1. Food was amazing! I got the salmon and my boyfriend got the fish tacos. (Their local beer was good also) 2. The woman seating us was such a baddie (in a good way) def helps the restaurant run smoothly. Our waiter was OK, just really hard to hear and soft spoken. When I couldn't hear him I don't know if I was annoying him when asking to repeat or not but was quick with service 3. The vibes, the English style pub life, THE CAPTIVA SUNSET read more

See all

Service was good, food mediocre. Atmosphere blaaa I would not recommend the Mucky Duck on Captiva. read more

Stopped in for some food. The vibes were beach and beer. Bbq shrimp for the win. Service was good. read more

See all

The Mucky Duck is amazing. Great prices, spectacular location, and awesome service. They even let you grab your meal to go and dine at the beach. This is such a clutch move to watch the sunset, especially when the nearby beach access (about 3 minute away with the same views) charges $25 for 2 hours parking. We had the burger and fries and they really hit the spot. I loved how juicy and perfectly medium the burger was cooked. And I didn't even mention all the incredible old school memorabilia on the walls and their super fun line up of shirts for sale. I mean, how can you not just love this spot. Seems like the employees really enjoy it too! read more

See all

We came here for Dinner. This is such a fun pub! No frills but a delicious grouper sandwich. Their rum punch is good too. Unfortunately from the hurricaine they built back such high dunes you cant see the water. Still fun place to eat. read more

See all

We stopped here for a late lunch when visiting Captiva Island. Mucky Duck was the local recommendation, but it does have a tourist trap feel to it. Parking was tight but we were able to find a spot. Service was a little slow and a bit curt, but despite us coming at an off-hour (~3pm), the restaurant was pretty full and lively, so I'll give service a pass. We started with the calamari as an appetizer. The calamari was excellent! It was served hot and each piece was tender - no notes. I also sampled the shrimp bisque but it was quite chunky/thick and not creamy. It felt like the texture came from puréeing the shrimp which I found to be off-putting. It's served with oyster crackers. My friend and I ordered the seafood platter, which is big enough to share. It came with clam strips, fried shrimp, peel and eat steamed shrimp, a piece of fried fish, a single bbq shrimp, French fries (similar to McDonald's shoestring fries), coleslaw, and all the necessary condiments - tartar sauce, cocktail sauces, and an aioli. It was quite filling. My favorites from the platter were the fried shrimp and steamed shrimp - they were cooked nicely and had good texture. While we were eating, the table next to us ordered the shrimp platter and crunchy shrimp - both looked really good. I was least impressed by the lone bbq shrimp - it was a grilled shrimp and topped with bbq sauce, which didn't add anything. You'd think because there was only one piece of shrimp, that it would be something special... it was anything but. Our table also ordered the Chicken Marco Rosa (chicken breast with goat cheese, sundried tomatoes, basil, and a lemon butter sauce, served with potatoes and green beans) and shrimp tacos. The lemon butter sauce was very tasty. The shrimp tacos come with two tacos and are also served with chips and salsa. The tortilla chips are comically and obviously store-bought. Overall, I would say the food is good, but nothing exceptional or worth going out of your way for. The grouper sandwich is market price, which was $40+ (which I find absurd). The Mucky Duck is "THE place to be" at sunset, but when you come at a time other than sunset, it's pretty average. read more

See all

I was excited to learn that this restaurant had finally reopened here after suffering damage from the last hurricane. Most everyone else seemed happy to support them, too, as they were quite busy at lunch. They have outside seating -- particularly good for the beach people in their covered bathing suits and sandy feet. Inside, it's air conditioned and the tables are spaced close together. I decided to do shrimp and shrimp. I started with a cup of their shrimp bisque. It was just okay. Warm on top but hotter as you dug down. After that, I had the steamed shrimp appetizer. This was much better! Peel n eat shrimp -- a nice portion -- along with cocktail sauce. I should have gotten some old bay on the side to jazz it up, but I still liked it. My husband had a Caesar salad with added grilled shrimp. It was a bit light on the dressing so he got some more to add in. The salad was fine once he got the extra dressing. I thought they should have removed the tail shells from his shrimp, however. I'm glad we came to try them, again. Now we know. They will do well here. read more

See all

After a ten year hiatus and a devastating hurricane, we decided to give one of our favorites a new try. They were open and busy both inside and outside. My Caesar salad with added shrimp was good. My draft beer was cold. I was happy. read more

See all

We decide to come to this place as we came here long time ago , but now is definitely something different, the plates are super high priced and what you get is just a slap in the face , we ordered some bbq shrimp with bacon , well .... This people couldn't find the smallest shrimp , we were so surprised. Then after how terrible food was and over highly priced, we thought we can at least go to the beach for a few minutes after we finished eating and then suddenly the restaurant parking attendant started telling us we need to go and can only park to eat there but not for beach , it was not even full , had lots of parking and in the past you were able to do it , that's why it was so great .... Definitely a not come back place At least server was friendly but other than her everything was unbelievable a no go read more

See all

The food was ok but very pricey for eating on a paper plate. No view of the water but a sand dune. Wait staff was just ok. So many other places to eat on the island with better food and friendly wait staff. read more

We absolutely loved our visit to the Mucky Duck. Being on the water was amazing. The sunsets were next level! Tiffany was our server and she was amazing. The food was delicious. I had the crunchy grouper sandwich. It was a ton of food and so delicious. Prices were also reasonable. Clean environment and great views. read more

The Mucky Duck - Seafood Near Me - Captiva, Florida

See all

This is a very busy restaurant on Captiva.They do not take reservations so it maybe a wait for a table inside.We enjoyed the food and the atmosphere,The staff were very busy but were very attentive to your needs .I really enjoyed our experience there and would return soon. read more

So happy to see this iconic establishment re-open after hurricane Ivan in 2022. It's been 40 years since I've been here to catch a sunset while staying on Sanibel Island. The vibe in this rebuilt / relaunched place was uplifting. We ordered a grouper sandwich, crab cakes and some of freshest oysters I've had ever. I also tried the shrimp bisque that was so delicious. Unfortunately, the newly erected sand dune/burm blocks the view to take in a sunset. Don't let that stop you from coming here for a satisfying experience on Captiva Island. read more

The Mucky Duck - Daily specials - Seafood Near Me - Captiva, Florida

See all

Fresh seafood I've tasted, I had the calamari and it was super tender very fresh. The service is different, you stand in line place your order then they calll (if you're sitting outside), and also have inside seating with a waitress or waiter. Just like it was before. And I'm so excited to see you guys are up and running after the hurricane, better than ever just minus the beautiful trees outside.. the beach is alone are totally worth a drive but go early before the traffic sets in. You will never see a better sunset in your life anywhere in Florida. I kinda wish I wouldn't have said that because it's giving away a treasure. read more

See all

Food was great. Restaurant was cute. Waiter was dry & a lil off putting. Oysters Rockefeller was AMAZING!! So was fish & chips & fries. Our friends had the seafood sampler and really like the bbq shrimp. I would recommend this restaurant and would go back. read more

The Mucky Duck - Seafood Near Me - Captiva, Florida

Nice local hangout beachfront must try at least once. As i stated from previous time i was here stay away from the crunchy grouper sandwich its no good tasting, overpriced & disappointing instead try a fish of the day Gulf grouper filet though $43 more appealing with green beans and salad, the clam chowder is a must try really good tasting the shrimp tacos though were disappointing small, not many & poor taste. The drink line is full most of the time and you can also order your food directly from the bar, take it outside to eat under an umbrella by the sand dunes. Beautiful sunsets as well. Rate 3.5-4.0 read more

This is always a staple when I visit Captiva. So happy they were able to reopen after the damage they suffered from the hurricane. After a long day on the beach we went in for a few snacks and a drink. We were so hungry we dug right in and forgot to take pictures, but we had a few appetizers. We had the Caesar salad which was very large and tasty. The mozzarella sticks which were just average. The most delicious part was the Captiva sandwich, which was focaccia bread pesto, Swiss cheese, turkey breast, prosciutto, lettuce, and tomato. The kettle chips that were homemade on the side tied it all together. We all had the Sangria which was delicious after sitting in the sun. read more

Very popular location for standard American food. Located next to beach but you can't see the beach due to sand dune. they have indoor seating but you can order your food inside and sit outside on tables. They call your name if you are outside. Very crowded with long lines nice ambience. The food was fair. The restaurant just reopened that week after the hurricane. If you want American food especially for kids - good choice. read more

About a week ago we went to the newly reopened Mucky Duck, an old favorite of ours. We were very disappointed. We go for the view and the for the grouper sandwich. There is no longer a view from outside or inside due to a tall sand burm. The grouper appeared to be a frozen item that was light on fish. The breading was awful. I was starving so i ate a small amount but did not finish it and left the restaurant hungry. Unfortunately there is no reason for us to go back. read more

Ate there this afternoon. We've eaten there before (before hurricane Ian) and it was always good. We had a great table and great service, but the food was absolutely horrible! I ordered the fried chicken fingers with fries. The fingers were dry, chewy, and tasted artificial. I truly couldn't believe that they would serve something so cheap. School cafeteria chicken fingers are better than this garbage. The fries were okay. My son asked the server if they were made fresh or frozen and was told they came frozen. My son ordered the sandwich with the turkey, pesto, etc.. He liked the sandwich but before ordering the side, he asked if the chips were made to order or regular bag chips. Guess what? Bag chips. My husband ordered the shrimp basket and felt it was okay. Not like some of the other restaurants on the island. We considered ordering dessert but changed our minds when we found out they weren't made in house (with the exception of the sundaes)! In all, it was a big disappointment and we'll probably never go back, which is sad because I was really rooting for them when they were rebuilding after the hurricane. But like another restaurant on Sanibel with the initials LF, the food was cheap, tasteless, and not worth the money or time. I suppose the after effects of the hurricane changed the trajectory of certain restaurants to continue the tradition of serving great food and instead, going cheap and not caring about quality! read more

You can get the same frozen shrimp and fish at the grocery store. Nothing fresh, all frozen, small portions and lacking taste. Waste of money! read more

Lunch with Family and Beach, I got Shrimp Bisque and Onion Rings to start, sorry no Picture of the Rings....but they were both so good, then Main Dish was: Shrimp Tacos with Chips and Dip, they were excellent and one of the best ones I've had yet, @websterbuffa88 Split a Half a Grilled Grouper Sandwich and she loved it read more

See all

Food was good and efficient service the ambiance was the usual restaurant, get there usually before 5 pm for parking and seating. It fills up quickly even during the summer. read more

The Mucky Duck - Mucky duck picture - Seafood Near Me - Captiva, Florida

Excellent food! Wife and I made a quick visit to the area for the day and had lunch here. Definitely recommend the shrimp quesadilla

Terrific servers, food, atmosphere! Perfect beachside hangout for drinks & food. They do it right despite large crowds!

The fish in the fish and chips was still frozen. The fish in the grouper sandwich tasted like catfish. read more

I thought the food was very good. Service was pretty good. About average. Loved the location and ambience.

I wouldn't call the server friendly or engaging, but the service was OK. The seafood platter was sub-par. The fried piece of fish tasted just like the frozen supermarket variety. The rest, just blah. The spinach salad was fresh. I would give that a 5 1/2 out of 10. They could do better. Nowadays, it seems like it's a cash grab, and the quality is desperately lacking. read more

Solid restaurant on the beach. Popped in here on a Tuesday night, and they weren't too busy (but nowhere on the island seems very busy this time of the year. Service was a little slow- had to wait quite a while on refills on drinks, but the food came out pretty quick. The place feels beachy, and if you are wanting a spot on the island to watch the sunset, this is probably one of the best places to do so. I had the teriyaki flank steak for dinner. The steak was well flavored in a nice marinade, but definitely undercoooked (ordered medium and it was still moo'ing on my plate). I also had some cole slaw not pictured- mayo based and needed doctoring up with some salt and pepper. No comment on the beans (wasn't expecting them to come as they weren't listed as the accompanying side on the menu). Overall, would return, but would be happy to try other places on the island before this one. read more

The Mucky Duck - Teriyaki steak - Seafood Near Me - Captiva, Florida

Cute place located right on the beach. The perfect scenery to watch the sunset! If you are going to sit outside, you do have to order at the bar for takeout, so we chose to dine inside. I shared the Chicken Piccata with another member of my party. (So attached photo is just half the serving!) The garlic red potatoes were delicious cooked perfectly. The green beans were good as well. As for the chicken piccata, the person I was sharing with and I both thought it had a weird flavor. It was coated in egg, but the egg would separate from the chicken when cutting. I personally thought it had a like movie theater butter flavor to it, strange. Service was good at first, with quick refills, but our server disappear for quite a while when we waited for the bill. Overall, I would return for the scenery, but would choose a different meal option. read more

The Mucky Duck - Chicken piccata (half of the serving) - Seafood Near Me - Captiva, Florida

This is a great place to eat. Well worth the wait. Go out to the beach while you wait if necessary

Great food, reasonable prices and friendly staff makes The Mucky Duck a great place to eat.

They have rebuilt and are finally open. Their alcohol supplier is very good but they need help with the food sources. The cod looked like three long pieces of a fish stick and the chicken looked like fried thin fish. The salads were fresh and tasty. Parking still a major challenge. If you do find a spot, as soon as you are finished eating, you will have to move your car. Be prepared to do a 12 point parking job to get out of the lot filled with big trucks or expensive sport cars. read more

The service, atmosphere and food was great! Highly recommend the artichoke appetizer!

The Mucky Duck is located on Captiva Island, directly on the beach. This is a place we have visited year after year. We really enjoy it! It has been a few years since I have left a review but felt it was time. They were closed for some time due to the hurricane, but they are open again and just as good as we remember. This location can get very busy, especially in the evening because of their views of the beach and sunset. We always come for lunch since it is less crowded. Their is pretty much the same, there are a few additional items at dinner which are also more expensive. The restaurant itself is not very large, there are only a few tables. Don't ask for a window, if they can't accommodate you and they ask, they bring you a mobile window and set it at the table. They make a big deal out of it and its funny but sort of embarrassing as well. They also have very few big tables. My only issue with this location is the staff and the service. It has always been fantastic, but ever since the hurricane, it seems to have gone down. This last time, we had 5. They tried to seat us at a very small table and add a chair. There would have virtually no room, so we had to ask. We were given a larger table reluctantly. This was my only issue; the hostess was not the friendliest. She moved us but I could tell she was annoyed. Our server was also very forgetful and just not accommodating. My dad ordered a crab cake sandwich with no onions. It came with onions on the lettuce and tomato. Instead of offering to get him a new one, he tried to explain to us for almost 5 minutes why the toppings came with onions. We didn't even understand what he was trying to explain. I finally stepped in and just asked, can you get him a new one. He did but it still had the onions. I honestly did not understand why this was so difficult, but the server was not helpful in it. If that had been an allergy, this would have been a bigger issue, but it was still not needed. He also forgot everything we asked for, more water, forgot, a to go box, he forgot. It was just really bad. My sister asked for cottage cheese instead of fries, he told her they don't have that. (It was on the menu and the table next to us had it) I honestly was confused with him. The service was our only issue. The food is great. I always order the seafood plate. This comes with fried shrimp, clam strips, steamed shrimp, a piece of fish and a BBQ bacon wrapped shrimp. It also comes with fries and coleslaw. It is so good and a great variety of items. Someone in our family always ordered the crunchy grouper sandwich. It is one of the more popular items and always great. You can add cheese to it if you want. This last time, my mom ordered their salad which she added blackened shrimp. This portion was large, but the shrimp were spicy for her. As I said, my dad ordered the crab cake. He enjoyed it, the actual crab cake. My husband usually chooses one of their specials. This year it was an angel hair pasta with loads of seafood and a tomato broth for the sauce. He loves it and is not even a huge pasta fan. All in all this is a great restaurant, it is one we visit year after year. The views are fantastic, they have seating outside and many times live music. I love their food here. This last time, the service was a little on the negative side but it would not detract us from coming and enjoying this restaurant year after year. I would definitely recommend checking it out. read more

See all

This was a great stop right on the beach! We came for sunset, but unfortunately, the night we were there the sunset was clouded. We were lucky enough to snag a window table. Our server was nice, but not too personable or welcoming.. we started with water and a few drinks. we ordered the spinach salad to share, which was such a highlight. we also ordered the shrimp and grouper scampi pasta(nightly special), as well as the shrimp sampler platter. Everything was pretty good other than some of the shrimp were ice cold and the grouper in the pasta was very fishy. Overall, it was a nice meal. read more

The Mucky Duck - Shrimp sampler - Seafood Near Me - Captiva, Florida

See all

Neat experience. Lots of history. Great views. Service was okay. The food was okay. The prices are okay. Glad they survived the hurricane. From my understanding, they had some alteration in the menu that are missing (sad) read more

See all

Today my family and I went to the Mucky Duck for lunch. All of us have been coming of years because of the quality of the food, and the view of the Gulf. When we arrived we were seat almost immediately. All of us knew what we were going to order. When our serve came and greeted us, it was go time. *I ordered the Chef Pasta( Angel Hair tossed with olive oil, basil, garlic, scallions, white wine, tomato, lobster and shrimp) It was one of the specials offered. The angel hair was perfectly cooked, the shrimp and lobster was tender and fresh, the sauce had loads of flavor. Just wonderfully prepared. For drinks I got a pint of an IPA, from Last Laugh. It was a delicious IPA and it so happened to pare well with my dish.*My wife ordered the Seafood Platter(Clam Strips, steamed shrimp, BBQ shrimp, Fried Cod, Fried Cod, with French fries and coleslaw) She loves this patter and has been a go to dish for a while. Nothing too oily, everything is well seasoned* My sister-in-law ordered the Crunchy Grouper Sandwich( served with French fries and coleslaw)She said it had a nice crunch, fish itself was tender, fries were perfect*My mother-in-law ordered a Caesar Salad with seared shrimp added to it. This was perfect for her because she wanted to eat light. The shrimp was nicely seared and fresh. Altogether the salad was well prepared * My father-in-law ordered the Maryland style Crab Cake sandwich ( served with French fries and coleslaw) He seemed to love the sandwich a lot. The only complaint was he asked for no red onion... and it was place on it anyways. Aside from that it was perfect. The server was apologetic, brought a new one. This is a must do when on the island. It's one of the pillars for sure. Aces! read more

The Mucky Duck - Maryland Crab Cake Sandwich - Seafood Near Me - Captiva, Florida

Love the island, restaurant location history and ambiance. When I visit an island, on a beach, I really hope to get fresh seafood. Sadly, that's a rarity at MD. I hate it because so many places on serene islands like Captiva, know you have very few choices and stock generic, frozen everything. The ratings tell you everything, 3 1/2 or lower. Because the drinks are good is the reason they get 3 stars, not the food. They need to wise up, raise prices and get FRESH! I have 6 more nights and I'll gladly spend the money on tolls and gas for good fresh seafood which is within 45 minutes. No more miniature breaded shrimp or frozen French fries, I'll find better. read more

So I've been hearing about this place from my husband and his family. They use to come here decades ago when he was a kid. This place has been a Captiva staple. I was excited to come here and I'm glad I did. They don't take reservations so that means that you will have to wait. We got lucky because the weekend weather sucked so there wasn't a long wait for a table. We probably waited like 5-10mins. As soon as you come in you see a large old school bar. They had a lot of fun sayings around it so it was cute. The place was packed, the restaurant and bar big not the outside sitting because of the weather. We were sat right I front of the windows which was great, we could see the ocean. The service was good. We got our food pretty fast. Let's talk about the food. I thought it would be just an American seafood place so I was happy. When we get there and I see the sign it says "English Pub"... my heart sank. The English are not known for their incredibly delicious cuisine. The inside did have an English pub feel, there was a lot of dark wood around and they have their own special lager (called the Mucky Duck Red Lager). I ordered the clam chowder soup and it was good. For the main dish I ordered the Pan Seared Snapper and it was very good. It had spinach, sun dried tomatoes, green beans on the side, and I got them with fries. EVERYTHING in my plate was tasty! The fries were super crispy and delicious even though I didn't taste any salt. We had a very good time here and we enjoyed making memories. The food was good. I feel like this is more of a dinner place than lunch. I recommend this place. read more

See all