Great food, super friendly staff, and great prices ! We really enjoyed the meatball app and the savory pig pizza is bomb! This is our go to pizza spot when we are on PI. read more

Told by a Cape Coral local guy to try this pizza spot in Pine Island near Matlache. I passed by it several times and noticed that the front of the building advertises pizza slices, so immediately it drew my attention. My pet peeve are pizza joints that are against slices. The pizza maker advised that one slice and a soda is $3.00, which is a fabulous deal. The slice per my request was cooked well done. It was placed into a box and I grabbed a Coke and left to eat in my car. The sauce was NOT zesty with a decent layer of cheese and the crust had a perfect crunch in every bite. Not an oversized slice with an above average taste at an insanely good value. read more

See all

Picked up a huge pizza that was lukewarm, soggy and no crispy crust or 'bite' never again it's so disappointing and I have had good ones in the past. Are you in a hurry? Is your oven not hot enough? It really was disgustingly soggy and undercooked. You win. We lost I guess. Trying like mad to heat it or cook it in oven but the crust tastes like it was made for shelf stable grocery stores not fresh or light. read more

Pine Island Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bokeelia, Florida

I can't say enough about this business. From their friendly atmosphere, amazing service and incredible food, I would highly recommend them to anyone. We cannot wait to go back! read more

Good pizza and great people. Highly recommend. Get the meat lovers and some garlic knots! They have some cool merch too!

Delicious pizza all day every day! My favorite place to go on the island. Fresh ingredients, friendly service, and great atmosphere.

Our go-to pizza spot, the service is always warm and welcoming. BBQ chicken, savory pig, and the white deluxe are bangers! We will always support small businesses, especially when the quality is top notch! Highly recommend if you're in the cape coral/ pine island area read more

Good pizza close to New York home pizza do miss that after 9 years I had about 2 slices of cheese before I hit the first stop light

We are CT pizza snobs but we have never found anything here locally that comes close to New Haven style that we are accustomed to. With that being said, we do like the pizza at PI compared to other local FL pizza we have tried. The crust is nice and thin and crisp and the sauce and cheese are pretty authentic The toppings choices are done to our liking. The people are nice and prices are fair. It's convenient and pretty good for FL pizza read more

Always high school or college students working when I come in. Customer service is lacking. If you call and cannot get through it is becuase they are deliberately taking the phone off the hook and are not sincerely apologetic about it. Try ordering online instead. Always check your pizza before you leave as the finished product is not consistent. Shame that places that make a killing because there are no other options are the ones lacking in service and end product. Parking lot is small, helpful hint is to park down the side street. Pizza is good, not great and definitely not bad. New York style thin crust. read more

The food is amazing and not too expensive! Danny and Jackson are so friendly and nice! Customer service there is excellent! We go every Sunday after church to eat lunch! read more

We had Pizza and wings at the house to watch the game and it was exactly what we wanted. we'll be ordering again.

I suggest if you order a pizza, open the box to check it before you leave. We got home and our pizza was burned! I love Pizza but not charred crust and the pizza itself was a little dried out from being overcooked. ‍ there wasn't anyone in there when i got there to pick it up. So it wasn't that they were swamped. Bought on Wed 11/13/2025 around 1pm. read more

Pine Island Pizza - Burned pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - Bokeelia, Florida

Delicious pizza and garlic knots! We dined in for lunch today. Service was excellent, friendly, and expedient. We had a large half cheese and half pepperoni pizza that was perfectly cooked and flavorful. The garlic knots are addicting! Will definitely be back! read more

Soggy undercooked crust. Paucity of cheese and sauce. Low quality room temperature toppings that seemingly were added after the pie came out of the oven. In short the worst pizza I've had in my 75 years on the planet. Disgusting. read more

The service was good and the staff were friendly. I unfortunately did not get to try my pizza though. I have a gluten allergy and was super excited to see they offered a gluten-free pizza, but there was a lot of cross contamination in the kitchen as they were making it, and I did not want to risk getting sick. read more

Pine Island Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bokeelia, Florida

This place is always a "good" place for pizza on the Island. However, it's run by a bunch a loud kids and that makes it hard to just relax and eat your meal. Forget trying to call and order anything because they just put you on hold and hang up. That has happened several times. I do not usually write one star reviews but I'm very annoyed with this place. I bet the owner has no idea. Make your employees behave as such. read more

This pizza spot was the closest we've found to the taste of pizza in the northeast. The owner sold the restaurant a couple years ago and I believe the previous owners son stayed on board and continued making the pies. I have not seen him there the last several visits and the pizza sauce and the cheese seem to be different. It is a different pie and recipe and not as delicious as the previous pies in my opinion. I have not tried any of their sandwiches yet. read more

I love this place. The food is always delicious, the service is excellent. I love this local place.

I order heart shape pizza, cheese and white pizza 12 wings, 6 Parmesan and 6 bbq it was good. The pizza was cooked to perfection. It was not greasy at all. I like this style pizza and definitely will order again from them. My son loved the pizza and his a picky eater. The location was clean and staff was friendly and very helpful. read more

Pine Island Pizza - White pizza heart shaped - Pizza Near Me - Bokeelia, Florida

Best Pizza in town! Staff were so welcoming. Food was great. Absolutely coming back again!

Always fresh, always hot, always delicious! It's my first time back in 15 months and they did a remodel. It's really clean, very functional and definitely comfortable! As always, the service is top notch! So glad you made your way over from Vegas! read more

Pine Island Pizza - 2 Slices and a pop for $6! All day! - Pizza Near Me - Bokeelia, Florida

Always friendly service but extremely inconsistant food. One time it even seemed as if they used a pre made crust. Its a hit or a miss.

Pine island pizza never disappoints their pizza is thin and delicious freshly made to order and don't miss out on the chicken wings yumm ! We love this pizza place family owned support your local business. read more

Pine Island Pizza - Chicken wings - Pizza Near Me - Bokeelia, Florida

See all

Great pizza and service. Love the sauce! We will definitely be back next time we are in the area.

don't waste your money. go buy a frozen pizza at Winn Dixie I am sure it will be better. we try to support local businesses when we travel. I had one piece it was so bad I threw it away. absolutely no flavor all in the crust or sauce. Shame on pine island pizza for charging over 25.00 for a 14 inch deluxe pizza. read more

Best Pizza in the area. Clean and family run business. Can't buy a single slice. Two slices 5 dollars, not a bad deal.

Love this place !! Pizza was delicious and the worker were super friendly and accommodating. Beautiful crust not to thick and not to thin! read more

Pine Island Pizza - Veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bokeelia, Florida

Pizza crust was burned and sauce seemed like just regular tomato sauce with no spices or seasoning. Previous owners pizza was much better. April 24 read more

*** update *** the owner contacted me after the post and made things right. Thank you Pete. We have gotten the Sicilian pizza from here a lot. Today it was very disappointing. The pizza was not cooked all the way . We asked for , and paid for , extra cheese and the pizza barely had any cheese . The cheese wasn't even melted all the way. Had to bring it home to try and bake it . Not worth the money at all . We love supporting local businesses but they have definitely gone downhill. read more

My go to New York style pizza place! A bit on the pricy side but worth it for the quality. Their large pizzas are just that, LARGE. The staff is also super friendly. This place will not disappoint! read more

Pine Island Pizza - Large cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bokeelia, Florida

The pizza is top-notch the best in Florida. The service is quick and friendly. The two slice lunch special is one heck of a deal. If you are ever out on the island it's a go. read more

Have you ever had "pizza" with rose petals as a topping? I have ... that's just one of my stories bearing witness to the confused journey of pizza in America. Being denied chili oil is another story I'll save for a different day. Flash forward to paradise on Pine Island and all my bad pizza memories are washed away by the welcoming folks at Pine island Pizza ... they know how to make pizza right without complicating the process. Their's is some of the best I've ever had . Has my stamp of approval as a local and loyal customer. What a treasure to have this kind of spot out here on the island! read more

They have the best food. The pizza, meatballs and subs are the best. I highly recommend

I try to support local but somethings I just can't ignore. Ordered a 14" medium/large pizza. Crust looked pre frozen, sauce was decent but the toppings? Terrible. Peppers and onions should not be diced, looked pre-frozen as well. Not spread out either, just like thrown in the middle. The best part? $18 for this pizza that looked like Digornio. Maybe a taste above. Figured I give them one more shot after a friend ordered a pizza last month, which we weren't super impressed with then either. Super expensive and super disappointed. Will not be back. read more

Pine Island Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bokeelia, Florida

Caveat Emptor- $28 for 16 inch pizza.+ $2 tip as more couldn't be justified due to excessive cost. This pizza is nothing to get overly excited about. Average pie with no special attributes like being wood fired. Four toppings Pepperoni, ground beef, mushroom and onions. Paid a 40% premium and had to go pick it up. This pie is $20 everywhere else and that's where we will go next time. Done going here. read more

Great Pizza, attentive service. Hours are somewhat confusing but good place for both dine in or eat out. Wish they delivered!

Really 'Top-Shelf' Pizza ...... especially for Pine Island. Handmade Ingredients ..... Hand tossed dough ..... Great atmosphere ..... Awesome family who own / operate (they were raised making Pizza in New York !) NOBODY on the Island has better Pizza. John St. James City, FL read more

Best NY style pizza I've had in Florida. My favorite is their Friday lunch special, the White pizza with tomatoes and spinach. Service is always fast and friendly. read more

This pizza is the real deal! If you like New York style pizza you will not be disappointed in this lovely little pizza place. It is a family owned business and all of the food is incredibly fresh. I have gluten-free issues and their gluten-free pizza is delicious. I tend to get the white pizza with various toppings. I cannot stress enough how incredibly scrumptious The taste of this white pizza is :-). My husband has had not only their regular pizza, but also their eggplant Parmesan hero which he told me was terrific. We've had beer and wine here. We've had their antipasto salad and their garden salad both which were freshly prepared with the most delicious salad dressing. I would definitely recommend this if you are a pizza person looking for an authentic flavor and taste. Everyone who works here is beyond nice! A great experience all around. read more