I'm just trying to figure out how difficult it is to read an order and fill it the way it's written. I ordered a 14" Italian sausage/pepperoni with extra cheese. In addition, I ordered garlic cheese bread. I pick up the pizza, get it home, open it up and, the pizza that they prepared for me was a 14" pepperoni only. The garlic cheese bread had very little cheese. The pizza itself was just ok. I have not ordered from Massey's since the Pandemic because of poor management. I'm done!!! read more

I havent had this in years but picked it up the other night and it was nice. Online ordering was easy and made it super simple to customize. I accidentally entered the wrong pickup time but called and it was fixed immediately. Nice sauce flavor and nice crust. read more

Massey's Pizza - two boxes of pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The staff at this location are always friendly no matter the time of day. And I'm always happy with their ability to follow requests. Sweet team, good food, all around good vibes. My boyfriend and I ended up eating more than half this in one sitting haha. read more

Massey's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I really like Massey pizza, but not all locations are the same quality, taste, etc. This is one of the excellent locations in my opinion. They also had a cinnamon desert sticks which was better than many of the other Pizza joints that offer cinnamon sticks. My kids unanimously agree with me. read more

I think Massey's is one the best pizza places in Columbus, easily in my top five. But the Massey's on 161 is exceptional, a great pizza everytime I go. Store is spotless and the people are friendly. My go to Massey's location. read more

Massey's Pizza - Pepperoni everywhere - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Love ordering pizzas from here. We always ask for extra well done and extra corn mill. Yum!

The pizza is not what it used to be. Tastes more like Donatos. The staff is friendly, the subs are fantastic!

Yep, it's the real deal! Great pizza! Inside is a dump though would make this a five star review. Can't beat the pizza quality!

It's a bit of a weird place, this Massey's location. That's what I think each time I pick up a pie here. I have yet to eat in but we've picked up a good number of pies here. The first time we came I had to get the bathroom unlocked. I'm guessing things have happened at some point and that's now how it goes here. It doesn't matter that it's a weird place because they (like the other Massey's, franchised or owned) make a SOLID pie. I think that their Ohio/Midwest style pie is the best that I have had. Beats Donatos hands down as well as some CBus pizza institutions that I won't name (but have previously reviewed). I've had quite the time eating pizza around CBus looking for perfect pies. Would I call this one perfect? Nope but they get pretty close! The ovens that they use result is a beautiful bake. Full disclosure: Massey's makes the only Ohio/Midwest thinner crust rectangle cut circle pie that I'll actually eat. read more

My favorite pizza in the entire world. When I come home to visit I order their lip smacking cornmeal crust thin and crispy pepperoni pizza as many times as I can. Nothing comes even close to this pie. read more

Love how Massey's Pizza has edge to edge pepperoni, but to me it's all about the cornmeal. This pizza has it, one of the best pizzas I've ever had. read more

See all

I love their pepperoni pizza!

as a person who has to watch out for high blood sugar, i was afraid i'd have to give up pizza forever. most of the carbohydrates in pizzas are from the crust, but massey's has the thinnest, yet tastiest thin crust pizza. the pepperoni and mushrooms i had were perfect too. thank you massey's for letting me return to a favorite food despite my need to watch carbohydrate intake. read more

They won't accept cash due to COVID and I think it's discrimination I don't like giving out my card information.

I love you guys pizza. A bit on the expensive side for the size but I guess it's worth it .

I'm a traditionalist. I like my pizza made the old-fashioned way, with dough made of yeast and flour with toppings and sauce and that's that. However, now that I'm on the keto diet, I have had to modify what I eat. My biggest fear in making that dietary change was that I would need to give up all the great things that make living worthwhile. Breads, potatoes and most of all Pizza would be eliminated from my diet. As I sat in my man cave one evening I watched a commercial detailing Massey's cauliflower crust pizza. I immediately dialed my local location and inquired about the cauliflower crust and whether or not it tasted as good as it looked on their commercial. The young lady told me that the pizza was the real deal and that it tasted better than it looked on the commercial. I was still somewhat skeptical but I ordered anyway. I ordered the 10in (it only comes in 10 inch size) and I opted for sausage, pepperoni and mushrooms as toppings. Well, I got the pizza home and opened the box. Wow. Wow. Wow! It looked like the Massey's Pizza I have enjoyed for over 20 years. It smelled like the pizza I have enjoyed for over 20 years and best of all it tasted like the pizza I have enjoyed for over 20 years! The crust was crisp and tasted like...real crust! I never thought I would weep tears of joy over a pizza but let me tell you it was that good! Its ridiculous how good the pizza tasted! It was perfection. So now the keto diet isn't so bad after all. I found the missing link to keto happiness and it is located at my local Massey's pizza shop. Do yourself a favor and make tracks to Massey's- you'll be glad you did! read more

14 people in here, and I have to ask if they will have pizza on the buffet.... seriously? It's a buffet. It's 12:15 pm prime lun h time and I have to ask for a pizza. Corporate needs to monitor their satellite stores. I've eaten Masseys for 30+ years at the Whitehall location. Should have just gone out of my way and eaten there. Added to this on 4/16/2017 I gave it another try only because I was meeting friends there. It all started with a phone call to the place asking about if they sold gift cards. They said yes. So i didnt discourage my buddies from going to this location. I arrived early to get the gift card out of the way before meeting my friends. So I said to the owner I needed a gift card, he responded with, my machine is broken down and I can't issue one.....So I responded with, why didn't you tell me that when I called? What a jerk. Then someone from the crowd yelled from across the room, don't give him any money he doesn't put any pizza out on the buffet. So this is a regular thing with this location. Turns out it's a franchise location. This was a bad idea letting this guy get hold of a Masseys Pizza location. They have wonderful pizza. This location needs shut down, or change the name. He is dragging the good name right through the mud. I will never go back there. I also added more pictures of the amount of people in the store with a picture of the two slices of pizza for 15 other people in the restaurant. And we had to ask for salad as well. What a shame. This guy should bow out of the pizza business. read more

See all

I haven't been to this Massey's (1951 E. Dublin Granville Rd) in about 2 years. It was old looking but the owner cared enough of his product that he made sure it came out good. Ever since the ownership change, the quality has gone done. I decided to check it out again since I was nearby but wow, I think it has gotten worse. I stopped by for lunch buffet and the whole time I was there, new pizza never came out. The pizza that was already there was old and cold. I waited as long as I could but didn't have enough time to wait. I don't think they cared since they put out 4 pizzas. Sorry owners but I will not come back. If I wanted to eat cold pizza, I could check my own fridge. read more

I went back again the other night to get another sub. It was the same one I had the last time, the Italian. I'm not sure what the problem was but this time it wasn't nearly as good. Undercooked, is my guess. So I'm nocking it down a couple of stars and probably not going to come back here for a good while. Maybe never. read more

What do you say about Massey's? Always good food and great service at the Graceland location. They took care of a large birthday group beautifully!! We visit this location regularly and will continue to do so! And the cauliflower crust is delicious!! read more

We ordered the large thin crust pepperoni pizza and the Pizza Deluxe sub. When I first had Masseys it was eleven years ago and I wasn't a fan. However after trying more pizza places I have to say I really liked it. The crust is crisp the pepporonis are ample and the sauce is tomatoey. I could use more sauce and cheese but I really liked it especially with lots of pepporonis and the crisp crust. The sub was loaded with lots of toppings and was very good not excellent one I've had elsewhere but very good. Anyhow now that I realize I do like their offerings I'm going to try more in the near future with my family's blessings! read more

Massey's Pizza - Large pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Good Neighborhood pizza place, very glad they are still in the neighborhood. Love the plentiful pepperoni and corn dusted crust.

not happy at all I will not be back fountain soda machine warm with no ice and flat . They have nats too ugh.. this place is very ran down but this dry old pizza I'm just not satisfied with this experience from the pop to the food read more

Massey's Pizza - Dry pizza wilted salad flat pop no ice pizza taste old and reheated - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Wow!! What a change I have seen in this Massey's location! The pizza is as amazing as ever... even better actually. They have also added a cauliflower crust pizza to the menu (I hear it is incredible - can't wait to try it). But the changes I'm most impressed with have nothing to do with the food itself. Apparently there are new owners since mid-April 2019... and you can tell THEY CARE! Much cleaner, repairs to the facility abound, the addition of TVs to the dining room! If you haven't been in lately I would highly recommend you stop in! read more

Massey's is yummy pizza for a good price. Try their lunch buffet, its $7.50 for all you can eat pizza, salad, and pasta, and that includes a soda whether you want it or not. Sometimes they are a bit slow getting pizzas out but they're delicious so you won't mind much. read more

I have never had a pizza from Masseys so we were at Subway and next door was a Masseys and my son wanted pizza so I ordered it online while ordering my food at subway. I went next door to see if the order was done come to find out I ordered from this one that my review is on instead of the one that is next door. So I called to cancel because it was to far from where I was, the associate that answered said he needed to get his manager, I said ok. A man said yes I explained that I ordered at the wrong location and he said what did u order ( a rude tone) I told him a large cheese pizza, he said a extra cheese and I said yes. He says it is ready in 10 min you coming to pick it up. I told him I ordered it from the wrong place, he said where did u want it, I told him where and he said so u want to cancel, I said yes I want to cancel. He tells me that when I ordered online it tells you what the location is, I said I know, then he tells me that they have to many people placing orders and canceling (I have never done this before and I felt bad as it is) but he repeated the part about ordering online with a stern voice which I reacted to by explaining to him I'm not a child, he then got really rude and said I know that I'm below u and your higher blah,blah (he would not let me get a word in) then he said I know you think you are above me, I said no I don't think that (again he wouldn't let me get anything out). Then he says I have said I'm sorry and I have cancel it, that is when I said u are being sarcastic and he then turned it toward me saying I was. At that time I was heated and so was my husband (he wanted the phone) but I was done so I let him finish talking and we both said bye. I have never had someone be so rude and disrespectful to me like this. I understand the issue but the tone of his voice was uncalled for. read more

UPDATE - Over the last year or so, all of the regular employees of this location have either left or been fired and the quality of the pizza has taken a significant turn for the worse. Additionally the neighborhood continues to be not the safest place as evidenced by the crowd of teenagers that was hanging outside the door of Massey's on a recent Saturday night. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza with extra cheese and extra sauce. Based on the growing crowd outside the door we briefly checked our pizza left quickly. We got home, the pizza did not have extra cheese or extra sauce. It was dry and terrible. Here is how bad the pizza was... my wife and I and our two daughters always finish a large Massye's pizza. There is never any pizza left. Almost half of the pizza went unfinished and no one ate it as leftovers. We actually threw away Massey's pizza. I've been eating Massey's since the 1980s and that has never, ever happened. Upset by the terrible quality of the pizza we attempted to contact Massey's. Calls to the store manager and Facebook posts by my wife have been ignored. For good pizza and for your personal safety I strongly recommend avoiding this location. We will drive down the road to Gahanna the next time we want Massey's pizza. read more

Came for a buffet on a Friday and literally they had almost no pizza out and what was out had clearly been sitting for quite some time. There was no rush to get more out. Salad bar all looked old. Will not return. read more

I have been meaning to order this soon. This is Massey's Godfather deep dish pizza and I guess I can say it was worth the wait. It's not Donato or Domino's or Pizza Hut. It's distinct on its own and the flavors are there. It is satisfying and delicious. read more

Massey's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I have not had this pizza for few years. I used to order regularly back then. I ordered online. Pizza was fine , did not seem to taste as good back then. Couple weeks later on way from work I ordered online again to see if last time was an off day. I get there and cannot understand the foreign kid. An adult came up and said they called to confirm my order because of wasted food. No problem. They did not leave a voice mail. I do not answer unfamiliar calls and check voice mails. Since no message I had no idea they called.I told the guy his and I had ordered online couple weeks ago. My pizza was not made. My previous order should have been in the computer as a customer like other pizza stores. I did not know they were franchised. I wont go back. I will keep ordering Eagles after work and drive a little out of the way or other pizza stores if I am near. read more

Our family had heard how wonderful the pizzas were at Massey's, so we decided to give it a try. Our order consisted of a pepperoni/banana peppers cauliflower crust pizza, a regular crust pepperoni pizza, and a regular crust Italian sausage/ham pizza. The cauliflower crust was rock hard. Not what I was expecting. The employee could hardly even cut through it when cutting it into pieces. Not impressed so we won't be getting this again. The other two regular crust pizzas were just okey. This crust was also too hard for our liking and the taste lacking. Not impressed so we won't be getting this again. We all decided this order of pizzas was not worth the expense. Donatos, Jet's, Pizza House, Tommy's.....any of these establishments will get our business just as they always have. read more

The cauliflower pizza is amazing! Definitely will be back and happy to have a place in town to offer a healthy alternative to pizza. The service is excellent with the new ownership. I had the pleasure of meeting Anita and she made my dining experience very enjoyable! read more

It is amazing pizza. Massey's fors it right. They are so friendly in there. The crispiness of the pizza is perfection. Their salads are great as well. Its always nice to have a local joint that does things so well read more

Not quite the Cadillac of Pizza their ads boast. Palatable, but the sauce is unremarkable, the crust is standard issue, and the two times i've gone to the lunch buffet, it seems they expect people to wait for an hour as they slowly expedite pizzas to the feeding trough. And the price was high for so little mediocre food. read more

Ordered a sub for the fourth time this summer and waited an hour and a half for it when they said an hour. Asked if I could have a discount or a free sub for my weight and they said no way. Don't understand the business model of having a customer and multiple customers at my business frequent their place and now they want to not how about a customer. Wish I could still go there because the sub quality is very good but it seems like they don't care about the customers.just order Jimmy John's it'll be way faster read more

This is the best darn pizza I've had in a very long time. The store was very clean and the customer service was spot on. The pizza came out fast and HOT! I ordered the cauliflower pizza crust and I was not disappointed. I will definitely be eating here more often. read more

By far the best pizza I have ever had. I used to be a fan of Donatos because I prefer a thin & crispy crust, but Massey's tops Donatos by far. Their cheese & sauce is amazing & the crust is perfect! I particularly LOVE their BLT pizza & I always get my regular (pepperoni, mushroom, & banana pepper). My dad lives in Florida now & when he comes home he would always request Donatos, but now he is a Massey's guy ever since I put him on to their pizza. Seriously best pizza I have ever had, hands down! read more

We have been getting Massey's for years and everything we get is great! Also, the guys working there are polite and give good service. We eat in and take home also. It is the top of my list for good pizza and subs! My advice, try it for yourself. Definitely worth a visit! read more

Had a large pepp, guido sub and cheesy bread. Can't go wrong with the pizza. Cadillac of pizza! The sub was wayyyy above average. One of the best I've tasted read more

always needs more sauce for me.. the crust can be hard at times.. pepperonis are toasted well. again I have had the best pizza in NYC so im comparing them to Lombardos.. read more