings if you're into that with bad store bought sauce and I tried their pizza today which I would compare closest to little Cesars. It tastes like fancy little cesars and for the price I don't feel it's worth it. read more

The pizza was great, the staff was very nice. Unfortunately the are no longer there. Went to get pizza on Sat Nov 25, and the place is on the market read more

This small place in a strip of stores caught our eye due to some yelp reviews. We were looking for a non fancy lunch and this fit the bill. There was only one other patron when we entered. They did a couple pickups and a couple people came in for slices while we were there. But it was pretty quiet. Quiet enough for the man who made our pizza to tell us he was from Pennsylvania and was still friends with all his classmates from grammar school (!)... Instead of getting slices, we decided to order a whole pizza and take the leftovers, if any, to our friends. We ordered a sausage and mushroom pizza. After helping ourselves to drinks (they carry Pepsi products), it wasn't too long a wait before he delivered our hot out of the oven pizza. The sliced mushrooms were fresh and the sausage pieces were tasty. The cheese was a good quality and melted nicely. The crust had a nice texture and was flavorful. We each added our favorites -- he likes to add crushed red peppers and garlic; I just opt for a bit of salt and maybe some oregano. All in all quite a decent pizza. There's so much bad pizza out there. I'm a bit spoiled having grown up with New Haven style pizza (look it up). And I don't care for deep dish Chicago style (this isn't). But if you like northeastern style, this will certainly do nicely. read more

See all

I will admit I am a bit of a pizza snob. I only eat Pizza once or twice a year, so when I do it has to blow me away and Joe Daddy's did! The Nonna was BOMB! Couldn't ask for a better slice then if I was on NY corner. Thanks for making this pizza worth the cheat meal!! read more

Great thin crust pizza delivered hot and tasty!!! Not greasy or overloaded with cheese. Would definitely order here again.

Sauce or cheese not for me, guess it's a NY thing we are love a good slice but this hit the mark

These folks were one of the few open right after Hurricane Ian, so we were able to get a hot meal and I won't ever forget that. In addition their pizza is great. I just did their lunch special, 7.95 for two slices and a drink. read more

Great Place Authentic Food Excellent Value Staff have a can do demeanor Great dining experience Staff goes above and beyond to please ...... read more

We have lived in Cape Coral for 6 months, Joe Dadys is one of the best pizzas we have found so far and we have tried many. But each their own, give it a try we love it. read more

Pizza is delicious but customer service was lacking. The guy acting like he didn't want to serve. No welcome, no goodbye - basically placed the food on the table and left. I have no clue why maybe because I'm black. Didn't realize it was that deep but. I probably will order and eat at home next time. Very uncomfortable atmosphere. read more

Great service and Great pizza. Owner is a awesome guy and we love going in and eating his delicious pizza. #1 pizza in Cape Coral

One of the best pizzas I've had! Thin, crispy, and not oily at all! Would highly recommend and I will sure be back.

Pizza very good nice & thin but for a place that calls its self NY pizza and can't get a slice of pizza @ 7:30 being single and only wanting a slice or two this place is not for me sorry to say And staff seemed happy that they don't served slices at night 3 times there 3 times no plain slices And only 7:30 at night and open till when on a Friday?? I guess they don't need the business. Plenty of other NY pizza places here now in the cape so I'll be looking. read more

Love their pizza! Recently moved to the Cape from the north and this is the closest to northern pizza as you can get. The sauce is amazing and the crust is great! Also they have the best meatball, mushroom and onion calzone around and it's HUGE. Will definitely be coming back! read more

Best pizza in South West Florida. Service was excellent, he was friendly and helpful. The pizza was perfect, as were their jalapeño poppers and meatballs. Can't wait for our next pizza night!! read more

The original Joe Daddy sold his business back in November; we did not know until tonight when picking up our order. Unfortunately, we were gravely disappointed. Poor Joe Daddy's name will be marred in history because of the terrible, terrible food coming out from this new management. At least if the pizza was half way good, the whole experience may not have been a total waste. Bye, bye, Joe Daddy- we will always remember and love you!! read more

Best pizza between N. Ft. Myers and Cape Coral. This is my 3rd trip. By the way, if you like great white pizza's they make 'em very well here read more

Large slices! Tasty sauce. Good prices. Friendly counter help. It's my go to spot for a quick 2 slices and a can.

Authentic pizzeria pizza. Crust is perfect... They don't skimp on the toppings when you order them. My only complaint is I wish they made an extra large 18-inch pizza. read more

My best pizza ever?! What a lucky choice. I'm staying over for one night in Cape Coral and I went to this absolutely fantastic place near my AirBnB. Didn't even expect to come across what is probably now the pizzas I ever had. Ordered at the counter (no waitress, no waiting) a works pie as soon as I got there along with a tap beer. Met a couple from Jersey so we started shooting the bull and before u know it my food arrived at the table. The crust was amazing (brick oven), the ingredients were well-proportioned and tasted great, but the cheese and especially the sauce were perfect. So perfect that it may be the best or tied for the best sauce I ever tasted! How can that be? Tied with Papa's Tomato Pies back in Trenton NJ. In this little place in a strip mall. Cape Coral, I hope you know how good you have it! Bravo Joe Daddy!! Oh and BTW, took home a pepperoni & sausage pie for the next day...even better. read more

Joe Daddy's Pizza - The best 'Works" Pie! - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Stopped after getting a manicure with mom, the food was amazing, great crispy crust. Can't wait to have their Mediterranean pizza again!!!! Thanks Mike for taking such good care of us! read more

Joe Daddy's Pizza - Mediterranean Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

My visit to this pizza place ended up been a great decision! The service was fast and the guy that works there was super cool. The pizza was delicious and Joe was funny, friendly and had a lot of stories to share making my visit feel like I was home!! Thank you guys!! read more

Best pizza we've had in Florida. Great crust, great sauce! We'll definitely be back!

Dined in, had mozzarella sticks, garlic knots, pizza and zeppoles. Everything was very good and fresh.

Yesterday for the first time I ordered a personal pizza from this store. A personal pizza that was almost $12 n definitely NOT worth it. Even though I was charged extra for the pepperoni, if there were 8 pieces in the whole pizza it was too much. First n last!! Live n learn. read more

Great thin and crispy pizza. Eat it there to enjoy it hot right out of the oven. Don't let the size of the place discourage you from eating there. Only serve soft drinks, but of server said we could BYOB. Walked next door to Publix and bought a few beers to drink with our pizza. Prices are not bad and our server was very attentive and friendly as was the owner. You can buy a slice or a whole pie. read more