Being a regular diner in most of Buffalo's restaurants, I was eagerly awaiting the unveil of Martin Cooks' new venue and cuisine now evolved into Roost. Having been to Martin Cooks several times I had high expectations for the evening.
We decided to wait until a month after the grand opening to avoid any of the usual opening jitters and buzz. I called on a Saturday morning for the day of, for a reservation for 2 people. Apparently they had no more reservations left, so we figured we would try for a seat at the bar. The restaurant was packed, we ended up waiting behind another couple at the bar for about a half hour until they finished their meal.
When the menu was presented there were only 3 cocktails available. None of them were appealing, one that particularly struck my attention was an egg white, gin and cream concoction...not exactly what I have in mind to drink with dinner.
The food menu was a good size offering several options for any type of guest, mostly Asian influenced. We decided to order the Beef Carpaccio with miso and pineapple, the Udon Bowl with shrimp and mushroom, and the Pork and Chicken Congee. When the carpaccio arrived, the meat was thinly pounded and tasty, aside from that, the rice chip and accompaniments were far overly salted. I am a person who enjoys a heavily seasoned dish, and this was almost unbearable. I witnessed the Chef making this dish in the open kitchen, and it seemed like this was his only dish because I was watching from my bar seat. It seems that aside from making this dish, his other job was to drink wine at his station and overly salt the meat. Next, the congee arrived. I admit that I am not a congee expert and wasn't sure what to expect, but I do feel I have keen sense of taste. What I did notice was that it was not a cohesive dish. The pork belly chunk garnishing the dish was overly browned in the fryer and completely dry in the center with no flavor at all. I am a major pork belly fan and I can't remember a time when I've had it prepared in such an unsuccessful way...Aside from the pork belly the chicken had an inconsistent, and somewhat fermented taste. Perhaps it was the fact that I saw about 10 rotisserie chickens fully browned, sitting on the workspace my entire dinner without being touched. Aside from the protein, the rest of the dish tasted like a goulash of everything Asian thrown in from the pantry. Next, the noodle bowl. The dish was an appropriate size garnished with two large prawns. I was a little taken aback because they did not give me a knife to cut off the intact shrimp tail, nor did they give me chopsticks or a ramen spoon. This dish had no flavor at all. It did not taste like an earthy, dried mushroom broth, nor did it have depth from shrimp stock, or any spice whatsoever. It tasted like watery noodles, fresh mushrooms steeped in water and that's about it. When I asked for chili oil for spice, they gave me a container of sweet chili sauce which is gummy, sweet, and has no spice whatsoever. After having those dishes I was not inclined to order dessert. On our way out, about three people working there asked how our meal was. I just smiled and left seeing as I didn't want to cause a disturbance on a bustling Saturday evening. read more