Romeo's Pizza..... Oh how I have missed you. It's been over 4 years since I've had their food. So I was so excited for my pizza. I got the Romeo's Deluxe Specialty Pizza. Minus the mushrooms. Just a 10 inch for me. Light on the sauce too. Nothing against Romeo's Pizza Sauce. It's actually the best I've ever had. I just don't like a pizza swimming in sauce. Theirs is a lil on the sweet side and it's delicious. They have a lot of tasty items on their menu. Their Bacon Cheese Breadsticks is The BOMB! Try it. And let me know what you think. read more

See all

We've ordered from the Hilliard location every week and have always had reliable service--until our last visit. The delivery time kept getting delayed, and when the driver finally arrived 30 minutes late, the pizza wasn't even in a warming bag. It was cold, overcooked, and reheating it didn't help. When I called the store, the person claiming to be in charge offered nothing more than a quick "sorry." No attempt to make it right, no coupon, no replacement--nothing. We've supported this location for a long time, but after this experience, we'll be choosing another local pizza shop for our business. William Morris read more

Customer service nightmare. Walked in for the first time at the Delaware location. We usually have pizza weekly and have never tried Romeo's. Waited at desk 5 minutes before someone appeared-mgr I think- ordered gluten free pizza and italian calzone from the menu in lobby. We were told they did not have either item-didn't run out-just don't carry anymore!! Coupon for free desert was not honored-has to be done online? I was holding a copy in my hand. Will not return -very negative experience. read more

Food is really good. Frequent coupon specials. Capone sauce and homemade ranch are amazing. Hence my 2 star review. They frequently leave things out of orders such as ranch and cutting pizza per request in the online orders. It's not rarely. I'd say half the time something is wrong. read more

We absolutely love Romeo's Pizza. We have tried every pizzeria in the area but we love Romeo's the best. Their pizza is perfectly made with chewy crisp crust and flavorful toppings. To top it off their service is excellent. We get pizza about 2-3 times a month and the Romeo's on Hard Road is our go to. read more

Never dissatisfied with their pizzza. So many types of crust to choose from. Love their butchers pizza read more

Very poor customer service. Waited a very long time for a response. Food is inconsistent at best. They offered no resolution.

Got order wrong, forgot salad, wont not refund or delivery. Toppings not on whole pizza.

I went to Romio pizza in Gahanna Ohio for the first time ever Monday. It was one of the worst pizza I've ever had. They never put on pepperoni so I had a $16 cheese pizza, and it was tasteless hardly no sauce and crust was hard and dry. why can't I find a good pizza in Ohio? read more

Romeo's wants the delivery driver to accept an iou at the end of the night rather than pay the tips out. When you refuse to work for an iou they tell you, you've volunteered to quit your job so now your check is minimum wage and your tips the costumer paid for your service will be on that check. Only because I told the owner I needed it in my bank to make my car payment read more

The pizza is really good for chain pizza. Their service is top notch and carry orders are fast and easy with Apple Pay. They have fixed their mess ups and even helped me out when I ordered the wrong thing! Staff is so nice and friendly. read more

Bringing my rating down to 1 star. We ordered gluten free pizza and since we eat here regularly, we noticed the crust looked different. We called and asked if they had changed suppliers. We were told they had run out of gluten free crust so they substituted their thin crust. Without asking or disclosing. To people with food allergies. AND IT WAS THE MANAGER'S IDEA Bad idea. So I asked for a refund and told them they were welcome to the pizza back that we were allergic to. They asked if they could call me back in an hour or so. Nope. You can't. So my husband went up and returned the pizza and the manager refused to speak to him. He finally did receive a refund. We contacted corporate by email (because CLEARLY their staff needs more training on what to do if you run out of a product and wanted to give them a chance to explain/apologize before blasting them publicly)...but we let a month go by and received no contact so we thought it would be wise to warn others with food allergies not to eat here. read more

I used to go to Romeo's quite a bit a few years ago, but this time was probably one of my worst pizza experiences at any Columbus shop I've ordered from. I ordered a medium traditional New York white and added mushrooms and sausage, and have a couple problems. 1. The pizza was a small 2. The pizza was cold, even though this location is less than 5 minutes walking distance 3. The pizza was $17 4. Delivery took over an hour 5. Garlic sauce is dry I ordered delivery for the convenience having just returned from being out of town for the holidays. Even if my delivery was the last before the delivery driver returned to the store, either keep the pizzas hot or don't schedule so many deliveries. The best thing I can say about this is that it is at least better than Papa John's. I think I'll stick to Jet's from now on, this was so disappointing. read more

Romeo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

it cost us $40 for a large pizza with 4 toppings to be delivered. The pizza was cold. They were extremely chintzy with the toppings. I would not recommend this pizza to anyone. read more

We were in town & looking to order in & have some decent pizza. I don't eat meat, but my husband does, so we decided to try the beyond chicken Buffalo pizza with plain ranch (no bacon). They were so nice on the phone, making sure to make it how I asked, without bacon. That pizza was delicious!!! We ate every crumb & we both loved it! My husband said he would eat that every day if he could. Thank you Romeo's!! read more

Burnt pizza. Could not eat this pizza. Meatball sub was not cut in half. Order some where else who takes pride in there pizza read more

Romeo's Pizza - Burnt cold garbage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Absolute WORST sub I've ever had! I ate two bites and told my husband it was awful and I didn't want it. He looked at it, opened it, and said "There's nothing on it!". I told him to try it and he spit it out because it was so burned and dry. Bun was completely burned - the entire outside of the bun. Inside was dry, the meat was dry and the wasn't much of it. There was a very slight smear of sauce alomg the edge, and nothing else. Biggest disappointment in food I've had in a LONG time. Would never eat here again, would never recommend it. read more

We love Romeo's. Love their sweet sauce. They give a side of sauce to dip your pizza in, it's called Capone sauce, it is good too. My only complaint is that they don't put enough sauce on the pizza so we always order extra or extra extra sauce to get enough. So if you like a lot of sauce like we do order extra sauce. read more

Their web-pickup time estimate was over-optimistic by 20 minutes tonight, but they were apologetic and working hard. Also the website would not "split-total" with a gift card, but they were able to do it at the counter. Pizza was good, Capone sauce is unique! read more

My fellow coworkers rave about this place. So i was curious and wanted to give it a try.. Being a frequent visitor at the taste of Chicago festival has ruined pizza for me especially living here in Columbus... my level of expectation of what a good pizza seems to be pretty different..... So I ordered the butcher and added jalepenos for an addition $2+ which I only literally got 14 thinly slices that was just dropped on top of what they gave me... pizza sauce seems a little too sweet for me but the Capone sauce wasn't bad.. 20 for a large is overpriced for the quality better off going to little Caesar's same quality but you will be saving much more.. read more

Romeo's Pizza - Butcher shop Pizza... from romeos - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

New pizza place that took over the Jordano's building. Delivery took and hour and a half. My "cheese"steak sub didn't have any cheese on it. barely any steak. I just scraped the meat from one side and put it all onto the other half. Husband's chicken club tasted weird. bland. The mushroom calzone wasn't bad. The pizza sauce was good. The crust was not. Just disappointed. read more

Romeo's Pizza - "Cheese" Steak sub? Where's the cheese? - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We ordered a veggie pizza for the first time in several years. What a disappointment! When my husband picked it up it was only luke warm. Then when he got home and looked at it, we found it was still raw. The veggies were raw and the crust hadn't even begun to brown. We had to slide it onto a cookie sheet and finish baking it. When we spend $25 on a pizza, we expect it to be cooked. Never again! read more

Romeo's delivers consistently tasty pizza. I've not been disappointed, not once. The sauce is sweet and zesty, which I know isn't for everyone, but it's exactly what I like. And speaking of sauce, they offer a huge variety, so whatever you're into, they can probably customize it. Online ordering is a breeze, but when you order, be prepared for the delivery person to arrive fairly quickly. The sides aren't bad, either. I've tried the boneless wings and this s'mores cake thing that melted in my mouth. read more

My family have occasionally ordered from Romeo's and they're delux pizza has always been good. Today though I'm not sure if the pizza has been sitting out for too long after coming out of the oven before delivery or if there's a new chef but the pizza was definitely too dry and definitely too little pizza sauce. read more

Pizza is one of my family's favorite foods. This location always proves it's worth. It has us coming back. The sweet sauce is not something you can get just anywhere. They do it just right. Thank you for being one of our go to pizza shops! We normally scarf down a large pepperoni and stuffed crust cheese with all the Capone sauce we can stow in a bag. That sauce goes so well with the fluffy crust and brings through excellent flavors. read more

Top-notch quality great value why pay for trash ingredient. when you can get good quality food for just about the same price. It's my go to place if I am hosting a get together party. FYI it even better the next day . read more

Way overpriced for what you get. It's almost as if they take pride in ripping you off. You want spinach on your pizza...here's 1 piece of spinach for you randomly tossed on one slice. Banana peppers...here's one or two to be "generous". They charge a premium pizza prize but don't follow through. The pizza itself, it's okay. It would be better with the toppings that you order and pay out the nose for. $60 for a small, a medium, and a stromboli. All missing toppings. read more

Just had a pizza that was like a bread stick circle. Hardly any sauce (secret is supposedly in the sauce, if so, why are you being so stingy with it), three jalapeños, and barely and cheese. I would say you need to explain how to make the pizza when you call because the staff really dropped the ball tonight read more

Sometimes Romeos is good, sometimes it's not. You never know what you're gonna get. I don't understand why a cheese pizza only has cheese on half the pizza. Like it's half way down on the piece of pizza. I guess they're trying to save money on cheese?? Disappointing pizza today for sure. read more

YUM! The biggest make it or break it for me when it comes to pizza is the sauce and the sauce here is the perfect amount of sweet tomato delish I need in my life. We ordered a regular pepperoni and a New York white pizza. The white pizza, admittedly, could have been better and lacked the garlic/creamy flavor I was hoping for, but that pepperoni pizza was LIFE. If you're looking for your average slice of pepperoni pizza, this is the place. Crust/sauce/cheese/topping ratio: PRIME. Reminds me of my favorite pizza shop from my hometown that everyone craves from time to time. My new favorite pizza to order in! read more

After trying Rome's at the Columbus Pizza Festival (or whatever it was called...), I was excited to try their NW Columbus location. I was not disappointed. I had their specialty pizza with sausage, potatoes (!), ranch almonds (!), and caramelized onions on a bacon ranch sauce (!). It was amazing. The pizza is rich, so that I wouldn't want to eat more than two slices at any one time. That being said, a brief 30-minute break was more than enough time to be ready for round 2. The onions were delicious, the sausage was crispy, the potatoes had a great creamy interior, and the sauce was the perfect base. The crust was nicely browned on the bottom, chewy on the edges, and just substantial enough to hold all the toppings. This is easily one of my favorite pizzas in Columbus, on par, for me, with Clever Crow in terms of overall quality. My only complaint was with the brownie bites, which smelled like a fryer and were, in my opinion, inedible. The pizza more than made up for this problem. The specialty pizzas are pricey, but their coupons are pretty robust, so you can find a deal. Even without the coupon, it's well worth the price. read more

Typical neighborhood pizza, certainly not gourmet. As good as most local joints but not top shelf. Depending on what you want to spend this is OK but definitely did not rock my boat! read more

I have been craving a good Chicago style deep dish stuffed pie! now even though I live a short hour and a half drive from downtown Chicago there are surprisingly not too many traditional pizzarias that se3rve up some good traditional stuffed/deep dish pies. I went on a small search and found Romeo's I browsed their menu and came across what in the pictures looked like and amazing Chicago style deep dish pie! I got excited and ordered a pie and some wings. what I got.... I can NOT put into words how bad this is... I am literally moments from actually shedding tears, I am literally considering throwing it away and finding another place to try and salvage this night from.... I took ONE bite and knew I had screwed up by giving them a chance... how could they possibly have gotten any awards for this? first of all they use a basic pizza crust you would see used for a hand tossed pizza, so naturally when they cooked it the dough did exactly what you would expect from a hand tossed basic dough. next it had a decent amount of toppings but it was just off.... I decide I am gonna pull off the top layer and see what is going on, I gasp in shock and disappointment I AM NOT exaggerating when I say MAYBE an ounce of cheese on the whole pie... ONE OUNCE. now I might be a little insane but I am pretty sure the whole premise of a Chicago Style deep dish and or stuffed pizza is that it is basically just cheese! and because it is the wrong style of dough used for this pie it had puffed up so much it gave the illusion that this was a deep dish pizza when in reallity it was literally all dough and nothing else. The ONLY good thing I will say about this pie is that the sauce they use is actually pretty tasty, its just too bad it is laying on a mountain of semi raw dough. I am not sure if I have been so discouraged of trying new things in my life... and Finally the wings.... first off the "medium buffalo" sauce they give you is literally just a solo ramekin of Frank's red hot sauce LITERALLY NOT buffalo sauce, if you don't understand the difference you have no bussiness coming at me with any snarky comments about that! the BBQ was actually not that horrible but was definitely some cheap generic type bulk sauce you get from Stans or GFS understandable it the restaurant world I get it! I have worked in the industry for 20+ years now. the wings!!!..... omg I was embarrassed for them! wings are one of the easiest menu items anyone could possibly make, and is truly hard to mess up, like if you mess them up you LITERALLY DO NOT CARE ABOUT YOUR JOB AND WHAT YOU ARE DOING. they were overcooked and dry and they were crusty and not the good type of fresh out of the fryer crispy oh noooooo they were nasty dry (i didn't use a timer) type screwed up! I have been cooking for work and at home for a passion for a very long time, let me tell you that pie was NOT a problem of a worker didnt care to do something right, oh no! that worker did their job to perfection that PIE is a product of bad business decisions made by an owner that cares only about one thing... their money. I will never ever make the mistake of ordering this garbage ever again and I hope people are lucky enough to read my review before making the same horrible mistake I did! read more

See all

Romeo's is definitely my favorite pizza of all time and I've ate a lot of pizza in my life. Their sauce is very delicious and sweet, and the cheese they use is awesome. They are very consistent with their pizzas too - I don't think I've ever had a bad one from them. I don't think I've ever ordered pizza from anywhere else since Romeo's. Why would I when theirs is so good? Watch out for coupons because the pizza is expensive without them. I live close to this location so I get them in the mail. Call and ask what specials they have or any coupons they have out currently - they'd probably honor them without you even having the coupon. My staple pizza order is a large 2 topping (pepperoni and extra cheese) for $10.99. You have to ask to get this special though and it's pick up only. I ordered the butcher shop awhile back and it was really good but would have been better with extra cheese/sauce. read more

This is my favorite pizza place of all time. I order several times a month. It's always the thing that helps me feel better when I'm feeling depressed. Delivery is always fast, pizza is always hot and delicious. Been going here for years and I've never had any reason to complain. If I could live off this pizza I would. read more

Romeos is the best pizza in town that delivers. These other reviews are silly. Try it or you're missing out! read more

Romeo's Pizza - New deep dish. Half pineapple half pepperoni. Whole yum. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

i Ordered Romeos this past Thursday and had it delivered and when the order arrived half of my order was missing. I called the store and was told the rest of my order was still there and if I wanted it that I needed to come and get. i honestly first thought he was joking But he wasn't. I proceeded to ask to speak to the manager and was Told my manager doesn't talk to customer that has issues and he hung up on me. I then called back and again was told he wouldn't put the manager on and he wasn't going to deliver them. I had to call the Bethel store to speak to a manager and she called the district manager which never called me back. Im the meantime I kept getting calls from Romeos calling me names and then would hang up. This happened 4 times. I finally got the manager at the hard rd store which said he would get the wings deliverEd and would refund the wings. I got the wings but it took 3 hours and was cold. I still havent gotten a full credit and when I called the next day to ask why I didn't receive full credit he said he was not going to give me a full credit for the wings and hung up. I have ordered from them for years but will never again. I can't believe they have such Unprofessional managers. read more

Excellent Customer Service. I've never been let down on Pizza at this Romeo's when it comes to Quality for the past 8 Years.

The food made me very sick. There was a foreign object in the sandwich. The fries were undercooked and tasted awful like they had been soaked in chemicals. The cookies were burned. Again, the food made me sick with diarrhea. This place should be investigated. Please do NOT eat anything from this restaurant. read more

I would avoid the Hard Road location. The manager is highly unprofessional, curses and calls you "dude" when dealing with customers. After a two hour delay on a delivery, I called to check on my order only to be dismissed, being told it's snowing and you bet your a## your pizza will be late. He hung up. This was our second order problem in a month with the same treatment by the manager. I had to go to the store to get a refund. The manager assured me corporate won't do anything as they don't care. read more