It's been my "go to" pizza for several years now... Delicious, authentic, reliable... there are lots of pizza places in the Cape, but IMO this is the best in terms of a genuine pizzeria... Maybe Downtown Pizza in Fort Myers is comparable. Prices however, have gotten out of hand. An 18-inch pizza with two toppings will set you back close to $30. The antipasto salad is now up to $18. read more

Sorry to say, this wasn't a four star visit. Three was a gift. Ordered two sandwiches, took a good bit longer than expected, 30-35 minutes became 50, hey it happens. But if I am waiting 50 minutes for a chicken parm vodka sandwich, it better be good. Soggy bread, chewy chicken and very little sauce with even less flavor. Wife got an eggplant sandwich, she was ok but said her bread also suffered from the sogginess. I gave three stars because 2 seemed unfair, this is a 2.5 place at best. Pizza in the display looked dry and less than enticing. Overall, there are more places to try in the area. read more

Luciano's Pizza - Soggy bread, chewy chicken and flavorless vodka sauce. looks far better than it tasted. - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

I really hate to do this; I've rated Luciano's very highly in the past. But they have been on the downward slide for a couple years now, so I'm updating my review to reflect the current situation. Our family likes our pizzas "Neapolitan" style, where the crust is firm, a little chewy, and there is some searing going on on the top of the crust. You know, like you get from a traditional wood fired pizza oven? We understand that Luciano's doesn't have wood ovens, but to compensate we've been ordering a large pizza: "Well Done, Thin, Crispy crust." On our last four or five orders the center has been coming out consistently under-cooked, limp, and soggy. (To the point that our previous to final order needed to be reheated on a skillet to "firm up" the crust enough to hold a piece to eat!) My wife, the baker in the family, suggested that maybe they just couldn't get the center of a larger sized pie crisped up, despite our asking for "crispy" and "well done." We decided to do a test: Two smaller pies, ordered the same as per our usual: "Well Done, Thin, Crispy crust." I added a note to the online order to the effect: "Don't be afraid to burn the top a little; we like it that way". When I picked up the pizza they popped open the boxes for inspection. One was fine; nice and caramelized on top, exactly as I hoped. The second was (supposed to be) a plain pepperoni. While it was cooked as ordered, it did not have one single disc of pepperoni on it; it was just a plain cheese pizza. The guy in the kitchen said send it back and I'll fix it. Let's look at some of the options he had available: 1) Remake the entire order to give the customer two fresh, hot pizzas as ordered. 2) Remake the pepperoni pizza, giving the customer one fresh, hot pizza as ordered, and another one that's been sitting under the heat lamp for a few minutes. 3) Offer a coupon for complimentary pizza of the same size on my next order, if I'd take the 'plain cheese'. 4) Offer to 'comp' the faulty pie. 5) Offer a discount, say ( 1/2 off because it's missing the meat) on our next order. 6) None of the above. He chose "None of the Above" and put pepperoni slices on the already well-well-done pizza and tossed it back in the oven. The problem with this is that a) the pizza went from "well done" to INCINERATED, while at the same time, b) the pepperoni didn't cook much at all and just sat there, looking forlorn on a bed of burnt cheese. When I got it home and gave it a good look I was appalled. It was so burnt that we ended up throwing half of it away and could only pick out spots here and there that were barely edible. And having to pitch a large portion of a $20 pepperoni pizza is unacceptable. And both pies suffered from the same limp crust as ever. Luciano's claims "New York Style" pizza, but there's no way one can fold a slice in half and eat it New York style; it's far too limp in the center. So: sayonara, Luciano's. You've been our go-to for pizza on many a Friday night, but the quality you're providing is inversely proportional to the prices you're charging. The prices keep going up and up and up while the quality and value (and focusing on customer expectations!) are sliding toward rock-bottom. Also, Luciano's, if you're reading this: I wish you'd stop pressing customers to add a tip to the bill before they have received any product or services. In cases like this, there should also be an option #7: Give me my tip back! read more

We ordered the XL pepperoni pizza. It was huge but most importantly delicious. It's difficult to find really good pizza but this pizza is so worth it. We decided to eat in and were greeted by a very friendly woman who took our order and was also our server. She brought out our pizza straight from the oven. It looked so good we couldn't wait to dig in. This pizza had the right amount of sauce and cheese and the dough was thin and crispy. There are only 2 tables but we were there while it was empty so it was fine for us. read more

Luciano's Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

Good pizza especially if your from the north east looking for a familiar style pizza , it's great. The wings are some of the best in town without a doubt highly recommend the wings , polite and good service also ! read more

Listen my wife and I went there today to eat , it was not good at all The guy who is on tik tok said the best pizza place in the Vape He has no clue must be from upstate my boy Ny Ny The mozzarella was chewy and no flavor also had a calzone You want good pizzza Grimaldis in Ft Myers a bit pricey but well worth it !!!!! The owner was very nice but not a place to eat a good pie Joey Digrego read more

Always a four hour wait to get a pizza. Wouldn't recommend a place that can't deliver a pie in a reasonable time.

They do a great job on the pizza and are fast. It's droopy in the center, if you fold it, but it's probably because it had sausage and pepperoni on it. I was not a fan of the garlic nots. They were like tough dinner rolls with the Parmesan on top and butter which was jelled at the bottom. Not much flavor at all. read more

Luciano's Pizza - Sausage and pepperoni pizza and bland, tough nots. Pizza was great! - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Ordered cheesesteaks last night. Such a disappointment. Meat was chewy and a couple in our group found gristle. Peppers and onions were chopped so thin, they were tough strings. Didn't even find any mushrooms. The roll was toasted to a heavy crisp. Overcooked ? Definitely NOT a place to order cheesesteaks. read more

Our go to for pizza! We usually just go with a cheese well done or meatball if we are wanting a topping. It's one of two pizza places that actually come close to nyc pizza good. It's a small shop more for takeout as it's just a couple of tables inside and outside, very very small and can be packed with many waiting for their order. Would be awesome if they could expand the place someday and have more team members so the pizza wait during those prime times wasn't as long but I get it and worth the wait! Just order about 30 - 45 minutes in advance you plan to actually pick up if during prime dinner time and you won't have to wait around. I have come to find if they say it will be about 15 - 25 minutes it's usually really 30 - 45. And again, we just order 1 large pizza. Don't bother ordering via app for delivery. Do wish they sold coke products too ! If you are from nyc area def give their pizza a try! read more

Stromboli's & Calzones are awesome! Sicilian Pizza is great too . I highly recommend this place! For take out only since it's very small.

ok, their pizza is ok, but i also ordered the 14" manhattan pizza, the eggplant parm, the caprese salad and a home made cannoli. the cannoli was tasty, but i expected 2 for 7.99. the outstanding entree by far was the stuffed eggplant, so yummy, the spaghetti was ok, but the eggplant was by far the star. overall i liked everything, the pizza, the entree, and dessert were worth it. a bit pricey but everything is these days. read more

See all

Caution! Stale pizza! I like 1) crispy pizza and 2) crispy crust. Both pizzas were soggy and stale. The "spicey" honey was the worst. Remember the little fake sausage you would find in a tostinos pizza roll or even on a bagel bite...that. I definitely was not fresh. And so even for a bogo deal that I got via Facebook...not worth the $13.50. read more

Stromboli :) very tasty Pizza was hot and fresh as a pickup order or a delivery. Recommended read more

The pizza is good but one day I decided to order the tiramisu because they claim it's homemade......what I got was a fuzzy blue molded store bought tiramisu the was 10 bucks total. When I get up there they don't say we'll give you a refund or even I'm sorry just "oh well get you another one" even though I the customer just drove up here myself it's not being accounted for and they asked if I wanted another cake to which I thought "oh well at least that's kind of thoughtful" but not she only meant that I can switch it out for a different dessert so I lied that I was happy because the only thing that would actually make me happy is if they don't get business because they wasted and disrespected mine and I know there not gonna change so yea don't go here if your looking for good clean pizza cause the other reviews will tell ya they're really unhealthy as well. Basically they have no integrity. I have a picture but I don't know how to show you guys read more

Ordered extra sauce, not on there BUT charged for it anyways. Oh well, one and done. Delivery was faster than expected but better out there for the cost. read more

We ordered takeout to try this place out and I'm glad we ordered conservatively. We usually order a margherita pizza as this is a pretty safe choice to test the quality of a place. It's a classic you can't get wrong, so we ordered an XL margherita and added prosciutto. We ate half for dinner and wish we could return the rest. It was stiff, flavorless, and incredibly lackluster. The only plus were the garlic knots that were decent. The marinara it came with was flat and sour. Tastes like they dumped a can of sauce in a cup. Not a fan and we won't be going back. read more

We are from Chicago and extremely picky with pizza. We had to order last minute due to a family emergency and did not want to order from a chain restaurant. We are new to the area and read the reviews for this restaurant through yelp. We were extremely surprised, the pizza was great! The sauce, toppings, and cheese were on point- we wish the crust was cooked a little more which is the only negative critique of the pizza. I, also, ordered an Italian sub, the sub was good, not the best but it hit the spot and what I liked about it was that it felt home made which at the end of the day is what I really appreciated about this place, it felt like I was eating at someones home. The staff was, also, super friendly and attentive. Will continue to order from here. read more

See all

Food lacks flavor and moisture. For the price, there are better choices. The jumbo chicken wings might be jumbo to a Cornish hen, but not a chicken. Overcooked, dry and tasteless would better describe them. Dont waste a thought with the sausage and peppers sub. It too was dry, and overcooked. Better restaurant options are abound, unless it's pizza, close another restaurant. read more

Pizza was PHENOMENAL as were the garlic knots. The knots were literally swimming in a pool of Deliciously seasoned butter with fresh chopped Garlic. The pizza toppings were incredibly flavorful and the sauce and crust were just delicious. would definitely eat here again!!! read more

Luciano's Pizza - Large Margherita Pizza, Large All Meat Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Called in a pizza and bread knots at 5:55pm, they said 20-25mins for it to be ready. I got there at 6:18pm, they told me in would be another 5mins. My food was not ready till 7:01pm. It took me about 5 mins to get home and my food was ice cold. read more

We are in N. fort Myers. We enjoyed Luciano's II a great deal. From the pizza to the entries to the staff. Unfortunately, it closed. Fat Boys Pizza took over the spot. Again, a tasty pizza. Not quite my preference. Don't avoid them, tho. Good quality product. read more

I think we got a trainee on the phone when we put in our delivery order and eventually ended up talking to someone else to straighten it all out. That was our only blip and I don't even count it because everyone needs job training. As for the food...hot damn, this place has some tasty pizza! Just ordered delivery GF Stuffed Pizza and a GF BBQ Chicken with added pineapples and jalapeños (trust me, try it). The showed up earlier than expected (delivery guy was pleasant), pizzas were loaded (these guys are NOT stingy with the toppings!), and they included a bunch of extra sauce with the order. Speaking of the sauce...scratch made and flavorful! We're going to use the leftovers on some pasta we have in the fridge - can't wait! As for the Stuffed Pizza, it sounded like a weird combo to me - ricotta, spinach, bacon, ham, garlic, and mozzarella. I was against ordering it because of the flavor profile (ham and garlic??), but my husband pushed for it, so we got it, and man, was I WRONG. It was sooo good. Simple ingredients, but the garlic is the star of this one....current favorite....will 100% be ordering it again....and probably again. The BBQ chicken was also pretty damn good too, but still loved the Stuffed a bit more. I am a garlic fan, so if that's you, I just found your new pizza. You're welcome. :) We've tried a few local pizza joints already and haven't been happy with either the service or the pizza, but I think we finally found what we've been looking for. Thank you, Luciano's!!! We'll be back! read more

Luciano's Pizza - Slices of Stuffed Pizza and a BBQ Chicken (+jalapenos, pineapples) YUM! - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

3 things about this place: 1. Heard good reviews about this place so decided to give this spot a shot after having a bad experience from a different spot. Inside was a size of chain places so mostly pick up orders. 2. Call in orders were made for one cheese and one pepperoni pizzas along with garlic rolls. They had the foods ready to go when I got there and they were still hot and fresh. Came home and got ready to eat but they got one of the orders wrong and got a pepperoni + mushroom pizza instead of the cheese pie. 3. Taste wise, pizzas were pretty solid. It's not your NY style pizza but one of the best I have had in SWFL and their marinara sauce was amazing. Garlic knots were fantastic and had the perfect amount of garlic and butter and the flavors were not overpowered, which I liked. Also, the pie portions were huge and will be enough for a family if you order a large. I recommend this place to people who are looking for good pizza spots in Cape Coral area and will definitely be back to try different items on their menu. read more

See all

locally is the closest to NY/NJ style thin sliced pizza- I've been going there for years and will continue

Best pizza ever and beats all others. I definitely recommend! Every one loves it. The lines for pickup are always long. The definitely need a bigger place. read more

Everyone liked the pizza. Ordered 4 different ones for our party. They delivered on time and everything was hot.

Definitely my top 3 pizza places. Cheese is Always cooked to shimmering golden brown. The dough is never too crispy or too chewy, Always just right. The overall quality of their ingredients are great and the staff are polite. read more

A little disappointed. Pizza still taste good. Just very disappointed that large spots on the pizza has missing cheese. It wasn't evenly distributed. I thought maybe the cheese slid when being taken out of the oven. But I'm thinking that's not what caused the spots? But I'm really thinking it may not have been evenly distributed because the pizza dough where there's no cheese on. It is dry, so like it was cooked in the oven that way. Tip just check your pizza before you take it. That's why I'm only giving it three stars. read more

Luciano's Pizza - Cheese pizza. I like this place but was a little disappointed when large spots of no cheese on the pizza. . - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Really good pizza and service my family and I love going here and enjoying their foods and services. Great company highly recommend.

Pizza was delicious, even good leftover. Loved the meatballs. Chocolate cake was average. Got it delivered. Will definitely order again.

Pizza was great both times I ordered. Friendly staff. I will continue to get my pizza from them!

This is exactly what I expect when I want a New York style pie. Great pizza at a good price! read more

Luciano's Pizza - Slice of pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

We have been ordering from Luciano's every Friday, almost, for a while. Recently on several occasions we asked for extra pepperoni and it didn't look like it had extra. Today's order the chicken tenders were crispy and had very little meat on them. Did they change their supply? If they did they made a mistake. The meatballs are fabulous as always. The pizza was so-so as was the taste of the toppings. I will order once more and if it comes out the same we will find a different place to get our Friday night dinner. We loved the original. read more

First. A Stromboli is the basic meats usually addition items you want. Very misleading. After spending over 15.00 and the build your Stromboli in accident, "wrong stromboli" I got a basic cheese stick with basil in it for 15+ dollars. Along with antipasta salad and wings. 60+ dollar order for crap. Then the best is their attitude when you call them out on it. GOOD luck Lucianos of Cape Coral. You won't make it with your lack of customer service and attitude. Snowbirds are here and I'll make sure I spread the word bc you can't do the right thing to a customer for over 12 years. There are alot of other pizza places. I do not recommend at this point. ​ read more

We are from Chicago and love our pizza and very picky. We've tried many pizzas in the Cape and this is our favorite!!! Of course it's not what we grew up with, it New York style and we love it! very flavorful, yummy cheese and toppings, friendly service! 2 slices and can Of soda lunch deal is a steal! Huge slices! Grandkids love it too!! read more

They accidentally kept my credit card but never called to tell me (they have my phone number from my order) After looking everywhere and forever I finally called them and they nonchalantly said, "yea it's here." Also, they answer the phone "Luciano's please hold" and then forget all about you.(literally, they never come back to you on hold.) This happened the past 6 (!!!!) times within a month. I kept trying because they are my nearest eatery. Sandwiches are sub-par yet over priced. Pizza good for 2 minutes, usually over cooked. Children for cashiers. Sweaty old men as cooks. Pass. read more

I ordered on the slice app and after 2 and a half hours after I ordered Luciano's canceled the order. This was a Saturday night and canceled at 9:45. Too late to order from anywhere else. I have to get up for work at 4:30am so I am going to bed bungle because at this point sleep it is a higher priority than eating. I used to get Togo from them frequently when I worked near by. I've ordered from them on slice a few times. Unless a good explanation is given for canceling my order I will not give them my business again. If you can't count on an order being fulfilled what good is placing the order? ?? read more

We had an excellent experience, and the pizza and sandwiches were very good! When we stepped in the store and realized it was a carry out restaurant we turned around and walked out because we thought they couldn't accommodate 6 people. To our surprise the manager came out and said that they could accommodate us. We ordered our pizza and they brought it to us at some outdoor tables. They definitely went above and beyond, and we will definitely be back! The pizza was very good too! read more

Always excellent service. Always clean. Best pizza in the Cape!! Our family loves eating here at least once a week. The desserts are to die for, too!! read more